The repair and maintenance of locomotives as sources of innovation and technology transfer. New insights from the Ryazan–Uralsk private railway (Russia,1890–1914)
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2021
The repair and maintenance of locomotives as sources of innovation and technology transfer. New insights from the Ryazan–Uralsk private railway (Russia,1890–1914)
This paper provides an overview of the practices of the repair, maintenance, and appropriation of locomotives on Russian railways at the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th centuries, exemplified by a case study of the Ryazan–Uralsk railway. Particular attention has been paid to the function of repair and maintenance in the railway context. Repair and maintenance have therefore been considered complex phenomena bringing together infrastructure, things to be repaired or maintained, and people involved in these actions on the one hand, and field research, innovation and business on the other. Based on a broad range of sources regarding the legal prescriptions, statistics, reports of railway employees to their superiors, financial documentation, and drafts of repaired locomotives, the diversity of the repair and maintenance of locomotives in late imperial Russia is analysed.
Al’bom parovozov.I͡ugo-Zapadnye zheleznye dorogi [The Album of Steam Locomotives. South-West Railways] (Kiev: Tipografiya i svetopechat’ S. V. Kul’zhenko, 1896).
2.
Valeriy V. Andreev, “Moskovsko-Kazanskaya zheleznaya doroga v kontse XIX – nachale XX vv.: modernizatsionniy factor v ekonomicheskom razvitii regiona” [“The Moscow–Kazan Railway at the End of the Nineteenth and the Beginning of the Twentieth Centuries: A Factor of Modernisation in the Economic Development of the Region”], PhD thesis, Cheboksary, 2007.
3.
Annuaire de la Russie. 1904. Premiére Année (St. Petersburg: Tsentral’niy Statisticheskiy Komitet, 1905).
4.
P. Belotserkovets, “Spravočnaja kniga i samoučitel’ dlja železnodorožnych masterov i desjatnikov. Izdanie pyatoe [Handbook and a Self-Learning Manual for Railway Workers. Fifth Edition] (St. Petersburg: Tipo-litografiya K. Pentkovskogo, 1909).
5.
Leonid I. Borodkin and Anna V. Dmitrieva, “Nobel Brothers Petroleum Company on the St.-Petersburg Stock Exchange: Factors of Share Prices Dynamics in the Early 20th Century”, Revue Fran Aise D'histoire Conomique N 7–8:1–2 (2017), 50–70.
6.
Juan M. Cano Sanchiz,
“Energy and Railway Workshops: An Archaeology of the FEPASA Complex (Jundiaí, Brazil)”, The Journal of Transport History39:2 (2018), 213–235.
7.
Alfred Chandler, The Visible Hand. The Managerial Revolution in American Business (
Cambridge MA & London:
The MIT Press, 1977).
8.
Christian Chevandier, Cheminots en usine. Les ouvriers des Ateliers d'Oullins au temps de la vapeur [Railway Workers in the Factory. The Workers of the Workshops Oullins in the Age of Steam] (
Lyon:
Presses Universitaires de Lyon, 1993).
9.
Christian Chevandier,
“Les Établissements, Les Hommes, le Travail, L’espace” [“Establishments, People, Work, Space”], Revue D’histoire Des Chemins de Fer28–29:28–29 (2003), 11–20.
10.
Christian Chevandier,
“Cheminots: des Images et Des Représentations si Prégnantes” [“Railroad Workers: So Significant Images and Representations”], Revue D’histoire Des Chemins de Fer36–37 (2007), 366–414.
11.
Peter H. Christensen, “Germany and the Ottoman Railways”, Art, Empire, and Infrastructure (
New Haven CT & London:
Yale University Press, 2017).
12.
Edward W. Constant II, “Communities and Hierarchies: Structure in the Practice of Science and Technology”, in Rachael Laudan (ed.), The Nature of Technological Knowledge. Are Models of Scientific Change Relevant? (Dordrecht: Springer, 1984), 27–46.
13.
