Objectives: This study examines the association between a country's gun availability and firearm-related terrorism. Methods: Employing data from 140 countries, we assess the possible relationship between a country's rate of suicide by firearm and their count of terrorist attacks involving a firearm through a series of structural equation models. Results: Collectively, we find that there is a positive relationship between gun availability and firearm-related terrorism in 2016 and 2017. However, this result fails our robustness check and is sensitive to the inclusion of the U.S. Conclusion: With important caveats, we believe the U.S. to be unique in terms of both gun availability and terrorism.
Ajdacic-GrossV.KilliasM.HeppU.GadolaE.BoppM.LauberC.RosslerW.. 2006. “Changing Times: A Longitudinal Analysis of International Firearm Suicide Data.” American Journal of Public Health96(10):1752–1755.
2.
Ajdacic-GrossV.KilliasM.HeppU.HaymozS.BoppM.GutzwillerF.RosslerW.. 2010. “Firearm Suicides and Availability of Firearms: The Swiss Experience.” European Psychiatry25(7):432–434.
3.
AltheimerI.2008. “Do Guns Matter? A Multi-Level Cross-National Examination of gun Availability on Assault and Robbery Victimization.” Western Criminology Review9(2):9–32.
4.
AltheimerI.BoswellM.. 2012. “Reassessing the Association Between gun Availability and Homicide at the Cross-National Level.” American Journal of Criminal Justice37:682–704.
5.
ArgomanizJ.Vidal-DiezA.. 2015. “Examining Deterrence and Backlash Effects in Counter-Terrorism: The Case of ETA.” Terrorism and Political Violence27(1):160–181.
6.
AyánM.RamirezM.DíazM.. 2009. “Path Analysis Models Versus Latent variable Models: Examples From Educational and Health Approaches.” International Journal of Hispanic Psychology2(2):91–110.
7.
BangaloreS.MesserliF. H.. 2014. “Gun Ownership and Firearm-Related Deaths.” American Journal of Medicine126:873–876.
8.
Beccaria, C. 1764. An essay on crimes and punishments.
9.
Bentham, J. 1789. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation.
10.
BertoliP.GrembiV.. 2017. “The Life-Saving Effect of Hospital Proximity.” Health Economics26:78–91.
11.
BetusAllisonKearnsErinLemieuxAnthony. 2019. “‘Terrorism’ or ‘Mental Illness?’: Factors That Impact How Media Label Terrorist Attacks.”
BollenK. A.1989. “A New Incremental Fit Index for General Structural Equation Models.” Sociological Methods & Research17(3):303–316.
14.
BoutwellJ.KlareM.. 1999. Light Weapons and Civil Conflict. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
15.
BrantinghamP. L.BrantinghamP. J.. 1990. “Situational crime prevention in practice”. Canadian journal of criminology32(1):17–40.
16.
BremS.RutherfordK. R.. 2001. “The Landmine Ban and the Debate on Small Arms and Light Weapons: Walking Together or Divided Agenda?” Security Dialogue32(2):169–186.
17.
BrittC. L.KleckG.BorduaD. J.. 1996. “A Reassessment of the D.C. Gun Law: Some Cautionary Notes on the Use of Interrupted Time Series Designs for Policy Impact.” Law & Society Review30(2):361–380.
18.
CaoL.CullenF. T.LinkB. G.. 1997. “The Social Determinants of Gun Ownership: Self-Protection in an Urban Environment.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal35(4):629–658.
19.
CarsonJ. V.2017. “Assessing the Effectiveness of High-Profile Targeted Killings in the “War on Terror:” A Quasi-Experiment.” Criminology & Public Policy16(1):191–220.
20.
ClarkeR. V. G. (Ed.). 1997. Situational Crime Prevention. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.
21.
ClarkeR. V.MayhewP.. 1988. “The British Gas Suicide Story and its Criminological Implications.” Crime and Justice10:79–116.
22.
ClarkeR. V. G.NewmanG. R.. 2006. Outsmarting the Terrorists. Greenwood Publishing Group.
23.
