Men are a small minority of childcare workers, and this has contributed to skills
shortages which have affected the sector’s ability to meet rising demand.
The paper looks at current initiatives aimed at recruiting men, particularly through
the Government’s National Recruitment Campaign, and the benefits which
might be gained from their inclusion in the workforce. It explores the barriers to
men’s employment in the sector, including men’s own perceptions
of gender roles and attitudes towards ‘women’s work’.
The paper identifies a range of measures which might lead to greater effectiveness
in both recruiting and retaining men to the sector.
Bertram, T.
and
Pascal C.
(2000), ‘The OECD thematic review of early
childhood education and care: background report for the United
Kingdom’,
Centre for Research in Early Childhood, University College, Worcester
.
2.
Cameron, C.
(1997),
‘A review of staffing in childcare centres in six countries’
, Early Child Development and Care, 137, pp.
47-67
.
3.
Cameron, C.
(2001),
‘Promise or problem? A review of the literature on men working in
early childhood services’
, Gender, Work and Organisation, 8, 4,
October, pp.
430-451
.
4.
Cameron, C.
(2004),
‘Building an integrated workforce for a long-term vision of
universal early education and care’
, Daycare Trust, November.
5.
Cameron, C.
,
Moss P.
, and
Owen, C.
(1999) Men in the Nursery: gender and caring work,
London, Paul Chapman Publishing
.
6.
Cameron, C.
,
Owen, C.
, and
Moss P.
(2001a), ‘Entry, retention and loss: a study of
childcare students and workers’, DfES research report no. 275.
7.
Cameron, C.
,
Mooney, A.
,
Owen, C.
, and
Moss, P.
(2001b), ‘Childcare students and nursery workers:
follow-up surveys and in-depth interviews’, DfES research report
no. 322.
8.
Cameron, C.
,
Mooney A
and
Moss, P.
(2002),
‘The childcare workforce: current conditions and future directions’
, Critical Social Policy, 22, 4, pp.
572-595
.
9.
Cameron, C.
,
Candapapa, M.
,
Mooney, A.
,
McQuail, S.
,
Moss, P.
and
Petrie, P.
(2003), ‘Early years and childcare international
evidence project’, DfES/SureStart Research Report.
10.
Children Now
(2004), ‘Who says men can’t
care?’, 1-7 December, pp. 18-19.
11.
Christie, A.
(1998),
‘A comparison of arguments for employing men as child care
workers and social workers in Denmark and the UK’
, Social Work in Europe, 5, 1.
12.
Cook, C.
(2005), “It’s not what men
do’: investigating the reasons for the low number of men in the early
childhood workforce’, in
Hirst, K.
and
Nutbrown, C.
(eds) (in press), Perspectives on Early Childhood Education: Essays in
Contemporary Research,
Stoke-on-Trent, Trentham Books
.
13.
Daycare Trust
(2001), ‘Who will care? Childcare for all thinking
big’, Briefing Paper 4,
Daycare Trust and Unison
.
14.
Daycare Trust
(2003), ‘Men and childcare’.
15.
DfEE
(1998), The Green Paper - Meeting the Childcare Challenge: A
Framework and Consultation Document.
DfES
(2005), Children’s Workforce Strategy: A Strategy
to Build a World-class Workforce for Children and Young People,
HMSO
.
18.
Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC)
(2003), ‘How can suitable, affordable childcare be
provided for all parents who need to work?’, EOC submission to
the Work and Pensions Select Committee Inquiry, February.
19.
Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC)
(2004a), Gender Issues in Modern Apprenticeships.
Employment Research Institute, Napier University
(2004), Gender Stereotyping in Career Choice: Research Project.
22.
Francis, B.
,
Osgood, J.
,
Dalgety, J.
and
Archer, L.
(2005), Gender Equality in Work Experience Placements for
Young People,
Manchester, Equal Opportunities Commission
.
23.
Fuller, A.
(2005), Employers, Young People and Gender Segregation,
Manchester, Equal Opportunities Commission
.
24.
Gould, T.
(1997), ‘Buildings as well as systems can appear as
negative to males in early years settings’ - Exploring the Role and
Status of the Male Educarer Working with the Under-threes,
OUP
.
25.
Hatten, W.
,
Vinter, L.
and
Williams, R.
(2002), Dads on Dads: Needs and Expectations at Home and at
Work, Equal Opportunities Commission EOC Research Discussion
Series,
Manchester, EOC
.
26.
HMSO
(1998), The Green Paper - Meeting the Childcare Challenge: A
Framework and Consultation Document, May.
27.
Hesketh, B.
,
Elmslie, S.
and
Kaldor, W.
(1990),
‘Career compromise: an alternative account to
Gottfredson’s theory’
, Journal of Counselling Psychology, 37, pp.
49-56
.
28.
Hill, R.
(1990),
‘Involving men in the caring and educational services’
, Local Government Policy Making, 17, Pt 3.
29.
IdeA
(1999), Childcare Workforce Surveys 1998,
DFES
.
30.
IDS
(2001), ‘Pay for nursery workers’, February.
31.
Jensen, J.
(1996), Men as Workers in Childcare Services: A Discussion
Paper, European Commission Network on Childcare and other measures to reconcile
Employment and Family Responsibilities for Women and Men,
Brussels, European Equal Opportunities Unit
.
32.
Land, H.
(2004), ‘Women, child poverty and childcare: making
the links’,
Daycare Trust
, facing the future policy paper.
33.
Lloyd, T.
