A growing body of research finds that immigration has a null or negative association with neighborhood crime rates. We build on this important literature by investigating the extent to which one theory, institutional completeness theory, may help explain lower crime rates in immigrant communities across the Southern California region. Specifically, we test whether two key measures of institutional completeness—the presence of immigrant/ethnic voluntary organizations in the community and the presence and diversity of immigrant/ethnic businesses in the community—account for lower crime rates in some immigrant communities.
Method:
Compiling a tract-level data set utilizing various data sources, we estimate negative binomial regression models predicting violent and property crime levels that include measures of institutional completeness while controlling for a range of neighborhood correlates of crime. We also account for possible endogeneity by estimating instrumental variable models.
Results:
The results reveal very limited support for institutional completeness theory.
Conclusions:
Several possible explanations for these findings are discussed.
AkinsScottRumbautRuben G.StansfieldRichard. 2009. “Immigration, Economic Disadvantage, and Homicide: A Community-level Analysis of Austin, Texas.” Homicide Studies13:307–14.
2.
Alvarez-RiveraLorna L.NoblesMatt R.LerschKim M.. 2014. “Latino Immigrant Acculturation and Crime.” American Journal of Criminal Justice39:315–30.
3.
BaureissGunter. 1981. “Institutional Completeness: Its Use and Misuse in Ethnic Relations Research.” Journal of Ethnic Studies9:101–10.
4.
BersaniBianca E.2014. “An Examination of First and Second Generation Immigrant Offending Trajectories.” Justice Quarterly31:315–43.
5.
BersaniBianca E.LoughranThomas A.PiqueroAlex R.. 2014. “Comparing Patterns and Predictors of Immigrant Offending among a Sample of Adjudicated Youth.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence43:1914–33.
6.
BeyerleinKraigHippJohn R.. 2005. “Social Capital, Too Much of a Good Thing? American Religious Traditions and Community Crime.” Social Forces84:995–1013.
7.
BoessenAdamHippJohn R.. 2015. “Close-ups and the Scale of Ecology: Land Uses and the Geography of Social Context and Crime.” Criminology53:399–426.
8.
BohonS.2001. Immigrant Workers and the Competition for Jobs. New York: Garland.
9.
BretonRaymond. 1964. “Institutional Completeness of Ethnic Communities and the Personal Relations of Immigrants.” American Journal of Sociology70:193–205.
10.
BursikRobert J.2006. “Rethinking the Chicago School of Criminology.” Pp. 20–35 in Immigration and Crime: Race, Ethnicity, and Violence, edited by RamiroM.ValenzuelaA.. New York: New York University Press.
11.
BursikRobert J.GrasmickHarold G.. 1993. Neighborhoods and Crime. New York: Lexington.
12.
ButcherKristin F.PiehlAnne Morrison. 1998. “Recent Immigrants: Unexpected Implications for Crime and Incarceration.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review51:654–79.
13.
ChavezJorge M.GriffithsElizabeth. 2009. “Neighborhood Dynamics of Urban Violence: Understanding the Immigration Connection.” Homicide Studies13:261–73.
14.
DesmondScott A.KubrinCharis E.. 2009. “The Power of Place: Immigrant Communities and Adolescent Violence.” The Sociological Quarterly50:581–607.
15.
DriedgerLeoChurchGlenn. 1974. “Residential Segregation and Institutional Completeness: A Comparison of Ethnic Minorities.” Canadian Review of Sociology11:30–52.
16.
FeldmeyerBenSteffensmeierDarrell. 2009. “Immigration Effects on Homicide Offending for Total and Race/Ethnicity-disaggregated Populations (White, Black, and Latino).” Homicide Studies13:211–26.
17.
GlazerNathanMoynihanDaniel P.. 1970. Beyond the Melting Pot: The Negroes, Puerto Ricans, Jews, Italians and Irish of New York City. Cambridge: MIT Press.
18.