CoffmanD. L.MacCallumR. C.. 2005. “Using Parcels to Convert Path Analysis Models Into Latent Variable Models.” Multivariate Behavioral Research40(2):235–259.
24.
CohenL. E.FelsonM.. 1979. “Social change and crime rate trends: A routine activity approach”. American sociological review588–608.
25.
CookP. J.LudwigJ.. 1996. Guns in America. Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.
26.
CookP. J.LudwigJ.. 1998. “Defensive Gun Uses: New Evidence From A National Survey.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology14(2):111–131.
27.
CooperN.MutimerD.. 2011. “Arms Control for the 21st Century: Controlling the Means of Violence.” Contemporary Security Policy32(1):3–19.
28.
CornishD. B.ClarkeR. V.. 2003. “Opportunities, Precipitators, and Criminal Decisions: A Reply to Wortley’s Critique of Situational Crime Prevention.” Crime Prevention Studies16:41–96.
29.
CozensP. M. 2011Urban planning and environmental criminology: Towards a new perspective for safer cities. Planning practice and research26(4):481–508.
30.
DahlbergS.HolmbergSörenRothsteinBoPachonNatalia AlvaradoSvenssonRichard. 2018. The Quality of Government Basic Dataset, Version Jan18. University of Gothenburg: The Quality of Government Institute (http://www.qog.pol.gu.se, doi: 10.18157/QoGBasJan18).
31.
DavisR. C.OrtizC.RoweR.BrozJ.RigakosG.CollinsP.. 2006. An Assessment of the Preparedness of Large Retail Malls to Prevent and Respond to Terrorist Attack. A Report Submitted to US Department of Justice.
32.
DierenfeldtR.BrownT. C.RolesR. A.. 2017. “Re-considering the Structural Covariates of Gun Crime: An Examination of Direct and Moderated Effects.” Deviant Behavior38(2):208–225.
33.
D’OrazioV.SalehyanI.. 2018. “Who Is A Terrorist? Ethnicity, Group Affiliation, and Understandings of Political Violence.” International Interactions44(6):1017–1039.
34.
DuganL.ChenowethE.. 2012. “Moving Beyond Deterrence: The Effectiveness of Raising the Expected Utility of Abstaining From Terrorism in Israel.” American Sociological Review77(4):597–624.
35.
Dugan, L., LaFree, G., & Piquero, A. R. (2005). Testing a rational choice model of airline hijackings. Criminology 43(4):1031–1065.
36.
DuganL.HuangJ. Y.LaFreeG.McCauleyC.. 2008. “Sudden Desistance From Terrorism: The Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of Armenia and the Justice Commandos of the Armenian Genocide.” Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict1(3):231–249.
37.
DugganM.2001. “More Guns, More Crime.” Journal of Political Economy109:1086–1114.
38.
FisherD.AsalV.. 2020 “Before and During Iraq: Was Insurgent Lethality Impacted by the Invasion of Iraq?” in Post-ISIS Era: Regional and Global Implications. NATO Science for Peace and Security Series, edited by CubuckuS.OzerenS.. Berlin: Springer.
39.
FisherD.BeckerM. H.. 2019. “The Heterogeneous Repercussions of Killing Osama Bin Laden on Global Terrorism Patterns.” European Journal of Criminology, Online First. doi: 10.1177/1477370819850103
40.
FolmerE. O.van der GeestM.JansenE.OlffH.AndersonT. M.PiersmaT.van GilsJ. A.. 2012. “Seagrass–Sediment Feedback: An Exploration Using A non-Recursive Structural Equation Model.” Ecosystems15(8):1380–1393.
41.
FreilichJ. D.2015. “Beccaria and situational crime prevention”. Criminal Justice Review40(2):131–150.
42.
FreilichJ. D.ChermakS. M.HsuH. Y.. 2018. “Deterring and Preventing Terrorism.” Pp. 434–443 in Routledge Handbook of Terrorism and counterterrorism.
43.
FreilichJ. D.GruenewaldJ.MandalaM.. 2019. “Situational Crime Prevention and Terrorism: An Assessment of 10 Years of Research.” Criminal Justice Policy Review30(9):1283–1311.