(1999), Young Men, The Job Market and Gendered Work,
Joseph Rowntree Foundation, YPS
.
34.
Manlove, E.
, and
Guzzel, J.
(1997),
‘Intention to leave, anticipated reasons for leaving and 12 month
turnover of child care center staff’
, Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 12,
2, pp.
145-167
.
35.
Meleady, C.
(1998), ‘The Sheffield Children’s
Centre’s experience of recruiting and training men to work in services
for young children’, in
Owen, C.
,
Cameron, C.
and
Moss, P.
(eds), Men as Workers in Services for Young Children: Issues of a Mixed
Gender Workforce,
London, Institute of Education
.
36.
Miller, L.
,
Neathey, F.
,
Pollard, E.
and
Hill, D.
(2004), ‘Occupational segregation, gender gaps and
skill gaps’, EOC Working Paper Series No. 15.
37.
Mooney, A.
,
Moss, P.
and
Owen, C.
(2001a), A Survey of Former Childminders, DfES Research
Report 330.
38.
Mooney, A.
,
Knight, A.
,
Moss, P.
and
Owen, C.
(2001b), Who cares? Childminding in the 1990s,
Family Policy Studies Centre, Family and Work Series.
39.
Morgan, D.
(1992), Discovering Men,
London, Routledge
.
40.
MORI
(2004a), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Overview Report,
DfES
.
41.
MORI
(2004b), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3,
Day Nurseries and other Full-day Care Provision,
DfES
.
42.
MORI
(2004c), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Playgroups and Pre-Schools,
DfES
.
43.
MORI
(2004d), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Out of School Clubs,
DfES
.
44.
MORI
(2004e), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Holiday Clubs,
DfES
.
45.
MORI
(2004f), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Childminders,
DfES
.
46.
MORI
(2004g), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Primary Schools with Nursery and Reception Classes,
DfES
.
47.
MORI
(2004h), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Primary Schools with Reception no Nursery Classes,
DfES
.
48.
MORI
(2004i), Childcare and Early Years Workforce Surveys 2002/3
Nursery Schools,
DfES
.
49.
Moss, P.
(2000), Workforce Issues in Early Childhood Education and
Care,
Institute for Child and Family Policy, Columbia University,
New York
.
50.
Moss, P.
(2006),
‘Farewell to childcare?’
, National Institute Economic Review, January.
51.
Murray, S.B.
(1996),
‘We all love Charles’ - Men in childcare and the social
construction of gender’
, Gender and Society, 10(4), pp.
368-385
.
52.
Observer (2005),
Childcare shake-up will send men into the nursery
, 6 March, p.
7
.
53.
Owen, C.
(2003a), ‘Men in the
nursery’, in
Brannen, J.
and
Moss, P.
(eds), Rethinking Children’s Care,
Buckingham, Open University Press
.
54.
Owen, C.
(2003b),
‘Men’s work? Changing the gender mix of the childcare
and early years workforce’
, Daycare Trust, June.
55.
Peeters, J.
(2003),
‘Men in childcare: first results of a project in Flanders’
, European Conference on Men in Childcare,
Ghent, 28 November 2003.
56.
Penn, H.
and
McQuail, S.
(1997), Childcare as a Gendered Occupation, DfEE
Research report 23.
57.
Rolfe, H.
(2005), Men in Childcare, Occupational Segregation,
Working Paper Series No. 35,
Equal Opportunities Commission
.
58.
Rolfe, H.
,
Metcalf, H.
,
Anderson, T.
and
Meadows, P.
(2003), Recruitment and Retention of Childcare, Early Years
and Play Workers: Research Study, DfES Research Report 409.
59.
Rose, M.
(2003),
‘Good deal, bad deal? Job satisfaction in occupations’
, Work Employment and Society, 17, 3, September.
60.
Rubery, J.
,
Smith, M.
,
Anxo, D.
and
Flood, L.
(2001),
‘The future European Labour supply: the critical role of the family’
, Feminist Economics, 7, 3, pp.
33-69
.
61.
Ruxton, S.
(1992), ‘What’s He Doing at the Family
Centre’: The Dilemmas of Men who Care for Children, A Research
Report,
NCH
.
62.
Scott, G.
,
Brown, U.
and
Campbell, J.
(2000), Visible Childcare: Invisible Workers, Trade
Union Research Unit Occasional Paper no. 1, April.
63.
Scott, G.
,
Campbell, J.
,
Brown, U.
(2001),
‘The contribution of childcare to local employment: poor work or
work for the poor?’
, Local Economy, September, 16, 3, pp.
187-197
.
64.
Simpson, R.
(2004),
‘Masculinity at work: the experiences of men in female dominated occupations’
, Work, Employment and Society, 18(2),
pp.
349-368
.
65.
Smith, M.
,
Sung, S.
,
Carroll, M.
, and
Oliver, G.
(2004),
‘Working in the child care sector: the tension of providing and
accessing care’
, paper presented at the Work, Employment and Society
Conference, Manchester, September.
Sure Start
(2004b), Important Update Information from the Childcare
Recruitment Team, August.
68.
Thurtle V.
and
Jennings P.
(1998),
‘The experience of students in a gender minority on courses at a
college of higher and further education’
, Journal of Education and Training, 50, 4.
69.
Vernon, J.
and
Smith, C.
(1994), Day Nurseries at a Crossroads: Meeting the Challenge
of Childcare in the Nineties,
National Children’s Bureau
.
70.
Wadsworth, J.
(2002),
‘The issues facing men working in early childhood education’
, Forum, 44, 1.
