Does violent repression strengthen the state? In this article we explore the legacies of repression by the Mexican government on subsequent patterns of state consolidation. We investigate how a particular form of state repression, forced disappearances of alleged leftist dissidents during the ‘Dirty War’, had path-dependent consequences for different dimensions of state capacity nearly 50 years later. To do so, we rely on data gathered from suppressed Mexican human rights reports of forced disappearances which, to our knowledge, have not been analyzed by social scientists before. Controlling for a rich set of pre-disappearances covariates we find that forced disappearances are positively correlated with contemporary measures of fiscal, territorial, and bureaucratic capacity. However, historical forced disappearances do not help the state to provide security, to consolidate its monopoly over the use of force, or to provide welfare-related public goods in the long run. Moreover, disappearances are negatively correlated with various measures of trust in the government. Forced disappearances committed by the state appear to have long-term yet heterogeneous effects on state consolidation.
BalcellsLaia (2012) The consequences of victimization on political identities: Evidence from Spain. Politics & Society40(3): 311–347.
4.
BalcellsLaiaSullivanChristopher M (2018) New findings from conflict archives: An introduction and methodological framework. Journal of Peace Research55(2): 137–146.
5.
BatesonRegina A (2013) Order and violence in postwar Guatemala. Unpublished PhD thesis, Yale University.
6.
BerrebiClaudeKlorEsteban F (2006) On terrorism and electoral outcomes: Theory and evidence from the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Journal of Conflict Resolution50(6): 899–925.
7.
BesleyTimothyPerssonTorsten (2008) War and state capacity. Journal of the European Economic Association6(2–3): 522–530.
8.
BesleyTimothyPerssonTorsten (2014) The causes and consequences of development clusters: State capacity, peace, and income. Annual Review of Economics6: 927–949.
9.
BoscoFernando J (2001) Place, space, networks, and the sustainability of collective action: The Madres de Plaza de Mayo. Global Networks1(4): 307–329.
10.
CardenasMauricioEslavaMarcelaRamirezSantiago (2016) Why internal conflict deteriorates state capacity? Evidence from Colombian municipalities. Defence and Peace Economics27(3): 353–377.
11.
CastellanosLauraCampoAlejandro Jiménez M del (2007) México Armado 1943–1981[Armed Mexico]. Mexico City: Era.
CNMH (2013) ¡Basta Ya! Colombia: Memorias de Guerra y Dignidad[Enough! Colombia: Memories of War and Dignity]. Bogotá: Centro Nacional de Memoria Histórica.
14.
Comisión Nacional de los Derechos Humanos, México (2016) Sistema nacional de alerta de violaciones a los derechos humanos [National warning system for human rights violations]http://appweb.cndh.org.mx/SNA/inicioant.asp).
15.
CostalliStefanoRuggeriAndrea (2017) The long-term electoral legacies of civil war in young democracies: Evidence from Italy (1946–1968) seminar presented at Nuffield College, University of Oxford, 26 January 2016.
16.
DavenportChristian (2005) Understanding covert repressive action: The case of the US government against the Republic of New Africa. Journal of Conflict Resolution49(1): 120–140.
17.
DavenportChristian (2007) State repression and political order. Annual Review of Political Science10: 1–23.
18.
DavenportChristian (2015) How Social Movements Die: Repression and Demobilization of the Republic of New Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
DiamondAlexisSekhonJasjeet S (2013) Genetic matching for estimating causal effects: A general multivariate matching method for achieving balance in observational studies. Review of Economics and Statistics95(3): 932–945.
GambettaDiego (1996) The Sicilian Mafia: The Business of Private Protection. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press.
24.
García de MirandaEnriquetade GyvesZaida F (1972) Nuevo Atlas Porrúa de la República Mexicana. Mexico City: Editorial Porrúa.
25.
GutiérrezFranciscoBuitragoDianaGonzálezAndreaLozanoCamila (2011) Measuring poor state performance: Problems, perspectives and paths ahead. Crisis States Research Centre Report.
Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (1970) Participación porcentual de las entidades federativas en el PIB nacional 1975–1980[Contributions of federal entities to national GDP (http://www.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/bie/).
