This study explores the nexus between low self-control and legal cynicism among a recent sample of at-risk youth while accounting for various features of direct and vicarious police stops.
Methods:
Analyses are based on data from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study, which employs a national sample of urban-born, at-risk youth.
Results:
A uniquely potent association between low self-control and legal cynicism emerged across samples with and without exposure to vicarious or direct police stops. Furthermore, among youth exposed to police stops, the link between low self-control and legal cynicism was largely robust to perceptions/features of these stops, including the degree of officer intrusiveness, arrest, perceptions of procedural justice, and youth feelings of social stigma following the stop.
Conclusions:
Programmatic efforts that both enhance the early development of self-control through mindfulness and curriculum-based interventions (e.g., Promoting Alternative THinking Strategies) and facilitate trauma-informed policing may be beneficial in curtailing the development of legal cynicism.
AjzenI.FishbeinM.. 1977. “Attitude-behavior Relations: A Theoretical Analysis and Review of Empirical Research.” Psychological Bulletin84(5):888.
2.
AllisonP.2012. “When Can You Safely Ignore Multicollinearity.” Statistical Horizons5(1):1–2.
3.
ArneklevB. J.GrasmickH. G.TittleC. R.BursikR. J.. 1993. “Low Self-control and Imprudent Behavior.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology9(3):225–47.
4.
AssariS.CaldwellC. H.MincyR.. 2018. “Family Socioeconomic Status at Birth and Youth Impulsivity at Age 15; Blacks’ Diminished Return.” Children5:58.
5.
BaumeisterR. F.BratslavskyE.FinkenauerC.VohsK. D.. 2001. “Bad Is Stronger Than Good.” Review of General Psychology5(4):323–70.
6.
BeaverK. M.DeLisiM.MearsD. P.StewartE.. 2009. “Low Self-control and Contact with the Criminal Justice System in a Nationally Representative Sample of Males.” Justice Quarterly26(4):695–715.
7.
BhaskaranK.SmeethL.. 2014. “What Is the Difference Between Missing Completely at Random and Missing at Random?” International Journal of Epidemiology43(4):1336–39.
8.
BouffardJ. A.RiceS. K.. 2011. “The Influence of the Social Bond on Self-control at the Moment of Decision: Testing Hirschi’s Redefinition of Self-control.” American Journal of Criminal Justice36(2):138–57.
9.
BoutwellB. B.BeaverK. M.. 2010. “The Intergenerational Transmission of Low Self-control.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency47(2):174–209.
10.
BradfordB.JacksonJ.StankoE. A.. 2009. “Contact and Confidence: Revisiting the Impact of Public Encounters with the Police.” Policing and Society19(1):20–46.
11.
BrownW.JenningsW. G.. 2014. “A Replication and an Honor-based Extension of Hirschi’s Reconceptualization of Self-control Theory and Crime and Analogous Behaviors.” Deviant Behavior35(4):297–310.
12.
BrunsonR. K.WeitzerR.. 2009. “Police Relations with Black and White Youths in Different Urban Neighborhoods.” Urban Affairs Review44(6):858–85.
13.
BurtC. H.SimonsR. L.SimonsL. G.. 2006. “A Longitudinal Test of the Effects of Parenting and the Stability of Self-control: Negative Evidence for the General Theory of Crime.” Criminology44(2):353–96.
14.
BushwayS.JohnsonB. D.SlocumL. A.. 2007. “Is the Magic Still There? The Use of the Heckman Two-step Correction for Selection Bias in Criminology.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology23(2):151–78.
15.
CalkinsS. D.1994. “Origins and Outcomes of Individual Differences in Emotion Regulation.” Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development59(2-3):53–72.
16.
CarrP. J.NapolitanoL.KeatingJ.. 2007. “We Never Call the Cops and Here Is Why: A Qualitative Examination of Legal Cynicism in Three Philadelphia Neighborhoods.” Criminology45(2):445–80.
17.
CaspiA.MoffittT. E.SilvaP. A.Stouthamer-LoeberM.KruegerR. F.SchmutteP. S.. 1994. “Are Some People Crime-prone? Replications of the Personality-crime Relationship across Countries, Genders, Races, and Methods.” Criminology32(2):163–96.
18.
CavanaghC.CauffmanE.. 2015. “Viewing Law and Order: Mothers’ and Sons’ Justice System Legitimacy Attitudes and Juvenile Recidivism.” Psychology, Public Policy, and Law21(4):432.
