Open disclosure is a valuable process which has the potential to benefit both the patients who receive the open disclosure and the health care professionals (or organisations) who provide it. The benefits from open disclosure will most often be seen when open disclosure is performed in an ‘ideal’ manner. When open disclosure is suboptimal, it can lead to harmful consequences for patients and health care providers alike. Numerous factors may contribute to an inadequate open disclosure including: potentially inadequate legal protection for health care professionals or organisations; failing to meet patient and/or family expectations; health care professionals experiencing a lack of education, training and support from the health care organisation; or a fear of litigation. An inadequate open disclosure may result in inadvertent consequences including: patients/families who are dissatisfied; potentially preventable litigation; legal repercussions for health care professionals and organisations; and patient harm where open disclosure is not implemented. This article seeks to explore these barriers and considers how the implementation of open disclosure could be improved to overcome these barriers. Overcoming these barriers should help to reduce the risk of inadvertent consequences and lead to better outcomes for patients, health care professionals and health care organisations.
IedemaRAllenSBrittonK, et al.
Patients’ and family members’ views on how clinicians enact and how they should enact incident disclosure: The “100 patient stories” qualitative study.BMJ2011;
343: d4423.
3.
StuddertDMPiperDIedemaR.Legal aspects of open disclosure II: Attitudes of health professionals — findings from a national survey.Med J Aust2010;
193: 351–355.
4.
BismarkMBiggarSCrockC, et al.The role of governing boards in improving patient experience: Attitudes and activities of health service boards in Victoria, Australia.Patient Exp J2014;
1: 144–152.
5.
Victorian Government. Targeting zero: Supporting the Victorian hospital system to eliminate avoidable harm and strengthen quality of care. Report, Victorian Government, Australia, October 2016.
6.
Expert Working Group to advise on legislative reforms arising from Targeting Zero. A statutory duty of candour. Report, Department of Health and Human Services, Victoria, October 2017.
7.
LambRMStuddertDMBohmerRMJ, et al.Hospital disclosure practices: Results of a national survey.Health Aff2003;
22: 73–83.
8.
IedemaRSorensenRManiasE, et al.
Patients' and family members' experiences of open disclosure following adverse events.Int J Qual Health Care2008;
20: 421–432.
9.
StuddertDMRichardsonMW.Legal aspects of open disclosure: A review of Australian law.Med J Aust2010;
193: 273–276.
10.
VinesP.Apologising to avoid liability: Cynical civility or practical morality. Syd L Rev2005;
27: 483–505.
11.
StuddertDMMelloMMGawandeAA, et al.Disclosure of medical injury to patients: An improbable risk management strategy.Health Aff2007;
26(1): 215–226.
12.
KramanSCranfillLHammG, et al.Advocacy: The Lexington Veterans Affairs Medical Centre.Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf2002;
28: 646–650.
13.
IedemaRSorensonRPiperD. Open disclosure: A review of the literature. Report, Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care and University of Technology Sydney, Sydney, February 2008.
14.
Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care. Open Disclosure Standard: Review Report. Report, Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Healthcare, Sydney, June 2012.
15.
Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care. Frequently asked questions about open disclosure: health service managers. Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care, Sydney.
16.
BismarkMDauerEA.Motivations for medico-legal action: Lessons from New Zealand.J Leg Med2006;
27: 55–70.
17.
VincentCPhillipsAYoungM.Why do people sue doctors? A study of patients and relatives taking legal action.Lancet1994;
343: 1609.
18.
WaltonMHarrisonRSmith-MerryJ, et al.
Disclosure of adverse events: A data linkage study reporting patient experiences among Australian adults aged > 45 years.Aust Health Rev2019;
43: 268–275.
19.
KmietowiczZ. A fifth of acute trusts may be under-reporting medical errors.BMJ2014;
348: g4257.
20.
ShawCColesJ. The reporting of adverse clinical incidents – international views and experience. Report, CASPE Research, London, October 2011.
LambR.Open disclosure: The only approach to medical error.BMJ Qual Saf2004;
13: 3–5.
23.
HarrisonRBirksYBosanquetK, et al.Enacting open disclosure in the UK National Health Service: A qualitative exploration.J Eval Clin Pract2017;
23: 713–718.
24.
Wighton v Arnot [2005] NSWSC 637.
25.
Gallardo v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust [2017] EWHC 3147 (QB).
26.
FinlayAStewartCLParkerM.Open disclosure: Ethical, professional and legal obligations, and the way forward for regulation.Med J Aust2013;
198: 445–448.
27.
Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations2014 (UK).
28.
NegriD. Regulating the duty of candour. Report, Action Against Medical Accidents, Croydon, October 2018.
29.
DaltonDWilliamsN. Building a culture of candour. Report, Royal College of Surgeons, London, March 2014.
30.
AllanAMcKillopDDooleyJ, et al.Apologies following an adverse medical event: The importance of focusing on the consumer's needs.Patient Educ Couns2015;
98: 1058–1062.
31.
MazorKMSimonSRYoodRA, et al.
Health plan members’ views about disclosure of medical errors.Ann Intern Med2004;
140: 409–418.
32.
GallagherTHWatermanADEbersAG, et al.Patients’ and physicians’ attitudes regarding the disclosure of medical errors.JAMA2003;
289: 1001–1007.
33.
RobbennoltJK.Apologies and medical error.Clin Orthop Relat Res2009;
467: 376–382.
34.
PiperD.The insurance implications of open disclosure in healthcare. Precedent2011;
104: 27–30.
35.
WolfZRHughesRG.Error reporting and disclosure. In: HughesRG (ed.) Patient Safety and Quality: An Evidence-Based Handbook for Nurses.
Rockville:
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US), 2008, pp.333–363.
36.
HobgoodCTamyo-SarverJElmsA, et al.Parental preferences for error disclosure, reporting, and legal action after medical error in the care of their children.Pediatrics2005;
116: 1276–1286.
37.
PiperDIedemaRBowerK.Rural patients’ experiences of the open disclosure of adverse events.Aust J Rural Health2014;
22: 197–203.
38.
StroudLWongBMHollenbergE, et al.Teaching medical error disclosure to physicians-in-training: A scoping review.Acad Med2013;
88: 884–892.
39.
AdamsMAElmunzerBJScheimanJM.Effect of a health system's medical error disclosure program on gastroenterology-related claims rates and costs.Am J Gastroenterol2014;
109: 460–464.
40.
BoothmanRC.Apologies and a strong defense at the University of Michigan Health System. Physician Exec2006;
32: 7–10.
41.
GallagherTHStuddertDLevinsonW.Disclosing harmful medical errors to patients.N Engl J Med2007;
356: 2713–2719.
42.
RamseyerJMRasmusenEB. Comparative Litigation Rates. Discussion paper, Harvard, MA, USA, November 2010.
