Students with aligned educational and occupational expectations have improved college and labor market outcomes. Despite extensive knowledge about the ways social background and school context contribute to educational expectations, less is known about the role of social intuitions in shaping expectational alignment. Drawing on data from the 2009 High School Longitudinal Study, I estimate the magnitude of socioeconomic inequality in alignment. I examine how differences in observed student characteristics contribute to, and whether school-based postsecondary planning initiatives mitigate, that inequality. Results from multinomial regression models show large socioeconomic differences in ninth-grade alignment, and I identify achievement, attitudes about college and careers, and relationships with significant others as contributors to those differences. Participation in postsecondary planning is associated with reduced uncertainty and increased alignment, but this relationship does not differ by social background, indicating that the examined college and career planning policies do little to address inequality in alignment.
American School Counselor Association. 2012. ASCA School Counselor Competencies. Alexandria, VA: American School Counselor Association.
2.
American School Counselor Association. 2014. Mindsets and Behaviors for Student Success: K–12 College- and Career-Readiness Standards for Every Student. Alexandria, VA: American School Counselor Association.
3.
ArmstrongElizabeth A.HamiltonLaura T.2013. Paying for the Party. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
4.
AveryChristopherKaneThomas J.2004. “Student Perceptions of College Opportunities: The Boston COACH Program.” Pp. 355–94 in College Choices: The Economics of Where to Go, When to Go, and How to Pay For It, edited by HoxbyC. M.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
5.
BourdieuPierre. 1988. The State Nobility: Elite Schools in the Field of Power. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
6.
BozickR.AlexanderKarlEntwisleDorisDauberSusanKerrKerri. 2010. “Framing the Future: Revisiting the Place of Educational Expectations in Status Attainment.”Social Forces88(5):2027–52.
7.
BrintSteven. 2017. Schools and Societies. 3rd ed. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
8.
BuchmannClaudiaDaltonBen. 2002. “Interpersonal Influences and Educational Aspirations in 12 Countries: The Importance of Institutional Context.”Sociology of Education75(2):99–122.
9.
CeciStephen J.PapiernoPaul B.2005. “The Rhetoric and Reality of Gap Closing.”American Psychologist60(2):149–60.
10.
ConleyDavid T.2012. A Complete Definition of College and Career Readiness. Portland, OR: Educational Policy Improvement Center.
11.
DominaThurstonConleyAnnemarieFarkasGeorge. 2011. “The Link between Educational Expectations and Effort in the College-for-All Era.”Sociology of Education84(2):93–112.
12.
DominaThurstonPennerAndrewPennerEmily. 2017. “Categorical Inequality: Schools as Sorting Machines.”Annual Review of Sociology43(1):311–30.
13.
DuncanGreg J.MurnaneRichard J.2011. Whither Opportunity? Rising Inequality, Schools, and Children's Life Chances. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
14.
EcclesJacquelynne S.WigfieldAllan. 2001. “Motivational Beliefs, Values, and Goals.”Annual Review of Psychology53:109–32.
15.
EngbergMark E.WolniakGregory C.2010. “Examining the Effects of High School Contexts on Postsecondary Enrollment.”Research in Higher Education51(2):132–53.
16.
EntrichSteve R.2019. “More Individual Choice? Students’ Share in Decision-Making at the Transition to High School in Japan (1995–2009).”Asia Pacific Journal of Education39(3):271–89.
17.
FrankKenneth A.LinQinyunMaroulisSpiroMuellerAnna S.XuRanRosenbergJoshua M.HayterChristopher S.MahmoudRamy A.DietzThomasZhangLixin. 2021. “Hypothetical Case Replacement Can Be Used to Quantify the Robustness of Trial Results.”Journal of Clinical Epidemiology134:150–59.
18.
FreelinBrittany N.StaffJeremy. 2020. “Uncertain Adolescent Educational Expectations and College Matriculation in the Wake of the Great Recession.”Sociological Quarterly. doi:10.1080/00380253.2020.1816862.
19.
GambettaDiego. 1987. Were They Pushed or Did They Jump?Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
20.
GerberTheodore P.CheungSin Yi. 2008. “Horizontal Stratification in Postsecondary Education: Forms, Explanations, and Implications.”Annual Review of Sociology34(2008):299–318.
21.
GoldinClaudia DaleKatzLawrence F.2008. The Race between Education and Technology. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
22.
