Prisons and Rural Pennsylvania Communities: Exploring the Health of the Relationship and the Possibility of Improvement

Abstract

This article is part of a larger study that sought to measure community satisfaction with and perceptions about the economic impact of state correctional facilities located within four rural communities in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.The project culminated in the development of recommendations for policies that could benefit rural communities presently hosting, or considering hosting, a correctional institution. This article briefly discusses the relevant literature and the methodology used in the study and then presents and discusses policy recommendations in a rank ordering based on their relative importance. The goal of this research is to recommend policies that may improve the sometimes strained relationships between correctional institutions and their host communities.

Keywords

prison siting economic impact community satisfaction policy recommendations prison infrastructure prison—community relationship NIMBY

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrams, K.S. ( 1988). Prisons as LULUs: A sequel, part 2. Environmental and Urban Issues, 15, 24-27.

American Correctional Association. (2003, January). Standards for adult correctional institutions (4th ed.) (ACA Standard 4-4020). Alexandria, VA: Author.

Beale, C. ( 1998). Rural prisons: An update. Rural Development Perspectives, 11, 25-27.

Beck, A.J. , & Gilliard, D.K. (1995). Prisoners in 1994 (NCJ 151654). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Carlson, K.A. ( 1991). What happens and what counts: Resident assessments of prison impacts on their communities. Humboldt Journal of Social Relations, 17, 211-237.

Carlson, K.A. ( 1992). Doing good and looking bad: A case study of prison/community relations. Crime and Delinquency, 38, 56-68.

Carlson, K.A. ( 1995). Prisons and rural communities: Making the most and losing the least from a growth industry. In D. W. Sears & J. N. Reid (Eds.), Rural development strategies (pp. 189-203). Chicago: Nelson-Hall.

Center for Rural Pennsylvania. (2001, November/December). Just the facts: Prison population growth (Newsletter) . Retrieved November 27, 2009, from http://www.ruralpa.org/news1101.html

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. (2003). Governor’s annual work force report. Retrieved August 5, 2003, from http://www.hrm.state.pa.us/oahrm/cwp/view.asp?a=135&q=160982

10.

Courtright, K.E. ( 2002). Video review [Review of the film Profits of Punishment] . Criminal Justice Policy Review, 13, 286-293.

11.

Courtright, K.E. , Hannan, M.J. , Packard, S.H. , & Brennan, E.T. ( 2006). Prisons and rural communities: Exploring economic impact and community satisfaction (Final Report). Harrisburg, PA: The Center for Rural Pennsylvania.

12.

Dickinson, C.J. ( 2003). Group: Rural prisons don’t provide economic boost . Central New York Business Journal, 17, 4-6.

13.

Donzinger, S. ( 1996). The real war on crime. New York: HarperCollins.

14.

Doyle, Z. ( 2002). Does crime pay? Pros and cons of rural prisons. Retrieved February 22, 2005, from http://www.nado.org/pub/july021.html

15.

Farkas, M.A. ( 1999). Not in my backyard: The issues and complexities surrounding prison siting. The Justice Professional, 12, 95-109.

16.

Glasmeier, A.K. , & Farrigan, T. ( 2007). The economic impacts of the prison development boom on persistently poor rural places. International Regional Science Review, 30, 274-299.

17.

Harrison, P.M. , & Beck, A.J. ( 2005). Prisoners in 2004 (NCJ 210677). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics .

18.

Hooks, G. , Mosher, C. , Rotolo, T. , & Lobao, L. ( 2004). The prison industry: Carceral expansion and employment in U.S. counties, 1969-1994. Social Sciences Quarterly, 85, 37-57.

19.

Imhoff, E.C. ( 2002). Determining the socioeconomic impacts of prison construction on rural communities: A case study of Somerset, Pennsylvania. Unpublished master’s thesis, Pennsylvania State University.

20.

King, R.S. , Mauer, M. , & Huling, T. ( 2004). An analysis of the economics of prison siting in rural communities. Criminology and Public Policy, 3, 453-480.

21.

Lawrence, S. , & Travis, J. ( 2004). The new landscape of imprisonment: Mapping America’s prison expansion (JPC Publication: CPR04 0121). Washington, DC: Urban Institute-Justice Policy Center.

22.

Marquart, J. ( 2004). Economic development is in the eye of the beholder. Criminology and Public Policy, 3, 489-492.

23.

Martin, R. , Champion, D. , & Gibney, T. ( 2002). Community perceptions about prison construction: A case study. In R. L. Gido & T. Alleman (Eds.), Turnstile justice: Issues in American corrections (2nd ed., pp. 176-207). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

24.

Martin, R. , Champion, D. , Gibney, T. , & Radakovic, G. ( 1999). SCI Pine Grove community impact survey descriptive analyses and report: Pine Grove Project Annual Report 1998-1999. Submitted to the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections.

25.

Martin, R. , & Myers, D.L. ( 2005). Public response to prison siting: Perceptions of impact on crime and safety. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 32, 143-171.

26.

Maxim, P. , & Plecas, D. ( 1983). Prisons and their perceived impact on the local community: A case study. Social Indicators Research, 13, 39-58.

27.

McShane, M.D. , & Williams, F.P. , III. (1992). Prison impact studies: Some comments on methodological rigor. Crime & Delinquency , 38, 105-120.

28.

Prison inmate count highest in history. (2003, January 27). Erie Times-News, p. B2.

29.

Sabol, W.J. , & Couture, H. ( 2008). Prison inmates at midyear 2007 (NCJ 221944). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.

30.

Sabol, W.J. , Couture, H. , & Harrison, P.M. (2007). Prisoners in 2006 (NCJ 219416). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.

31.

Schlosser, E. ( 1998). The prison-industrial complex. Atlantic Monthly, 282, 51-77.

32.

Shichor, D. ( 1992). Myths and realities in prison siting. Crime & Delinquency, 38, 70-87.

33.

Silas, F.A. ( 1984). Not in my neighborhood. American Bar Association Journal, 70(27), 27-29.

34.

Swanson, C. ( 1993). Citizens’ perceptions of prison effects on their community. State and Local Government Review, 25, 107-116.

35.

Swift, R.B. ( 2007, February 11). Corrections planning for prison expansion . The Daily Item. Retrieved February 12, 2007 , from http://www.dailyitem.com

36.

Thies, J.M. ( 2000, April). Prisons and host communities: Debunking the myths and rebuilding community relations. Corrections Today, 62, 136-139.

37.

Tully, H.A. , Winter, J.P. , Wilson, J.E. , & Scanlon, T.J. ( 1982). Correctional institution impact and host community resistance . Canadian Journal of Criminology, 24, 133-139.

38.

U.S. Department of Justice. (1992). Issues in siting correctional facilities. Washington, DC : Government Printing Office.

39.

Young, M.G. ( 1998). Rethinking community resistance to a prison siting: Results from a community impact assessment. Canadian Journal of Criminology , 40, 323-327.