In the early 1970s several studies refuted the superiority of social class to income as a basis for segmenting the markets for a wide variety of durable and nondurable goods. This study also examines the relative effectiveness of social class and income, as well as their combination, over a wide range of consumption areas. The author uses frequency of usage criteria for nondurables and quality or feature-level indices for durables. MANOVA, ANOVA, and loglinear modeling results show social class to be superior to income in segmenting food and non-soft drink/non-alcoholic beverage markets, as well as shopping behavior and evening television viewing. Income is superior to social class for major appliances, soft drinks, mixers, and alcoholic beverages. The combination of income and social class is superior for makeup and clothing, as well as automobile and television ownership, and thus a modified form of the relative income and status incongruence hypotheses is supported.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BishopY. M., FinebergS. E., and HollandP. W. (1975), Discrete Multivariate Analysis: Theory & Practice. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
2.
ColemanR. P. (1960), “The Significance of Social Stratification in Selling,” in Marketing: A Maturing Discipline, BellMartin L., ed. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 171–84.
3.
CurtisWilliam H. (1972), “Social Class or Income?” Journal of Marketing, 36 (January), 67–8.
4.
DardisRachael and SandlerMarie (1971), “Shopping Behavior of Discount Store Customers in a Small City,”Journal of Retailing, 47, 60–72.
5.
DillonW. R. (1979), “On the Analysis of Multiway Contingency Tables: An Alternative Method for Selecting Variables Prior to Logit Analysis,”Journal of Marketing, 43 (October).
6.
EngelJ. F., BlackwellR. D., and KollatD. T. (1978), Consumer Behavior, 3rd edition. Hinsdale, Illinois: Dry-den Press.
7.
EngelJ. F., KollatD. T., and BlackwellR. D. (1973), Consumer Behavior, 2nd edition. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
8.
FoxallGordon (1975), “Social Factors in Consumer Choice: Replication and Extension,”Journal of Consumer Research, 2 (June), 60–4.
9.
GlennNorval D. (1967), “Massification versus Differentiation: Some Trend Data From National Surveys,”Social Forces, 46 (December).
10.
GlennNorval D. and AlstopJon P. (1968), “Cultural Distances Among Occupational Categories,”American Sociological Review, 33 (June).
11.
HirischR. and PetersM. (1974), “Selecting the Superior Segmentation Correlate,”Journal of Marketing, 38, 60–3.
12.
HollingsheadA. B. and RedlichF. C. (1958), Social Class and Mental Illness. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
13.
JackmanMary R. (1979), “The Subjective Meaning of Social Class Identification in the United States,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 43, 443–62.
14.
LenskiGerhard E. (1956), “Status Crystalization: A Non-Vertical Dimension of Social Status,”American Sociological Review, 21 (August), 458–64.
15.
LenskiGerhard E. (1966), Power and Privileges. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
16.
LevyS. J. (1966), “Social Class and Consumer Behavior,” in On Knowing the Consumer. NewmanJ. W., ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.146–60.
17.
LevyS. J. (1971), “Symbolism and Life Style,” in Perspectives in Marketing Management, SturdivantF. D., ed. Glenview, Illinois: Scott, Foresman and Company, 112–18.
18.
MalewskiAndzrej (1966), “The Degree of Status Incongruence and Its Effects,” in Class, Status, and Power, 2nd edition, BendixReinhard and LipsetSeymour M., eds. New York: Free Press, 303–8.
19.
MartineauPierre (1958), “Social Classes and Spending Behavior,”Journal of Marketing, 23, 121–41.
20.
MatthewsH. Lee and SlocumJohn W. (1969), “Social Class and Commercial Bank Credit Card Usage,”Journal of Marketing, 33 (January) 71–78.
21.
MatthewsH. Lee and SlocumJohn W. (1972), “A Rejoinder to ‘Social Class or Income?’” Journal of Marketing, 36 (January), 60–70.
22.
McCarthyE. and ShapiroS. (1975), Basic Marketing, 1st Canadian Edition. Georgetown, Ontario: Irwin Dorsy, Ltd.
23.
MyersJ. H. and GuttmanJ. (1974), “Life Style: The Essence of Social Class,” in Lifestyle and Psychographics, WellsWilliam D., ed. Chicago: American Marketing Association, Chapter 10.
24.
MyersJ. H. and MountJ. (1973), “More on Social Class vs. Income as Correlates of Buyer Behavior,”Journal of Marketing, 37, 71–3.
25.
MyersJ. H., StantonR., and HaugA. (1971), “Correlates of Buyer Behavior—Social Class vs. Income,”Journal of Marketing, 35, 8–15.
26.
NisbettR. A. (1968), “The Decline and Fall of Social Class,” in Tradition and Revolt, NisbettR. A., ed. New York: Random House.
27.
OverallJ. and KlettJ. (1972), Applied Multivariate Analysis. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
28.
ParkerRichard (1974), “Fact and Fancy About America's Classless Society,”Business and Society Review/Innovation, 10 (Summer).
29.
PerraultW. and DardenW. (1975), “Unequal Cell Sizes in Marketing Hypotheses: Use of the General Linear Hypothesis,”Journal of Marketing Research, 12 (August), 333–42.
30.
PetersWilliam H. (1970), “Relative Occupational Class Income: A Significant Variable in the Marketing of Automobiles,”Journal of Marketing, 34 (April), 74–7.
31.
PrasadV. Kanti (1975), “Socio-economic Product Risk and Patronnage Preferences of Retail Shoppers,”Journal of Marketing, 39, 42–7.
32.
RainwaterL., ColemanR. P., and HandelG. (1959) Workingman's Wife. New York: Oceana Publications.
33.
ReynoldsF. D. and WellsW. D. (1977), Consumer Behavior. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
34.
RichStuart A. and JainSubhash C. (1968), “Social Class and Life Cycle as Predictors of Shopping Behavior,”Journal of Marketing Research, 5 (February), 41–9.
35.
RobertsonT. S. (1970), Consumer Behavior. Glenview, Illinois: Scott, Foresman and Company.
36.
RossM. (1965), “Updown and Downtown,”American Sociological Review, 30, 255–9.
37.
SlocumJohn W. and Lee MatthewsH. (1970), “Social Class and Income as Indicators of Consumer Credit Behavior,”Journal of Marketing, 34 (April), 69–74.
38.
TigertD. and ArnoldS. (1971), “Profiling Self-Designated Opinion Leaders and Self-Designated Innovators Through Life Style Research,” in Proceedings and Annual Conferences, GardnerD., ed. College Park, Maryland: Association for Consumer Research, 425–45.
39.
TuckerW. T. (1964), The Social Context of Economic Behavior. New York: Holt, 42–3.
40.
WassonChester R. (1969), “Is It Time to Quit Thinking of Income Classes?” Journal of Marketing, 33 (April), 54–7.
41.
WellsWilliam D., BanksSeymour, and TigertDouglas (1967), “Order in the Data,” in Proceedings of the American Marketing Association, MoyerRead, ed. 263–6.
42.
WellsWilliam D., and TigertDouglas J. (1971), “Activities, Interests, and Opinions,”Journal of Advertising Research, 11 (August), 27–35.
43.
WindY. (1978), “Issues and Advances in Segmentation Research,”Journal of Marketing Research, 15 (August), 317–37.
44.
ZaltmanGerald and WallendorfMelanie (1979), Consumer Behavior: Basic Findings and Management Implications. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
