The authors investigate how heuristics and analytics contribute to the advertising budget decision by decomposing it into four components: (1) baseline spending, (2) adaptive experimentation, (3) advertising-to-sales ratio, and (4) competitive parity. They propose a methodology to estimate and infer the weights of these four components. Applying this methodology to sales and advertising data across eight brands from three categories substantiates for the first time, and uniformly across all brands, that managers depart from optimality through adaptive experimentation, which is in line with dual control theory that suggests they do so to learn about advertising effectiveness. The adaptive experimentation finding, combined with evidence on the use of heuristic methods, suggests that budget decision making is characterized by bounded rationality. Furthermore, budgeting decisions are brand-specific, reflecting the considerations of a brand’s market position and performance. Finally, simulation studies show that brands from categories with high uncertainty in advertising effectiveness can benefit from double-digit revenue lifts by placing higher emphasis on adaptive experimentation.
AchenChristopher H. (1982). Interpreting and Using Regression. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE Publications.
2.
AckoffRussell L.EmshoffJames R. (1975), “Advertising Research at Anheuser-Busch, Inc. (1963–68),” Sloan Management Review (Winter), 16 (2), 1–15.
3.
AssmusGertFarleyJohn U.LehmannDonald R. (1984), “How Advertising Affects Sales: Meta-Analysis of Econometric Results,” Journal of Marketing Research, 21 (1), 65–74.
4.
AtamanM. BerkHeerdeHarald J. vanMelaCarl F. (2010), “The Long-Term Effect of Marketing Strategy on Brand Sales,” Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (5), 866–82.
5.
AveryJill (2016), “Brand Portfolio Strategy and Brand Architecture,” Case No. 517021. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School.
6.
BaumolWilliam J. (1962), “On the Theory of Expansion of the Firm,” The American Economic Review, 52 (5), 1078–87.
7.
BignéJ. Enrique (1995), “Advertising Budget Practices: A Review,” Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising, 17 (2), 17–31.
8.
BronnenbergBart J.KrugerMichael W.MelaCarl F. (2008), “Database Paper—The IRI Marketing Data Set,” Marketing Science, 27 (4), 745–48.
9.
BruceNorris (2008), “Pooling and Dynamic Forgetting Effects in Multi-Theme Advertising: Tracking the Ad Sales Relationship With Particle Filters,” Marketing Science, 27 (4), 659–73.
10.
ChintaguntaPradeep K.JainDipak (1992), “A Dynamic Model of Channel Member Strategies for Marketing Expenditures,” Marketing Science11 (2), 168–88.
11.
DanaherPeter J.BonfrerAndréDharSanjay (2008), “The Effect of Competitive Advertising Interference on Sales for Packaged Goods,” Journal of Marketing Research, 45 (2), 211–25.
12.
DanaherPeter J.RustRonald (1994), “Determining the Optimal Level of Media Spending,” Journal of Advertising Research, 34 (1), 28–35.
13.
DanenbergNickKennedyRachelBealVirginiaSharpByron (2016), “Advertising Budgeting: A Reinvestigation of the Evidence on Brand Size and Spend,” Journal of Advertising, 45 (1), 139–46.
14.
DavidsonRussellMacKinnonJames G. (2004), Econometric Theory and Methods. New York: Oxford University Press.
15.
EastlackJoseph O.RaoAmbar G. (1989), “Advertising Experiments at the Campbell Soup Company,” Marketing Science, 8 (1), 57–71.
16.
FarrisPaul W.WestDouglas C. (2007), A Fresh View of the Advertising Budget Process. London: SAGE Publications.
17.
FeldbaumAleksandr A. (1965), Optimal Control Systems. New York: New York Academic Press.
18.
FilatovNikolai M.UnbehauenHeinz (2004), Adaptive Dual Control: Theory and Applications. Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, Germany: Springer.
19.
GunnyKatherine (2005), “What Are the Consequences of Real Earnings Management?” ProQuest Dissertations Publishing, University of California, Berkeley.
20.
HillSamEttensonRichardTysonDane (2005), “Achieving the Ideal Brand Portfolio,” MIT Sloan Management Review, 46 (2), 85–90.
21.
KolsariciCerenVakratsasDemetrios (2010), “Category- Versus Brand-Level Advertising Messages in a Highly Regulated Environment,” Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (6), 1078–89.
22.
KolsariciCerenVakratsasDemetrios (2015), “Correcting for Misspecification in Parameter Dynamics to Improve Forecast Accuracy with Adaptively Estimated Models,” Management Science, 61 (10), 2495–513.
23.
KruskalWilliamMajorsRuth (1989), “Concepts of Relative Importance in Recent Scientific Literature,” The American Statistician, 43 (1), 2–6.
24.
LewisRandall A.RaoJustin M. (2015), “The Unfavorable Economics of Measuring the Returns to Advertising,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130 (4), 1941–73.
25.
LittleJohn D. C. (1966), “A Model of Adaptive Control of Promotional Spending,” Operations Research, 14 (6), 1075–97.
26.
LittleJohn D. C. (1977), “Optimal Adaptive Control: A Multivariate Model for Marketing Applications,” IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 22 (2), 187–95.