GoldenbergSheldonHainesValerie A.. 1992. “Social Networks and Institutional Completeness: From Territory to Ties.” Canadian Journal of Sociology17:301–12.
19.
GostjevFeodor A.NielsenAmie L.. 2017. “Speaking the Same Language? English Language Fluency and Violent Crime at the Neighborhood Level.” The Sociological Quarterly58:111–39.
20.
GraifCorinaSampsonRobert J.. 2009. “Spatial Heterogeneity in the Effects of Immigration and Diversity on Neighborhood Homicide Rates.” Homicide Studies13:242–60.
21.
GreeleyAndrew. 1971. Why Can’t They Be Like Us? America’s White Ethnic Groups. New York: Dutton.
22.
Gyimah-BrempongKwabena. 2001. “Alcohol Availability and Crime: Evidence from Census Tract Data.” Southern Economic Journal68:2–21.
23.
HaganJohnPalloniAlberto. 1999. “Sociological Criminology and the Mythology of Hispanic Immigration and Crime.” Social Problems46:617–32.
24.
HippJohn R.2010. “A Dynamic View of Neighborhoods: The Reciprocal Relationship between Crime and Neighborhood Structural Characteristics.” Social Problems57:205–30.
25.
HippJohn R.BoessenAdam. 2013. “Egohoods as Waves Washing across the City: A New Measure of ‘Neighborhoods.’” Criminology51:287–327.
26.
HippJohn R.TitaGeorge E.BoggessLyndsay N.. 2009. “Inter- and Intra-group Violence: Is Violent Crime an Expression of Group Conflict or Social Disorganization?” Criminology47:521–64.
27.
HumT.2002. “A Protected Niche? Immigrant Ethnic Economies and Labor Market Segmentation.” Pp. 279–314 in Prismatic Metropolis: Inequality in Los Angeles, edited by BoboL. D.OliverM. L.JohnsonJ. H.JrValenzuelaA.Jr. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
28.
JoyRichard J.1972. Languages in Conflict. Toronto, Canada: McClelland and Stewart.
29.
KaneKevinHippJohn R.KimJae Hong. 2017. “Analyzing Accessibility Using Parcel Data: Is There Still an Access-space Tradeoff in Long Beach, California?” The Professional Geographer69:486–503.
30.
KornhauserRuth D.1978. Social Sources of Delinquency. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
31.
KrivoLauren J.PetersonRuth D.. 1996. “Extremely Disadvantaged Neighborhoods and Urban Crime.” Social Forces75:619–48.
32.
KubrinCharis E.HippJohn R.. 2016. “Do Fringe Banks Create Fringe Neighborhoods? Examining the Spatial Relationship between Fringe Banking and Neighborhood Crime Rates.” Justice Quarterly33:755–84.
33.
KubrinCharis E.HippJohn R.KimYoung-An. 2016. “Different Than the Sum of Its Parts: Examining the Unique Impacts of Immigrant Groups on Neighborhood Crime Rates.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology. doi:10.1007/s10940-016-9320-y.
34.
KubrinCharis E.IshizawaHiromi. 2012. “Why Some Immigrant Neighborhoods Are Safer Than Others: Divergent Findings from Los Angeles and Chicago.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science641:148–73.
35.
KubrinCharis E.DesmondScott A.. 2015. “The Power of Place Revisited: Why Immigrant Communities Have Lower Levels of Violence.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice13:345–66.
36.
LeeMatthew T.MartinezRamiro. 2002. “Social Disorganization Revisited: Mapping the Recent Immigration and Black Homicide Relationship in Northern Miami.” Sociological Focus35:363–80.
37.
LopezKristina M.MillerHolly Ventura. 2011. “Ethnicity, Acculturation, and Offending: Findings from a Sample of Hispanic Adolescents.” The Open Family Studies Journal4:27–37.
38.
MacDonaldJohnSaundersJessica. 2012. “Are Immigrant Youth Less Violent? Specifying the Reasons and Mechanisms.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science641:125–47.
