This study estimates the effect of neighborhood disadvantage on bachelor’s degree attainment with data from a long-term follow-up of the Project on Human Development in Chicago Neighborhoods. We focus on heterogeneous effects by race and class as well as individual and neighborhood mechanisms that might explain observed patterns, including parents’ educational expectations, collective efficacy, social relationships, and neighborhood violence. Using newly developed methods for estimating longitudinal treatment effects, we find that cumulative neighborhood disadvantage in adolescence is strongly associated with lower bachelor’s attainment among high-income blacks and Latinos. We find no effect for whites and at most a modest effect among low- and middle-income blacks/Latinos. A sensitivity analysis suggests that the estimated effect for high-income blacks/Latinos is plausibly causal. These results support an advantage-leveling model of neighborhood effects and add important nuance for research considering how and for whom neighborhoods influence life chances.
AaronsonDaniel. 1998. “Using Sibling Data to Estimate the Impact of Neighborhoods on Children’s Educational Outcomes.”Journal of Human Resources33(4):915–46.
2.
AinsworthJames W.2002. “Why Does It Take a Village? The Mediation of Neighborhood Effects on Educational Achievement?”Social Forces81(1):117–52.
3.
BesbrisMaxFaberJacob WilliamRichPeterSharkeyPatrick. 2015. “Effect of Neighborhood Stigma on Economic Transactions.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences112(16):4994–98.
4.
BischoffKendraReardonSean F.2014. “Residential Segregation by Income, 1970–2009.” Pp. 208–33 in Diversity and Disparities, edited by LoganJ. R.New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
5.
Brooks-GunnJeanneDuncanGreg J.KlebanovPamela KatoSealandNaomi. 1993. “Do Neighborhoods Influence Child and Adolescent Development?”American Journal of Sociology99(2):353–95.
6.
BrowningChristopher R.BurringtonLori A.LeventhalTamaBrooks-GunnJeanne. 2008. “Neighborhood Structural Inequality, Collective Efficacy, and Sexual Risk Behavior among Urban Youth.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior49(3):269–85.
7.
BrowningChristopher R.CagneyKathleen A.2002. “Neighborhood Structural Disadvantage, Collective Efficacy, and Self-Rated Physical Health in an Urban Study.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43(4):383–99.
8.
CardDavid. 1999. “The Causal Effect of Education on Earnings.”Handbook of Labor Economics3:1801–63.
9.
CarlsonDevenCowenJoshua M.2015. “Student Neighborhoods, Schools, and Test Score Growth: Evidence from Milwaukee, Wisconsin.”Sociology of Education88(1):38–55.
10.
CascianoRebeccaMasseyDouglas S.2012. “Neighborhood Disorder and Individual Economic Self-Sufficiency: New Evidence from a Quasi-Experimental Study.”Social Science Research41:802–19.
11.
CharlesCamille Zubrinsky. 2003. “The Dynamics of Racial Residential Segregation.”Annual Review of Sociology29(1):167–207.
12.
ChettyRajHendrenNathanielJonesMaggie R.PorterSonya R.2018. “Race and Economic Opportunity in the United States: An Intergenerational Perspective.” NBER Working Paper No. 24441. https://www.nber.org/papers/w24441.
13.
ChettyRajHendrenNathanielKatzLawrence F.2016. “The Effects of Exposure to Better Neighborhoods on Children: New Evidence from the Moving to Opportunity Project.”American Economic Review106(4):855–902.
14.
ColemanJames S.1988. “Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.”American Journal of Sociology94:S95–120.
15.
CraneJonathan. 1991. “The Epidemic Theory of Ghettos and Neighborhood Effects on Dropping Out and Teenage Childbearing.”American Journal of Sociology96(5):1226–59.
16.
CrowderKyleSouthScott J.2003. “Neighborhood Distress and School Dropout: The Variable Significance of Community Context.”Social Science Research32(4):659–98.
17.
CrowderKyleSouthScott J.2011. “Spatial and Temporal Dimensions of Neighborhood Effects on High School Graduation.”Social Science Research40(1):87–106.
18.
DarrahJenniferDeLucaStefanie. 2014. “‘Living Here Has Changed My Whole Perspective’: How Escaping Inner-City Poverty Shapes Neighborhood and Housing Choice.”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management33(2):350–84.
19.
DiPreteThomas A.EirichGregory M.2006. “Cumulative Advantage as a Mechanism for Inequality: A Review of Theoretical and Empirical Developments.”Annual Review Sociology32:271–97.
20.
DowneyDouglas B.CondronDennis J.2016. “Fifty Years since the Coleman Report: Rethinking the Relationship between Schools and Inequality.”Sociology of Education89(3):207–20.
21.
DuncanGreg J.1994. “Families and Neighbors as Sources of Disadvantage in the Schooling Decisions of White and Black Adolescents.”American Journal of Education103(1):20–53.
