A National Analysis of Music Coursetaking,Social-Emotional Learning,and Academic Achievement Using Propensity Scores

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine the association between curricular high school music participation, academic achievement, and social-emotional learning. The analysis involved a “doubly robust” approach combining propensity score weighting and nested multiple regression using data from the nationally representative High School Longitudinal Study of 2009. Results of the study were mixed. Preliminary tests revealed many significant differences between the choral and instrumental students and the control group, but the propensity score weighting moderated almost all of these effects to nonsignificance. The only unambiguously positive finding was that instrumental music students had higher reading scores than comparable students who did not enroll in music. Yet, subpopulation effects emerged for certain categories of music students based on factors such as race, sex, and prior school achievement. Although the lack of widespread main effects in this study coheres with prior research, the results for certain subpopulations suggest intriguing future directions for research on potential extramusical benefits of music education.

Keywords

music education academic achievement social-emotional learning test scores advocacy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abril

C. R.

(2017, May 15). Should we keep using the term “general” in general music? Music in a Minuet, National Association for Music Education. https://nafme.org/should-we-keep-using-term-general-music/

Adderley

Kennedy

Berz

(2003). “A home away from home”: The world of the high school music classroom. Journal of Research in Music Education, 51(3), 190–205. https://doi.org/10.2307/3345373

Austin

P. C.

Stuart

E. A.

(2015). Moving towards best practice when using inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) using the propensity score to estimate causal treatment effects in observational studies. Statistics in Medicine, 34, 3661–3679. https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.6607

Bang

Robins

J. M.

(2005). Doubly robust estimation in missing data and causal inference models. Biometrics, 61(4), 962–972. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0420.2005.00377.x

Bartolome

S. J.

(2013). “It’s like a whole bunch of me!”: The perceived values and benefits of the Seattle Girls’ Choir experience. Journal of Research in Music Education, 60(4), 395–418. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022429412464054

Bergee

M. J.

Weingarten

K. M.

(2021). Multilevel models of the relationship between music achievement and reading and math achievement. Journal of Research in Music Education, 68(4), 398–418. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022429420941432

Bradby

Pedroso

Rogers

(2007). Secondary School Course Classification System: School Codes for the Exchange of Data (SCED) (NCES 2007-341). National Center for Education Statistics. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2007/2007341.pdf

Brenner

(2010). Reflecting on the rationales for string study in schools. Philosophy of Music Education Review, 18(1), 45–64. https://doi.org/10.2979/PME.2010.18.1.45

Broh

B. A.

(2002). Linking extracurricular programming to academic achievement: Who benefits and why? Sociology of Education, 75(1), 69–95. https://doi.org/10.2307/3090254

10.

Brown

N. C. M.

(2001). The meaning of transfer in the practices of arts education. Studies in Art Education, 43(1), 83–102. https://doi.org/10.2307/1320994

11.

Cabanac

Perlovsky

Bonniot-Cabanac

M.-C.

Cabanac

(2013). Music and academic performance. Behavioural Brain Research, 256, 257–260. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2013.08.023

12.

Catterall

J. S.

(2009). Doing well and doing good by doing art: A 12-year national study of education in the visual and performing arts. Imagination Group/I-Group Books.

13.

Chapman

L. H.

(2001). Can the arts win hearts and minds? Arts Education Policy Review, 102(5), 21–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/10632910109600012

14.

Chen

C.-S.

Sable

Mitchell

Liu

(2012). Documentation to the NCES Common Core of Data public elementary/secondary school universe survey: School year 2009–10 (NCES 2011-348rev). National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education. http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubs.info.asp?pubid=2011348rev

15.

Cohen

R. I.

(2017, February 14). Top 10 reasons to support the arts in 2017. ARTS Blog. http://blog.americansforthearts.org/2017/02/14/top-10-reasons-to-support-the-arts-in-2017

16.

Costa-Giomi

(1999). The effects of three years of piano instruction on children’s cognitive development. Journal of Research in Music Education, 47(3), 198–212. https://doi.org/10.2307/3345779

17.

