Analysing the Relevance of the MIP Scoreboard's Indicators

Abstract

The EU established an early warning system by introducing the Macroeconomic Imbalance Procedure (MIP) in the wake of the recent recession. Nevertheless, it has been found by some authors to be rather vague when launching the Excessive Imbalances Procedure. Performed analysis reflects on such views and treats the MIP indicators as a system while assessing the significance of all particular variables separately. This assessment was accomplished by applying a multivariate unbalanced logit model, utilising all 14 MIP headline indicators, using time horizons ranging from one to three years before crisis, which was represented by periods with output gap lower than negative 2 per cent. The approach was confronted with the estimates of a linear probability model to provide an idea about the robustness of the results. In the short term, activity rates, youth unemployment rates and private sector debt are the best performing indicators, complemented by current account balances in the long term.

Keywords

MIP scoreboard Early warning systems Binary response models Logit

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alcidi

and Gros

(2014), ‘Implications of EU governance reforms. Rationale and practical application’, Etla Reports, no. 25.

Alessi

, Antunes

, Babaecky

, Baltussen

, Behn

, Bonfim

, Bush

, Datken

, Frost

, Guimaraes

, Havránek

, Joy

, Kauko

, Matěju

, Monteiro

, Neudorfer

, Peltonen

, Rodrigues

P.M.M.

, Rusnák

, Schudel

, Sigmund

, Stremmel

, Šmídková

, Van Tilburg

, Vašíček

and Žigarová

(2014), ‘Comparing different early warning systems: results from a horse race competition among members of the macro-prudential research network’, preliminary and incomplete draft. Available at: <http://www.ecb.europa.eu/events/pdf/conferences/140623/Vasicek-et-al_Comparing-Different-Early-Warning-Systems.pdf?F96bbb525a26071ecf97f9154fb3cc73>.

Alessi

and Detken

(2011), ‘Quasi real time early warning indicators for costly asset price boom/bust cycles: a role for global liquidity’, European Journal of Political Economy, 27, 3, pp. 520–33.

Antunes

, Bonfim

, Monteiro

and Rodrigues

P.M.M.

(2014), ‘Early warning indicators of banking crises: exploring new data and tools’, Banco de Portugal, Economic Bulletin.

Babecky

, Havránek

, Matějů

, Rusnák

, Šmídková

and Vašíček

(2013), ‘Leading indicators of crisis incidence: evidence from developed countries’, Journal of International Money and Finance, 35, pp. 1–19.

Barrell

, Davis

E.P.

, Karim

and Liadze

(2010a), ‘Bank regulation, property prices and early warning systems for banking crises in OECD countries’, Journal of Banking and Finance, 34, pp. 2255–64.

Barrell

, Davis

E.P.

, Karim

and Liadze

(2010b), ‘Was the subprime crisis unique? An analysis of the factors that help predict banking crises in OECD countries’, NIESR Discussion Paper No. 363.

Barrios

, Barry

and Strobl

(2002), ‘FDI and structural convergence in the EU periphery’, Centre for European Policy Research, Workshop and Conferences, no. 2319.

Berti

, Salto

and Laquien

(2012), ‘An early-detection index of fiscal stress for EU countries’, European Commission Economic Papers, no. 475.

10.

Borgy

, Clerc

and Renne

J. P.

(2014), ‘Measuring aggregate risk: can we robustly identify asset-price boom-bust cycles?’, Journal of Banking and Finance, 46, pp. 132–50.

11.

Cameron

A.C.

and Trivedi

P.K.

(2010), Microeconometrics Using Stata, Revised Edition, Stata Press.

12.

Canova

(1994), ‘Were financial crises predictable?’, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 26, 1, pp. 102–24.

13.

Checherita

and Rother

(2010), ‘The impact of high and growing government debt on economic growth: an empirical investigation for the Euro Area’, ECB Working Paper, no. 1237.

14.

Christensen

and Li

(2014), ‘Predicting financial stress events: a signal extraction approach’, Journal of Financial Stability, 14, pp. 54–65.

15.

Cazacu (Bancu)

A.-M.

(2015), ‘Export performance of central and eastern European countries: macro and micro fundamentals’, Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 195, pp. 514–23.

16.

Council of the European Union (2016), ‘Outcome of proceedings, alert mechanism report 2106 – ECOFIN Council conclusions’, 15 January, http://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST-5318-2016-INIT/en/pdf.

17.

Crespo

and Fontoura

M.R.

(2007), ‘Integration of CEECs into EU market: structural change and convergence’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 45, 3, pp. 611–32.

18.

Csortos

and Szalai

(2013), ‘Assessment of macroeconomic imbalance indicators’, MNB Bulletin.

19.

De Grauwe

(2012), ‘In search of symmetry in the Eurozone’, CEPS Policy Brief, no. 268.

20.

Dumitrescu

E.I.

, Hurlin

CH.

