The General Medical Council clearly states that a doctor must offer help when off-duty, if an emergency arises. However, despite an English doctor’s professional duty to offer their assistance, this duty does not exist as a legal duty. Therefore, a doctor would not be held negligent for failing to offer help, outside of their clinical setting. This article will critically analyse the reasons behind this lack of legal duty, comparing the law to other jurisdictions.
MulheronR.Medical negligence: non patient and third party claims. Ashgate publication 2010.
3.
Capital and Counties (Capco) v Hampshire County Council, [1997] QB 1004. [49]–[50].
4.
F v WestBerkshire HA in UKHL, 1991.
5.
WilliamsK.Doctors as Good Samaritans: some empirical evidence concerning emergency medical treatment in Britain. J Law Soc2003;
30: 258–282.
6.
Professional standards authority for health and social care v HCPC Matthew Geary [2016] EWHC 2210.
7.
Donoghue v Stevenson, 1932, AC.
8.
Caparo Industriesplc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605.
9.
Bible: Luke 10: 25–37.
10.
Stovin v WIse [1996] AC 923 3 WLR 388.
11.
Home Office v Dorset Yacht Co. Ltd. [1970] UKHL 2.
12.
R v Miller [1982] UKHL 6.
13.
Woodland v Essex CC [2013] UKSC 66.
14.
R v Evans [2009] EWCA Crim 650, 1WLR.
15.
Barnett v Chelsea [1969] 1 QB 428.
16.
HillV.Chief Constable of West Yorkshire [1989] AC 53: Slade LJ [344].
17.
Alexandrou v Oxford [1993] 4 All ER 328.
18.
Rigby v Chief Constable of Northamptonshire(1985) 1 WLR 1242.
19.
Michael v CC of South Wales [2015] SC UKSC 2.
20.
Kent v Griffiths and Others [2001] QB 36 [2000] 2 All ER 474.
21.
Darnley v Croydon [2017] EWCA Civ 151.
22.
Bishara v Sheffield Teaching Hospital NHS trust [2007] EWCA Civ 353 [2007] All ER [9].
23.
Watson v British Boxing Board of Control Ltd [2001] QB 1134 [2001] 2 WLR 1256.
24.
JacksonE.Medical law. 6th edition, 2016.
25.
National Health Service Regulations2015 (2015 No. 1862) Part 5 Regulation 17(7): requiring that immediately necessary treatment of any person to whom the contractor has been requested to provide treatment owing to an accident or emergency at any place in the contractor’s practice area).
26.
Lowns v Woods [1996] AustTorts Reports 81–37.
27.
Egedebo v WindermereDistrict Hospital Association [1993] 8 BCLR(2d)63(BCCA).
28.
Jane Doe v MetropolitanToronto municipality [1990] 74 OR 225.
29.
SuttonV.Is there a doctor (and lawyer) in the house? Why our good Samaritan laws are doing more harm than good: a fifty state survey. J Health Biomed Law2010; 6: 261–300.
30.
SmitsJM.The Good Samaritan in European private law: on the perils of principles without a programme and a programme for the future. Inaugural Lecture, Maastricht University, 2000.
31.
SteelSTofarisS.Police liability in negligence for failure to prevent crime: time to rethink. University of Cambridge Faculty of Law Research Paper No. 39, 2014.
32.
Duff v Highlands and islands Fire Board [1995] SLT 1362; Burnett v Grampian Fire and Rescue services [2007] SLT 61.
33.
AJ Allan (Blairnyle) Ltd v StrathclydeFire board [2016] CSIH 3 [2016] SLT 253.
34.
GordonG.A song of fire and ice: A J Allan (Blairnyle) Limited & Anor v Strathclyde Fire Board. Edinburgh Law Review, 2017; 21(127).
35.
Osman v UK [1998] ECHR 101.
36.
Van Calle v UK [2012] ECHR 13.
37.
Grant-KelsJMAndersonJKKelsBD.The unsolicited ominous diagnosis. Legal, moral, and ethical considerations. J Am Acad Dermatol2011;
66: 985–987.
38.
R(on the application of Burke v GMC) [2005] EWCA Civ 1003 2 FLR 1205.