39.
MacDonaldJohn M.HippJohn R.GillCharlotte. 2013. “The Effects of Immigrant Concentration on Changes in Neighborhood Crime Rates.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology29:191–215.
40.
MartinezRamiro. 2002. Latino Homicide: Immigration, Violence and Community. New York: Routledge.
41.
MartinezRamiroStowellJacob I.CancinoJeffrey M.. 2008. “A Tale of Two Border Cities: Community Context, Ethnicity, and Homicide.” Social Science Quarterly89:1–16.
42.
MartinezRamiroStowellJacobLeeMatthew. 2010. “Immigration and Crime in an Era of Transformation: A Longitudinal Analysis of Homicides in San Diego Neighborhoods, 1980−2000.” Criminology48:797–829.
43.
MartinezRamiroLeeMatthew T.. 2000. “On Immigration and Crime.” Pp. 485–24 in Criminal Justice 2000: The Nature of Crime: Continuity and Change, Vol. 1. Washington, DC. Retrieved (https://www.ncjrs.gov/criminal_justice2000/vol_1/02j.pdf).
44.
MartinezRamiroLeeMatthew T.NielsenAmie L.. 2004. “Segmented Assimilation, Local Context and Determinants of Drug Violence in Miami and San Diego: Does Ethnicity and Immigration Matter?” International Migration Review38:131–57.
45.
MasseyDouglas S.1999. “Why Does Immigration Occur? A Theoretical Synthesis.” Pp. 34–52 in The Handbook of International Migration: The American Experience, edited by HirschmanCharlesKasinitzPhilipDeWindJosh. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
46.
McCordJoan. 1995. “Ethnicity, Acculturation, and Opportunities: A Study of Two Generations.” Pp. 69–81 in Ethnicity, Race, and Crime, edited by HawkinsDarnell F.Albany: State University of New York Press.
47.
MorenoffJeffrey D.AstorAvraham. 2006. “Immigrant Assimilation and Crime: Generational Differences in Youth Violence in Chicago.” Pp. 36–63 in Immigration and Crime: Race, Ethnicity, and Violence, edited by MartinezRamiroValenzuelaAbel. New York: New York University Press.
48.
MrozThomas A.BollenKenneth A.SpeizerIlene S.ManciniDominic J.. 1999. “Quality, Accessibility, and Contraceptive Use in Rural Tanzania.” Demography36:23–40.
49.
NielsenAmie L.MartinezRamiro. 2009. “The Role of Immigration for Violent Deaths.” Homicide Studies13(3): 274–87.
50.
NielsenAmie L.LeeMatthew T.MartinezRamiro. 2005. “Integrating Race, Place and Motive in Social Disorganization Theory: Lessons from a Comparison of Black and Latino Homicide Types in Two Immigrant Destination Cities.” Criminology43:837–72.
51.
OlsonChrista PolczynskiLaurikkalaMinna K.Huff-CorzineLinCorzineJay. 2009. “Immigration and Violent Crime: Citizenship Status and Social Disorganization.” Homicide Studies13:227–41.
52.
OsgoodWayne D. “Poisson-Based Regression Analysis of Aggregate Crime Rates.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology16:21–43.
53.
OuseyGrahamKubrinCharis E.. 2018. “Immigration and Crime: Assessing a Contentious Issue.” Annual Review of Criminology1:63–84.
54.
PortesAlejandroJensenLeif. 1992. “Disproving the Enclave Hypothesis: Reply.” American Sociological Review57: 418–20.
55.
PortesAlejandroManningRobert D.2005. “The Immigrant Enclave: Theory and Empirical Examples.” The Urban Sociology Reader38:583–94.
56.
PortesAlejandroManningRobert D.1986. “The Immigrant Enclave: Theory and Empirical Examples. Pp. 47–68 in Competitive Ethnic Relations, edited by OlzakSusanNagelJoane. Cambridge, United States: Academic Press.