19.
ChappleC. L.2005. “Self-control, Peer Relations, and Delinquency.” Justice Quarterly22(1):89–106.
20.
CloggC. C.PetkovaE.HaritouA.. 1995. “Statistical Methods for Comparing Regression Coefficients between Models.” American Journal of Sociology100(5):1261–93.
21.
ClowardR. A.OhlinL. E. (1960). Delinquency and Opportunity: A Theory of Delinquent Gangs. Glencoe: Free Press.
22.
CohnE. S.WhiteS. O.. 1990. Legal Socialization: A Study of Norms and Rules. New York: Springer-Verlag.
23.
DeLisiM.BergM. T.. 2006. “Exploring Theoretical Linkages between Self-control Theory and Criminal Justice System Processing.” Journal of Criminal Justice34(2):153–63.
24.
DeLisiM.VaughnM. G.. 2014. “Foundations of a Temperament-based Theory of Life-course Antisocial Behavior and Criminal Justice System Involvement.” Journal of Criminal Justice42:10–25.
25.
Del ToroJ.LloydT.BuchananK. S.RobinsS. J.BencharitL. Z.SmiedtM. G.ReddyK. S.PougetE. R.KerrisonE. M.GoffP. A.. 2019. “The Criminogenic and Psychological Effects of Police Stops on Adolescent Black and Latino Boys.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences116(17):8261–68.
26.
DesmondM.PapachristosA. V.KirkD. S.. 2020. “Police Violence and Citizen Crime Reporting in the Black Community.” American Sociological Review. doi: 10.1177/0003122419895979.
27.
DevlinD. N.GottfredsonD. C.. 2018. “Policing and the School-to-Prison Pipeline.” Pp. 291–308in The Palgrave International Handbook of School Discipline, Surveillance, and Social Control. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan.
28.
DickmanS. J.1990. “Functional and Dysfunctional Impulsivity: Personality and Cognitive Correlates.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology58(1):95.
29.
EisenbergN.SpinradT. L.EggumN. D.. 2010. “Emotion-related Self-regulation and Its Relation to Children’s Maladjustment.” Annual Review of Clinical Psychology6:495–525.
30.
FaganJ.PiqueroA. R.. 2007. “Rational Choice and Developmental Influences on Recidivism among Adolescent Felony Offenders.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies4(4):715–48.
31.
FaganJ.TylerT. R.. 2005. “Legal Socialization of Children and Adolescents.” Social Justice Research18(3):217–41.
32.
FineA.CauffmanE.. 2015. “Race and Justice System Attitude Formation during the Transition to Adulthood.” Journal of Developmental and Life-course Criminology1(4):325–49.
33.
FlexonJ. L.GreenleafR. G.LurigioA. J.. 2012. “The Effects of Self-control, Gang Membership, and Parental Attachment/identification on Police Contacts among Latino and African American Youths.” International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology56(2):218–38.
34.
ForrestW.HayC.WiddowsonA. O.RocqueM.. 2019. “Development of Impulsivity and Risk-seeking: Implications for the Dimensionality and Stability of Self-control.” Criminology57(3):512–43.
35.
GauJ. M.2015. “Procedural Justice, Police Legitimacy, and Legal Cynicism: A Test for Mediation Effects.” Police Practice and Research16(5):402–15.
36.
GauJ. M.BrunsonR. K.. 2010. “Procedural Justice and Order Maintenance Policing: A Study of Inner-city Young Men’s Perceptions of Police Legitimacy.” Justice Quarterly27(2):255–79.
37.
GellerA.FaganJ.. 2019. “Police Contact and the Legal Socialization of Urban Teens.” The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences5(1):26–49.
38.
GellerA.FaganJ.TylerT.LinkB. G.. 2014. “Aggressive Policing and the Mental Health of Young Urban Men.” American Journal of Public Health104(12):2321–27.
39.
GelmanA.FaganJ.KissA.. 2007. “An Analysis of the New York City Police Department’s “Stop-and-frisk” Policy in the Context of Claims of Racial Bias.” Journal of the American Statistical Association102(479):813–23.
40.
GibsonC. L.SullivanC. J.JonesS.PiqueroA. R.. 2010. “Does It Take a Village?” Assessing Neighborhood Influences on Children’s Self-control.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency47(1):31–62.
41.