22.
EcclesJacquelynne S.MidgleyCarolWigfieldAllanBuchananChristy MillerReumanDavidFlanaganConstanceIverDouglas Mac. 1993. “Development during Adolescence: The Impact of Stage-Environment Fit on Young Adolescents’ Experiences in Schools and Families.”American Psyhcologist48(2):90–101.
23.
EllwoodDavidKaneThomas J.2000. “Who Is Getting a College Education? Family Background and the Growing Gaps in Enrollment.” Pp. 283–324 in Securing the Future: Investing in Children from Birth to College, edited by DanzigerS.WaldfogelJ.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
24.
EnsmingerMargaret E.LamkinRebecca P.JacobsonNora. 1996. “School Leaving: A Longitudinal Perspective Including Neighborhood Effects.”Child Development67(5):2400–16.
25.
FosterE. MichaelMcLanahanSara. 1996. “An Illustration of the Use of Instrumental Variables: Do Neighborhood Conditions Affect a Young Person’s Chance of Finishing High School?”Psychological Methods1(3):249–60.
26.
GalsterGeorgeAnderssonRogerMusterdSakoKauppinenTimo M.2008. “Does Neighborhood Income Mix Affect Earnings of Adults? New Evidence from Sweden.”Journal of Urban Economics63:858–70.
27.
GalsterGeorgeMarcotteDave E.MandellMarvWolmanHalAugustineNancy. 2007. “The Influence of Neighborhood Poverty During Childhood on Fertility, Education, and Earnings Outcomes.”Housing Studies22(5):723–51.
28.
GintherDonnaHavemanRobertWolfeBarbara. 2000. “Neighborhood Attributes as Determinants of Children’s Outcomes: How Robust Are the Relationships?”Journal of Human Resources35(4):603–42.
29.
GoldsmithPat Rubio. 2009. “Schools or Neighborhoods or Both? Race and Ethnic Segregation and Educational Attainment.”Social Forces87:1913–41.
30.
GreenlandS.2003. “Quantifying Biases in Causal Models: Classical Confounding vs Collider-Stratification Bias.” Epidemiology14(3):300–306.
31.
HardingDavid J.2003. “Counterfactual Models of Neighborhood Effects: The Effect of Neighborhood Poverty on Dropping out and Teenage Pregnancy.”American Journal of Sociology109(3):676–719.
32.
KaoGraceThompsonJennifer S.2003. “Racial and Ethnic Stratification in Educational Achievement and Attainment.”Annual Review of Sociology29:417–42.
33.
KesslerRonald C.MickelsonKristin D.WilliamsDavid R.1999. “The Prevalence, Distribution, and Mental Health Correlates of Perceived Discrimination in the United States.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40(3):208–30.
34.
LeeBarrett A.OropesaR. S.KananJames W.1994. “Neighborhood Context and Residential Mobility.”Demography31(2):249–70.
35.
LevyBrian L.2018. “Heterogeneous Impacts of Concentrated Poverty during Adolescence on College Outcomes.”Social Forces. https://doi.org/10.1093/sf/soy116.
36.
LichterDaniel T.ParisiDomenicoTaquinoMichael C.2015. “Toward a New Macro-segregation? Decomposing Segregation within and between Metropolitan Cities and Suburbs.”American Sociological Review80(4):843–73.
37.
MasseyDouglas S.DentonNancy A.1993. American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
38.
MorganStephen L.WinshipChristopher. 2007. Counterfactuals and Causal Inference: Methods and Principles for Social Research. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
39.
O’RandAngela M.1996. “The Precious and the Precocious: Understanding Cumulative Disadvantage and Cumulative Advantage over the Life Course.”The Gerontologist36(2):230–38.
40.
OwensAnn. 2010. “Neighborhoods and Schools as Competing and Reinforcing Contexts for Educational Attainment.”Sociology of Education83(4):287–311.
41.
OwensAnnClampet-LundquistSusan. 2017. “Housing Mobility and the Intergenerational Durability of Neighborhood Poverty.”Journal of Urban Affairs39(3):400–20.
42.
PerkinsKristin L.SampsonRobert J.2015. “Compounded Deprivation in the Transition to Adulthood: The Intersection of Racial and Economic Inequality among Chicagoans, 1995–2013.”RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences1(1):35–54.
43.
ReardonSean F.2011. “The Widening Academic Achievement Gap between the Rich and the Poor: New Evidence and Possible Explanations.” Pp. 91–117 in Whither Opportunity? Rising Inequality, Schools, and Children’s Life Chances, edited by DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J.New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
44.
ReardonSean F.BischoffKendra. 2011. “Income Inequality and Income Segregation.”American Journal of Sociology116(4):1092–153.
45.