44.
FreilichJ. D.NewmanG. R.. 2017. “Situational Crime Prevention.” in Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal justice.
45.
GauJ. M.2010. “Basic Principles and Practices of Structural Equation Modeling in Criminal Justice and Criminology Research.” Journal of Criminal Justice Education21(2):136–151.
46.
GollobH. F.ReichardtC. S.. 1991. “Interpreting and Estimating Indirect Effects Assuming Time Lags Really Matter.” in Best Methods for the Analysis of Change: Recent Advances, Unanswered Questions, Future Directions, edited by CollinsL. M.HornJ. L.. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
47.
GoreaR. K.2006. “Impact of Proliferation of Small Arms and Light Weapons in South Asia.” Medicine, Conflict and Survival22(3):199–206.
48.
GrabherrS.JohnerS.DilitzC.BuckU.KilliasM.ManginP.PlattnerT.. 2010. “Homicide-suicide Cases in Switzerland and Their Impact on the Swiss Weapon law.” The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology31(4):335–349.
49.
GrillotS. R.2011. “Guns in the Balkans: Controlling Small Arms and Light Weapons in Seven Western Balkan Countries.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies10(2):147–171.
50.
GripL.2015. “History Never Repeats? Imports, Impact and Control of Small Arms in Africa.” Contemporary Security Policy36(1):79–103.
51.
GruenewaldJ.2011. “A Comparative Examination of Homicides Perpetrated by far-Right Extremists.” Homicide Studies15(2):177–203.
52.
GruenewaldJ.KleinB. R.FreilichJ. D.ChermakS.. 2016. “American Jihadi Terrorism: A Comparison of Homicides and Unsuccessful Plots.” Terrorism and Political Violence: 1–20.
53.
HammM S. 2007. Terrorism as crime: from Oklahoma City to Al-Qaeda and beyond. Vol 7, NYU Press.
54.
HauserW.KleckG.. 2013. “Guns and Fear: A one-way Street?” Crime and Delinquency59(2):271–291.
55.
HaydukL. A.RobinsonH. P.CummingsG. G.BoaduK.VerbeekE. L.PerksT. A.. 2007. “The Weird World, and Equally Weird Measurement Models: Reactive Indicators and the Validity Revolution.” Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal14(2):280–310.
56.
HaywoodK.2007. “Situational Crime Prevention and its Discontents: Rational Choice Theory Versus the “Culture of now.” Social Policy & Administration41(3):232–250.
57.
HemenwayD.MillerM.. 2000. “Firearm Availability and Homicide Rates Across 26 High-Income Countries.” The Journal of Trauma, Injury, Infection, and Critical Care49:985–988.
58.
HenselerJ.2018. “Partial Least Squares Path Modeling: Quo Vadis?” Quality & Quantity52(1):1–8.
59.
HoffmanB.Forest.J.2017. Inside Terrorism (Revised Edition). Columbia University Press.
HuffC.KertzerJ. D.. 2018. “How the Public Defines Terrorism.” American Journal of Political Science62(1):55–71.
62.
HureauD. M.BragaA. A.. 2018. “The Trade in Tools: The Market for Illicit Guns in High-Risk Networks.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal56(3):510–545.
63.
HurkaS.KnillC.. 2020. “Does Regulation Matter? A Cross-National Analysis of the Impact of gun Policies on Homicide and Suicide Rates.” Regulation & Governance14:787–803.
64.
JacksonB. A.FrelingerD. R.. 2008. “Rifling Through the Terrorists’ Arsenal: Exploring Groups’ Weapon Choices and Technology Strategies.” Studies in Conflict & Terrorism31(7):583–604.
JungR. S.JasonL. A.. 1988. “Firearm Violence and the Effects of gun Control Legislation.” American Journal of Community Psychology16:515–524.
67.
KatesD. B.1989. “Firearms and Violence: Old Premises and Current Evidence.” Pp. 197–215, Vol. 1 in Violence in America: The History of Crime, edited by GurrT. R.. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
68.
