The Cognitive and Academic Profiles of Reading and Mathematics Learning Disabilities

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine the cognitive and academic profiles associated with learning disability (LD) in reading comprehension, word reading, applied problems, and calculations. The goal was to assess the specificity hypothesis, in which unexpected underachievement associated with LD is represented in terms of distinctive patterns of cognitive and academic strengths and weaknesses. At the start of 3rd grade, the authors assessed 684 students on five cognitive dimensions (nonverbal problem solving, processing speed, concept formation, language, and working memory), and across Grades 3 through 5, the authors assessed performance in each academic area three to four times. Based on final intercept, the authors classified students as LD or not LD in each of the four academic areas. For each of these four LD variables, they conducted multivariate cognitive profile analysis and academic profile analysis. Results, which generally supported the specificity hypothesis, are discussed in terms of the potential connections between reading and mathematics LD.

Keywords

reading disability math disability cognitive profiles academic profiles specificity hypothesis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ackerman

P. T.

Dykman

R. A.

(1993). Phonological processes, confrontation naming, and immediate memory in dyslexia. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 26, 597–609.

Balota

D. A.

Yap

M. J.

Cortese

M. J.

(2006). Visual word recognition: The journey from features to meaning (a travel update). In Traxler

Gernsbacher

M. A.

(Eds.), Handbook of psycholinguistics (2nd ed., pp. 285–375). Amsterdam, Netherlands: Academic Press.

Barrouillet

Fayol

Lathuliére

(1997). Selecting between competitors in multiplication tasks: An explanation of the errors produced by adolescents with learning disabilities. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 21, 253–275.

Beneventi

Tønnessen

F. E.

Ersland

Hugdahl

(2010). Working memory deficit in dyslexia: Behavioral and fMRI evidence. International Journal of Neuroscience, 120, 51–59.

Benjamini

Hochberg

(1995). Controlling the false discovery rate: A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 57, 289–300.

Berninger

V. W.

Abbott

R. D.

Thomson

Wagner

Swanson

H. L.

Wijsman

E. M.

Raskind

(2006). Modeling phonological core deficits within a working memory architecture in children and adults with developmental dyslexia. Scientific Studies of Reading, 10, 165–198.

Berninger

V. W.

Raskind

Richards

Abbott

Stock

(2008). A multidisciplinary approach to understanding developmental dyslexia within working-memory architecture: Genotypes, phenotypes, brain, and instruction. Developmental Neuropsychology, 33, 707–744.

Bernstein

I. H.

Garbin

C. P.

Teng

G. K.

(1988). Applied multivariate analyses. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.

Blachman

B. A.

(1984). Relationship of rapid naming ability and language analysis skills to kindergarten and first-grade reading achievement. Journal of Educational Psychology, 76, 610–622.

10.

Bowers

P. G.

(1995). Tracing symbol naming speed’s unique contributions to reading disability over time. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 7, 189–216.

11.

Bowers

P. G.

Swanson

L. B.

(1991). Naming speed deficits in reading disability. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 51, 195–219.

12.

Brady

S. A.

Shankweiler

D. P.

(Eds.). (1991). Phonological processes in literacy: A tribute to Isabelle Y. Liberman. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

13.

Bruck

(1992). Persistence of dyslexics’ phonological awareness deficits. Developmental Psychology, 28, 874–886.

14.

Bull

Johnston

R. S.

(1997). Children’s arithmetical difficulties: Contributions from processing speed, item identification, and short-term memory. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 65, 1–24.

15.

Bus

A. G.

Ijzendoorn

M. H.

(1999). Phonological awareness and early reading: A meta-analysis of experimental training studies. Journal of Educational Psychology, 91, 403–414.

16.

Butterworth

(l999). The mathematical brain. London, UK: Macmillan.

17.

Catts

H. W.

Fey

M. E.

Zhang

Tomblin

J. B.

(2001). Estimating the risk of future reading disabilities in kindergarten children: A research-based model and its clinical implementations. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 32, 38–50.