Edward W. Constant II, “The Social Locus of Technological Practice: Community, System, or Organization?”, in Wiebe E. Bijker, Thomas P. Hughes and Trevor Pinch (eds), The Social Construction of Technological Systems. New Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology (Cambridge MA and London: The MIT Press, 2012), 217–36.
14.
Roland Cvetkovski, Modernisierung Durch Beschleunigung. Raum Und Mobilität im Zarenreich [Modernization through Acceleration. Space and Mobility in the Russian Empire] (Frankfurt: Campus, 2006).
15.
Eisuke Daito,
“Railways and Scientific Management in Japan 1907–30”, Business History31:1 (1989), 1–28.
16.
Mikhail A. Davydov, “Dvadtsat’ Let Do Velikoy Voyny”, Rossiyskaya Modernizatsija Vitte-Stolypina [Twenty Years before the Great War. Russian Modernisation of Vitte-Stolypin] (
St. Petersburg:
Aleteyya, 2016).
17.
Christof Dejung, “Transregional Study of Class, Social Groups, and Milieus”, in Matthias Middell (ed.), The Routledge Handbook of Transregional Studies (London and New York NY: Routledge, 2019), 74–81.
18.
Colleen A. Dunlavy, “Politics and Industrialization”,Early Railroads in the United States and Prussia (
Princeton NJ:
Princeton University Press, 1994).
19.
David Edgerton,
“From Innovation to Use: Ten Eclectic Theses on the Historiography of Technology”,History and Technology: An International Journal16:2 (1999), 111–36.
20.
Frank Edward and Michael Hård,
“Maintaining the Local Empire: The Public Works Department in Dar es Salaam, 1920–60”, The Journal of Transport History41:1 (2020), 27–46.
21.
Steven J. Ericson, “Taming the Iron Horse. Western Locomotive Makers and Technology Transfer in Japan, 1870–1914”, in Gail Lee Bernstein et al. (eds), Public Spheres, Private Lives in Modern Japan, 1600–1950 (Cambridge MA & London: The MIT Press, 2005), 185–217.
22.
G.M. Fadeev (ed.), “Istoriya Zheleznodorozhnogo Transporta” [History of Railways]. vol. 1 (Moskva: Ivan Fedorov, 1994).
23.
Robert Garbe, “Die Dampflokomotiven Der Gegenwart ” [Contemporary Steam Locomotives] (Berlin: Springer, 1907).
24.
Peter Gatrell, The Tsarist Economy 1850–1917 (
London:
Palgrave, 1986).
25.
A.V. Gaydamakinet al. Istoriya Zheleznodorozhnogo Transporta Rossii: uchebnoe Posobie [The History of Railway Transport: A Textbook] (
Moscow:
FGBOU, 2012).
26.
Alexander Gerschenkron, Economic Backwardness in Historical Perspective.A Book of Essays (
Cambridge MA:
Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1962).
27.
Jan-Bart Gewald, André Lileveld and Iva Peša, “Introduction: Transforming Innovations in Africa; Explorative Studies on Appropriation in African Societies”, in Jan-Bart Gewald, André Lileveld and Iva Peša (eds), Transforming Innovations in Africa. Explorative Studies on Appropriation in African Societies (Leiden & Boston MA: Brill, 2012), 1–16.
Loren Graham, The Ghost of the Executed Engineer. Technology and the Fall of the Soviet Union (
Harvard MA:
Harvard University Press, 1996).
30.
Stephen Graham and Nigel Thrift,
“Out of Order. Understanding Repair and Maintenance”, Theory, Culture and Society24:3 (2007), 1–25.
31.
Takeshi Hayashi, The Japanese Experience in Technology. From Transfer to Self-Reliance (
Tokyo:
United Nations University Press, 1990).
32.
Christopher R. Henke, “Negotiating Repair: The Infrastructural Contexts of Practice and Power”, in StrebelIgnaz, et al. (eds), Repair Work Ethnographies. Revisiting Breakdown, Relocating Materiality (
Leiden and Boston MA:
Palgrave, 2019), 255–82.