GiffordF.ReisigM.. 2019. “A Multidimensional Model of Legal Cynicism.” Law and Human Behavior43(4):383–96.
42.
GillC.GottfredsonD.HutzellK.. 2016. “Can School Policing Be Trauma-informed? Lessons from Seattle.” Policing39(3):551–65.
43.
GottfredsonM. R.HirschiT.. 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
44.
GrahamJ. W.2009. “Missing Data Analysis: Making It Work in the Real World.” Annual Review of Psychology60:549–76.
45.
GrasmickH. G.TittleC. R.BursikR. J.JrArneklevB. J.. 1993. “Testing the Core Empirical Implications of Gottfredson and Hirschi’s General Theory of Crime.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency30(1):5–29.
46.
GrossJ. J.1999. “Emotion and Emotion Regulation.” Handbook of Personality: Theory and Research2:525–52.
47.
GruenewaldJ.PridemoreW. A.. 2012. “A Comparison of Ideologically-motivated Homicides from the New Extremist Crime Database and Homicides from the Supplementary Homicide Reports Using Multiple Imputation by Chained Equations to Handle Missing Values.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology28(1):141–62.
48.
HayC.ForrestW.. 2006. “The Development of Self-control: Examining Self-control Theory’s Stability Thesis.” Criminology44(4):739–74.
49.
HirschiT.2004. “Self-control and Crime”. Pp. 537–52in Handbook of Self-regulation: Research, Theory, and Application, edited byBaumeisterR. F.VohsK. D.. New York: Guilford.
50.
HirschiT.GottfredsonM.. 1983. “Age and the Explanation of Crime.” American Journal of Sociology89(3):552–84.
51.
HirschiT.GottfredsonM.. 1986. “The Distinction between Crime and Criminality.” Critique and Explanation: Essays in Honor of Gwynne Nettler55:69.
52.
HitchensB. K.CarrP. J.Clampet-LundquistS.. 2018. “The Context for Legal Cynicism: Urban Young Women’s Experiences with Policing in Low-income, High-crime Neighborhoods.” Race and Justice8(1):27–50.
53.
HoferM. S.WomackS. R.WilsonM. N.. 2020. “An Examination of the Influence of Procedurally Just Strategies on Legal Cynicism among Urban Youth Experiencing Police Contact.” Journal of Community Psychology48(1):104–23.
54.
JacobsenW. C.2019. “The Intergenerational Stability of Punishment: Paternal Incarceration and Suspension or Expulsion in Elementary School.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency56(5):651–93.
55.
JacksonD. B.FahmyC.VaughnM. G.TestaA.. 2019. “Police Stops among At-risk Youth: Repercussions for Mental Health.” Journal of Adolescent Health65(5):627–32.
56.
JacksonD. B.TestaA.VaughnM. G.. (2020). Low self-control and the adolescent police stop: Intrusiveness, emotional response, and psychological well-being. Journal of Criminal Justice66: 101635.
57.
JonesS.LynamD. R.PiqueroA. R.. 2015. “Substance Use, Personality, and Inhibitors: Testing Hirschi’s Predictions about the Reconceptualization of Self-control.” Crime & Delinquency61(4):538–58.
58.
KaiserK.ReisigM. D.. 2019. “Legal Socialization and Self-reported Criminal Offending: The Role of Procedural Justice and Legal Orientations.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology35(1):135–54.
59.
KarlsonK. B.HolmA.BreenR.. (2012). Comparing regression coefficients between same-sample nested models using logit and probit: A new method. Sociological Methodology42(1):286–313.
60.
KirkD. S.2016. “Prisoner Reentry and the Reproduction of Legal Cynicism.” Social Problems63(2):222–43.
61.
LittleR. J.RubinD. B.. 2002. Statistical Analysis with Missing Data. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
62.
MaguireE. R.LowreyB. V.JohnsonD.. 2017. “Evaluating the Relative Impact of Positive and Negative Encounters with Police: A Randomized Experiment.” Journal of Experimental Criminology13(3):367–91.
63.
MaransS.AdnopozJ.. 1995. The Police Mental Health Partnership: A Community-based Response to Urban Violence. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
64.
MaransS.MurphyR. A.CaseyR. L.BerkowitzS. J.BerkmanM.. 2006. “Mental Health-law Enforcement Collaborative Responses to Children’s Exposure to Violence.” Interventions for Children Exposed to Violence4:111–34.
65.