Costa-Giomi

(2004). Effects of three years of piano instruction on children’s academic achievement, school performance and self-esteem. Psychology of Music, 32(2), 139–152. https://doi.org/10.1177/0305735604041491

18.

Costa-Giomi

(2015). The long-term effects of childhood music instruction on intelligence and general cognitive abilities. Update: Applications of Research in Music Education, 33(2), 20–26. https://doi.org/10.1177/8755123314540661

19.

Dagaz

M. C.

(2012). Learning from the band: Trust, acceptance, and self-confidence. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 41(4), 432–461. https://doi.org/10.1177/0891241612447813

20.

Degé

Wehrum

Stark

Schwarzer

(2014). Music lessons and academic self-concept in 12- to 14-year-old children. Musicae Scientiae, 18(2), 203–215. https://doi.org/10.1177/1029864914523283

21.

Demorest

S. M.

Morrison

S. J.

(2000). Does music make you smarter? Music Educators Journal, 87(2), 33–58. https://doi.org/10.2307/3399646

22.

Duprey

M. A.

Pratt

D. J.

Jewell

D. M.

Cominole

M. B.

Fritch

L. B.

Ritchie

E. A.

Rogers

J. E.

Wescott

J. D.

Wilson

D. H.

(2018). High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 (HSLS:09) Base-year to second follow-up (NCES 2018-140). National Center for Education Statistics. https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2018140

23.

Edgar

S. N.

Elias

M. J.

(2020). Setting the stage for social emotional learning (SEL) policy and the arts. Arts Education Policy Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/10632913.2020.1777494

24.

Edgar

S. N.

Morrison

(2020). A vision for social emotional learning and arts education policy. Arts Education Policy Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/10632913.2020.1774830

25.

Elliott

D. J.

Silverman

McPherson

G. E.

(2019). Philosophical and qualitative perspectives on assessment in music education: Introduction, aims, and overview. In Elliott

D. J.

Silverman

McPherson

G. E.

(Eds.), The Oxford handbook of philosophical and qualitative assessment in music education (pp. 3–26). Oxford University Press.

26.

Ellis

P. D.

(2010). The essential guide to effect sizes: Statistical power, meta-analysis, and the interpretation of research results. Cambridge University Press.

27.

Elpus

(2013a). Arts education and positive youth development: Cognitive, behavioral, and social outcomes of adolescents who study the arts. National Endowment for the Arts. https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Research-Art-Works-Maryland.pdf

28.

Elpus

(2013b). Is it the music or is it selection bias? A nationwide analysis of music and non-music students’ SAT scores. Journal of Research in Music Education, 61(2), 175–194. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022429413485601

29.

Elpus

Abril

C. R.

(2019). Who enrolls in high school music? A national profile of U.S. students, 2009–2013. Journal of Research in Music Education, 67(3), 323–338. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022429419862837

30.

Fitzpatrick

K. R.

(2006). The effect of instrumental music participation and socioeconomic status on Ohio fourth-, sixth-, and ninth-grade proficiency test performance. Journal of Research in Music Education, 54(1), 73–84. https://doi.org/10.2307/3653456

31.

Foster

E. M.

Jenkins

J. V.

(2017). Does participation in music and performing arts influence child development? American Educational Research Journal, 54(3), 399–443. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831217701830

32.

Gouzouasis

Guhn

Kishor

(2007). The predictive relationship between achievement and participation in music and achievement in core grade 12 academic subjects. Music Education Research, 9(1), 81–92. https://doi.org/10.1080/14613800601127569

33.

Graham

J. W.

(2009). Missing data analysis: Making it work in the real world. Annual Review of Psychology, 60, 549–576. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.psych.58.110405.085530

34.

Guhn

Emerson

S. D.

Gouzouasis

(2020). A population-level analysis of associations between school music participation and academic achievement. Journal of Educational Psychology, 112(2), 308–328. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000376

35.

Guo

Fraser

M. W.

(2015). Propensity score analysis: Statistical methods and applications (2nd ed.). SAGE.

36.

