Co-operation or unification: Is the future of police multi-agency working simply to become one agency?

Abstract

In 2014 Professor Tim Hope stated that he would “give up the police service”, proposing that the “police service should merge thoroughly with health, ambulance and fire services to become a harm-response service”. This article examines the practicalities of such a proposal,considering different aspects within policing that require multi-agency co-operation and whether that could be replaced by unification. It concludes that in all instances, bar one notable exception in the form of mental health response, the police necessarily stand apart from other agencies for good reason and that unification would be counterproductive to Hope's aims.

Keywords

Police Multi-Agency Harm Public Protection Community Policing MASH MARAC Mental Health

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act (2014) Legislation.gov.uk. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2014/12/contents.

Banks

Dutch

Wang

(2008) Collaborative efforts to improve system response to families who are experiencing child maltreatment and domestic violence. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 23(7): 876–902.

Barak

Weinborn

Sherman

(2016) Soft” policing at hot spots - do police community support officers work? A randomized controlled trial. Experimental Criminology 12: 277–317.

Barclay

(2011) ‘The Extremist Reaction to the UK’s Prevent Strategy. Current Trends in Islamist Ideology 12: 73–91.

Bartkowiak-Théron

Asquith

(2012) ‘Vulnerability and diversity in policing. In: Bartkowiak-Théron

Asquith

(eds.), Policing Vulnerability. Annadale, VA: Federation Press, pp. 278–293.

BBC News (2017) Bijan Ebrahimi: Police ‘failed’ murdered man for years. BBC News. [Online] Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-bristol-40494218 (accessed on 9 March 2022).

Bernard

Harris

(2016) Safeguarding Black Children: Good Practice in Child Protection. London, UK: Jessica Kingsley.

Bichard

(2004) The Bichard Inquiry Report. London, UK: The Stationery Office.

Blackburn

, (2015 22 April) Mass killings of strikers warrant international investigation, International Union Rights 22, 12.

10.

Braga

Turchan

Papachristos

, et al. (2019) Hot spots policing of small geographic areas effects on crime. Campbell Systematic Reviews 15(1046).

11.

Brown

(2016) Mental Health Cop. [Online] Available at https://mentalhealthcop.wordpress.com/2016/04/24/police-crisis-care-responses-part-2 (accessed on 14 November 2021).

12.

Carley

Mackway-Jones

Donnan

(1998) Major incidents in Britain over the past 28 years: the case for the centralised reporting of major incidents. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 52: 392–398.

13.

Cashmore

Jordan

(2017) Have Community Protection Officers (CPO’s) met Expectations? Managerial opinions of Nottingham City Council’s wardens as policing partners. Internet Journal of Criminology. Available at: https://www.internetjournalofcriminology.com/_files/ugd/b93dd4_11c303282a9e4ad5b7011276555f3bd8.pdf.

14.

Chaytor

(2009) Fiona Pilkington yobs protected by police. The Mirror 30. Available at: https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/fiona-pilkington-yobs-protected-by-police-421707.

15.

Civil Contingencies Act (2004) Legislation.gov.uk. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/36/contents.

16.

Coates

Kautt

Mueller-Johnson

(2009) Penalty notices for disorder: influences on police decision making. Journal of Experimental Criminology 5(4): 399–428.

17.

Coleman

(2018) Angry People in Local Newspapers. London, UK: Michael Joseph.

18.

College of Policing (2015a) College of Policing Analysis: Estimating Demand on the Police Service, s.L. College of Policing.

19.

College of Policing (2015b) Harm’s Way: The Role of the Police in Keeping Children Safe. London, UK: HMSO.

20.

College of Policing (2021a) College of Policing APP Critical Incident Management. Ryton-on-Dunsmore, UK: College of Policing. Available at: https://www.app.college.police.uk/app-content/critical-incident-management/phase-2-managing-critical-incidents/.

21.

College of Policing (2021b) Briefing Note for Adults at Risk: Initial Response and Safeguar``ding, s.L. Ryton-on-Dunsmore, UK: College of Policing.

22.

Crawford

Lister

Blackburn

, et al. (2005) Plural Policing: The Mixed Economy of Visible Patrols in England and Wales. Bristol, England: The Policy Press.

23.

Crime and Act, Disorder (1998). [Online] Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/37/section/17 (accessed on 16 June 2021).

24.

Crimestoppers (n.d) Who We Are. Crimestoppers-uk.org. Available at: https://crimestoppers-uk.org/about-the-charity/who-we-are.

