This article studies the impact of business modernization on the sales performance of traditional retailers in an emerging market. The authors define modernization as the adoption of physical structures and tangible practices of organized retail chains (e.g., exterior signage with store name and logo, a database to record product-level information). To address this research question, they implement a randomized field experiment in Mexico City with 1,148 retailers. The sample is randomized as follows: 385 firms are externally modernized in ways that are visible to customers, 383 firms are internally modernized in ways that are not visible to customers, and 380 firms form a control group. The authors find a significant and persistent main effect of modernization on sales. Firms in both treatment groups increase monthly sales by 15%–19% 24 months after study recruitment. In terms of novel mechanism evidence, externally modernized firms improve their store-level branding, while internally modernized firms strengthen their product management. This article also provides an exploratory analysis to guide policy makers, managerial stakeholders, and retailers on how to modernize for the highest returns. This analysis suggests that it is most useful to modernize a firm’s exterior appearance, customer engagement methods, demand analysis, and stock-ordering processes. Finally, the largest improvements come from the initial few modernizing changes, after which returns are diminishing.
AndersonStephen J.ChandyRajeshZiaBilal (2018), “Pathways to Profits: The Impact of Marketing vs. Finance Skills on Business Performance,” Management Science, 64 (12), 5559–83.
5.
BaskerEmek (2007), “The Causes and Consequences of Wal-Mart's Growth,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 21 (3), 177–98.
6.
BeamanLoriMagruderJeremyRobinsonJonathan (2014), “Minding Small Change Among Small Firms in Kenya,” Journal of Development Economics, 108 (May), 69–86.
7.
BloomNicholasEifertBennMahajanAprajitMcKenzieDavidRobertsJohn (2013), “Does Management Matter? Evidence from India,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 128 (1), 1–51.
8.
BrescianiSabrinaEpplerMartin J. (2010), “Brand New Ventures? Insights on Start-Ups’ Branding Practices,” Journal of Product & Brand Management, 19 (5), 356–66.
9.
BronnenbergBart J.EllicksonPaul B. (2015), “Adolescence and the Path to Maturity in Global Retail,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 29 (4), 113–34.
10.
BruhnMiriamKarlanDeanSchoarAntoinette (2018), “The Impact of Consulting Services on Small and Medium Enterprises: Evidence from a Randomized Trial in Mexico,” Journal of Political Economy, 126 (2), 635–87.
CalderonGabrielaCunhaJesse M.De GiorgiGiacomo (2020), “Business Literacy and Development: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial in Rural Mexico,” Economic Development and Cultural Change, 68 (2), 507–40.
13.
CorstenDanielGruenThomas (2003), “Desperately Seeking Shelf Availability: An Examination of the Extent, the Causes, and the Efforts to Address Retail Out-of-Stocks,” International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 31 (12), 605–17.
14.
CosséThomas J.SwanJohn E. (1983), “Strategic Marketing Planning by Product Managers—Room for Improvement?” Journal of Marketing, 47 (3), 92–102.
15.
De AndradeGustavo HenriqueBruhnMiriamMcKenzieDavid (2013), “A Helping Hand or the Long Arm of the Law? Experimental Evidence on What Governments Can Do to Formalize Firms,” The World Bank, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/16323.
16.
De MelSureshMcKenzieDavidWoodruffChristopher (2013), “The Demand for, and Consequences of, Formalization Among Informal Firms in Sri Lanka,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5 (2), 122–50.
17.
De MelSureshMcKenzieDavidWoodruffChristopher (2014), “Business Training and Female Enterprise Start-up, Growth, and Dynamics: Experimental Evidence from Sri Lanka,” Journal of Development Economics, 106 (January), 199–210.
18.
DrexlerAlejandroFischerGregSchoarAntoinette (2014), “Keeping It Simple: Financial Literacy and Rules of Thumb,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 6 (2), 1–31.
19.
DuRex YuxingJooMingyuWilburKenneth C. (2019), “Advertising and Brand Attitudes: Evidence from 575 Brands over Five Years,” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 17 (3), 257–323.
20.
FafchampsMarcelWoodruffChristopher (2016), “Identifying Gazelles: Expert Panels vs. Surveys as a Means to Identify Firms With Rapid Growth Potential,”World Bank Economic Review, 31 (3), 670–86.
21.
FarrisPaul W.BendleNeil T.PfeiferPhillip E.ReibsteinDavid J. (2010), Marketing Metrics: The Definitive Guide to Measuring Marketing Performance, 2nd ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education.
22.
GrewalDhruvKrishnanR.BakerJulieBorinNorm (1998), “The Effect of Store Name, Brand Name and Price Discounts on Consumers’ Evaluations and Purchase Intentions,” Journal of Retailing, 74 (3), 331–52.