KalyvasStathis NKocherMatthew A (2007) How ‘free’ is free riding in civil wars? Violence, insurgency, and the collective action problem. World Politics59(2): 177–216.
LeeMelissa MZhangNan (2013) The art of counting the governed: Census accuracy, civil war, and state presence. CDDRL Working papers no. 146, October. Center on Democracy, Development, and the Rule of Law, Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies, Stanford University.
36.
LessingBenjamin (2015) Logics of violence in criminal war. Journal of Conflict Resolution59(8): 1486–1516.
37.
LeviMargaret (1998) A state of trust. In: BraithwaiteValerieLeviMargeret (eds) Trust and Governance. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 77–101.
38.
LupuNoamPeisakhinLeonid (2017) The legacy of political violence across generations. American Journal of Political Science61(4): 836–851.
MuellerChristian (2015) Myers index for R: v0.9 (10.5281/zenodo.33616).
43.
MyersRobert J (1940) Errors and bias in the reporting of ages in census data. Transactions of the Actuarial Society of America41.
44.
Naval Intelligence Division (1919) A Handbook of Mexico. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
45.
NunnNathanWantchekonLeonard (2011) The slave trade and the origins of mistrust in Africa. American Economic Review101(7): 3221–3252.
46.
OsorioJavier (2015) The contagion of drug violence: Spatiotemporal dynamics of the Mexican war on drugs. Journal of Conflict Resolution59(8): 1403–1432.
47.
OsorioJavierSchubigerLiviaWeintraubMichael (2017) Historical legacies of conflict: From the Cristero rebellion to self-defense forces in Mexico (http://michael-weintraub.squarespace.com/research).
48.
PensadoJaime (2013) Rebel Mexico: Student Unrest and Authoritarian Political Culture During the Long Sixties. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
49.
PhillipsBrian J (2017) Indiscriminate vs. selective repression: Evidence from Argentina’s dirty war. Working paper.
50.
QuirkGregory JCascoLeonel (1994) Stress disorders of families of the disappeared: A controlled study in Honduras. Social Science & Medicine39(12): 1675–1679.
RosenbaumPaul R (2002) Observational Studies. New York: Springer.
53.
RozenasArturasSchutteSebastianZhukovYuri (2017) The political legacy of violence: The long-term impact of Stalin’s repression in Ukraine. Journal of Politics79(4): 1147–1161.
54.
SchubigerLivia I (2013) Repression and mobilization in civil war: The consequences of state violence for wartime collective action. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Zurich.
55.
Secretaría de Desarrollo Social (2016) Padrón de beneficiarios [Registry of beneficiaries] (http://pub.sedesol.gob.mx/spp/).
56.
Secretaría de Gobernación (2012) Encuesta nacional sobre cultura política y prácticas ciudadanas [National survey of political culture and citizenship practices] (http://www.encup.gob.mx/en/Encup/Quinta_ENCUP_2012).
SekhonJasjeet S (2011) Multivariate and propensity score matching software with automated balance optimization: The matching package for R. Journal of Statistical Software42(7): 1–52.
60.
SteeleAbbeyPaikChristopherTanakaSeiki (2017) Constraining the samurai: Rebellion and taxation in early modern Japan. International Studies Quarterly61(2): 352–370.
61.
SullivanChristopher M (2016) Undermining resistance: Mobilization, repression, and the enforcement of political order. Journal of Conflict Resolution60(7): 1163–1190.
62.
SullivanChristopher MDavenportChristian (2018) Resistance is mobile: Dynamics of repression, challenger adaptation, and surveillance in US ‘Red Squad’ and black nationalist archives. Journal of Peace Research55(2): 175–189.
63.
TillyCharles (1992) Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990–1992. Oxford: Blackwell.
US Department of State (1986) National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book, Guatemala’s Disappeared: 1977–86.
66.
VanderwoodPaul J (1992) Disorder and Progress: Bandits, Police, and Mexican Development. Wilmington, DE: Rowman & Littlefield.
67.
WeberMax (1968) Politics as a Vocation. Philadelphia, PA: Fortress.
68.
ZhukovYuri MTalibovaRoya (2018) Stalin’s terror and the long-term political effects of mass repression. Journal of Peace Research55(2): 267–283.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