25.

Criminal Justice and Court Services Act (2000) Legislation.gov.uk. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/43/contents.

26.

Dandurand

Farr

(2010) A Review of Selected Witness Protection Programmes. Canada: Research and National Coordination, Organized Crime Division, Law Enforcement and Policy Branch. Available at: https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2011/sp-ps/PS4-96-2010-eng.pdf.

27.

Derbyshire Times (2016) Derbyshire’s new joint police and firs headquarters unveiled. Derbyshire Times. Available at: https://www.derbyshiretimes.co.uk/news/derbyshires-new-joint-police-and-fire-headquarters-unveiled-767378.

28.

Duncan

EAS

Best

Dougall

, et al. (2019) Epidemiology of emergency ambulance service calls related to mental health problems and self harm: a national record linkage study. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine 27(34): 34.

29.

Dunne

Finalay

(2016) Multi-Agency Safeguarding Hub - A New Way of Working. Archives of Disease in Childhood 101: A369–A370.

30.

Felitti

Anda

Nordenberg

, et al. (1998) Relationship of Childhood Abuse and Household Dysfunction to Many of the Leading Causes of Death in Adults. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 14(4): 245–258.

31.

Ferrandino

Joseph

(2013) Community Policing: What It Is Not. In: Peak

Kenneth

(ed). Encyclopedia of Community Policing and Problem Solving. London: SAGE Publications, 61–65.

32.

Fleming

Goodman

Knight

, et al. (2006) Delivering effective multi-agency work for victims and witnesses of crime. Practice 18(4): 265–278.

33.

Ford

Newbury

Meredith

, et al. (2020) Understanding the outcome of police safeguarding notifications to social services in South Wales. The Police Journal: Theory, Practice and Principles 93(2): 87–108.

34.

Fyson

Kitson

(2012) Outcomes following adult safeguarding alerts: a critical analysis of key factors. The Journal of Adult Protection 14(2): 93–103.

35.

Gearson

Berry

(2021) British Troops on British Streets: Defence’s Counter-Terrorism Journey from 9/11 to Operation Temperer. Taylor, Francis: Studies in Conflict & Terrorism. online(https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/citedby/10.1080/1057610X.2021.1902604?scroll=top&needAccess=true)

36.

Gresham

Stockdale

Bartholomew

(2003) Evaluating the Impact of Crimestoppers. London, UK: Home Office.

37.

Government

H M

(2018) CONTEST: The United Kingdom’s Strategy for Countering Terrorism. London, UK: HM Government.

38.

Harvie

Manzi

(2011) Interpreting Multi-Agency Partnerships: Ideology, Discourse and Domestic Violence. Social & Legal Studies 20(1): 79–95.

39.

Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary (2015) PEEL: Police Effectiveness 2015 (Vulnerability) A National Overview, s.L. Cardiff, Glamorgan: HMIC.

40.

HMICFRS (2021) Strategy 2021–25. Available at: https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/wp-content/uploads/hmicfrs-strategy-2021-25.pdf.

41.

Holmes

(2021) Comfort Zone: A Life of Challenge, Risk and Reward. Nottingham, Texas: Self.

42.

Home Office (1991) Safer Communities: The Local Delivery of Crime Prevention through the Partnership Approach. London, UK: Home Office.

43.

Home Office (2010) National Support Framework: Delivering Safer And Confident Communities, s.L. London, UK: Home Office.

44.

Home Office (2014) Multi Agency Working and Information Sharing Project: Final Report. London, UK: Home Office.

45.

Hope

(2008) Dodgy evidence - fallacies and facts of crime reduction. Safer Communities 7(3): 35–38.

46.

Hope

(2009) The illusion of control. Criminology & Criminal Justice 9(2): 125–134.

47.

Hope

(2014) ‘I would Give up the Police Service. London, UK: Center of Crime and Justice Studies. [Online] Available at: https://www.crimeandjustice.org.uk/resources/i-would-give-police-service.

48.

Hope

(2015) Things can only get better. Criminal Justice Matters 102(1): 6–8.

49.

Hope

(2020) Epistemic public criminology: The fallacies of evidence-based policing. In: Daems

Pleysier

(eds), Criminology and Democratic Politics. London, UK: Routledge.

50.

Housing Act (1996) Legislation.gov.uk. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/52/contents.

51.

