This article examines the negotiation of sexual and religious identities of four celibate LGBTQ+ women who, as adults, convert to Catholicism. Through semi-structured interviews, a model of conversion was developed by integrating previous theoretical work on religion and identity. Important moments in the conversion process led to identity integration in these individuals: (1) Experiencing ‘The Call’ (the initial interest in Catholicism), (2) Encountering the Religious ‘Other’ (association with a welcoming and enduring Catholic LGBTQ+ Community), (3) Immersion in Church Teaching (relationship with Church Teaching and social movements in the Church), (4) Reframing Identity in the Context of the Church (internal restructuring of identity importance). Interviews with the four respondents indicate that some celibate LBGTQ women who choose to convert to Catholicism may experience minimal levels of cognitive dissonance.
BaumeisterRFShapiroJPTiceDM (1985) Two kinds of identity crisis. Journal of Personality53(3): 407–424.
2.
BiggsABroughP (2005) Investigating the moderating influences of gender upon role salience and work-family conflict. Equal Opportunities International24(2): 30–41.
BoswellJ (2015) Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality: Gay People in Western Europe from the Beginning of the Christian Era to the Fourteenth Century, Thirty-fifth Anniversary Edition. Chicago, IL; London: The University of Chicago Press.
5.
CooperJFazioR (1984) A new look at cognitive dissonance theory. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology17: 229–265.
6.
DeguaraA (2018) Destroying false images of God: The experiences of LGBT Catholics. Journal of Homosexuality65(3): 317–337.
7.
DillonM (2018) Postsecular Catholicism: Relevance and Renewal. New York: Oxford university press.
8.
DufourLR (2000) Sifting through tradition: The creation of Jewish feminist identities. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion39(1): 90–106.
9.
FestingerL (1957) A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
10.
GoffmanE (1959) The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
11.
HalamaPHalamováJ (2005) Process of religious conversion in the Catholic Charismatic movement: A qualitative analysis. Archive for the Psychology of Religion27(1): 69–92.
12.
HartJRichardsonD (1981) The Theory and Practice of Homosexuality. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Law Book Company of Australasia.
13.
HoughtonMTaskerF (2021) Exploring lesbian and bisexual Catholic women’s narratives of religious and sexual identity formation and integration. Journal of Homosexuality68(1): 47–69.
14.
JonesSRAbesES (2013) Identity Development of College Students: Advancing Frameworks for Multiple Dimensions of Identity. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.
15.
LampeNCavendishJSumerauJE (2019) Producing an LGBT religious organizational identity: The case of DignityUSA. The Qualitative Report24(9): 2164–2177.
16.
MahaffyKA (1996) Cognitive dissonance and its resolution: A study of lesbian Christians. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion35(4): 392–402.
17.
PeshkinA (1986) God’s Choice: The Total World of Christian Fundamentalist School. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
RamboLR (1992) The psychology of conversion. In:MalonyHNSouthardS (eds) Handbook of Religious Conversion. Birmingham: Religious Education Press, pp.159–177.
21.
RamboLR (1993) Understanding Religious Conversion. New Haven, CT and London: Yale University Press.
22.
RodriguezEM (2010) At the intersection of Church and gay: A review of the psychological research on gay and lesbian Christians. Journal of Homosexuality57(1): 5–38.
23.
RodriguezEMOuelletteSC (2000) Gay and lesbian Christians: Homosexual and religious identity integration in the members and participants of a gay-positive Church. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion39(3): 333–347.
24.
StrykerSBurkeP (2000) The past, present, and future of an identity theory. Social Psychology Quarterly63(4): 284–297.
25.
SubhiNGeelanD (2012) When Christianity and homosexuality collide: Understanding the potential intrapersonal conflict. Journal of Homosexuality59(10): 1382–1402.
26.
ThummaS (1991) Negotiating a religious identity: The Case of the gay evangelical. Sociological Analysis52(4): 333–347.
27.
WedowRSchnabelLWedowLKDKoniecznyME (2017) ‘I’m Gay and I’m Catholic’: Negotiating two complex identities at a Catholic University. Sociology of Religion: A Quarterly Review78(3): 289–317.
28.
WilcoxMM (2002) When Sheila’s a lesbian: Religious individualism among lesbian gay, bisexual, and transgender Christians. Sociology of Religion63: 497–513.
29.
WilcoxMM (2003) Coming Out in Christianity: Religion Identity and Community. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
30.
WilcoxMM (2009) Queer Women and Religious Individualism. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
31.
YarhouseMABurkettLAKreeftEM (2002) Paraprofessional Christian ministries for sexual behavior and same-sex identity concerns. Journal of Psychology and Theology30(3): 209–227.
32.
YipAKT (1997) Dare to differ: Gay and lesbian Catholics’ assessment of official Catholic positions on sexuality. Sociology of Religion58(2): 165–180.
33.
YipAKT (2002) The persistence of faith among non-heterosexual Christians: Evidence for the neo-secularization Thesis of religious transformation. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion41(2): 199–212.
34.
YipAKT (2005) Religion and the politics of spirituality/sexuality: Reflections on researching British lesbian gay, and bisexual Christians and Muslims. Fieldwork in Religion1(3): 271–289.
