Distraction as a Function of Within-Task Stimulation for Hyperactive and Normal Children

Abstract

Research indicates that increased distal and especially peripheral environmental stimulation does not distract the hyperactive child but may actually have a facilitative effect on performance. Increased within-task stimulation, however, has been found to be disruptive, but these studies have generally confounded increased stimulation with increased task complexity (by increasing the number of competing cues). The present study sought to assess task performance of hyperactive and normal children with and without within-task color, holding task complexity constant. Using a repeated-measures design performance was measured on four tasks: two visual-motor drawing tasks, one visual-concentration task, and a combined visual-motor and visual-concentration task. Error analyses indicated generally poorer performance by hyperactives than by normals, and contrary to prediction, on two of the tasks hyperactives performed better without color than with. Hyperactives tended to perform faster than normals on the visual-motor tasks but performed slower than normals on tasks involving visual concentration. Implications of results and related evidence suggest (1) locus of added stimulation may be important in determining effects on performance, and (2) impulsivity or response speed may be unrelated to performance problems of hyperactive children.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams, J. , Hayden, B.S. , Canter, A. : The relationship between the Canter Background Interference Procedure and the hyperkinetic behavior syndrome. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1974, 7, 54–59.

Alwitt, L.F. : Attention on a visual task among nonreadcrs and readers. Perceptual Motor Skills, 1966, 23, 361–362.

Atkinson, B.R. , Seunath, D.H. : The effect of stimulus change on attending behavior in normal children and children with learning disorders. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1973, 6, 569–573.

Beery, K.E. , Buktenica, N.A. : Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration. Chicago: Follett Publishing Co., 1967.

Browning, R.M. : Hypo-responsiveness as a behavioral correlate of brain-damage in children. Psychological Reports, 1967, 20, 251–259.

Campbell, S.B. , Douglas, V.I. , Morgenstern, G. : Cognitive styles in hyperactive children and the effect of methylphenidate. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 1971, 12, 55–67.

Carter, J.L. , Diaz, A. : Effects of visual and auditory background on reading test performance. Exceptional Children, 1971, 38, 43–50.

Cromwell, R.L. , Foshee, J.G. : Studies in activity level. IV. Effects of visual stimulation during task performance in mental-defectives. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 1960, 65, 248–251.

Cruickshank, W.M. : The learning environment. In W. Cruickshank and D. Hallahan (Eds.), Perceptual and Learning Disabilities in Children. Syracuse, N.Y. Syracuse University Press, 1975, pp. 227–277.

10.

Cruickshank, W.M. , Bentzen, F.A. , Ratzeburg, F.H. , Tannhauser, M.T. : A Teaching Method for Brain-Injured and Hyperactive Children: A Demonstration Pilot Study. Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University press, 1961.

11.

Davids, A. : An objective instrument for assessing hyperkinesis in children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1971, 4, 35–37.

12.

Douglas, V.I. : Sustained attention and impulse control: Implications for the handicapped child. In A. Swets & L. Elliot (Eds.), Psychology of the Handicapped Child. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1974, pp. 149–168.

13.

Douglas, V.I. , Parry, P. , Marton, P. , Garson, C. : Assessment of a cognitive training program. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 1976, 4(4), 389–410.

14.

Frostig, M. : Developmental Test of Visual Perception. Palo Alto, Calif.: Consulting Psychologists Press, 1963.

15.

Hallahan, D.P. , Kauffman, J.M. : Introduction to Learning Disabilities. Princeton, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1976.

16.

Hallahan, D.P. , Kauffman, J.M. , Ball, D.W. : Selective attention and cognitive tempo of low achieving and high achieving sixth grade males. Perceptual Motor Skills, 1973, 36, 579–583.

17.

Jacobs, N.T. : A Comparison of Hyperactive and Normal Boys in Terms of Reaction Time, Motor Time, and Decisionmaking Time, under Conditions of Increasing Task Complexity. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of California at Los Angeles, 1972.

18.

Kasper, J.C. , Millichap, J.G. , Backus, R. , Child, D. , Schulman, J.L. : A study of the relationship between neurological evidence of brain damage in children and activity and distractibility. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1971, 36, 329–337.

19.

Keogh, B.K. : Hyperactivity and learning disorders: Review and speculation. Exceptional Children, 1971, 38, 101–109.

20.

Mondani, M.S. , Tutko, T.A. : Relationship of academic under-achievement to incidental learning. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1969, 33, 558–560.

21.

Sabatino, D.A. , Ysseldyke, J.E. : Effect of extraneous "back-ground" on visual-perceptual performance of readers and non-readers. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1971, 35, 323–328.

22.

Shores, R.E. , Haubrich, F.A. : Effect of cubicles in educating emotionally disturbed children. Exceptional Children, 36, 21–24.

23.

Somervill, J.W. , Warnberg, L.S. , Bost, D.E. : Effects of cubicles versus increased stimulation on task performance by first grade males perceived as distractible and nondistractible. The Journal of Special Education, 1973, 7, 169–185.

24.

Strauss, A.A. , Lehtinen, L.E. : Psychopathology and Education of the Brain-Injured Child. New York: Grune and Stratton, 1947.

25.

Zentall, S.S. : Optimal stimulation as theoretical basis of hyperactivity. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1975, 45, 549–563.

26.

Zentall, S.S. , Environmental stimulation model. Exceptional Children, 1977, 43, 502–510.

27.

Zentall, S.S. , Zentall, T.R. : Activity and task performance of hyperactive children as a function of environmental stimulation. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1976, 44, 693–697.

28.

Zentall, S.S. , Zentall, T.R. , Booth, M.E. : Within-task stimulation: Effects on activity and spelling performance in hyperactive and normal children. Journal of Educational Research, 1978, 71, 223–230.