18.

Cohen

(1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

19.

Compton

D. L.

(2000). Modeling the growth of decoding skills in first-grade children. Scientific Studies of Reading, 4, 219–258.

20.

Conners

F. A.

Atwell

J. A.

Rosenquist

C. J.

Sligh

A. C.

(2001). Abilities underlying decoding difference in children with intellectual disability. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 45, 292–299.

21.

Daneman

Carpenter

P. A.

(l980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 19, 450–466.

22.

Dickinson

D. K.

McCabe

Anastasopoulos

Peisner-Feinberg

E. S.

Poe

M. D.

(2003). The comprehensive language approach to early literacy: The interrelationship among vocabulary, phonological sensitivity, and print knowledge among preschool-age children. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95, 465–481.

23.

Dirks

Spyer

van Lieshout

C. D. M.

de Sonneville

(2008). Prevalence of combined reading and arithmetic disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 41, 460–473.

24.

Efron

(1982). The jackknife, the bootstrap, and other resampling plans. Philadelphia: SIAM.

25.

Engle

R. W.

Tuholski

S. W.

Laughlin

J. E.

Conway

A. R. A.

(1999). Working memory, short-term memory, and general fluid intelligence: A latent-variable approach. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 128, 309–331.

26.

Feigenson

Dehaene

Spelke

(2004). Core systems of number. TRENDS in Cognitive Science, 8, 307–314.

27.

Fletcher

J. M.

Lyon

G. R.

Fuchs

L. S.

Barnes

M. A.

(2007). Learning disabilities: From identification to intervention. New York, NY: Guilford.

28.

Fletcher

J. M.

Shaywitz

S. E.

Shankweiler

D. P.

Katz

Liberman

I. Y.

Stuebing

K. K.

. . . Shaywitz

B. A.

(1994). Cognitive profiles of reading disability: Comparisons of discrepancy and low achievement definitions. Journal of Educational Psychology, 85, 1–18.

29.

Fuchs

L. S.

Compton

D. L.

Fuchs

Paulsen

Bryant

J. D.

Hamlett

C. L.

(2005). The prevention, identification, and cognitive determinants of math difficulty. Journal of Educational Psychology, 97, 493–513.

30.

Fuchs

L. S.

Fuchs

Compton

D. L.

Powell

S. R.

Seethaler

P. M.

Capizzi

A. M.

. . . Fletcher

J. M.

(2006). The cognitive correlates of third-grade skill in arithmetic, algorithmic computation, and arithmetic word problems. Journal of Educational Psychology, 98, 29–43.

31.

Fuchs

L. S.

Fuchs

Stuebing

Fletcher

J. M.

Hamlett

C. L.

Lambert

(2008). Problem solving and computational skill: Are they shared or distinct aspects of mathematical cognition? Journal of Educational Psychology, 100(1), 30-47.

32.

Fuchs

L. S.

Hamlett

C. L.

Fuchs

(1990). Test of Computational Fluency. Available from L. S. Fuchs, 328 Peabody, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN 37203.

33.

Fuchs

L. S.

Powell

S. R.

Seethaler

P. M.

Cirino

P. T.

Fletcher

J. M.

Fuchs

. . . Zumeta

R. O.

(2009). Remediating number combination and word problem deficits among students with mathematics difficulties: A randomized control trial. Journal of Educational Psychology, 101, 561–576.

34.

Fuchs

L.S.

Geary

D.C.

Compton

D.L.

Fuchs

Hamlett

C.L.

Seethaler

P.M.

Bryant

J.V.

Schatschneider

(2010). Do different types of school mathematics development depend on different constellations of numerical and general cognitive abilities? Developmental Psychology, 46, 1731–1746.

35.