Hahs-Vaughn

D. L.

(2015). Propensity score analysis with complex survey samples. In Pan

Bai

(Eds.), Propensity score analysis: Fundamentals and developments (pp. 236–264). Guilford Press.

37.

Hallam

(2010). The power of music: Its impact on the intellectual, social and personal development of children and young people. International Journal of Music Education, 28(3), 269–289. https://doi.org/10.1177/0255761410370658

38.

Hallberg

Cook

T. D.

Steiner

P. M.

Clark

M. H.

(2018). Pretest measures of the study outcome and the elimination of selection bias: Evidence from three within study comparisons. Prevention Science, 19, 274–283. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11121-016-0732-6

39.

Harder

V. S.

Stuart

E. A.

Anthony

J. C.

(2010). Propensity score techniques and the assessment of measured covariate balance to test causal associations in psychological research. Psychological Methods, 15(3), 234–249. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0019623

40.

Haviland

Nagin

D. S.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

(2007). Combining propensity score matching and group-based trajectory analysis in an observational study. Psychological Methods, 12(3), 247–267. https://doi.org/10.1037/1082-989X.12.3.247

41.

Helmrich

B. H.

(2010). Window of opportunity? Adolescence, music, and algebra. Journal of Adolescent Research, 25(4), 557–577. https://doi.org/10.1177/0743558410366594

42.

Hoffman

D. M.

(2009). Reflecting on social emotional learning: A critical perspective on trends in the United States. Review of Educational Research, 79(2), 533–556. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654308325184

43.

Johnson

C. M.

Memmott

J. E.

(2006). Examination of relationships between participation in school music programs of differing quality and standardized test results. Journal of Research in Music Education, 54(4), 293–307. https://doi.org/10.1177/002242940605400403

44.

Kinney

D. W.

(2008). Selected demographic variables, school music participation, and achievement test scores of urban middle school students. Journal of Research in Music Education, 56(2), 145–161. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022429408322530

45.

Kinney

D. W.

(2019). Selected nonmusic predictors of urban students’ decisions to enroll and persist in middle and high school music ensemble electives. Journal of Research in Music Education, 67(1), 23–44. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022429418809972

46.

Mahoney

J. L.

Durlak

J. A.

Weissberg

R. P.

(2018). An update on social and emotional learning outcome research. The Phi Delta Kappan, 100(4), 18–23. https://kappanonline.org/social-emotional-learning-outcome-research-mahoney-durlak-weissberg/

47.

Miksza

(2007). Music participation and socioeconomic status as correlates of change: A longitudinal analysis of academic achievement. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 172, 41–58.

48.

Miksza

(2010). Investigating relationships between participation in high school music ensembles and extra-musical outcomes: An analysis of the Education Longitudinal Study of 2002 using a bioecological development model. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 186, 7–25.

49.

Morgan

S. L.

Winship

(2007). Counterfactuals and causal inference: Methods and principles for social research. Cambridge University Press.

50.

National Association for Music Education. (2020). Music education and social emotional learning. https://nafme.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/NAfME-SEL-Brochure-May-2020.pdf

51.

Omasta

Graham

Milling

S. L.

Murray

Jensen

A. P.

Siebert

J. J.

(2020). Social emotional learning and the national core arts standards: A cross-disciplinary analysis of policy and practices. Arts Education Policy Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/10632913.2020.1773366

52.

Portowitz

Lichtenstein

Egorova

Brand

(2009). Underlying mechanisms linking music education and cognitive modifiability. Research Studies in Music Education, 31(2), 107–128. https://doi.org/10.1177/1321103X09344378

53.

Raghunathan

Solenberger

Berglund

P. A.

van Hoewyk

(2016). IVEware: Imputation and variance estimation software (Version 0.3) [Computer software]. Survey Research Center, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan. https://www.src.isr.umich.edu/software/

54.

Richerme

L. K.

(2020). Every Student Succeeds Act and social emotional learning: Opportunities and considerations for P-12 arts educators. Arts Education Policy Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/10632913.2020.1787284

55.