MastrofskiS. D.ReisigM. D.McCluskeyJ. D.. 2002. “Police Disrespect toward the Public: An Encounter-based Analysis.” Criminology40(3):519–52.
66.
MatzaD.1964. Delinquency and Drift. New York: Wiley.
67.
MazerolleL.AntrobusE.CardwellS. M.PiqueroA. R.BennettS.. 2019. “Harmonizing Legal Socialization to Reduce Antisocial Behavior: Results from a Randomized Field Trial of Truanting Young People.” Justice Quarterly, 1–28. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2019.1618894
68.
McLeanK.WolfeS. E.PrattT. C.. 2019. “Legitimacy and the Life Course: An Age-graded Examination of changes in Legitimacy Attitudes Over Time.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency56(1):42–83.
69.
McLeanK.WolfeS. E.RojekJ.AlpertG. P.SmithM. R.. 2019. “Police Officers as Warriors or Guardians: Empirical Reality or Intriguing Rhetoric?” Justice Quarterly1–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2018.1533031
70.
MearesT. L.2014. “The Law and Social Science of Stop and Frisk.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science10:335–52.
71.
MorrisR. G.GerberJ.MenardS.. 2011. “Social Bonds, Self-control, and Adult Criminality: A Nationally Representative Assessment of Hirschi’s Revised Self-control Theory.” Criminal Justice and Behavior38(6):584–99.
72.
MouleR. K.JrFoxB. H.ParryM. M.. 2019. “The Long Shadow of Ferguson: Legitimacy, Legal Cynicism, and Public Perceptions of Police Militarization.” Crime and Delinquency65(2):151–82.
NaC.PaternosterR.. 2012. “Can Self-control Change Substantially Over Time? Rethinking the Relationship between Self- and Social Control.” Criminology50(2):427–62.
75.
NivetteA. E.EisnerM.MaltiT.RibeaudD.. 2015. “The Social and Developmental Antecedents of Legal Cynicism.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency52(2):270–98.
76.
NivetteA.EisnerM.RibeaudD.. 2020. “Evaluating the Shared and Unique Predictors of Legal Cynicism and Police Legitimacy from Adolescence into Early Adulthood.” Criminology58(1):70–100.
77.
PandeyA.HaleD.DasS.GoddingsA. L.BlakemoreS. J.VinerR. M.. 2018. “Effectiveness of Universal Self-regulation–based Interventions in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.” JAMA Pediatrics172(6):566–75.
78.
PaternosterR.BrameR.. 2000. “On the Association among Self-control, Crime, and Analogous Behaviors.” Criminology38(3):971–82.
79.
PaternosterR.BrameR.MazerolleP.PiqueroA.. 1998. “Using the Correct Statistical Test for the Equality of Regression Coefficients.” Criminology36(4):859–66.
80.
PetterutiA.2011. Education under Arrest: The Case against Police in Schools. Washington, DC: Justice Policy Institute.
81.
PiqueroA. R.BouffardJ. A.. 2007. “Something Old, Something New: A Preliminary Investigation of Hirschi’s Redefined Self-control.” Justice Quarterly24(1):1–27.
82.
PiqueroA. R.Gomez-SmithZ.LangtonL.. 2004. “Discerning Unfairness Where Others May Not: Low Self-control and Unfair Sanction Perceptions.” Criminology42(3):699–734.
83.
PogarskyG.PiqueroA. R.PaternosterR.. 2004. “Modeling Change in Perceptions about Sanction Threats: The Neglected Linkage in Deterrence Theory.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology20(4):343–69.
84.
PosnerM. I.RothbartM. K.. 2000. “Developing Mechanisms of Self-regulation.” Development and Psychopathology12(3):427–41.
85.
PotthoffR. F.TudorG. E.PieperK. S.HasselbladV.. 2006. “Can One Assess Whether Missing Data Are Missing at Random in Medical Studies?” Statistical Methods in Medical Research15(3):213–34.
86.
PrattT. C.CullenF. T.. 2000. “The Empirical Status of Gottfredson and Hirschi’s General Theory of Crime: A Meta-analysis.” Criminology38(3):931–64.
87.
President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. (2015). Final Report of the President’s Task Force on 21stCentury Policing. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.
88.
ReichmanN. E.TeitlerJ. O.GarfinkelI.McLanahanS. S.. 2001. “Fragile Families: Sample and Design.” Children and Youth Services Review23(4-5):303–26.