, Candelon

(2010), ‘How to evaluate an early warning system: towards a unified statistical framework for assessing financial crises forecasting methods’, available at <https://hal.inria.fr/file/index/docid/450050/filename/EWS_candumhur.pdf>.

21.

Essl

and Stiglbauer

(2012), ‘Prevention and correction of macroeconomic imbalances: the excessive imbalance procedure’, Monetary Policy and The Economy Q4/11, pp. 99–113.

22.

European Central Bank (2015), ‘Real convergence in the euro area: evidence, theory and policy implications’, ECB Economic Bulletin, Issue 5, pp. 30–45.

23.

European Commission (2011), ‘Commission staff working document. Scoreboard for the surveillance of macroeconomic imbalances: envisaged initial design’, Brussels, 8.11.2011, SEC (2011) 1361 final.

24.

European Commission (2012), ‘Scoreboard for the surveillance of macroeconomic imbalances’, European Economy Occasional Papers, no. 92.

25.

European Commission (2015a), ‘Cyclical Adjustment of Budget Balances’, Autumn 2015.

26.

European Commission (2015b), ‘Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Central Bank. On steps towards completing economic and monetary union’, Brussels, 21.10.2015, COM (2015) 600 final.

27.

European Commission (2015c), ‘Report from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Central Bank and the European Economic and Social Committee. Alert Mechanism Report 2016’, Brussels, 26.11.2015, COM (2015) 691 final.

28.

European Commission (2016), ‘The macroeconomic imbalance procedure. Rationale, process, application: a compendium’, European Economy Institutional Papers, 039, November.

29.

Frankel

and Saravelos

(2010), ‘Can leading indicators assess country vulnerability? Evidence from the 2008–9 Global Financial Crisis’, Harvard Kennedy School, mimeo.

30.

Hallwirth

(2014), ‘Überwachung der Wettbewerbsfähigkeit in der Europäischen Wirtschafts– und Währungsunion’, Wirtschaftsdienst, 94, 11, pp. 798–805.

31.

Hartmann

(2015), ‘Real estate markets and macroprudential policy in Europe’, ECB Working Paper Series, no. 1796.

32.

Hošková

(2001), ‘Impact of foreign direct investment on the economy of Slovakia’, National Bank Slovakia.

33.

Kaminsky

, Lizando

and Reinhart

(1998), ‘Leading indicators of currency crisis’, IMF Staff Papers, 45, 1.

34.

Kaminsky

G.L.

and Reinhart

C.M.

(1999), ‘The twin crises: the causes of banking and balance-of-payments problems’, American Economic Review, 89, 3, pp. 473–500.

35.

Kamps

Ch.

, De Stefani

, Leiner-Killinger

, Rüffer

and Sondermann

(2013), ‘Would the strengthened EU fiscal and economic governance framework have helped signalling sovereign debt crises?’, Paper presented at Banca d'Italia 15th Public Finance Workshop.

36.

Kamps

Ch.

, De Stefani

, Leiner-Killinger

, Rüffer

and Sondermann

(2014), ‘The identification of fiscal and macroeconomic imbalances. Unexploited synergies under the strengthened EU governance framework’, ECB Occasional Paper Series, no 157.

37.

Marchiori

, Pierrard

and Sneessens

H. R.

(2011), ‘Demography, capital flows and unemployment’, IZA DP, no. 6094.

38.

Moschella

(2014), Monitoring macroeconomic imbalances: is EU surveillance more effective than IMF surveillance?’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 52, 6, pp. 1273–89.

39.

Official Journal of the European Union (2011a), ‘Regulation (EU) No 1174/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 November 2011 on enforcement measures to correct excessive macroeconomic imbalances in the euro area’.

40.

Official Journal of the European Union (2011b), ‘Regulation (EU) No 1176/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 November 2011 on the prevention and correction of macroeconomic imbalances’.

41.

Official Journal of the European Union (2012), ‘Consolidated version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union’.

42.

Reinhart

C.M.

and Rogoff

K.S.

(2009), This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.

43.

Sarlin

(2013), ‘On policymakers’ loss functions and the evaluation of early warning systems’, ECB Working Paper Series, no. 1509.

44.

Schularick

and Taylor

A.M.

(2012), ‘Credit booms gone bust: monetary policy, leverage cycles, and financial crises, 1870–2008’, American Economic Review, 102, 2, pp. 1029–61.

45.

Stankovičová

and Vojtková

(2007), Viacrozmerné štatistické metódy s aplikáciami, Bratislava, Iura edition.

46.

Taylor

A.M.

(2012), ‘The great leveraging’, NBER Working Paper, no. 18290.

47.

Verick

Sh.

(2011), ‘Giving up job search during a recession: the impact of the global financial crisis on the South African labour market’, IZA DP, no. 6116.

48.

Wooldridge

J.M.

(2010), Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, Second edition, MIT Press.

49.

Wooldridge

J.M.

(2013), Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach, Fifth international edition, USA, Cengage Learning.