Abstract
This paper reconstructs the design history of the Ayalon Crosstown Expressway in Tel Aviv, a project that initiated the technology transfer of American and European transport planning methods to Israel. It examines the unstable, evolving dynamics between agents pushing the technology such as the World Bank and international traffic planning firms, and local institutions pulling or opposing it such as the city, the highway company, and various competing governmental departments. The five successive plans developed for that highway by Canadian, American, French, and British planners offer themselves to comparative analysis of national design philosophies of urban highway systems. Through a close reading of the different geometric plans of one bifurcating interchange, the paper analyses how the technology was adapted to fit the Israeli political, administrative, and economic environment, and identifies a shift in highway planning rationality and techniques for governing mobility at the American source of innovation.
Keywords
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Holtzman, Dan. Interview, Tel Aviv, 15 November 2016 .
2.
Fuchs, Daniel. Interview, Tel Aviv, 14 September 2016 .
3.
Imperial College Archive, London.
4.
Israel State Archive, Jerusalem.
5.Tel Aviv Municipal Archive , Tel Aviv.
6.World Bank Group Archives , http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/home.
7.Madeleine Akrich , “The De-scription of Technical Objects”, in Wiebe E. Bijker and John Law (eds), Shaping Technology/Building Society (Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 1992 ), 205–24.
8.Michele Alacevich , The Political Economy of the World Bank (Palo Alto CA: Stanford University Press, 2009 ).
9.BCEOM and SETEC , Economic Transportation Survey (Jerusalem: Ministry of Labour, 1966 ).
10.Marshal Berman . All That Is Solid Melts into Air: The Experience of Modernity (New York NY: Simon & Schuster, 1982 ).
11.Colin Buchanan , Traffic in Towns: A Study of the Long Term Problems of Traffic in Urban Areas (London: HMSO, 1963 ).
12.Robert Caro , The Power Broker: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York (New York NY: Vintage, 1975 ).
13.Cartier-Cote-Piette-Boulva-Wermenlinger and Associates, Philippe Ewart and Associates, & T.M.D ., The Ayalon Project: Feasibility Study and Engineering Report (Tel-Aviv: Netivey Ayalon, 1968 ).
14.Agnes Deboulet , “Urban Highways as an Embodiment of Mega and Elite Projects: A New Realm of Conflicts and Claims in Three Middle Eastern Capital Cities”, Built Environment 36:2 (2010 ), 146–61.
15.Marc Desportes , “The History of Highway Nodes”, Flux 5 (1991 ), 21–33.
16.Joseph F.C. DiMento and Cliff Ellis , Changing Lanes; Visions and Histories of Urban Freeways (Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 2012 ).
17.David Engerman , “The Romance of Economic Development and New Histories of the Cold War”, Diplomatic History 28:1 (2004 ), 23–54.
18.Eran Fietelson , “The Development of Transport infrastructure in Israel: Geopolitical, Economic, and Security Considerations”, Studies in the Geography of Israel 13 (1993 ), 461–72.
19.J. A. Fraenkel , “The Treatment of Intersections”, Journal of the Association of Engineers and Architects in Israel 3 (1958 ), 79–81.
20.Simon Gunn , “The Buchanan Report, Environment and the Problem of Traffic in 1960s Britain”, Twentieth Century British History 22:4 (2011 ), 521–42.
21.Aaron B . Horwitz, “Preliminary Master Plan for Tel Aviv-Yafo”, Yediot Tel Aviv-Yafo 22:8/9 (1954 ), 2–17.
22.Jane Jacobs , The Death and Life of Great American Cities (New York NY: Random House, 1961 ).
23.John H. Jones , The Geometric Design of Modern Highways (New York NY: Wiley, 1961 ).
24.Louis W. Kemp , “Aesthetes and Engineers: The Occupational Ideology of Highway Design”, Technology and Culture 27:4 (1986 ), 759–97.
25.Yossi Klein , The Beginning of Tel Aviv’s Americanization (Jerusalem: Carmel, 2011 ).
26.Maxwell Lay , “An Historical Review of the Assessment and Management of Congestion”, Road and Transport Research 21:2 (2012 ), 32–45.
27.Jack E. Leisch , “Adaptability of Interchange Types on Interstate System”, Journal of the Highway Division 84:1525 (1958 ), 1–32.
28.Jack E. Leisch , System Planning and Functional Design; Tel Aviv Metropolitan Area Highway Transportation Plan (Tel Aviv: Netivey Ayalon Ltd., 1975 ).
29.Jack E. Leisch , “Dynamics of Highway Design for Safety”, Transportation 6 (1977 ), 71–83.
30.Nathan Marom , City of Concept: Planning Tel Aviv (Tel Aviv: Babel, 2009 ).
31.Ministry of Transport, Israel Transportation Sector: Development Plan 1967/68–1971/72 . Jerusalem: Governmental Printer, 1967 .
32.François Molle , Peter Mollinga and Philippus Wester, “Hydraulic Bureaucracies and the Hydraulic Mission: Flows of Water, Flows of Power”, Water Alternatives 2:3 (2009 ), 328–49.
33.Gijs Mom , “Roads Without Rails: European Highway-Network Building and the Desire for Long-Range Motorized Mobility”, Technology and Culture 46:4 (2005 ), 745–72.
34.N. D. Lea & Associates , Urban Transportation Developments in Eleven Canadian Metropolitan Areas (Ottawa: Canadian Good Roads Association, 1966 ).
35.Per Ostby , “Educating the Norwegian Nation: Traffic Engineering and Technological Diffusion”, Comparative Technology Transfer and Society 2:3 (2004 ), 247–72.
36.Panayiota Pyla , Landscapes of Development: The Impact of Modernization Discourses on the Physical Environment of the Eastern Mediterranean (Cambridge CA: Harvard University Press, 2013 ).
37.Ronald Richardson , George McNevin and Walter Rooke, Building for People: Freeway and Downtown – New Frameworks for Modern Needs (Toronto: The Ryerson Press, 1970 ).
38.Kristin Ross , Fast Cars, Clean Bodies; Decolonization and the Reordering of French Culture (Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 1996 ).
39.Bruce E. Seely , “‘Push’ and ‘Pull’ Factors in Technology Transfer: Moving American-Style Highway Engineering to Europe, 1945–1965”, Comparative Technology Transfer and Society 2:3 (2004 ), 229–46.
40.Arieh Sharon , Physical Planning in Israel (Jerusalem: Government Press, 1951 ).
41.
Nathaniel Smith, “The Idea of the French Hexagon”, French Historical Studies 6:2 (1969 ), 139–55.
42.John Urry , “The ‘System’ of Automobility”, Theory, Culture & Society 21:4/5 (2004 ), 25–39.
43.George M. Webb , Correlation of Geometric Design and Directional Signing (Sacramento CA: California Division of Highways, 1959 ).
44.Thomas Zeller , Driving Germany: The Landscape of the German Autobahn, 1930–1970 (New York NY: Berghahn Books, 2007 ).