33.
Anthony Heywood, Engineer of Revolutionary Russia. Iurii V. Lomonosov (1876–1952) and the Railways (London: Routledge, 2010).
34.
John Hurd, and Ian J.Kerr, India’s Railway History. A Research Handbook (Leiden and Boston MA: Palgrave, 2012).
35.
Steven J. Jackson, “Rethinking Repair”, in Tarleton Gillespie, Pablo J. Boczkowski and Kirsten A. Foot (eds), Media Technologies. Essays on Communication, Materiality, and Society (Cambridge MA & London: The MIT Press, 2014), 221–39.
36.
G.M. Kovel’man, Tvorchestvo pochetnogo akademika inzhenera Vladimira Grigor’evicha Shukhova [The Work of the Distinguished Academician Engineer Vladimir Grigor’evich Shukhov] (Moscow: GILSASM, 1961).
37.
Stefan Krebs, Gabriele Schabacher and Heike Weber, “Kulturen des Reparierens” [“Cultures of Repair and the Lifetime of Things”], in Stefan Krebs, Gabriele Schabacher and Heike Weber (eds), Kulturen Des Reparierens [Cultures of Repair] (Bielefeld: Transcript, 2018), 9–46.
38.
José Luis, Lalana Soto and Luis Santos y Ganges, “Modernization of Railway Workshops”, in Magda Pinheiro (ed.), Railway Modernization. An Historical Perspective (19th and 20th Centuries) (Lisboa: Centro de Estudos de História Contemporánea Portuguesa, 2009), 123–48, here 124.
39.
Christophe Lejeune, “Interruptions, Lunch Talks, and Support Circles: An Ethnography of Collective Repair in Steam Locomotive Restoration”, in StrebelIgnaz, et al. (eds), Repair Work Ethnographies. Revisiting Breakdown, Relocating Materiality (
Leiden & Boston MA:
Palgrave, 2019), 221–51.
40.
G. Lomonosoff, Lokomotivversuche in Russland [Locomotive Testing in Russia] (Berlin: vDi-Verlag, 1926).
41.
Nuno Luís Madureira,
“Oil in the Age of Steam”, Journal of Global History5:1 (2010), 75–94.
42.
Darina Martykánová and Meltem Kocaman, “A Land of Opportunities: Foreign Engineers in the Ottoman Empire”, in Concha Roldán, Daniel Brauer and Johannes Rohbeck (eds), Philosophy of Globalization (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2018). 237–51.
43.
Oskar Mertens, 1882–1911. Dreißig Jahre Russischer Eisenbahnpolitik Und Deren Wirtschaftliche Rückwirkung [1882–1911. Thirty Years of Russian Railway Politics and Its Economic Impact] (Berlin: Springer, 1919).
44.
Matthias Middell and Katja Naumann, “A New Challenge to the Writing of History in Europe at the End of the Twentieth Century?”, in Matthias Middell and Lluis Roura (eds), Transnational Challenges to National History Writing (London: Palgrave, 2013), 423–43.
45.
Boris N. Mironov, “Rossiyskaya Imperiya: ot Traditsii k Modernu [The Russian Empire: From Tradition to Modernity]”, Dmitriy Bulanin 1 (2014) (St. Petersburg: Dmitriy Bulanin, 2014).
46.
Ekaterina Nozhova, Networks of Construction (
Munich:
Hirmer, 2016).
47.
Ocherk Seti Russkikh Zheleznykh Dorog, ee Ustroystva, Soderzhaniya i Deyatel’nosti po 1892 g. [The Description of Russia’s Railway Network, Its Organisation, Maintenance and Operations Until 1892], 2 vols. (St. Petersburg: Tipografiya brat’ev Panteleevykh, 1896).
Opyt sravnitel’nogo statisticheskogo obsledovaniya vsekh proisshestviy, byvshikh na Ruzhd [Experience of Comparative Statistical Research on All the Accidents Happened on the Ryazan–Uralsk Railway] (Saratov: Obshchestvo Ruzhd, 1914).
