This study addressed the validity of distinguishing children with reading disabilities according to the presence or absence of discrepancies between intelligence test scores and academic achievement. Three definitions of reading disability were used to provide criteria for five groups of children who (a) met a discrepancy-based definition uncorrected for the correlation of IQ and achievement; (b) met a discrepancy-based definition correcting for the correlation of IQ and achievement; (c) met a low achievement definition with no IQ discrepancy; (d) met criteria a and b; and (e) met none of the criteria and had no reading disability. Comparison of these five groups on a set of 10 neuropsychological tests corrected for correlations with IQ showed that group differences were small and accounted for little of the variability among groups. These results question the validity of segregating children with reading deficiencies according to discrepancies with IQ scores.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Clements, S.D. (1966). Minimal brain dysfunction in children. NINDB Monograph No. 3. Washington, DC: U.S. Dept. of Health, Education and Welfare.
2.
Cone, T.E., & Wilson, L.R. (1981). Quantifying a severe discrepancy: A critical analysis. Learning Disability Quarterly, 4, 359–371.
3.
Fletcher, J.M., Espy, K.A., Francis, D.J., Davidson, K.C., Rourke, B.P., & Shaywitz, S.E. (1989). Comparisons of cutoff score and regression-based definitions of reading disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 334–338.
4.
Fletcher, J.M., Francis, D., Rourke, B.P., Shaywitz, B., & Shaywitz, S.E. (in press). Classification of learning disabilities: Relationships with other childhood disorders. In G.R. Lyon, D. Gray, J. Kavanagh, & N. Krashegor (Eds.), Better understanding of learning disabilities. New York: Brookes.
5.
Fletcher, J.M., & Morris, R.D. (1986). Classification of disabled learners: Beyond exclusionary definitions. In S. Ceci (Ed.), Handbook of cognitive, social, and neuropsychological aspects of learning disabilities (Vol. 1, pp. 55–80). New York: Erlbaum.
6.
Frankenberger, W., & Fronzaglio, K. (1991). A review of states' criteria for identifying children with learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 24, 495–500.
7.
Jastak, J.L., & Jastak, S.R. (1965). Wide range achievement test. Wilmington, DE: Guidance Associates.
8.
Lyon, G.R. (1989). IQ is irrelevant to the definition of learning disabilities: A position in search of logic and data. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 504–506, 512.
9.
Reynolds, C.R. (1984). Critical measurement issues in learning disabilities. The Journal of Special Education, 18, 451–476.
10.
Rodgers, B. (1983). The identification and prevalence of specific reading retardation. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 53, 369–373.
11.
Rourke, B.P. (1978). Reading, spelling, and arithmetic disabilities: A neuropsychologic perspective. In H.R. Myklebust (Ed.), Progress in learning disabilities (Vol. 4, pp. 97–120). New York: Grune & Stratton.
12.
Rourke, B.P. (1981). Neuropsychological assessment of children with learning disabilities. In S.B. Fikskov & T.J. Boll (Eds.), Handbook of clinical neuropsychology (pp. 453–478). New York: Wiley.
13.
Rourke, B.P., Fisk, J.L., & Strang, J.D. (1986). Neuropsychological assessment of children. New York: Guilford Press.
14.
Rutter, M. (1974). Emotional disorder and educational under-achievement. Archives of Diseases in Childhood, 49, 249–256.
15.
Rutter, M. (1990). Isle of Wight revisited: Twenty-five years of child psychiatric epidemiology. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 29, 633–653.
16.
Rutter, M., & Yule, W. (1975). The concept of specific reading retardation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 16, 181–197.
17.
Satz, P., & Fletcher, J.M. (1980). Minimal brain dysfunctions: An appraisal of research concepts and methods. In H.E. Rie & E.D. Rie (Eds.), Handbook of minimal brain dysfunctions: A critical review (pp. 669–714). New York: Wiley.
18.
Share, D.L., McGhee, R., & Silva, P.D. (1989). I.Q. and reading progress: A test of the capacity notion of I.Q. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 28, 97–100.
19.
Shaywitz, S.E., Escobar, M.D., Shaywitz, B.A., Fletcher, J.M., & Makuch, R. (1992). Distribution and temporal stability of dyslexia in an epidemiological sample of 414 children followed longitudinally. The New England Journal of Medicine, 326, 145–150.
20.
Siegel, L. (1989). IQ is irrelevant to the definition of learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 469–478.
21.
Silva, P.A., McGee, R., & Williams, S. (1985). Some characteristics of nine year old boys with general reading backwardness or specific reading retardation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 20, 407–421.
22.
Stanovich, K.E. (1988). Explaining the differences between the dyslexic and the garden-variety poor reader: The phonological-core variable-difference model. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 590–604.
23.
Strauss, A.A., & Lehtinen, L. (1947). Psychopathology and education of braininjured children. New York: Grune & Stratton.
24.
Texas State Board of Education. (1989). Rules for special education services. Austin, TX: Author.
25.
Torgesen, J.K. (1989). Why IQ is relevant to the definition of learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 484–486.
26.
Wechsler, D. (1949). Wechsler intelligence scale for children. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
27.
Wilson, L., & Cone, T. (1984). The regression equation method of determining academic discrepancy. Journal of School Psychology, 22, 95–110.
