Alternative Perceptual Mapping Techniques: Relative Accuracy and Usefulness

Abstract

Perceptual mapping is widely used in marketing to analyze market structure, design new products, and develop advertising strategies. This article presents theoretical arguments and empirical evidence which suggest that factor analysis is superior to discriminant analysis and similarity scaling with respect to predictive ability, managerial interpretability, and ease of use.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beckwith

N. E.

and Lehmann

D. R.

(1975), “The Importance of Halo Effects in Multi-Attribute Attitude Models,” Journal of Marketing Research, 12 (August), 265–75.

Best

R. J.

(1976), “The Predictive Aspects of a Joint Space Theory of Stochastic Choice,” Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (May), 198–204.

Carmone

F. J.

, Green

P. E.

, and Jain

A. K.

(1978), “The Robustness of Conjoint Analysis: Some Monté Carlo Results,” Journal of Marketing Research, 15 (May), 300–3.

Carroll

J. D.

and Chang

J. J.

(1964), “A General Index of Nonlinear Correlation and Its Application to the Interpretation of Multidimensional Scaling Solutions,” American Psychologist, 19.

Carroll

J. D.

and Chang

J. J.

(1970), “Analysis of Individual Differences in Multidimensional Scaling via an N-way Generalization of the Eckart-Young Decomposition,” Psychometrika, 35, 283–319.

Cattin

and Wittink

D. R.

(1976), “A Monté Carlo Study of Metric and Nonmetric Estimation Methods for Multiattribute Models,” Research Paper No. 341, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University (November).

Cooley

W. W.

and Lohnes

P. R.

(1971), Multivariate Data Analysis. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Cort

S. G.

and Dominguez

L. V.

(1977), “Cross Shopping and Retail Growth,” Journal of Marketing Research, 14 (May), 187–92.

Day

G. S.

, Deutscher

, and Ryans

A. B.

(1976), “Data Quality, Level of Aggregation, and Nonmetric Multidimensional Scaling Solutions,” Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (February), 92–7.

10.

Dixon

W. J.

(1975), BMDP: Biomedical Computer Programs. Los Angeles: University of California Press.

11.

Englund

, Hundt

, and Lee

(1978), “An Empirical Comparison of Factor Analysis and Discriminant Analysis for Non-Work Trips in Evanston,” Technical Report, Transportation Center, Northwestern University (August).

12.

Etgar

(1977), “Channel Environment and Channel Leadership,” Journal of Marketing Research, 14 (February), 69–76.

13.

Gensch

P. H.

and Golob

T. F.

(1975), “Testing the Consistency of Attribute Meaning in Empirical Concept Testing,” Journal of Marketing Research, 12 (August), 348–54.

14.

Green

P. E.

(1975), “On the Robustness of Multidimensional Scaling Techniques,” Journal of Marketing Research, 12 (February), 73–81.

15.

Green

P. E.

and Carmone

F. J.

(1969), “Multidimensional Scaling: An Introduction and Comparison of Nonmetric Unfolding Techniques,” Journal of Marketing Research, 7 (August), 330–41.

16.

Green

P. E.

, and Wachspress

D. D.

(1977), “On the Analysis of Qualitative Data in Marketing Research,” Journal of Marketing Research, 14 (February), 52–9.

17.

Green

P. E.

and Rao

(1972), Applied Multidimensional Scaling. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc.

18.

Green

P. E.

and Srinivasan

(1978), “Conjoint Analysis in Consumer Behavior; Status and Outlook,” Journal of Consumer Research, 5 (September), 103–23.

19.

Green

P. E.

and Wind

Yoram

(1973), Multiattribute Decisions in Marketing. Hinsdale, Illinois: The Dryden Press.

20.

Green

P. E.

and Wind

Yoram

(1975), “New Way to Measure Consumer's Judgments,” Harvard Business Review (July–August).

21.

Harmon

H. H.

(1967), Modern Factor Analysis. Chicago: University of Chicago.

22.

Hauser

J. R.

(1978), “Testing the Accuracy, Usefulness, and Significance of Probabilistic Choice Models: An Information Theoretic Approach,” Operations Research, 26 (May–June), 406–21.

23.