GoyetteKimberly A.2008. “College for Some to College for All: Social Background, Occupational Expectations, and Educational Expectations over Time.”Social Science Research37(2):461–84.
23.
GrodskyEricJacksonErika. 2009. “Social Stratification in Higher Education.”Teachers College Record111(10):2347–84.
24.
GrodskyEricRiegle-CrumbCatherine. 2010. “Those Who Choose and Those Who Don’t: Social Background and College Orientation.”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science627(1):14–35.
25.
GysbersNorman C.2013. “Career-Ready Students: A Goal of Comprehensive School Counseling Programs.”Career Development Quarterly61(3):283–88.
26.
HamiltonLauraRoksaJosipaNielsenKelly. 2018. “Providing a ‘Leg Up’: Parental Involvement and Opportunity Hoarding in College.”Sociology of Education91(2):111–31.
27.
HollandM. M.2015. “Trusting Each Other: Student- Counselor Relationships in Diverse High Schools.”Sociology of Education88(3):244–62.
28.
HollandM. M.DeLucaS.2016. “‘Why Wait Years to Become Something?’ Low-Income African American Youth and the Costly Career Search in For-Profit Trade Schools.”Sociology of Education89(4):1–18.
29.
HoxJoop. 1996. “The Basic Two-Level Regression Model.” Pp. 11–39 in Multilevel Analysis—Techniques and Applications, edited by Joop Hox. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
30.
HoxbyCarolineTurnerSarah. 2013. “Expanding College Opportunities for High-Achieving, Low Income Students.”Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Discussion Paper 12-01.
31.
HughesKatherine L.KarpMelinda Mechur. 2004. School-Based Career Development: A Synthesis of the Literature. New York: Institute on Education and the Economy, Teachers College, Columbia University.
32.
JacobBrian A.WilderTamara. 2011. “Educational Expectations and Attainment.” National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper Series, Working Paper 15683.
33.
JohnsonJeanRochkindJonOttAmber N.DupontSamantha. 2010. Can I Get a Little Advice Here? How an Overstretched High School Guidance System Is Undermining Students’ College Aspirations. San Francisco: Public Agenda.
34.
KimSoobinKlagerChristopherSchneiderBarbara. 2019. “The Effects of Alignment of Educational Expectations and Occupational Aspirations on Labor Market Outcomes: Evidence from NLSY79.”Journal of Higher Education90(6):992–1015.
35.
KuijpersM.MeijersF.GundyC.2011. “The Relationship between Learning Environment and Career Competencies of Students in Vocational Education.”Journal of Vocational Behavior78(1):21–30.
36.
KurbanElizabeth R.CabreraAlberto F.2019. “Building Readiness and Intention towards STEM Fields of Study: Using HSLS:09 and SEM to Examine This Complex Process among High School Students.”Journal of Higher Education91(4):620–50.
37.
LareauAnnette. 2011. Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life. 2nd ed. Berkeley: University of California Press.
38.
LegewieJoschaDiPreteThomas A.2014. “The High School Environment and the Gender Gap in Science and Engineering.”Sociology of Education87(4):259–80.
39.
MeeceJudith L.HutchinsBryan C.ByunSoo-yongFarmerT. W.IrvinMatthew J.WeissMargaret. 2013. “Preparing for Adulthood: A Recent Examination of the Alignment of Rural Youth's Future Educational and Vocational Aspirations.”Journal of Educational and Developmental Psychology3(2):175–92.
40.
MizeTrenton. 2019. “Best Practices for Estimating, Interpreting, and Presenting Nonlinear Interaction Effects.”Sociological Science6:81–117.
41.
MorganStephen L.2005. On the Edge of Commitment: Educational Attainment and Race in the United States. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
42.
MorganStephen L.GelbgiserDafnaWeedenKim A.2013. “Feeding the Pipeline: Gender, Occupational Plans, and College Major Selection.”Social Science Research42(4):989–1005.
43.
MorganStephen L.LeenmanTheodore S.ToddJennifer J.WeedenKim A.2012. “Occupational Plans, Beliefs about Educational Requirements, and Patterns of College Entry.”Sociology of Education83(3):197–217.
44.
MortimerJeylan T.Zimmer-GembeckMelanie J.HolmesMikkiShanahanMichael J.2002. “The Process of Occupational Decision Making: Patterns during the Transition to Adulthood.”Journal of Vocational Behavior61(3):439–65.
45.
NielsenKelly. 2015. “‘Fake It ’Til You Make It’: Why Community College Students’ Aspirations ‘Hold Steady.’”Sociology of Education88(4):265–83.
