A review of empirical studies concerned with increasing response rates to mail questionnaires reveals the limited evidence upon which most widely accepted techniques are based. The only techniques which seem to be consistently effective in increasing response rates are followup letters and monetary incentives enclosed with the mail questionnaires.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsJ. Stacy. “An Experiment on Question and Response Bias,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 20(Fall 1956), 593–8.
2.
AndreasenAlan R.“Personalizing Mail Questionnaire Correspondence,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 34(Summer 1970), 273–7.
3.
BachrachStanley D., and ScobleHarry M.“Mail Questionnaire Efficiency: Controlled Reduction of Non-Response,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 31(Summer 1967), 265–71.
4.
BaurE. Jackson. “Response Bias in a Mail Survey,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 11(Winter 1947), 594–600.
5.
BlairWilliam S.“How Subject Matter Can Bias a Mail Survey,”Mediascope, (February 1964), 70–2.
6.
BoekWalter E., and LadeJames H.“A Test of the Usefulness of the Postcard Technique in a Mail Questionnaire Study,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 27(Summer 1963), 303–6.
7.
BoydHarper W.Jr., and WestfallRalph. “Interviewers as a Source of Error in Surveys,”Journal of Marketing, 19(April 1955), 311–24.
8.
BoydHarper W.Jr.“Interviewer Bias Revisited,”Journal of Marketing Research, 2(February 1965), 58–63.
9.
BoydHarper W.Jr.“Interviewer Bias Once More Revisited,”Journal of Marketing Research, 7(May 1970), 249–53.
10.
BoydHarper W.Jr.Marketing Research: Text and Cases.Homewood, Ill.: Richard D. Irwin, 1972.
11.
BradtKenneth. “The Usefulness of a Postcard Technique in a Mail Questionnaire Study,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 19(Summer 1955), 218–22.
12.
BrennanRobert. “Trading Stamps as an Incentive,”Journal of Marketing, 22(January 1958), 306–7.
13.
BrownMorton L.“Use of a Postcard Query in Mail Surveys,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 29(Winter 1965), 635–7.
14.
BrunnerAllen G., and CarrollStephen J.Jr.“The Effect of Prior Notification on the Refusal Rate in Fixed Address Surveys,”Journal of Advertising Research, 9(March 1969), 42–4.
15.
CahalanDon. “Effectiveness of a Mail Questionnaire Technique in the Army,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 15(Fall 1951), 575–8.
16.
CampbellDonald T.“Bias in Mail Surveys,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 13(Fall 1949), 562.
17.
CasePeter. “How to Catch Interviewer Errors,”Journal of Advertising Research, 11(April 1971), 39–43.
18.
ClausenJohn A., and FordRobert N.“Controlling Bias in Mail Questionnaires,”Journal of the American Statistical Association, 42(September 1947), 497–511.
19.
CoxEli, Thomas AndersonW.Jr. III, and FulcherDavid. “Reappraising Mail Survey Response Rates,”Journal of Marketing Research, 11(November 1974), 413–7.
20.
DemingW. Edward. “On a Probability Mechanism to Attain an Economic Balance Between the Resultant Error of Response and the Bias of Non-Response,”Journal of The American Statistical Association, 48(December 1953), 363–70.
21.
DeutscherIrwin. “Physicians’ Reaction to a Mailed Questionnaire: A Study in Resistentialism,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 20(Fall 1956), 599–604.
22.
DillmanDon A.“Increasing Mail Questionnaire Response in Large Samples of the General Public,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 36(Summer 1972), 254–7.
23.
DonaldMarjorie N.“Implications of Non-Response for the Interpretation of Mail Questionnaire Data,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 24(Spring 1960), 99–114.
24.
EcklandBruce. “Effects of Prodding to Increase Mail Back Returns,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 49(June 1965), 165–9.
25.
ErdosPaul L., and MorganArthur J.Professional Mail Surveys.New York: McGraw-Hill, 1970.
26.
FerberRobert. “The Problem of Bias in Mail Returns: A Solution,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 12(Winter 1948), 669–76.
27.
FerrisAbbot L.“A Note on Stimulating Response to Questionnaires,”American Sociological Review, 16(April 1951), 247–9.
28.
FordNeil M.“Questionnaire Appearance and Response Rates in Mail Surveys,”Journal of Advertising Research, 8(September 1968), 43–5.
29.
FordRobert N., and ZeiselHans. “Bias in Mail Surveys Cannot be Controlled by One Mailing,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 13(Fall 1949), 495–501.
30.
FrankRonald E., MasseyWilliam F., and LodahlThomas M.“Purchasing Behavior and Personal Attributes,”Journal of Advertising Research, 9(December 1969), 15–24.
31.
FrankelLester R.“How Incentives and Subsamples Affect the Precision of Mail Surveys,”Journal of Advertising Research, 1(September 1960), 1–5.
32.
FranzenRaymond, and LazarsfeldPaul F.“Mail Questionnaires as a Research Problem,”Journal Of Psychology, 20(October 1945), 293–320.
