Racialized tracking is central to sociological explanations for racially stratified educational outcomes. However, school officials’ decision-making is of debated importance for explaining racialized tracking. We contribute to this literature by examining the effects of schools’ enrollment policies for Advanced Placement (AP) courses. Using a unique combination of school survey data and administrative data from Wisconsin, we examine what happens to racial inequality in AP participation when school officials enforce performance-based selection criteria, which we call “course gatekeeping.” We find that course gatekeeping has racially disproportionate effects. Although racialized differences in prior achievement partially explain the especially large negative effects among students of color, course gatekeeping producesBlack-white and Hispanic-white disparities in participation even among students with similar, relatively low prior achievement. We further find that course gatekeeping has longer-run effects, particularly discouraging Black and Asian or Pacific Islander students from attending highly selective four-year colleges.
AlonSigal. 2009. “The Evolution of Class Inequality in Higher Education: Competition, Exclusion, and Adaptation.”American Sociological Review74(5):731–55.
2.
AveryChristopherGurantzOdedHurwitzMichaelSmithJonathan. 2018. “Shifting College Majors in Response to Advanced Placement Exam Scores.”Journal of Human Resources53(4):918–56.
3.
BastedoMichael N.HowardJoseph E.FlasterAllyson. 2016. “Holistic Admissions After Affirmative Action: Does ‘Maximizing’ the High School Curriculum Matter?”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis38(2):389–409.
4.
BennettPamela R.XieYu. 2003. “Revisiting Racial Differences in College Attendance: The Role of Historically Black Colleges and Universities.”American Sociological Review68(4):567–80.
5.
BowmanNicholas A.BastedoMichael N.2018. “What Role May Admissions Office Diversity and Practices Play in Equitable Decisions?”Research in Higher Education59(4):430–47.
6.
CalarcoJessica McCrory. 2020. “Avoiding Us versus Them: How Schools’ Dependence on Privileged ‘Helicopter’ Parents Influences Enforcement of Rules.”American Sociological Review85(2):223–46.
7.
CardDavidGiulianoLaura. 2016. “Universal Screening Increases the Representation of Low-Income and Minority Students in Gifted Education.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America113(48):13678–83.
8.
CharlesCamille Z.RoscignoVincent J.TorresKimberly C.2007. “Racial Inequality and College Attendance: The Mediating Role of Parental Investments.”Social Science Research36(1):329–52.
9.
ClotfelterCharles T.LaddHelen F.VigdorJacob L.2003. “Segregation and Resegregation in North Carolina's Public School Classrooms.”North Carolina Law Review81(4):1463–512.
College Division of Barron's Profiles of American Colleges. 2008. 2009 Barron's Profiles of American Colleges. Hauppauge, NY: Barron’s Educational Series.
12.
CongerDylanKennedyAlecLongMark C.McGhee, Jr.Raymond2021. “The Effect of Advanced Placement Science on Students’ Skills, Confidence, and Stress.”Journal of Human Resources56(1):93–124.
13.
CongerDylanLongMark C.IatarolaPatrice. 2009. “Explaining Race, Poverty, and Gender Disparities in Advanced Course-Taking.”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management28(4):555–76.
14.
ConwellJordan A.2020. “Diverging Disparities: Race, Parental Income, and Children's Math Scores, 1960-2009.”Sociology of Education110(9):1689–99.
15.
CortesKalena E.2010. “Do Bans on Affirmative Action Hurt Minority Students? Evidence from the Texas Top 10% Plan.”Economics of Education Review29(6):1110–24.
16.
CurtisKatherineLessemSarah. 2014. 2010 Census Chartbook: Demographic Trends in Wisconsin. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Madison Applied Population Laboratory.
17.
DiamondJohn B.2006. “Still Separate and Unequal: Examining Race, Opportunity, and School Achievement in ‘Integrated’ Suburbs.”The Journal of Negro Education75(3):495–505.
18.
DominaThurstonMcEachinAndrewHanselmanPaulAgarwalPriyankaHwangNaYoungLewisRyan. 2019. “Beyond Tracking and Detracking: The Dimensions of Organizational Differentiation in Schools.”Sociology of Education92(3):293–322.
19.
DowneyDouglas B.AinsworthJames W.QianZhenchao. 2009. “Rethinking the Attitude-Achievement Paradox among Blacks.”Sociology of Education82(1):1–19.
20.
DynarskiSusan M.HemeltSteven W.HymanJoshua M.2015. “The Missing Manual: Using National Student Clearinghouse Data to Track Postsecondary Outcomes.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis37(1S):53S–79S.