50.
Jürgen Osterhammel, “Transferanalyse Und Vergleich im Fernverhältnis” [“Transfer Analysis and Comparison from the Distance Relationship”], in Hartmut Kaelble and Jürgen Schriewer (eds), Vergleich Und Transfer. Komparatistik in Den Sozial-, Geschichts- Und Kulturwissenschaften [Comparison and Transfer. Comparative Studies in Social, Historical and Cultural Studies] (Frankfurt/New York: Campus, 2003), 439–66.
51.
Petrov Nikolay Pavlovich, “Glavnye prichiny chrezvychaynogo rosta raskhodov russkikh zheleznykh dorog s 1903 po 1907 gg. i mera vliyaniya etikh prichin [The Main Reasons for the Increase of Expenses on Russian State-Owned Railways from 1903 to 1907 and Their Impact] (St. Petersburg: Gosudarstvennaya Tipografiya, 1909).
52.
Moritz Pollitzer and Die Bahnerhaltung, Theoretische Und Praktische Anleitung Zum Eisenbahn-Erhaltungsdienste [The Maintenance of Railways. A Theoretical and Practical Manual for the Maintenance of Railways]. 2 vols. (
Brünn:
Buschak und Irrgang, 1874–1876).
53.
I.V. Porokh (ed.), Ocherki Istorii Saratovskogo Povolzhya. Vol. 2 (1894-1917) [The History of the Volga Area near Saratov, vol. 2 (1894–1917)] (Saratov: Izdatel’stvo Saratovskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta, 1999).
54.
Irina Potkina,
“The Nikolskaya Mill Partnership and the West European Firms: Some Aspects of Technological Transfer”, Revue Fran Aise D'histoire ConomiqueN 7-8:1–2 (2017), 34–48.
55.
Pyatidesyatiletie Ryazansko–Ural’skoy Zheleznoy Dorogi [The Fiftieth Anniversary of the Ryazan–Uralsk Railway] (Saratov: Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva, 1916).
56.
Alfred Rieber, The Imperial Russian Project. Autocratic Politics, Economic Development, and Social Fragmentation (
Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 2017).
57.
Victor Röllet al. Encyklopädie des gesamten Eisenbahnwesens [Encyclopaedia of the Entire Railway Transport]. 7 vol. (Vienna, 1890–1912).
58.
Andrew L. Russell and Lee Vinsel,
“After Innovation, Turn to Maintenance”, Technology and Culture59:1 (2018), 1–25.
59.
Ryazansko–Ural’skaya Zheleznaya Doroga i ee Rayon [The Ryazan–Uralsk Railway and Its Region] (St. Petersburg: Tipo-litografiya N.I. Evstifeeva, 1913).
G. Saar, Saratovskaja Promyšlennost' v 90-ch i Načale 900-ch gg [Industry in Saratov in the 90s and the Beginning of the 900s] (Saratov: unknown publisher, 1928).
62.
Frithjof Benjamin Schenk, Russlands Fahrt in Die Moderne. Mobilität Und Sozialer Raum im Eisenbahnzeitalter [Russia’s Journey into Modernity. Mobility and Social Space in the Railway Age] (Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 2014).
63.
Josef Otto Slezak, The Locomotive Works of Europe (
Vienna:
Josef Otto Slezak, 1962).
64.
Walter Sperling, Der Aufbruch Der Provinz. Die Eisenbahn Und Die Neuordnung Der Räume im Zarenreich [Emergence of the Province. Railways and the New Spatial Order in the Russian Empire] (
Frankfurt:
Campus, 2011).
65.
Nicolas Spulber, Russia’s Economic Transitions. From Late Tsarism to the New Millennium (
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2003).
66.
Statisticheskiy sbornik Ministerstva Putey Soobshcheniya [Statistical Handbook of the Ministry of Transport]. vol. 31–145 (St. Petersburg: Tipografiya Ministerstva Putey Soobshcheniya, 1893–1914).
67.