Rickard

N. S.

Appelman

James

Murphy

Gill

Bambrick

(2013). Orchestrating life skills: The effect of increased school-based music classes on children’s social competence and self-esteem. International Journal of Music Education, 31(3), 292–309. https://doi.org/10.1177/0255761411434824

56.

Rickard

N. S.

Bambrick

C. J.

Gill

(2012). Absence of widespread psychosocial and cognitive effects of school-based music instruction in 10–13-year-old students. International Journal of Music Education, 30(1), 57–78. https://doi.org/10.1177/0255761411431399

57.

Ridgeway

Kovalchik

S. A.

Griffin

B. A.

Kabeto

M. U.

(2015). Propensity score analysis with survey weighted data. Journal of Causal Inference, 3(2), 237–249. https://doi.org/10.1515/jci-2014-0039

58.

Ridgeway

McCaffrey

Morral

Burgette

Griffin

B. A.

(2017). Toolkit for weighting and analysis of nonequivalent groups: A tutorial for the twang package. RAND Corporation. ftp://xyz.csail.mit.edu/pub/CRAN/web/packages/twang/vignettes/twang.pdf

59.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

(2010). Design of observational studies. Springer.

60.

Schafer

J. L.

Kang

(2008). Average causal effects from nonrandomized studies: A practical guide and simulated example. Psychological Methods, 13(4), 279–313. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0014268

61.

Schellenberg

E. G.

Weiss

M. W.

(2013). Music and cognitive abilities. In Deutsch

(Ed.), The psychology of music (3rd ed., pp. 499–550). Academic Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-381460-9.00012-2

62.

Shadish

W. R.

Cook

T. D.

Campbell

D. T.

(2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Wadsworth.

63.

Shaw

B. P.

(2020). A national analysis of music coursetaking, social-emotional learning, and academic achievement using propensity scores [Doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University]. http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu1586447314622808

64.

Shin

(2011). An investigation of participation in weekly music workshops and its relationship to academic self-concept and self-esteem of middle school students in low-income communities. Contributions to Music Education, 38(2), 29–42.

65.

Southgate

D. E.

Roscigno

V. J.

(2009). The impact of music on childhood and adolescent achievement. Social Science Quarterly, 90(1), 4–21. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6237.2009.00598.x

66.

Steiner

P. M.

Cook

T. D.

Shadish

W. R.

Clark

M. H.

(2010). The importance of covariate selection in controlling for selection bias in observational studies. Psychological Methods, 15(3), 250–267. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0018719

67.

Stevenson

L. M.

Deasy

(2005). Third space: When learning matters. Arts Education Partnership.

68.

Taylor

R. D.

Oberle

Durlak

J. A.

Weissberg

R. P.

(2017). Promoting positive youth development through school-based social and emotional learning interventions: A meta-analysis of follow-up effects. Child Development, 88(4), 1156–1171. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12864

69.

Vitale

J. L.

(2011). Music makes you smarter: A new paradigm for music education? Perceptions and perspectives from four groups of elementary education stakeholders. Canadian Journal of Education, 34(3), 317–343.

70.

Wasserstein

R. L.

Lazar

N. A.

(2016). The ASA’s statement on p-values: Context, process, and purpose. The American Statistician, 70(2), 129–133. https://doi.org/10.1080/00031305.2016.1154108

71.

West

Clauhs

(2015). Strengthening music programs while avoiding advocacy pitfalls. Arts Education Policy Review, 116(2), 57–62. https://doi.org/10.1080/10632913.2015.1007831

72.

What Works Clearinghouse. (2014). Procedures and standards handbook, Version 3.0. Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/pdf/reference_resources/wwc_procedures_v3_0_standards_handbook.pdf

73.

Winner

Cooper

(2000). Mute those claims: No evidence (yet) for a causal link between arts study and academic achievement. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 34(3/4), 11–75. https://doi.org/10.2307/3333637

74.

Yang

(2015). The impact of music on educational attainment. Journal of Cultural Economics, 39(4), 369–396. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10824-015-9240-y

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

1.12 MB