21.
EvansBrent J.2019. “How College Students Use Advanced Placement Credit.”American Educational Research Journal56(3):925–54.
FergusonRonald F.2003. “Teachers’ Perceptions and Expectations and the Black-white Test Score Gap.”Urban Education38(4):460–507.
24.
FoxLindsay. 2016. “Seeing Potential: The Effects of Student–Teacher Demographic Congruence on Teacher Expectations and Recommendations.”AERA Open 2(1). doi:10.1177/2332858415623758.
25.
FrancisDania V.DarityWilliam A.2020. “Isolation: An Alternative to the ‘Acting white’ Hypothesis in Explaining Black Under-Enrollment in Advanced Courses.”Journal of Economics, Race, and Policy3(2):117–22.
26.
FrancisDania V.De OliveiraAngela C. M.DimmittCarey. 2019. “Do School Counselors Exhibit Bias in Recommending Students for Advanced Coursework?”B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy19(4):1–47.
27.
GamoranAdam. 1992. “The Variable Effects of High School Tracking.”American Sociological Review57(6):812–28.
28.
GamoranAdamMareRobert D.1989. “Secondary School Tracking and Educational Inequality: Compensation, Reinforcement, or Neutrality?”American Journal of Sociology94(5):1146–83.
29.
GershensonSethHoltStephen B.PapageorgeNicholas W.2016. “Who Believes in Me? The Effect of Student–Teacher Demographic Match on Teacher Expectations.”Economics of Education Review52:209–24.
30.
GoffPeterCarlBradleyYangMinseok. 2018. “Supply and Demand for Public School Teachers in Wisconsin.” WCER Working Paper No. 2018-2. Madison, WI: Wisconsin Center for Education Research, University of Wisconsin–Madison.
31.
GrissomJason A.ReddingChristopher. 2016. “Discretion and Disproportionality: Explaining the Underrepresentation of High-Achieving Students of Color in Gifted Programs.”AERA Open2(1). doi:10.1177/2332858415622175.
32.
GurantzOded. 2019. “How College Credit in High School Impacts Postsecondary Course-Taking: The Role of AP Exams.” EdWorkingPaper No. 19-110. Providence, RI: Annenberg Institute at Brown University.
33.
HanselmanPaul. 2020. “Tournament Mobility in Mathematics Course-Taking Pathways.”Socius6. doi:10.1177/2378023120927604.
34.
HoutMichaelDiPreteThomas A.2006. “What We Have Learned: RC28’s Contributions to Knowledge about Social Stratification.”Research in Social Stratification and Mobility24(1):1–20.
35.
KarlsonKristian Bernt. 2015. “Expectations on Track? High School Tracking and Adolescent Educational Expectations.”Social Forces94(1):115–41.
36.
KellySean. 2007. “The Contours of Tracking in North Carolina.”The High School Journal90(4):15–31.
37.
KellySean. 2009. “The Black-white Gap in Mathematics Course Taking Effects of Mathematics Course.”Sociology of Education82(1):47–69.
38.
KellySeanCarbonaroWilliam. 2012. “Curriculum Tracking and Teacher Expectations: Evidence from Discrepant Course Taking Models.”Social Psychology of Education15(3):271–94.
39.
KellySeanPriceHeather. 2011. “The Correlates of Tracking Policy: Opportunity Hoarding, Status Competition, or a Technical-Functional Explanation?”American Educational Research Journal48(3):560–85.
40.
KolluriSuneal. 2018. “Advanced Placement: The Dual Challenge of Equal Access and Effectiveness.”Review of Educational Research88(5):671–711.
41.
LewisAmanda E.DiamondJohn B.2015. Despite the Best Intentions: How Racial Inequality Thrives in Good Schools. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
42.
Lewis-McCoyR. L’Heureux. 2014. Inequality in the Promised Land: Race, Resources, and Suburban Schooling. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
43.
LucasSamuel. 1999. Tracking Inequality: Stratification and Mobility in American High Schools. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
44.
LucasSamuel R.BerendsMark. 2002. “Sociodemographic Diversity, Correlated Achievement, and De Facto Tracking.”Sociology of Education75(4):328–48.
45.
LucasSamuel R.BerendsMark. 2007. “Race and Track Location in U.S. Public Schools.”Research in Social Stratification and Mobility25(3):169–87.
46.
LucasSamuel R.MolinaSantiago J.ToweyJohn M.2020. “Race/Ethnicity over Fifty Years of Structural Differentiation in K-12 Schooling: Period-Specific and Life-Course Perspectives.”Annual Review of Sociology46:355–78.