Ignaz Strebel, Alain Bovet and Philippe Sormani, “Introduction: When Things Break Down”, in IgnazStrebel, et al. (eds), Repair Work Ethnographies. Revisiting Breakdown, Relocating Materiality (
Leiden & Boston MA:
Palgrave, 2019), 1–27.
68.
Komla Tsey, From Head-Loading to the Iron Horse. Railway Building in Colonial Ghana and the Origins of Tropical Development Account (
Bamenda:
Langaa RPCIG, 2012).
69.
Thomas Urquhart,
“On the Use of Petroleum Refuse as Fuel in Locomotive Engines”, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers35:1 (1884), 272–330.
70.
Thomas Urquhart,
“Supplementary Paper on the Use of Petroleum Refuse as Fuel in Locomotive Engines”, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers40:1 (1889), 36–84.
71.
Steven W. Usselman,
“Air Brakes for Freight Trains: Technological Innovation in the American Railroad Industry1869-1900”, Business History Review58:1 (1984), 30–50.
72.
Steven Usselman, Regulating Railroad Innovation. Business, Technology, and Politics in America, 1840–1920 (
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2002).
73.
Ustav Kievskogo obshchestva dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami [The Statute of the Kiev Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers] (Kiev: Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva, 1910).
74.
Ustav Odesskogo obshchestva dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami [The Statute of the Odessa Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers] (Odessa: Tipografiya “Izdatel”, 1911).
75.
Ustav Severo-zapadnogo obshchestva dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami [The Statute of the Nord-Western Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers] (Vil’no: Tipografiya Iosifa Zavadskogo, 1911.
76.
UstavS. -Peterburgskogo obshchestva dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami [The Statute of the St. Petersburg Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers] (St. Petersburg: Leshtukovskaya parovaya skoropechatnya P. O. Yablonskogo, 1912).
77.
I.I. Volgunov, Al’bom chertezheĭ obshchago raspolozhenii͡a puteĭ, zdaniĭ i mostovykh sooruzheniĭ sushchestvui͡ushchikh v Rossii zheleznykh dorog. Seriya II [The Album of Drawings of the Buildings on Russian Railways. vol.
II] (
Moscow:
Pechatni͡a S. P. I͡akovleva, 1872).
78.
Volzhskoe obshchestvo dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami. Otchet o deyatel’nosti Obshchestva za 1912 God. Perviy operatsionniy god [Volga Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers. Yearly Report 1912. First Operation Year] (Saratov: Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva, 1913).
79.
Volzhskoe obshchestvo dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami. Otchet o deyatel’nosti Obshchestva za 1913 god. Vtoroy operatsionniy god [Volga Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers. Yearly Report 1913. Second Operation Year] (Saratov: Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva, 1914).
80.
Volzhskoe obshchestvo dlya nadzora za parovymi kotlami. Otchet o deyatel’nosti obshchestva za 1914 god. Tretiy operatsionniy god [Volga Society for the Surveillance of Steam Boilers. Yearly Report 1914. Third Operation Year] (Saratov: Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva, 1915).
81.
Michael Werner and Bénédicte Zimmermann,
“Vergleich, Transfer, Verflechtung. Der Ansatz Der Histoire Croisée Und Die Herausforderung Des Transnationalen” [“Comparison, Transfer, Entanglement. The Approach of Histoire Croisée and the Challenge of the Transnational”, Geschichte Und Gesellschaft28 (2002), 607–36.
82.
John Westwood, A History of Russian Railways (
London:
George Allen and Unwin, 1964).
83.
John Westwood, Soviet Railways to Russian Railways (
London:
Palgrave, 2002).
84.
Shehu TijjaniYusuf, “Stealing from the Railways: Blacksmiths, Colonialism and Innovation in Northern Nigeria”, in GewaldJan-BartLileveldAndréPešaIva (eds), Transforming Innovations in Africa. Explorative Studies on Appropriation in African Societies (
Leiden & Boston MA:
Brill, 2012), 275–96.