HochStephen J.BradlowEric T.WansinkBrian (1999), “The Variety of an Assortment,” Marketing Science, 18 (4), 527–46.
25.
INEGI-ENIGH (2018), “Encuesta Nacional de Ingresos y Gastos de los Hogares [National Survey of Household Income and Expenditure, 2018],” Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y Geografia (accessed December 6, 2021), https://en.www.inegi.org.mx/programas/enigh/nc/2018/#Microdata
KamakuraWagner A.MazzonJose A. (2013), “Socioeconomic Status and Consumption in an Emerging Economy,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 30 (1), 4–18.
28.
KellerKevin Lane (1993), “Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Managing Customer-Based Brand Equity,” Journal of Marketing, 57 (1), 1–22.
29.
KellerKevin LaneLehmannDonald R. (2006), “Brands and Branding: Research Findings and Future Priorities,” Marketing Science, 25 (6), 740–59.
30.
KimWoo GonKimHong-Bumm (2004), “Measuring Customer-Based Restaurant Brand Equity,” Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 45 (2), 115–31.
31.
KohliChiranjeevLaBahnDouglas W. (1997), “Creating Effective Brand Names: A Study of the Naming Process,” Journal of Advertising Research, 37 (1), 67–75.
32.
MaddenThomas J.FehleFrank RudolfFournierSusan (2002), “Brands Matter: An Empirical Investigation of Brand-Building Activities and the Creation of Shareholder Value,”Division of Research, Harvard Business School.
33.
McKenzieDavid (2012), “Beyond Baseline and Follow-Up: The Case for More T in Experiments,” Journal of Development Economics, 99 (2), 210–21.
34.
McKenzieDavid (2020), “Small Business Training to Improve Management Practices in Developing Countries: Reassessing the Evidence for ‘Training Doesn’t Work’,” working paper, The World Bank, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/34506.
35.
McKenzieDavidSakhoYaye Seynabou (2010), “Does It Pay Firms to Register for Taxes? The Impact of Formality on Firm Profitability,” Journal of Development Economics, 91 (1), 15–24.
36.
McKenzieDavidSansoneDario (2017), “Man vs. Machine in Predicting Successful Entrepreneurs: Evidence from a Business Plan Competition in Nigeria,” working paper, The World Bank, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/29007.
37.
McKenzieDavidWoodruffChristopher (2014), “What Are We Learning From Business Training and Entrepreneurship Evaluations Around the Developing World?” The World Bank Research Observer, 29 (1), 48–82.
38.
MitraDebanjanGolderPeter N. (2006), “How Does Objective Quality Affect Perceived Quality? Short-Term Effects, Long-Term Effects, and Asymmetries,” Marketing Science, 25 (3), 230–47.
39.
Monroe SullivanDanielShawSamuel C. (2011), “Retail Gentrification and Race: The Case of Alberta Street in Portland, Oregon,” Urban Affairs Review, 47 (3), 413–32.
40.
MoralesAndrea C. (2005), “Giving Firms an ‘E’ for Effort: Consumer Responses to High-Effort Firms,” Journal of Consumer Research, 31 (4), 806–12.
41.
NarayanVishalRaoVithala R.SudhirK. (2015), “Early Adoption of Modern Grocery Retail in an Emerging Market: Evidence from India,” Marketing Science, 34 (6), 825–42.
42.
PolitisDiamanto (2005), “The Process of Entrepreneurial Learning: A Conceptual Framework,” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 29 (4), 399–424.
43.
SimonsonAlexSchmittBernd H. (1997), Marketing Aesthetics: The Strategic Management of Brands, Identity, and Image. New York: Simon and Schuster.
44.
SteinAlishaRamaseshanBalasubramani (2016), “Towards the Identification of Customer Experience Touch Point Elements,” Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 30 (May), 8–19.
45.
SudhirK.TalukdarDebabrata (2015), “The ‘Peter Pan Syndrome’ in Emerging Markets: The Productivity-Transparency Trade-off in IT Adoption,” Marketing Science, 34 (4), 500–521.
46.
TyagiRajesh K.SawhneyMohanbir S. (2010), “High-Performance Product Management: The Impact of Structure, Process, Competencies, and Role Definition,” Journal of Product Innovation Management, 27 (1), 83–96.
47.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (2017), UNCTAD Handbook of Statistics 2017. New York: United Nations.
VerhoefPeter C.SlootLaurens M. (2006), “Out-of-Stock: Reactions, Antecedents, Management Solutions, and a Future Perspective,” in Retailing in the 21st Century, Manfred Krafft and Murali K. Mantrala, eds. Berlin: Springer, 239–53.
50.
WarrinerAmy BethKupermanVictorBrysbaertMarc (2013), “Norms of Valence, Arousal, and Dominance for 13,915 English Lemmas,” Behavior Research Methods, 45 (4), 1191–1207.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
