James Conant envisioned the American comprehensive high school as a democratic institution that would bring together students from diverse backgrounds in a shared civic experience. Dustin Hornbeck builds on John Rury’s 2002 critique to argue that the high school has not just fragmented but shifted toward an “outsourced” model. Drawing on both historical context and current developments, he explores how proliferating curricular choice pressures have reshaped the high school landscape. Rather than serving as a civic commons, today’s high school increasingly functions as a delivery system for individualized credentials.
AbowitzK.K. (2024, June3). School boards, long locally focused and nonpartisan, get dragged into the national political culture wars. The Conversation.
2.
AltenbaughR. J. (2003). The American people and their education: A social history. Merrill/Prentice Hall.
3.
AngusD. L.MirelJ. (1999). The failed promise of the American high school, 1890-1995. Teachers College Press.
4.
BartonK.C.HoL. (2023). Collaborative deliberation in the classroom. Phi Delta Kappan, 104 (5), 44-49.
5.
BaumannP.BrennanJ. (2017). State civic education policy: Framework and gap analysis tool. Education Commission of the States.
6.
BotsteinL. (1999, May17). Let teenagers try adulthood. The New York Times.
7.
BoydD. (2014). It’s complicated: The social lives of networked teens. Yale University Press.
8.
CarnevaleA.P.RoseS.J.CheahB. (2021). The college payoff: More education doesn’t always mean more earnings. Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce.
9.
ChubbJ.E.MoeT.M (1990). Politics, markets, and America’s schools. The Brookings Institution.
10.
ConantJ.B. (1959). The American high school today: A first report to interested citizens. McGraw-Hill.
11.
ConantJ.B. (1961). Slums and suburbs: A commentary on schools in metropolitan areas. Signet Books.
12.
Commission on the Reorganization of Secondary Education. (1918). Cardinal principles of secondary education. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Education.
13.
CusickP.A. (1983). The egalitarian ideal and the American high school: Studies of three schools. Longman Publishing Group.
14.
FinkJ. (2025, September30). High school dual enrollment grows to 2.8 million. Community College Research Center.
15.
FournalJ.MargolisA. (2024). Good conflict. Phi Delta Kappan, 105 (8), 32-37.
16.
FriedmanM.FriedmanR. D.AdamsJ. (1980). Free to choose: A personal statement (Vol. 249). Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
17.
GoldmanSachs. (2023, March27). Generative AI could raise global GDP by 7 percent.
18.
GoldsteinD. (2022, April18). Florida rejects math textbooks, citing “prohibited topics.” The New York Times.
19.
HornbeckD. (2025). How social studies teachers in the united states conceptualize and teach about democracy: Survey perspectives. The Social Studies, 1-16.
20.
HornbeckD.MalinJ.R. (2023). Demobilizing knowledge in American schools: Censoring critical perspectives. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 10 (1), 1-13.
21.
KaufmanJ.H.DilibertiM.K.ThompsonL.E. (2023). Walking on eggshells: Teachers’ responses to classroom restrictions. RAND Corporation.
22.
KrugE. A. (1964). The Shaping of the American High School. Harper & Row.
23.
LabareeD.F. (1997). How to succeed in school without really learning: The credentials race in American education. Yale University Press.
24.
LabareeD.F. (2018). Public schools for private gain: The declining American commitment to the public good. Phi Delta Kappan, 100 (3), 8-13.
25.
LevyF.MurnaneR.J. (2004). The new division of labor: How computers are creating the next job market. Princeton University Press.
26.
National Commission on Excellence in Education. (1983). A nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform. U.S. Department of Education.
27.
National Education Association. (1894). Report of the Committee of Ten on secondary school studies, with the reports of the conferences arranged by committee. American Book Company.
28.
PDK International. (2019). Frustration in the schools: Teachers speak out on pay, funding, and feeling valued. Phi Delta Kappan, 101 (1), NP1-NP24.
29.
PowellA.G.FarrarE.CohenD.K. (1985). The shopping mall high school: Winners and losers in the educational marketplace. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
30.
RavitchD. (1983). The Troubled Crusade: American Education, 19451980. Publication Sales, Basic Books, Inc.
31.
RuryJ.L. (2002). Democracy’s high school? Social change and American secondary education in the post-Conant era. American Educational Research Journal, 39 (2), 307-336.
32.
RuryJ. L. (2013). The historical development of urban education. In Urban Education (pp. 8-19). Routledge.
33.
SedlakM.WheelerC.PullinD.C.CusickP.A. (1986). Selling students short: Classroom bargains and academic reform in the American high school. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
34.
Southern Poverty Law Center. (2023). Year in hate and extremism 2023: Anti-CRT and school board disruption.
35.
StanfordL.LiebermanM.IfatusinV.A. (2024, January31; updated 2025, May 8). Which states have private school choice?Education Week.
36.
StitzleinS. (2021). Even as our nation seeks unity, let there be dissent in schools. Phi Delta Kappan, 103 (1), 43-48.
37.
Tennessee Board of Regents. (2023, April24). Dual enrollment in Tennessee’s community and technical colleges increased 68% since 2015.
38.
ThayerV. (1932). The Report of the Commission on the Reorganization of Secondary Education. Junior-Senior High School Clearing House, 7 (1), 49-55.
39.
TurnerC. (2025, May14). What to know about a federal proposal to help families pay for private school. NPR.
40.
VailK. (2023). Preventing online radicalization and extremism in boys. Phi Delta Kappan, 104 (7), 30-35.
41.
VarkeyT.C.VarkeyJ.A.DingJ.B.VarkeyP.K.ZeitlerC.NguyenA.M.MerhavyZ.I.ThomasC. R. (2023). Asynchronous learning: A general review of best practices for the 21st century. Journal of Research in Innovative Teaching & Learning, 16 (1), 4-16.
42.
WinthropR.ShoukryY.NitkinD. (2023). The disengagement gap: Why student engagement isn’t what parents expect. The Brookings Institution.