KatesD. B.1997. “Making A Case for Gun Ownership: Israeli-US Contrasts.” Christian Science Monitor90:15–18.
69.
KattelmanK. T.2020. “Assessing Success of the Global War on Terror: Terrorist Attack Frequency and the Backlash Effect.” Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict13(1):67–86.
70.
KhalilU.2017. “Do More Guns Lead to More Crime? Understanding the Role of Illegal Firearms.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization133:342–361.
71.
KilliasM.1993a. “International Correlations Between Gun Ownership and Rates of Homicide and Suicide.” Canadian Medical Association Journal148(10):1721–1725.
72.
KilliasM.1993b “Gun Ownership, Suicide, and Homicide: An International Perspective.” in Understanding Crime: Experiences of Crime and Crime Control, edited by del FrateA.ZvekicU.van Dijik (pp. 289-303)J. J. M.. Rome: UNICRI.
73.
KilliasM.van KesterenJ.RindlisbacherM.. 2001. “Guns, Violent Crime, and Suicide in 21 Countries.” Canadian Journal of Criminology43:429–448.
74.
KinsellaD.2006. “The Black Market in Small Arms: Examining A Social Network.” Contemporary Security Policy27(1):100–117.
75.
KlareM.1999 “An Overview of the Global Trade in Small Arms and Light Weapons.” Pp. 3–10 in Small Arms Control: Old Weapons, new Issues, edited by LumpeL.GabelnickT.. New York, NY: Ashgate.
76.
KleckG.1997. Targeting Guns: Firearms and Their Control. New York, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
77.
KleckG.2001. “Impossible Policy Evaluations and Impossible Conclusions: A Comment on Koper and Roth.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology17(1):75–80.
78.
KleckG.2004. “Measures of Gun Ownership Levels for Macro-Level Crime and Violence Research.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency41(1):3–36.
79.
KleckG.2015. “The Impact of Gun Ownership Rates on Crime Rates: A Methodological Review of the Evidence.” Journal of Criminal Justice43:40–48.
80.
KleckG.2021. “The Cross-National Association of Gun Ownership Rates and Suicide Rates: An Analysis of 194 Nations.” Archives of Suicide Research: 1–9. DOI: 10.1080/13811118.2021.1922110
81.
KleckG.KovandzicT.SaberM.HauserW.. 2011. “The Effect of Perceived Risk and Victimization on Plans to Purchase A Gun for Self-Protection.” Journal of Criminal Justice39(4):312–319.
82.
KleckG.McElrathK.. 1991. “The Effects of Weaponry on Human Violence.” Social Forces69(3):669–692.
83.
KleckG.PattersonB.. 1993. “The Impact of Gun Control and Gun Ownership Levels on Violence Rates.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology9:249–287.
84.
KleinB. R.GruenewaldJ.SmithB. L.. 2017. “Opportunity, Group Structure, Temporal Patterns, and Successful Outcomes of Far-Right Terrorism Incidents in the United States.” Crime & Delinquency63(10):1224–1249.
85.
KlineR. B.2015. “The Mediation Myth.” Basic and Applied Social Psychology37(4):202–213.
86.
Koehler-DerrickG.MiltonD. J.. 2019. “Choose Your Weapon: The Impact of Strategic Considerations and Resource Constraints on Terrorist Group Weapon Selection.” Terrorism and Political Violence31(5):909–928.
87.
KopelD. B.1992. The Samurai, the Mountie, and the Cowboy: Should America Adopt the Gun Controls of Other Democracies?Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.
88.
KoperC. S.RothC. S.. 2001a. “The Impact of the 1994 Federal Assault Weapon Ban on Gun Violence Outcomes: An Assessment of Multiple Outcome Measures and Some Lessons for Policy.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology17(1):33–74.
89.
KovandzicT.KleckG.. 2021. “The Impact of Firearm Levels on Homicide Rates: The Effects of Controlling for Cultural Differences in Cross-National Research.” American Journal of Criminal Justice: 1–15. (Online First).
90.