33.
FrazierGeorge, and BirdKermit. “Increasing the Response of a Mail Questionnaire,”Journal of Marketing, 22(October 1958), 186–7.
34.
GannonMartin, and NothernJoseph, and CarrolStephenJr.“Characteristics of Non-Respondents Among Workers,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 55(December 1971), 586–8.
35.
GelbBetsy, “Incentives to Increase Survey Returns: Social Class Considerations,”Journal of Marketing Research, 7(February 1975), 107–9.
36.
GoldsteinHyman, and KrollBernard H.“Methods of Increasing Mail Response,”Journal of Marketing, 21(July 1957), 55–7.
37.
GullahornJohn, and GullahornJeanne. “An Investigation of the Effects of Three Factors on Response to Mail Questionnaires,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 27(Summer 1963), 294–6.
38.
HacklerJames, and BourgettePatricia. “Dollars, Dissonance, and Survey Returns,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 37(Summer 1973), 276–81.
39.
HancockJohn W.“An Experimental Study of Four Methods of Measuring Unit Costs of Obtaining Attitude Toward the Retail Store,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 24(April 1940), 213–30.
40.
HeatonEugene E.Jr.“Increasing Mail Questionnaire Returns with a Preliminary Letter,”Journal of Advertising Research, 5(December 1965), 36–9.
41.
HochstimJoseph R.“A Critical Comparison of Three Strategies of Collecting Data from Households,”Journal of The American Statistical Association, 62(September 1967), 976–89.
42.
HochstimJoseph R., and AthanasopoulosDemetrious A.“Personal Follow-up in a Mail Survey: Its Contribution and Its Cost,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 34(Spring 1970), 69–81.
43.
HoustonMichael, and JeffersonRobert. “The Negative Effect of Personalization on Response Patterns in Mail Surveys,”Journal of Marketing Research, 7(February 1975), 114–7.
44.
JahodaMarie, and DeutschMorton, and CookStuart W.Research Methods in Social Relations, Vols. I and II. New York: Dryden Press, 1951.
45.
KawashMary B., and AleamoniLawrence M.“Effect of Personal Signature on the Initial Rate of Return of a Mailed Questionnaire,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 55(December 1971), 589–92.
46.
KephartWilliam M., and BresslerMarvin. “Increasing the Responses to Mail Questionnaires,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 22(Summer 1958), 123–32.
KimballAndrew E.“Increasing the Rate of Return in Mail Surveys,”Journal of Marketing, 25(October 1961), 63–5.
49.
KnoxJohn B.“Maximizing Responses to Mail Questionnaires,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 15(Summer 1951), 366–7.
50.
KnudsonDean O., and PopeHallowell, and IrishDonald P.“Response Differences to Questions on Sexual Standards: An Interview Questionnaire Comparison,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 31(Summer 1967), 290–7.
51.
LarsonRichard F., and CattonWilliam R.Jr.“Can the Mail-Back Bias Contribute to a Study's Validity?”American Sociological Review, 24(April 1959), 243–5.
52.
LevineSol, and GordonGerald. “Maximizing Returns on Mail Questionnaires,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 22(Winter 1958), 568–75.
53.
LongworthDonald S.“Use of a Mailed Questionnaire,”American Sociological Review, 18(June 1953), 310–3.
54.
LubinBernard, LevittEugene E., and ZuckermanMarvin. “Some Personality Differences between Respondents and Nonrespondents to a Survey Questionnaire,”Journal of Consulting Psychology, 26(April 1962), 192–7.
55.
MasonWard S., DresselRobert J., and BainRobert K.“An Experimental Study of Factors Affecting Response to a Mail Survey of Beginning Teachers,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 25(Summer 1961), 296–9.
56.
McDonaghEdward C., and Leon RosenblumA.“A Comparison of Mailed Questionnaires and Subsequent Structured Interviews,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 29(Spring 1965), 131–6.
57.
MyersJames H., and HaugArne F.“How a Preliminary Letter Affects Mail Survey Returns and Costs,”Journal of Advertising Research, 9(September 1969), 37–9.
58.
NewmanSheldon W.“Differences Between Early and Late Respondents to a Mailed Survey,”Journal of Advertising Research, 2(June 1962), 37–9.
59.
NuckolsRobert C.“Personal Interview Versus Mail Panel Survey,”Journal of Marketing Research, 1(February 1964), 11–6.
60.
O'DellWilliam F.“Personal Interviews or Mail Panels?”Journal of Marketing, 26(October 1962), 34–9.
ParsonsRobert J., and MedfordThomas S.“The Effect of Advance Notice in Mail Surveys of Homogenous Groups,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 36(Summer 1972), 258–9.
63.
PearlinLeonard I.“The Appeals of Anonymity in Questionnaire Response,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 25(Winter 1961), 640–7.
64.
ReussCarl F.“Differences Between Persons Responding and Not Responding to a Mailed Questionnaire,”American Sociological Review, 8 (August 1943), 433–8.