Hauser

J. R.

and Urban

G. L.

(1977), “A Normative Methodology for Modeling Consumer Response to Innovation,” Operations Research, 25 (July–August), 579–619.

24.

Heeler

R. M.

, Whipple

T. W.

, and Hustad

T. P.

(1977), “Maximum Likelihood Factor Analysis of Attitude Data,” Journal of Marketing Research, 14 (February), 42–51.

25.

Jain

A. K.

and Pinson

(1976), “The Effect of Order of Presentation of Similarity Judgments on Multidimensional Scaling Results: An Empirical Comparison,” Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (November), 435–9.

26.

Johnson

R. M.

(1971), “Market Segmentation: A Strategic Management Tool,” Journal of Marketing Research, 8 (February), 13–18.

27.

Johnson

R. M.

(1970), “Multiple Discriminant Analysis Applications to Marketing Research,” Market Facts, Inc. (January).

28.

Jolson

Marvin A.

and Spath

Walter F.

(1973), “Understanding and Fulfilling Shoppers' Requirements,” Journal of Retailing, 49 (Summer).

29.

Klahr

David

(1969), “A Monté Carlo Investigation of the Statistical Significance of Kruskal's Non-metric Scaling Procedure,” Psychometrika, 34 (September), 319–30.

30.

Koppelman

Frank S.

and Hauser

John

(1977), “Consumer Travel Choice Behavior: An Empirical Analysis of Destination Choice for Non-Grocery Shopping Trips,” Technical Report, Transportation Center, Northwestern University (March).

31.

Lerman

S. R.

and Manski

C. F.

(1976), “Alternative Sampling Procedure for Disaggregate Choice Model Estimation,” Transportation Research Record, 592, Transportation Research Board.

32.

MacKay

David B.

and Olshavsky

Richard W.

(1975), “Cognitive Maps of Retail Locations; An Investigation of Some Basic Issues,” Journal of Consumer Research, 2 (December).

33.

Manski

C. F.

and Lerman

S. R.

(1977), “The Estimation of Choice Probabilities from Choice Based Samples,” Econometrica, 45 (November).

34.

McFadden

Daniel

(1970), “Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior,” in Frontiers in Econometrics, Zaremblea

, ed. New York: Academic Press, 105–42.

35.

Nie

N. H.

, Hull

G. H.

, Jenkins

J. G.

, Steinbrenner

, and Bent

D. H.

(1975), SPSS: Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, 2nd edition. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.

36.

Pekelman

and Sen

(1977), “Improving Prediction in Conjoint Measurement,” Working Paper, Graduate School of Management, University of Rochester (January).

37.

Pessemier

E. A.

(1977), Product Management: Strategy and Organization. New York: Wiley/Hamilton.

38.

Rummel

R. J.

(1970), Applied Factor Analysis. Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press.

39.

Silk

A. J.

and Urban

G. L.

(1978), “Pretest Market Evaluation of New Packaged Goods: A Model and Measurement Methodology,” Journal of Marketing Research, 15 (May), 171–91.

40.

Simmie

Patricia

(1978), “Alternative Perceptual Models: Reproducibility, Validity, and Data Integrity,” Proceedings of the American Marketing Association Educators Conference, Chicago (August).

41.

Singston

Ricardo

(1975), “Multidimensional Scaling Analysis of Store Image and Shopping Behavior,” Journal of Retailing, 51, 2.

42.

Stopher

P. R.

, Watson

P. L.

, and Blin

J. J.

(1974), “A Method for Assessing Pricing and Structural Changes on Transport Mode Use,” Interim Report to the Office of University Research, U.S. Department of Transportation, Transportation Center, Northwestern University (September).

43.

Summers

J. O.

and MacKay

D. B.

, (1976), “On the Validity and Reliability of Direct Similarity Judgments,” Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (August), 289–95.

44.

Urban

G. L.

(1975), “PERCEPTOR: A Model for Product Positioning,” Management Science, 8 (April), 858–71.

45.

Whipple

T. W.

(1976), “Variation Among Multidimensional Scaling Solutions: An Examination of the Effect of Data Collection Differences,” Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (February), 98–103.

46.

Wilkie

W. L.

and Pessemier

E. A.

(1973), “Issues in Marketing's Use of Multi-Attribute Attitude Models,” Journal of Marketing Research, 10 (November), 428–41.