KovandzicT.SchafferM. E.KleckG.. 2012. “Gun Prevalence, Homicide Rates and Causality: A GMM Approach to Endogeneity Bias.” in The Sage Handbook of Criminological Research Methods, edited by GaddD.KarstedtS.MessnerS. F. (pg. 1-57). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
91.
KovandzicT.SchafferM. E.KleckG.. 2013. “Estimating the Causal Effect of Gun Prevalence on Homicide Rates: A Local Average Treatment Effect Approach.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology29:477–541.
92.
KwonI. G.BaackD. W.. 2005. “The Effectiveness of Legislation Controlling Gun Usage: A Holistic Measure of Gun Control Legislation.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology64(2):533–547.
93.
LafreeG. 1999. “A summary and review of cross-national comparative studies of homicide”. Homicide: A sourcebook of social research1:125.
94.
LaFreeG.BersaniB. E.. 2014. “County-Level Correlates of Terrorist Attacks in the U.S.” Criminology & Public Policy13(3):455–481.
95.
LaFreeG.DuganL.. 2007. “Introducing the Global Terrorism Database.” Terrorism and Political Violence19(1):181–204. doi: 10.1080/09546550701246817
96.
LaFreeG.DuganL.KorteR.. 2009. “The Impact of British Counterterrorist Strategies on Political Violence in Northern Ireland: Comparing Deterrence and Backlash Models.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal47(1):17–45.
97.
LankfordA.2016. “Public Mass Shootings and Firearms: A Cross-National Study of 171 Countries.” Violence and Victims31(2):187–199.
98.
LathamA.1999. “Light Weapons and Human Security—A Conceptual Overview.” Pp. 13–14 in Small Arms Control: Old Weapons, New Issues, edited by LumpeL.GabelnickT.. New York, NY: Ashgate.
99.
LegaultR. L.HendricksonJ. C.. 2009. “Weapon Choice and American Political Violence: A Comparison of Terrorists and Other Felons in Federal Custody.” Criminology & Public Policy8(3):531–559.
100.
LesterD.1991. “Crime as Opportunity: A Test of the Hypothesis With European Homicide Rates.” British Journal of Criminology31(2):186–188.
101.
LoftinC.McDowallD.WiersemaB.TalbertJ. C.. 1991. “Effects of Restrictive Licensing of Handguns on Homicide and Suicide in the District of Columbia.” New England Journal of Medicine325:1615–1620.
102.
LottJ. R.2003. The Bias Against Guns: Why Almost Everything You’ve Heard About Gun Control Is Wrong. Washington, D.C.: Regnery Publishing.
103.
LottJ. R.MustardD. B.. 1997. “Crime, Deterrence, and Right-to-Carry Concealed Handguns.” Journal of Legal Studies26:1–68.
104.
MacCallumR. C.AustinJ. T.. 2000. “Applications of Structural Equation Modeling in Psychological Research.” Annual Review of Psychology51(1):201–226.
105.
MacKinnonD. P.KrullJ. L.LockwoodC. M.. 2000. “Equivalence of the Mediation, Confounding and Suppression Effect.” Prevention Science1(4):173–181.
106.
MalikO. F.SchatA. C.RaziqM. M.ShahzadA.KhanM.. 2018. “Relationships Between Perceived Risk of Terrorism, Fear, and Avoidance Behaviors among Pakistani University Students: A Multi-Group Study.” Personality and Individual Differences124:39–44.
MaxwellS. E.ColeD. A.MitchellM. A.. 2011. “Bias in Cross-Sectional Analyses of Longitudinal Mediation: Partial and Complete Mediation Under an Autoregressive Model.” Multivariate Behavioral Research46(5):816–841.
109.
McDowallD.LoftinC.WiersemaB.. 1996. “Using Quasi-Experiments to Evaluate Firearm Laws: Comment on Britt et al.’s Reassessment of the D.C. Gun Law.” Law & Society Review30(2):381–392.
MillerE.2016. Patterns of Terrorism in the United States, 1970-2014. College Park, MD: START.
112.
MillerM.AzraelD.HemenwayD.. 2002. “Firearm Availability and Unintentional Firearm Deaths, Suicide, and Homicide among 5–14 Year Olds.” Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery52(2):267–275.