46.
PernaLaura W.Rowan-KenyonHeather T.ThomasScott L.BellAngelaAndersonRobertLiChunyan. 2008. “The Role of College Counseling in Shaping College Opportunity: Variations across High Schools.”Review of Higher Education31(2):131–59.
47.
RenzulliLindaBarrAshley B.2017. “Adapting to Family Setbacks: Malleability of Students’ and Parents’ Educational Expectations.”Social Problems64:351–72.
48.
RoderickMelissaCocaVanessaNagaokaJenny. 2011. “Potholes on the Road to College: High School Effects in Shaping Urban Students’ Participation in College Application, Four-Year College Enrollment, and College Match.”Sociology of Education84(3):178–211.
RosenbaumJames E.Deil-AmenReginaPersonAnn E.2006. After Admission: From College Access to College Success. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
51.
RosenbergJoshua M.XuRanFrankKenneth A.2018. Konfound-It! Quantify the Robustness of Causal Inferences. http://konfound-it.com.
52.
Rowan-KenyonHeather T.PernaLaura W.SwanAmy K.2011. “Structuring Opportunity: The Role of School Context in Shaping High School Students’ Occupational Aspirations.”Career Development Quarterly59(June):330–44.
53.
SabatesRicardoHarrisAngel L.StaffJeremy. 2011. “Ambition Gone Awry: The Long-Term Socioeconomic Consequences of Misaligned and Uncertain Ambitions in Adolescence.”Social Science Quarterly92(4):959–77.
54.
Schmitt-WilsonSarahFaasCaitlin. 2016. “Alignment of Educational and Occupational Expectations Influences on Young Adult Educational Attainment, Income, and Underemployment.”Social Science Quarterly97(5):1174–88.
55.
SchneiderBarbaraKimSoobinKlagerChristopher. 2017. “Co-development of Education Aspirations and Postsecondary Enrollment Especially among Students Who Are Low Income and Minority.”Research in Human Development14(2):143–60.
56.
SchneiderBarbaraStevensonDavid. 1999. The Ambitious Generation: America's Teenagers, Motivated but Directionless. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
57.
SewellWilliam H.HallerArchibald O.PortesAlejandro. 1969. “The Educational and Early Occupational Attainment Process.”American Sociological Review34(1):82–92.
58.
SewellWilliam H.HauserRobert M.1972. “Causes and Consequences of Higher Education: Models of the Status Attainment Process.”American Journal of Agricultural Economics54(5):851–61.
59.
SirinS. R.2005. “Socioeconomic Status and Academic Achievement: A Meta-analytic Review of Research.”Review of Educational Research75(3):417–53.
60.
StaffJeremyHarrisAngelSabatesRicardoBriddellLaine. 2010. “Uncertainty in Early Occupational Aspirations: Role Exploration or Aimlessness?”Social Forces89(2):659–83.
61.
StephanJennifer L.RosenbaumJames E.2013. “Can High Schools Reduce College Enrollment Gaps with a New Counseling Model?”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis35(2):200–19.
62.
StephanJennifer L.RosenbaumJames E.PersonAnn E.2009. “Stratification in College Entry and Completion.”Social Science Research38(3):572–93.
63.
WeedenKim A.GelbgiserDafnaMorganStephen L.2020. “Pipeline Dreams: Occupational Plans and Gender Differences in STEM Major Persistence and Completion.”Sociology of Education93(4):297–314.
64.
WelchMatthewFeyginAmyEnglishDavid. 2018. Iowa College and Career Readiness Indicators Literature Review. Chicago: Midwest Comprehensive Center and College and Career Readiness Center.
65.
WhistonSusan C.KellerBriana K.2004. “The Influences of the Family of Origin on Career Development: A Review and Analysis.”Counseling Psychologist32(4):493–568.
66.
WoodsChenoa S.DominaThurston. 2014. “The School Counselor Caseload and the High School– to–College Pipeline.”Teachers College Record116(10):1–30.
67.
XieYuGoyetteKimberly. 2003. “Social Mobility and the Educational Choices of Asian Americans.”Social Science Research32(3):467–98.
68.
YatesScott S.HarrisAngelSabatesRicardoStaffJeremy. 2010. “Early Occupational Aspirations and Fractured Transitions: A Study of Entry into ‘NEET’ Status in the UK.”Journal of Social Policy40(3):513–34.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
