This study attempts to simulate management's earnings per-share forecasts using six naive time series models. The results indicate two (random walk and random walk with a drift) of the six models were significantly more accurate than the other four models in simulating management's earnings forecast. Both exhibited a tendency to consistently underforecast earnings, and it was hypoth esized that this could be due to an inherent bias in the data.
The results for the remainingfour models were not as favorable. The two submartingales and the simple linear trend models exhibited a high degree of variability in accuracy and significant biases based on the magnitude of the forecast. The arithmetic average model appeared to be unbiased but exhibited a high degree of variability. The results of the study indicate that it may be possible to simulate management's earnings forecasts using relatively naive mathemati cal models.
Albrecht, W.S., L.L. Lookabill and J.C. McKeown"The Time Series Properties of Annual Earnings," Journal of Accounting Research (Autumn, 1977), pp. 226-244.
2.
Ajinkya, B.B. and M.J. Gift "Corporate Managers' Earnings Forecasts and Symmetrical Adjustments of Market Expectations," Journal of Accounting Research (Autumn, 1984), pp. 425-444.
3.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, Financial Forecasts and Projects Task Force, Guide for Review of a Financial Forecast, (AICPA,1980).
4.
_______, Auditing Standards Board, Statement on Standards for Accountant's Services on Prospective Financial Information, (AICPA,1985).
5.
Baker, H.K. and J.A. Haslem "Information Needs of Individual Investors ," Journal of Accountancy (November, 1973), pp. 64-69.
6.
Basi, B.A. , K.J. Carey and R.D. Twark "A Comparision of the Accuracy of Corporate and Security Analysts' Forecasts of Earnings ," The Accounting Review (April, 1976), pp. 244-254.
7.
Brown, L.D. and M.S. Rozeff "The Superiority of Analysts Forecasts as Measures of Expectations: The Journal of Finance . (March, 1978), pp.1-16.
8.
Cameron, A.B. "A Comparison of the Accuracy of Management Earnings Forecasts and Alternative Surrogate Measures," Ph.D. diss., University of Utah (1982).
9.
_______, "A Review of Management's Earnings Forecast Research ," Journal of Accounting Literature (1986 ), PP.57-83.
10.
Cameron, A.B. and J.W. Bartley "A New Look at the Accuracy of Managers' Earnings Forecasts," Unpublished working paper, University of Utah (1987).
11.
Chant, P.D. "On the Predictability of Corporate Earnings Per Share Behavior," Journal of Finance (March, 1980), pp. 13-21.
12.
Copeland, R.M. and R.J. Marioni "Executives Forecasts of Earnings per Share Versus Forecasts of Naive Models," Journal of Business (October,1972), pp. 497-512.
13.
Crichfield, T., T. Dyckman and J. Lakonishok "An Evaluation of Security Analysts' Forecasts," The Accounting Review (July,1978 ), pp. 651-668.
14.
Elton, E.J. and M.J. Gruber "Earnings Estimates and the Accuracy of Expectation Data," Management Science (April, 1972), pp. 409-424.
15.
Foster, G. "Stock Market Reaction to Estimates of Earnings per Share by Company Officials," Journal of Accounting Research (Spring, 1973), pp. 25-37.
16.
Green, D. and J. Segall "The Predictive Power of First Quarter Earnings Reports: A Replication," Empirical Research in Accounting: Selected Studies, Supplement to Vol. 4, Journal of Accounting Research (1966), pp. 21-36.
17.
_______, "The Predictive Power of First Quarter Earnings Reports," The Journal of Business (January, 1967), pp. 44-55.
18.
Hassell, J.M. and R.H. Jennings "Relative Forecast Accuracy and the Timing of Earnings Forecast Announcements," The Accounting Review . (January,1986), pp. 58-75.
19.
Imhoff, E. "The Representativeness of Management's Earnings Forecasts," The Accounting Review (October, 1978), pp. 836-850.
20.
Imhoff, E. and P. Pare "Analysis and Comparison of Earnings Forecast Agents," Journal of Accounting Research (Autunm, 1982), pp. 429-439.
21.
Jaggi, B. "Further Evidence on the Accuracy of Management Forecasts Vis-a-Vis Analysts' Forecasts," The Accounting Review (January,1980), pp. 96-101.
22.
Johnson, T.E. and T.G. Schmitt "Effectiveness of Earnings per Share Forecasts ," Financial Management (Summer, 1974), pp. 64-72.
23.
Lev, B. and S. Sunder "Methodological Issues in the Use of Financial Ratios," Journal of Accounting and Economics (1979), pp.187-210.
24.
McGrath, P.S. and F.J. Walsh "Disclosure of Financial Forecasts to Security Analysts and the Public," The Conference Board Report No. 602 (1973), pp. 1-23.
25.
Morton, B. "Reporting Profit Expectations," Management Accounting (February,1972), pp. 33-37.
26.
Nickerson, C.A., L.E. Pointer and R.H. Strawser "Published Forecasts: Choice or Obligation ?," Financial Executive (February, 1974), pp. 70-73.
27.
Patell, J.M. "Corporate Forecasts of Earnings per Share and Stock Price Behavior: Empirical Tests," Journal of Accounting Research (Autumn,1976), pp. 246-276.
28.
Penman, S.H. "An Empirical Investigation of the Voluntary Disclosure of Corporate Earnings Forecasts," Journal of Accounting Research (Spring,1980), pp.132-160.
29.
Ruland, W. "The Accuracy of Forecasts by Management and by Financial Analysts," The Accounting Review (April, 1978), pp. 439-447.
30.
Schreuder, H. and J. Klaassen "Confidential Revenue and Profit Forecasts by Management and Financial Analysts: Evidence from the Netherlands ," The Accounting Review (January,1984 ), pp. 64-77.
31.
Securities and Exchange Commission "Disclosure of Projections of Future Economic Performance," Release No. 33-5581 (April, 1975).
32.
_______, "Safe Habor Rule for Projections," Release No. 6084 and 15944 (June, 1979).
33.
_______, . "Instructions for the Presentation of Pro Forma Financial Information and Requirements for Financial Statements of Businesses Acquired or to be Acquired," Release No. 33-6413 (July,1982).
34.
Watts, R.L. and R.W. Leftwich "The Time Series of Annual Earnings," Journal of Accounting Research (Autumn, 1977), pp. 253-271.
35.
Waymire, G. "Additional Evidence on the Accuracy of Analyst Forecasts Before and After Voluntary Management Earnings Forecasts," The Accounting Review (January 1986), pp.129-142.