27.
LiuYanShankarVenkatesh (2015), “The Dynamic Impact of Product-Harm Crises on Brand Preference and Advertising Effectiveness: An Empirical Analysis of the Automobile Industry,” Management Science, 61 (10), 2514–35.
28.
LowGeorge S.MohrJakki J. (1999), “Setting Advertising and Promotion Budgets in Multi-Brand Companies,” Journal of Advertising Research, 39 (1), 67–78.
29.
LowGeorge S.MohrJakki J. (2000), “Advertising vs. Sales Promotion: A Brand Management Perspective,” Journal of Product & Brand Management, 9 (6), 389–414.
30.
MarchJames G.SimonHerbert A. (1958), Organizations. New York: Wiley.
31.
NaikPrasad A.MantralaMurali K.SawyerAlan G. (1998), “Planning Media Schedules in the Presence of Dynamic Advertising Quality,” Marketing Science, 17 (3), 214–35.
NaikPrasadRamanKalyan (2003), “Understanding the Impact of Synergy in Multimedia Communications,” Journal of Marketing Research, 40 (4), 375–88.
34.
NaikPrasad A.RamanKalyanWinerRussell S. (2005), “Planning Marketing-Mix Strategies in the Presence of Interaction Effects,” Marketing Science, 24 (1), 25–34.
35.
NerloveMarcArrowKenneth J. (1962), “Optimal Advertising Policy Under Dynamic Conditions,” Economica, 29 (114), 129–42.
36.
OsingaErnst C.LeeflangPeter S. H.WieringaJaap E. (2010), “Early Marketing Matters: A Time-Varying Parameter Approach to Persistence Modeling,” Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (1), 173–85.
37.
PekelmanDovTseEdison (1980), “Experimentation and Budgeting in Advertising: An Adaptive Control Approach,” Operations Research, 28 (2), 321–47.
38.
PiercyNigel F. (1987), “The Marketing Budgeting Process: Marketing Management Implications,” Journal of Marketing, 51 (4), 45–59.
39.
RamanKalyan (1990), “Stochastically Optimal Advertising Policies Under Dynamic Conditions: The Ratio Rule,” Optimal Control Applications and Methods, 11 (3), 283–88.
40.
RamanKalyanMantralaMurali K.SridharShrihariTangYihui Elina (2012), “Optimal Resource Allocation with Time-Varying Marketing Effectiveness, Margins, and Costs,” Journal of Interactive Marketing, 26 (1), 43–52.
41.
RosenzweigPhil (2014), “The Benefits—and Limits—of Decision Models,” McKinsey Quarterly(February), 1–10.
42.
RubelOlivierNaikPrasad A.SrinivasanShuba (2011), “Optimal Advertising When Envisioning a Product-Harm Crisis,” Marketing Science, 30 (6), 1048–65.
43.
RubelOlivierPrasadAshutosh (2016), “Dynamic Incentives in Sales Force Compensation,” Marketing Science, 35 (4), 676–89
44.
SahniNavdeep S. (2015), “Effect of Temporal Spacing Between Advertising Exposures: Evidence from Online Field Experiments,” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 13 (3), 203–47.
45.
SethiSuresh P.ThompsonGerald L. (2000), Optimal Control Theory, 2nd ed. New York: Springer.
46.
SethuramanRajTellisGerard J.BrieschRichard A. (2011), “How Well Does Advertising Work? Generalizations from Meta-Analysis of Brand Advertising Elasticities,” Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (3), 457–71.
47.
TullDonald S.WoodVan R.DuhanDaleGillpatrickTomRobertsonKim R.HelgesonJames G. (1986), “‘Leveraged’ Decision Making in Advertising: The Flat Maximum Principle and Its Implications,” Journal of Marketing Research, 23 (1), 25–32.
48.
VakratsasDemetriosNaikPrasad (2007), “Essentials of Planning Media Schedules,” in Handbook of Advertising, AmblerTimTellisGerard, eds. London: SAGE Publications.
49.
VanHeerdeHarald J.HelsenKristiaanDekimpeMarnik G. (2007), “The Impact of a Product-Harm Crisis on Marketing Effectiveness,” Marketing Science, 26 (2), 230–45.
50.
VarianHal R. (2016), “Causal Inference in Economics and Marketing,” Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences, 113 (27), 7310–15.
51.
WangFangZhangXiao-Ping (2008), “Reasons for Market Evolution and Budgeting Implications,” Journal of Marketing, 72 (5), 15–30.
52.
WestDouglasFordJohn B.FarrisPaul W. (2014), “How Corporate Cultures Drive Advertising and Promotion Budgets: Best Practices Combine Heuristics and Algorithmic Tools,” Journal of Advertising Research, 54 (2), 149–62.
53.
WhiteHalbert (1980), “A Heteroskedasticity-Consistent Covariance Matrix Estimator and a Direct Test for Heteroskedasticity,” Econometrica, 48 (4), 817–38.
54.
WittenmarkBjörn (1975), “An Active Suboptimal Dual Controller for Systems with Stochastic Parameters,” Automatic Control Theory and Applications, 3 (1), 13–19.
