The Management of Operable Breast Cancer in Scotland Surgeons' Opinions

Abstract

This report gives the responses of general surgeons in Scotland to two questionnaires. Satisfactory rates were obtained: 82% for the more detailed survey in 1988 and 62% for the second survey (1991), where non-respondents were not followed up. In 1988 the rationale was the poor participation in the Scottish breast conservation trial while the 1991 survey further investigated the diversity of surgical opinion identified in the first. The limited trial support in 1988 was mainly due to reluctance to accept all treatment options. The majority were prepared to consider trial participation although 47% believed this compromised doctor-patient relationships. Although breast-conserving therapy was widely supported, many different views on management were encountered, both in the degree of influence of specific factors and in the decisions taken in relation to them. We believe these surveys have re-inforced a need for management guidelines, particularly as around half the patients with symptomatic breast cancer were being treated in non-specialist units.