57.
PortesAlejandroRumbautRuben. 2014. Immigrant America: A Portrait. Berkeley: University of California Press.
58.
PutnamRobert D.2000. Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.
59.
RobertsLance W.BoldtEdward D.1979. “Institutional Completeness and Ethnic Assimilation.” Journal of Ethnic Studies7:103–8.
60.
RumbautRuben G.GonzalesRobert G.KomaieGolnazMorganCharlie V.Tafoya-EstradaRosaura. 2006. “Immigration and Incarceration: Patterns and Predictors of Imprisonment among First- and Second-generation Young Adults.” Pp. 64–89 in Immigration and Crime: Race, Ethnicity, and Violence, edited by MartinezRamiroValenzuelaAbel. New York: New York University Press.
61.
RumbautRuben G.EwingWalter A.2007. The Myth of Immigrant Criminality and the Paradox of Assimilation: Incarceration Rates among Native and Foreign-Born Men. Washington, D.C.: Immigration Policy Center, American Immigration Law Foundation.
62.
RumbautRuben G.2008. “The Coming of the Second Generation: Immigration and Ethnic Mobility in Southern California.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science620:196–236.
63.
SampsonRobert J.MorenoffJeffrey D.RaudenbushStephen. 2005. “Social Anatomy of Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Violence.” American Journal of Public Health95:224–32.
64.
ShawClifford R.HenryMcKay. 1969 [1942] Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas. Chicago, IL, US: University of Chicago Press.
65.
StowellJacob I.MartinezRamiro. 2007. “Displaced, Dispossessed, or Lawless? Examining the Link between Ethnicity, Immigration, and Violence.” Journal of Aggression and Violent Behavior5:564–81.
66.
StowellJacob I.MartinezRamiro. 2009. “Incorporating Ethnic-specific Measures of Immigration in the Study of Lethal Violence.” Homicide Studies13:315–24.
67.
TaftDonald R.1933. “Does Immigration Increase Crime?” Social Forces12:69–77.
68.
TonryMichael. 1997. “Ethnicity, Crime, and Immigration.” Crime & Justice21:1–29.
69.
VelezMaria B.2009. “Contextualizing the Immigration and Crime Effect: An Analysis of Homicide in Chicago Neighborhoods.” Homicide Studies13:325–35.
70.
WaldingerRoger. 1993. “The Ethnic Enclave Debate Revisited.” International Journal of Urban Regional Research17:444–53.
71.
WarnerBarbara D.RountreePamela Wilcox. 1997. “Local Social Ties in a Community and Crime Model: Questioning the Systemic Nature of Informal Social Control.” Social Problems44:520–36.
72.
WatersMary C.EschbachKarl. 1995. “Immigration and Ethnic and Racial Inequality in the United States.” Annual Review of Sociology21:419–46.
73.
WilsonK. L.PortesAlejandro. 1980. “Immigrant Enclaves: An Analysis of the Labor Market Experiences of Cubans in Miami.” American Journal of Sociology86:295–319.
74.
WilsonWilliam Julius. 1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
75.
WoJames C.2014. “Community Context of Crime: A Longitudinal Examination of the Effects of Local Institutions on Neighborhood Crime.” Crime and Delinquency62:1286–312.
76.
WoJames C.HippJohn R.BoessenAdam. 2016. “Voluntary Organizations and Neighborhood Crime: A Dynamic Perspective.” Criminology54:212–41.
77.
ZhouMin. 2010. Chinatown: The Socioeconomic Potential of an Urban Enclave. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
ZhouMinBankstonCarl L.. 2006. “Delinquency and Acculturation in the Twenty-first Century: A Decade’s Change in a Vietnamese American Community.” Pp. 117-39 in Immigration and Crime: Race, Ethnicity, and Violence, edited by MartinezRamiroValenzuelaAbel. New York: New York University.
