Two marketing studies that investigated relationships between self-confidence and persuasibility are reanalyzed. It is shown that the results of these studies are mostly contradictory, that some conclusions drawn by the investigators are wrong, that other conclusions are dubious, and that, in all, self-confidence is not an important determinant of persuasibility.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BellGerald D., “Self-confidence and Persuasion in Car Buying,” Journal of Marketing Research, 4 (February 1967), 46–53.
2.
BellGerald D., “The Automobile Buyer After the Purchase,” Journal of Marketing, 31 (July 1967), 12–6.
3.
LeonardBerkowitz and LundyRichard M., “Personality Characteristics Related to Susceptibility to Influence by Peers or Authority Figures,” Journal of Personality, 25 (March 1957), 306–16.
4.
CohenArthur R., “Some Implications of Self-Esteem for Social Influence,” in HovlandCarl I. and JanisIrving L., eds., Personality and Persuasibility, New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1959.
5.
CostnerHerbert L., “Criteria for Measures of Association,” American Sociological Review, 30 (June 1965), 341–51.
6.
CoxDonald F., ed., Risk Taking and Information Handling in Consumer Behavior, Division of Research, Graduate School of Business Administration, Harvard University, Boston, 1967.
7.
DonaldF. Cox and BauerRaymond A., “Self-confidence and Persuasibility in Women,” Public Opinion Quarterly, 28 (Fall 1964), 453–66.
8.
CrutchfieldRichard S., “Conformity and Characters,” American Psychologist, 10 (May 1955), 191–8.
9.
Richard DeCharms and RosenbaumMilton E., “Status Variables and Matching Behavior,” Journal of Personality, 28 (October 1960), 492–502.
10.
DobzhanskyTheodore, “On Diversity and Equality,” Columbia University Forum, 8 (Spring1967), 5.
11.
EkeblandFrederick A., The Statistical Method in Business, New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 1962.
12.
FerberRobert, Statistical Techniques in Market Research, New York: McGraw-Hill Book Co., Inc., 1949.
13.
GelfandDonna M., “The Influence of Self-Esteem on Rate of Verbal Conditioning and Social Matching Behavior,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 65C (October 1962), 259–65.
14.
LeoA. Goodman and KruskalWilliam H., “Measures of Association for Cross-Classifications,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 49 (December 1954), 732–64.
15.
HochbaumGodfrey M., “The Relation Between Group Member's Self-Confidence and Their Reaction to Group Pressures to Uniformity,” American Sociological Review, 19 (June 1954), 678–87.
16.
HowardJohn A. and ShethJagdish, Theory of Buyer Behavior, 1967, mimeographed.
17.
JanisIrving L., “Personality and Susceptibility to Persuasion,” Journal of Personality, 22 (June 1954), 504–18.
18.
JanisIrving L., “Anxiety Indices Related to Susceptibility to Persuasion,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 51 (November 1955), 663–7.
19.
IrvingL. Janis and FieldPeter B., “Sex Difference and Personality Factors Related to Persuasibility,” in HovlandCarl I. and JanisIrving L., eds., Personality and Persuasibility, New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1959.
20.
KelmanHerbert C., “Effects of Success and Failure on ‘Suggestibility’ in the Autokinetic Situation,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 45 (April 1950), 267, 285.
21.
GeraldS. Lesser and AbelsonRobert P., “Personality Correlates of Persuasibility in Children,” in HovlandCarl I. and JanisIrving L., eds., Personality and Persuasibility, New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1959.
22.
LintonHarriet B., “Rorschach Correlates of Response to Suggestion,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 49 (January 1954), 75–83.
23.
LintonHarriet B. and GrahamElaine, “Personality Correlates of Persuasibility,” in HovlandCarl I. and JanisIrving L., eds., Personality and Persuasibility, New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1959.
24.
MausnerBernard, “The Effect of Prior Reinforcement on the Interaction of Observed Pairs,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 49 (January 1954), 65–8.
25.
BernardMausner and BlochBarbara L., “A Study of the Additivity of Variables Affecting Social Interaction,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 54 (March 1957), 250–6.
RyanThomas A., “Multiple Comparisons in Psychological Research,” Psychological Bulletin, 56 (October 1959), 26–47.
28.
RyanThomas A., “Significance Tests for Multiple Comparison of Proportions, Variances, and Other Statistics,” Psychological Bulletin, 57 (July 1960), 318–28.
29.
SamelsonFranz, “Conforming Behavior Under Two Conditions of Conflict in the Cognitive Field,” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 55 (September 1957), 181–7.
30.
WirthEdward D.Jr., “Developing Marketing Strategy Through Multiple Regression,” Journal of Marketing Research, 4 (August 1967), 318–9.