Huggins

Benjamin

(2018) New Police and Fire Community Support Officer role is piloted in Salisbury. What Works - College of Policing. Available at: https://whatworks.college.police.uk/About/News/Pages/PFCSO.aspx.

52.

Independent Police Complaints Commission (2009) IPCC Report into the Contact between Fiona Pilkingtonand Leicestershire Constabulary 2004-2007, s.L. London, UK: Independent Police Complaints Commission.

53.

Innes

Weston

(2010) Re-thinking the Policing of Anti-social Behaviour. Cardiff, Glamorgan: HMIC.

54.

Ipsos

(2012) Policing Anti-social Behaviour - the Public Perspective: Wave 2, s.L. London, UK: Ipsos MORI.

55.

JESIP (2016) JESIP Fact Sheet 1, s.L: Joint Emergency Interoperability Protocols. Venice, Italy: JESIP

56.

Johnston

(1993) Privatisation and Protection: Spatial and Sectoral Ideologies in British Policing and Crime Prevention. The Modern Law Review 56(6): 771–792.

57.

Johnston

(2003) From ‘pluralisation’ to ‘the police extended family’: discourses on the governance of community policing in Britain. International Journal of the Sociology of Law 31(3): 185–204.

58.

Kerslake

(2018) The Kerslake Report.

59.

King

, et al. (2014) Improving information sharing in safeguarding: MASH in London. Advances in Dual Diagnosis 7(1).

60.

Kitchener

Haydon

(1959) 'A City's Crime-Buster Writes Fairy Tales. In: Electrical Double Layer in Colloid ScienceNature. 3rd May. North Sydney, New South Wales: Sydney Morning Herald, 183, pp. 78–80.

61.

Laming (2003) The Victoria Climbié Inquiry, s.l. Wembley, England: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.

62.

Lipsky

(1980) Street Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. s.l. New York City, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

63.

Lock

(2013) Serious Case Review Re: Daniel Pelka, Coventry. Coventry Safeguarding Children Board.

64.

Haringey

LSCB

(2009) Serious Case Review: Baby Peter, sl.

65.

Maguire

, et al. (2001) ‘Risk Management of Sexual and Violent Offenders: The Work of Public Protection Panels. In: Police Research Series Paper, No. 139. London, UK: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate.

66.

Marriott

Shelley

(2022) Take a look inside the new joint Nottinghamshire police and fire headquarters. Worksop Guardian. Available at: https://www.worksopguardian.co.uk/news/people/take-a-look-at-new-joint-nottinghamshire-police-and-fire-headquarters-3549463.

67.

McCallum

(2017). Multi-Agency Learning Review Following The Murder of Bijan Ebrahimi. Bristol, Massachusetts: Safer Bristol Partnership.

68.

McCoy

Butler

Quigg

(2016) Evaluation of the Liverpool Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conference (MARAC). Mount Pleasant, Liverpool: John Moores University.

69.

McLaughlin

, 2015 7th July ‘Domestic Violence: Are Maracs Making a Difference to Victims’ Lives?’ London, UK: The Guardian.

70.

Mental Health Act (1983) Legislation.gov.uk. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1983/20/section/136.

71.

Merrick

(2006) Social Work and Child Abuse: Still Walking the Tightrope? 2nd ed. Abingdon, VA: Routledge.

72.

Morris

(2017 5th July) Police Failed to Protect Bijan Ebrahimi Prior to His Murder, IPCC Says. London, UK: The Guardian.

73.

Myhill

Quinton

(2011) It’s a Fair Cop? Police Legitimacy, Public Cooperation, and Crime Reduction: An interpretative Evidence Commentary, s.L. London, UK: National Policing Improvement Agency.

74.

National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) (2016) Learning into Practice: Inter-professional Communication and Decision Making – Practice Issues Identified in 38 Serious Case Reviews, s.L. London, UK: NSPCC. [Online] Available at: https://www.nottinghamcity.gov.uk/information-for-residents/community/community-protection/community-protection/(accessed on 17 June 2021).

75.

North Yorkshire PFCC (n.d) North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner. Available at: https://www.northyorkshire-pfcc.gov.uk/.

76.

Nottingham City Council (2017) What Do They Know? Nottingham, England: Nottingham City Council. [Online] Available at https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/396695/response/964279/attach/html/3/9393FinalResponse.pdf.html (accessed on 14 November 2021).

77.

Nottingham City Council Community Protection (n.d) Community Protection. Available at: https://www.nottinghamcity.gov.uk/information-for-residents/community/community-protection/community-protection/.