ReardonSean F.BischoffKendraOwensAnnTownsendJoseph B.2018. “Has Income Segregation Really Increased? Bias and Bias Correction in Sample-Based Segregation Estimates.”Demography55(6):2129–60.
46.
ReardonSean F.FoxLindsayTownsendJoseph. 2015. “Neighborhood Income Composition by Household Race and Income, 1990–2009.”The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science660(1):78–97.
47.
RenzulliLindaBarrAshley B.2017. “Adapting to Family Setbacks: Malleability of Students’ and Parents’ Educational Expectations.”Social Problems64(3):351–72.
48.
RubinowitzLeonard S.RosenbaumJames E.2000. Crossing the Class and Color Lines: From Public Housing to White Suburbia. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
49.
SampsonRobert J.2012. Great American City: Chicago and the Enduring Neighborhood Effect. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
50.
SampsonRobert J.GrovesW. Byron. 1989. “Community Structure and Crime: Testing Social-Disorganization Theory.”American Journal of Sociology94(4):774–802.
51.
SampsonRobert J.MorenoffJeffrey D.EarlsFelton J.1999. “Beyond Social Capital: Spatial Dynamics of Collective Efficacy for Children.”American Sociological Review64(5):633–60.
52.
SampsonRobert J.MorenoffJeffrey D.Gannon-RowleyThomas. 2002. “Assessing ‘Neighborhood Effects’: Social Processes and New Directions in Research.”Annual Review of Sociology28:443–78.
53.
SampsonRobert J.RaudenbushStephen W.1999. “Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces: A New Look at Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods.”American Journal of Sociology105(3):603–51.
54.
SampsonRobert J.RaudenbushStephen W.2004. “Neighborhood Seeing Disorder: Stigma and the Social Construction of ’Broken Windows.’”Social Psychology Quarterly67(4):319–42.
55.
SampsonRobert J.SharkeyPatrickRaudenbushStephen W.2008. “Durable Effects of Concentrated Disadvantage on Verbal Ability among African- American Children.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences105(3):845–52.
56.
SharkeyPatrick. 2010. “The Acute Effect of Local Homicides on Children’s Cognitive Performance.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America107(26):11733–38.
57.
SharkeyPatrick. 2014. “Spatial Segmentation and the Black Middle Class.”American Journal of Sociology119(4):903–54.
58.
SharkeyPatrickFaberJacob W.2014. “Where, When, Why, and for Whom Do Residential Contexts Matter? Moving Away from the Dichotomous Understanding of Neighborhood Effects.”Annual Review of Sociology40:559–79.
59.
SharkeyPatrickSchwartzAmy EllenEllenIngrid GouldLacoeJohanna. 2014. “High Stakes in the Classroom, High Stakes on the Street: The Effects of Community Violence on Student’s Standardized Test Performance.”Sociological Science1:199–220.
60.
SmallMario Luis. 2004. Villa Victoria: The Transformation of Social Capital in a Boston Barrio. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
61.
SmallMario LuisFeldmanJessica. 2012. “Ethnographic Evidence, Heterogeneity, and Neighbourhood Effects after Moving to Opportunity.” Pp. 57–77 in Neighbourhood effects research: New perspectives, edited by van HamM.ManleyD.BaileyN.SimpsonL.MaclennanD.London: Springer.
62.
SouthScott J.CrowderKyle D.1999. “Neighborhood Effects on Family Formation: Concentrated Poverty and Beyond.”American Sociological Review64(1):113–32.
63.
VanderWeeleTyler J.2009. “Marginal Structural Models for the Estimation of Direct and Indirect Effects.”Epidemiology20(1):18–26
64.
VanderWeeleTyler J.DingPeng. 2017. “Sensitivity Analysis in Observational Research: Introducing the E-Value.”Annals of Internal Medicine167(4):268–74.
65.
VenkateshSudhir A.2000. American Project: The Rise and Fall of a Modern Ghetto. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
WodtkeGeoffrey T.AlmirallDaniel. 2017. “Estimating Moderated Causal Effects with Time-Varying Treatments and Time-Varying Moderators: Structural Nested Mean Models and Regression with Residuals.”Sociological Methodology47(1):212–45.
68.
WodtkeGeoffrey T.ElwertFelixHardingDavid J.2016. “Neighborhood Effect Heterogeneity by Family Income and Developmental Period.”American Journal of Sociology121(4):1168–222.
69.
WodtkeGeoffrey T.HardingDavid J.ElwertFelix. 2011. “Neighborhood Effects in Temporal Perspective The Impact of Long-Term Exposure to Concentrated Disadvantage on High School Graduation.”American Sociological Review76(5):713–36.
70.
WodtkeGeoffrey T.ParbstMatthew. 2017. “Neighborhoods, Schools, and Academic Achievement: A Formal Mediation Analysis of Contextual Effects on Reading and Mathematics Abilities.”Demography54(5):1653–76.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