ReisigM. D.WolfeS. E.HoltfreterK.. 2011. “Legal Cynicism, Legitimacy, and Criminal Offending: The Nonconfounding Effect of Low Self-control.” Criminal Justice and Behavior38(12):1265–79.
92.
RosenbaumD. P.SchuckA. M.CostelloS. K.HawkinsD. F.RingM. K.. 2005. “Attitudes toward the Police: The Effects of Direct and Vicarious Experience.” Police Quarterly8(3):343–65.
93.
RozinP.RoyzmanE. B.. 2001. “Negativity Bias, Negativity Dominance, and Contagion.” Personality and Social Psychology Review5(4):296–320.
94.
SampsonR. J.BartuschD. J.. 1998. “Legal Cynicism and (subcultural) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Difference.” Law & Society Review32:777.
95.
SchuckA.MartinC.. 2013. “Residents’ Perceptions of Procedural Injustice during Encounters with the Police.” Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice11(4):219–37.
96.
SkoganW. G.2006. “Asymmetry in the Impact of Encounters with Police.” Policing & Society16(02):99–126.
97.
SkoganW. G.FrydlK.. 2004. Fairness and Effectiveness in Policing: The Evidence. National Academies Press.
StataCorp. 2017. Stata Statistical Software: Release 15. College Station, TX: StataCorp.
100.
SteffensmeierD.UlmerJ.. (2002). “Age and crime”. Pp. 31–37 in Encyclopedia of Crime and Justice, edited byKadishS.. New York, NY: Mac-millan.
101.
SundareshR.YiY.RoyB.RileyC.WildemanC.WangE. A.. 2020. “Exposure to the US Criminal Legal System and Well-being: A 2018 Cross-sectional Study.” American Journal of Public Health110(S1):S116–22.
102.
ThomasK. J.2018. “Revisiting Delinquent Attitudes: Measurement, Dimensionality and Behavioral Effects.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology34(1):313–41.
103.
TrinknerR.CohnE. S.. 2014. “Putting the “Social” Back in Legal Socialization: Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and Cynicism in Legal and Nonlegal Authorities.” Law and Human Behavior38(6):602.
104.
TrinknerR.TylerT. R.. 2016. “Legal Socialization: Coercion versus Consent in an Era of Mistrust.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science12:417–39.
105.
TurnerM. G.PiqueroA. R.. 2002. “The Stability of Self-control.” Journal of Criminal Justice30(6):457–71.
106.
TurneyK. 2019. “Vicarious and Contingent Consequences of Adolescent Police Exposure.” Working Paper No. wp19-01-ff, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Center for Research on Child Wellbeing, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ.
107.
TuzzoloE.HewittD. T.. 2006. “Rebuilding Inequity: The Re-emergence of the School-to-prison Pipeline in New Orleans.” The High School Journal90(2):59–68.
108.
TylerT. R.2006. Why People Obey the Law. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
109.
TylerT. R.FaganJ.GellerA.. 2014. “Street Stops and Police Legitimacy: Teachable Moments in Young Urban Men’s Legal Socialization.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies11(4):751–85.
110.
VaughnM. G.DeLisiM.BeaverK. M.WrightJ. P.. 2009. “Identifying Latent Classes of Behavioral Risk based on Early Childhood Manifestations of Self-control.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice7:16–31.
111.
VazsonyiA. T.MikuškaJ.KelleyE. L.. 2017. “It’s Time: A Meta-analysis on the Self-control-deviance Link.” Journal of Criminal Justice48:48–63.
112.
WaltersG. D.2014. “Pathways to Early Delinquency: Exploring the Individual and Collective Contributions of Difficult Temperament, Low Maternal Involvement, and Externalizing Behavior.” Journal of Criminal Justice42(4):321–26.
113.
WeitzerR.TuchS. A.. 2005. “Racially Biased Policing: Determinants of Citizen Perceptions.” Social Forces83(3):1009–30.
114.
WildemanC.2010. “Paternal Incarceration and Children’s Physically Aggressive Behaviors: Evidence from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study.” Social Forces89(1):285–309.
115.
WolfeS. E.2011. “The Effect of Low Self-control on Perceived Police Legitimacy.” Journal of Criminal Justice39(1):67–74.
116.
ZimmermanG. M.2010. “Impulsivity, Offending, and the Neighborhood: Investigating the Person–context Nexus.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology26(3):301–32.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