113.
MillerM.HemenwayD.AzraelD.. 2007. “State-level Homicide Victimization Rates in the US in Relation to Survey Measures of Household Firearm Ownership, 2001–2003.” Social Science & Medicine64(3):656–664.
MillsapR. E.2007. “Structural Equation Modeling Made Difficult.” Personality and Individual Differences42(5):875–881.
116.
MironJ. A.2001. “Violence, Guns, and Drugs: A Cross-Country Analysis.” The Journal of Law and Economics44:615–633.
117.
National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START). 2017. Global Terrorism Database [Data File and Codebook]. Retrieved from (https://www.start.umd.edu/gtd).
118.
NewmanG.MarongiuP.. 1997Situational crime prevention and the Utilitarian theories of Jeremy Bentham. Rational Choice and Situational Crime Prevention: Theoretical Foundations137–62.
119.
PiazzaJ. A.2016. “Oil and Terrorism: An Investigation of Mediators.” Public Choice169(3-4):251–268.
120.
PiazzaJ. A.ChoiS. W.. 2018. “International Military Interventions and Transnational Terrorist Backlash.” International Studies Quarterly62(3):686–695.
121.
PoeR.2001. The Seven Myths of gun Control: Reclaiming the Truth About Guns, Crime, and the Second Amendment. Roseville, CA: Forum.
122.
RegensJ. L.SchultheissA.MouldN.. 2015. “Regional Variation in Causes of Injuries among Terrorism Victims for Mass Casualty Events.” Frontiers in Public Health3:198.
123.
RosenbaumJ. E.2012. “Gun Utopias? Firearm Access and Ownership in Israel and Switzerland.” Journal of Public Health Policy33(1):46–58.
124.
ShawC.MckayH.. 1942. Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
125.
SiegelM.RossC. S.KingC.. 2013. “The Relationship Between Gun Ownership and Firearm Homicide Rates in the United States, 1981–2010.” American Journal of Public Health103(11):2098–2105.
126.
SloanJ. H.KellermannA. L.ReayD. T.FerrisJ. A.KoepsellT.RivaraF. P.LoGergoJ.. 1988. “Handgun Regulations, Crime, Assaults, and Homicide: A Tale of Two Cities.” New England Journal of Medicine319(19):1256–1262.
127.
SmithD. A.UchidaC. D.. 1988. “The Social-Organization of Self-Help-A Study of Defensive Weapon Ownership.” American Sociological Review53(1):94–102.
128.
StamatelJ.RatajczakK.HoekstraR.. 2020. “Do Gun Policies Really Protect Women? A Cross-National Test of the Relationship Between Gun Regulations and Female Homicide Victimization.” Journal of Mediterranean Knowledge5(1):19–46.
129.
StohlR.SchroederM.SmithD.. 2007. The Small Arms Trade. Oxford, UK: Oneworld.
130.
StroebeW.LeanderN. P.KruglanskiA. W.. 2017. “The Impact of the Orlando Mass Shooting on Fear of Victimization and Gun-Purchasing Intentions: Not What One Might Expect.” Plos One12(8):e0182408.
131.
SturupJ.RostamiA.MondaniH.GerellM.SarneckiJ.EdlingC.. 2019. “Increased Gun Violence among Young Males in Sweden: A Descriptive National and International Comparison.” European Journal of Criminal Justice Policy Research25:265–378.
132.
TaylorI.WuZ.. 2013. “China’s Arms Transfers to Africa and Political Violence.” Terrorism and Political Violence25(3):457–475.
133.
TennenbaumA.1992 “Israel has a Successful gun Control Policy.” in Gun Control: Current Controversies, edited by CozicC. P.WekesserC.. San Diego, CA: Greenhaven.
134.
TesslerR. A.MooneyS. J.WittC. E.O’ConnellK.JennessJ.VavilalaM. S.RivaraF. P.. 2017. “Use of Firearms in Terrorist Attacks: Differences Between the U.S., Canada, Europe, Australia, and New Zealand.” JAMA Internal Medicine177(12):1865–1868.
