Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This study hypothesized that subjects would have increased language productivity when talking to members of their own ethnic group than when talking to members of a different ethnic group. Males (N=148) between the ages of 7-9 years participated in this study. Subjects consisted of 22 black children who were required to give a speech to all black children (BS-BA); 22 black children who were required to give a speech to all white children (BS-WA) ; 22 white children who were required to give a speech to all white children (WS-WA); and 22 white children required to give a speech to all black children (WS-BA). The speeches were recorded and analysed. The results support the hypothesis of this study. Since language productivity depended on the interaction of race and context, the results were seen as not in accord with the deficiency theory of black-white differences in language productivity.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baratz, J.C. ( 1969). A bi-dialectal task for determining language proficiency in economically disadvantaged negro children. Child Developm. , 40, 889-901.

Bernat, E. ( 1969). How speakers of different ages alter their speech when conversing with small children. (Unpublished term paper), cited in Cazden (1970).

Brown, R. ( 1973). A First Language: The Early Stages (Cambridge, Mass.) , 53-5.

Cazden, C. ( 1970). The situation: A neglected source of social class differences in language use. Journal of Social Issues, 26, 35-60.

Dale, P.S. ( 1972). Language Development: Structure and Function (Hinsdale, Ill.), 274-6.

Hays, W.B. ( 1963). Statistics for Psychologists (New York).

John, V. ( 1963). The intellectual development of slum children: Some preliminary findings, Amer. J. Orthopsychiatry, 33, 813-22.

Kirk, R.E. ( 1968). Experimental Design: Procedures for the Behavioral Sciences (Belmont, California).

Labov, W. ( 1966). The Social Stratification of English in New York City (Washington D.C.).

10.

Osser, H. , Wang, M.D. , and Zaid, F. ( 1969). The young child's ability to imitate and comprehend speech: a comparison of two subcultural groups, Child Developm. , 40, 1063-75.

11.

Shuy, R.W. ( 1969). A linguistic background for developing beginning reading materials for black children. In J. C. Baratz and R. W. Shuy (eds.), Teaching Black Children to Read (Washington D.C.).

12.

Stewart, W.A. ( 1969). On the use of Negro dialect in the teaching of reading . In J. C. Baratz and R. W. Shuy (eds.), Teaching Black Children to Read (Washington D.C.).

13.

Somervill, M.A. ( 1975). Language of the disadvantaged: toward resolution of conflict . J. Negro Educ., 43, 284-301.

14.

Terrell, F. ( 1975). Dialectal differences between middle-class black and white children who do and do not associate with lower-class black children . Lang. Speech, 18, 65-73.

15.

Yurchak, M.J. ( 1969). Differences in speech of a three-year-old addressing mother and sister (Unpublished term paper), cited in Cazden, C. ( 1970).

Language Productivity of Black and White Children in Black Versus White Situations

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References