78.

Ofsted (2010) Learninvg Lessons from Serious Case Reviews: Interim Report 2009–10 Ofsted’s Evaluation of Serious Case Reviews 1 April to 30 September 2009, s.L. Cambridge, York: The Office for Standards in EducationChildren's Services and Skills.

79.

Oppetit

Campelo

Bouzar

, et al. (2019) Do Radicalized Minors Have Different Social and Psychological Profiles From Radicalized Adults? Frontiers in Psychiatry 10(644): 644.

80.

Peyton

Sierra-Arévalo

Rand

(2019) A field experiment on community policing and police legitimacy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116(40): 19894–19898.

81.

Police

(2019 April 2019) Dunkirk and Lenton Ward Strategic Priorities. [Online] Available at: https://www.nottinghamshire.police.uk/priority/dunkirk-and-lenton-ward-strategic-priorities-april-2019 (accessed on 17 June 2021).

82.

Popkess

(1959 April–June), Traffic Wardens: Food For Thought. The Police Journal: Theory, Practice and Principles. 32, pp. 86–95.

83.

Punti

Perfect

Kirubarajan

, et al. (2018) A systematic review of co-responder models of police mental health 'street' triage. BMC Psychiatry 18: 256.

84.

Rawlinson

, 2021 2 December Arthur Labinjo-Hughes: Father and Partner Found Guilty of Killing Son, Six. Kings Place, London: The Guardian.

85.

Reeves

(2012) How multi-agency are Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Committees? The Probation Journal 60(1): 40–55.

86.

Robbins

McLaughlin

Banks

, et al. (2014) Domestic violence and multi-agency risk assessment conferences (MARACs): a scoping review. The Journal of Adult Protection 16(6): 389–398.

87.

Robinson

(2005) Domestic Violence MARACS (Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conferences) for Very High-Risk Victims in Cardiff, Wales: Views from the Victims. Cardiff, Wales: Cardiff University.

88.

Robinson

(2004) Domestic Violence MARACs (Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conferences) for Very High-Risk Victims in Cardiff, Wales: A Process and Outcome Evaluation. Cardiff, Wales: Cardiff University.

89.

Sandeman

, 2018 26 December. Life on the Streets of Nottingham as a Community Protection Officer. Tollhouse, CA. Nottingham Post.

90.

Scales

Kailee

(2020) What Defunding the Police Really Means. BlackLivesMatter.com. Available at: https://blacklivesmatter.com/what-defunding-the-police-really-means/.

91.

Seddon

(2007) Who Cares? How State Funding and Political Activism Change Charity. London, UK: Civitas.

92.

Shaw

Greenhow

(2020) Children in care: Exploitation, offending and the denial of victimhood in a prosecution-led culture of practice. The British Journal of Social Work 50(5): 1551–1569.

93.

Sherman

Gartin

Buerger

(1989) Hot spots of predatory crime: routine activities and the criminology of place*. Criminology 27(1): 27–56.

94.

Shorrock

McManus

Kirby

(2019) Practitioner perspectives of multi-agency safeguarding hubs (MASH). The Journal of Adult Protection 22(1): 9–20.

95.

Spridgeon

Dale

(2021) Nottinghamshire’s ‘eye in the sky’ drones gets an upgrade. Mansfield Chad. Available at: https://www.chad.co.uk/news/crime/nottinghamshires-eye-in-the-sky-drones-gets-an-upgrade-3343486.

96.

Turner

Colombo

(2007) Multi-agency public protection panels: speaking different languages. Mental Health Practice 10(5): 24–25.

97.

van den Heuvel

Alison

Crego

(2012) How uncertainty and accountability can derail strategic ‘save life’ decisions in counter-terrorism simulations: A descriptive model of choice deferral and omission bias. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 25(2): 165–187.

98.

Walker

(2009 28 September) Police Errors Contributed to Suicide of Tormented Mother Fiona Pilkington. London, UK: The Guardian.

99.

Waring

Alison

Shortland

, et al. (2020) The role of information sharing on decision delay during multiteam disaster response. Cognition, Technology & Work 22: 236–279.

100.

West Midlands Police (2021) THRIVE. west-midlands.police.uk. Available at: https://foi.west-midlands.police.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/THRIVE.pdf.

101.

Windle

Moyle

Coomber

(2020) ‘Vulnerable’ kids going country: Children and young people’s involvement in county lines drug dealing. Youth Justice 20(1–2): 64–78.