MelguizoTatiana. 2010. “Are Students of Color More Likely to Graduate from College If They Attend More Selective Institutions? Evidence from a Cohort of Recipients and Nonrecipients of the Gates Millennium Scholarship Program.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis32(2):230–48.
49.
MichelmoreKatherineDynarskiSusan M.2017. “The Gap within the Gap: Using Longitudinal Data to Understand Income Differences in Educational Outcomes.”AERA Open3(1). doi:10.1177/233285841769.
50.
MickelsonRoslyn Arlin. 1990. “The Attitude-Achievement Paradox among Black Adolescents.”Sociology of Education63(1):44–61.
51.
MickelsonRoslyn Arlin. 2001. “Subverting Swann: First- and Second-Generation Segregation in the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools.”American Educational Research Journal38(2):215–52.
52.
MilewskiGlenn B.GillieJacqueline M.2002. “What Are the Characteristics of AP® Teachers? An Examination of Survey Research.” The College Board Research Report No. 2002-10. College Entrance Examination Board, New York, NY.
53.
MoodyJames. 2001. “Race, School Integration, and Friendship Segregation in America.”American Journal of Sociology107(3):679–716.
54.
OakesJeannie. 1994. “More Than Misapplied Technology: A Normative and Political Response to Hallinan on Tracking.”Sociology of Education67(2):84–91.
55.
O’ConnorCarlaMuellerJenniferLewis-McCoyR. L’HeureuxRivas-DrakeDeborahRosenbergSeneca. 2011. “‘Being’ Black and Strategizing for Excellence in a Racially Stratified Academic Hierarchy.”American Educational Research Journal48(6):1232–57.
56.
PriceHeather E.2021. “The College Preparatory Pipeline: Disparate Stages in Academic Opportunities.”American Educational Research Journal58(4):785–814.
57.
RayVictor. 2019. “A Theory of Racialized Organizations.”American Sociological Review84(1):26–53.
58.
RodriguezAwildaMcGuireKeon M.2019. “More Classes, More Access? Understanding the Effects of Course Offerings on Black-white Gaps in Advanced Placement Course-Taking.”The Review of Higher Education42(2):641–79.
59.
RosenbaumJames E.1976. Making Inequality: The Hidden Curriculum of High School Tracking. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons Inc.
60.
RowlandM. LanceShircliffeBarbara J.2016. “Confronting the ‘Acid Test’: Educators’ Perspectives on Expanding Access to Advanced Placement at a Diverse Florida High School.”Peabody Journal of Education91(3):404–20.
SchneiderJack. 2009. “Privilege, Equity, and the Advanced Placement Program: Tug of War.”Journal of Curriculum Studies41(6):813–31.
63.
SmallMario L.WinshipChristopher. 2007. “Black Students’ Graduation from Elite Colleges: Institutional Characteristics and between-Institution Differences.”Social Science Research36(3):1257–75.
64.
SmeedingTimothy M.ThorntonKatherine. 2018. Poverty, Incomes, Race and Ethnicity in Wisconsin and Milwaukee: A Supplement to the 2016 Wisconsin Poverty Report. Madison, WI: Institute for Research on Poverty.
65.
SmithJonathanHurwitzMichaelAveryChristopher. 2017. “Giving College Credit Where It Is Due: Advanced Placement Exam Scores and College Outcomes.”Journal of Labor Economics35(1):67–147.
66.
SørensenAage Bøttger. 1970. “Organizational Differentiation of Students and Educational Opportunity.”Sociology of Education43(4):355–76.
67.
SpadeJoan Z.ColumbaLynnVanfossenBeth E.1997. “Tracking in Mathematics and Science: Courses and Course-Selection Procedures.”Sociology of Education70(2):108–27.
TaliaferroJocelyn De VanceDeCuirGunbyJessica T.2008. “African American Educators’ Perspectives on the Advanced Placement Opportunity Gap.”Urban Review40(2):164–85.
70.
TysonKarolyn. 2011. Integration Interrupted: Tracking, Black Students, and Acting white after Brown. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
71.
U.S. Department of Education. 2022. Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2022 Reading Assessment. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/.
72.
WooldridgeJeffrey M.1999. “Distribution-Free Estimation of Some Nonlinear Panel Data Models.”Journal of Econometrics90(1):77–97.
73.
YonezawaSusanWellsAmy StuartSernaIrene. 2002. “Choosing Tracks:‘Freedom of Choice’ in Detracking Schools.”American Educational Research Journal39(1):37–67.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
