Abstract
NOR (Natural Organic Reduction) is the four-to-six-week process of composting a human corpse into soil. While to the general public, NOR may sound like a biologically-sound, basic, holistic answer to the question of body disposition, death care industry professionals know it is not nearly that simple. With NOR recently legalized in New York, major problems will be brought forth in five categories including the following: (1) Disease control with regard to soil, water and air contamination, (2) Cost efficiency, (3) Soil retrieval issues, (4) Impossible accommodations during an epidemic or pandemic, and (5)Failure to Protect What Should Be Sacred Ground/Failure To Provide A Physical Memorial For Decedents. This article will explain the NOR process and address the five problematic issues this process brings forth.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ask a Mortician
. “Let's visit the human composting facility!” (2021 , October 22). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LJSEZ_pl3Y
2.
Britannica
T.
Editors of Encyclopaedia (2022 , December 30). Cremation . Encyclopedia Britannica https://www.britannica.com/topic/cremation
3.
Cemetery.com
. (2023 ). What is a Cemetery? https://www.cemetery.com/learning-center/guide-to-cemeteries/what-is-a-cemetery/
4.
Little
B.
(2019 , November 5). “The environmental toll of cremating the dead .” National Geographic . https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/is-cremation-environmentally-friendly-heres-the-science#:∼:text=Matthews_estimates_that_one_cremation,of_CO2_emissions_each_year
5.
Maezes
C.
(2022 ). Natural organic reduction in vermont . Vermont General Assembly . https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2022/WorkGroups/House_General/Bills/H.244/Witness_Documents/H.244∼Carolyn_Maezes∼Natural_Organic_Reduction_in_Vermont∼1-26-2022.pdf
6.
Marsh
P.
(2021 ). HB 2574 - natural organic reduction – Q&A - Oregon legislative assembly . Oregon State Legislature . https://www.oregonlegislature.gov/marsh/Documents/HB2574_Natural_Organic_Reduction.pdf?ID=43
7.
Molina
A.
(2021 , July 13). “The catholic church opposes composting human remains — but it’s becoming legal in more states” . American Magazine . https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2021/07/13/composting-human-remains-catholic-church-opposition-241031
8.
Moon
P.
(2022 March 2). “Terramation” O2Compost: Compost systems and training . https://www.o2compost.com/blog.aspx?post=8825&title=Terramation
9.
National Collaborating Centre for Environmental Health
. “Crematoria and air quality fact sheet” (2020 , March 30). Retrieved January 4, 2023 from https://ncceh.ca/documents/guide/crematoria-and-air-quality-fact-sheet.
10.
New York Penal Law
. (2022 ). § 145.26: Aggravated Cemetery Desecration in the Second Degree . https://casetext.com/statute/consolidated-laws-of-new-york/chapter-penal/part-3-specific-offenses/title-i-offenses-involving-damage-to-and-intrusion-upon-property/article-145-criminal-mischief-and-related-offenses/section-14526-aggravated-cemetery-desecration-in-the-second-degree
11.
NYC 311.
(2022 ). Scattering ashes and cremated remains in parks . https://portal.311.nyc.gov/article/?kanumber=KA-03480#:∼:text=New_York_City_Parks_including,be_scattered_to_complete_dispersal
12.
Oliverie Funeral Home
. (2021 , August 9). Why you should keep a loved one’s remains in a cremation niche . https://www.oliveriefuneralhome.com/why-you-should-keep-a-loved-ones-remains-in-a-cremation-niche
13.
Palmer
B.
(2015 , May 19). “Do we exhale carbon?” . Natural Resources Defense Council . https://www.nrdc.org/stories/do-we-exhale-carbon#:∼:text=The_average_human_exhales_about,CO2_as_his_sedentary_brethren
14.
Parting
. (2022 , September 14). Funeral costs: What does a cremation with services cost? https://www.parting.com/blog/cremation-costs-how-much-does-a-cremation-with-services-cost/
15.
Recompose
. (2022 ). A full-service funeral home specializing in human composting . “How It Works ”. https://recompose.life/planning-ahead/#how-it-works
16.
Return Home
. (2020 , December 10). “The legality of eco-friendly organic burial” . https://returnhome.com/the-legality-of-eco-friendly-burial/#:∼:text=Currently%2C_Washington%2C_Oregon%2C_Colorado,natural_organic_reduction_is_legal
17.
Simply Cremation.
(2023 ). Cremation frequently asked questions: Questions about the cremation process . https://csofhr.com/resources/cremation-faq/#:∼:text=Cremated_remains_resemble_coarse_sand,eight_pounds_of_cremated_remains