Geary

D. C.

Hoard

M. K.

Byrd-Craven

Nugent

Numtee

(2007). Cognitive mechanisms underlying achievement deficits in children with mathematical learning disability. Child Development, 78, 1343–1459.

36.

Glass

G. V.

(Ed.). (2006). Meta-analysis: The quantitative synthesis of research findings. In Green

J. L.

Camilli

Gregory

P. B.

(Eds.), Handbook of complementary methods in education research (pp. 427–438). Washington, DC: American Educational Research Association.

37.

Halberda

Mazzocco

Feigenson

(2008, October 2). Individual differences in non-verbal number acuity correlate with maths achievement. Nature, 455, 665–668.

38.

Hart

S. A.

Petrill

S. A.

Thompson

L. S.

(2010). A factorial analysis of timed and untimed measures of mathematics and reading abilities in school aged twins. Learning and Individual Differences, 20, 61–134.

39.

Hecht

(in press). Sources of group and individual differences in emerging fraction skills. Journal of Educational Psychology.

40.

Hecht

S. A.

Torgesen

J. K.

Wagner

R. K.

Rashotte

C. A.

(2001). The relations between phonological processing abilities and emerging individual differences in mathematical computational skills: A longitudinal study from second to fifth grades. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 79, 192–227.

41.

Hitch

G. J.

McAuley

(1991). Working memory in children with specific arithmetical learning disabilities. British Journal of Psychology, 82, 375–386.

42.

Hochberg

(1988). A sharper Bonferroni procedure for multiple tests of significance. Biometrika, 75, 800-802.

43.

Ijzendoorn

M. H.

Bus

A. G.

(1994). Meta-analytic confirmation of the nonword reading deficit in developmental dyslexia. Reading Research Quarterly, 29, 266–275.

44.

Jordan

N. C.

Levine

S. C.

Huttenlocher

(1995). Calculation abilities in young children with different patterns of cognitive functioning. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 28, 53–64.

45.

Juel

Griffith

P. L.

Gough

P. B.

(1986). Acquisition of literacy: A longitudinal study of children in first and second grade. Journal of Educational Psychology, 78, 243–255.

46.

Kavale

K. A.

Reese

J. H.

(1992). The character of learning disabilities: An iowa profile. Learning Disability Quarterly, 15(2), 74-94.

47.

Kintsch

Greeno

J. G.

(1985). Understanding and solving word arithmetic problems. Psychological Review, 92, 109–129.

48.

Kirk

S. A.

(1963). Behavioral diagnosis and remediation of learning disabilities. Conference on Exploring Problems of the Perceptually Handicapped Child, 1, 1–23.

49.

Leach

J. M.

Scarborough

H. S.

Rescorla

(2003). Late-emerging reading disabilities. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95, 211–224.

50.

LeBlanc

M. D.

Weber-Russell

(1996). Text integration and mathematics connections: A computer model of arithmetic work problem-solving. Cognitive Science, 20, 357–407.

51.

Liberman

I. Y.

Shankweiler

D. P.

Liberman

A. M.

(1989). The alphabetic principle and learning to read. In Shankweiler

D. P.

Liberman

I. Y.

(Eds.), Phonology and reading disability: Solving the reading puzzle (IARLD Monograph Series; pp. 1–33). Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

52.

Logie

R. H.

Baddeley

A. D.

(1987). Cognitive processes in counting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 13, 310–326.

53.

Manis

F. R.

Doi

L. M.

Bhadha

(2000). Naming speed, phonological awareness, and orthographic knowledge in second graders. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 33, 325–333.

54.

Manis

F. R.

Seidenberg

M. S.

Doi

L. M.

(1999). See Dick RAN: Rapid naming and the longitudinal prediction of reading subskills in first and second graders. Scientific Studies of Reading, 3, 129–157.

55.

Mayer

R. E.

(1992). Knowledge and thought: Mental models that support scientific reasoning. In Duschl

R. A.

Hamilton

R. J.

(Eds.), Philosophy of science, cognitive psychology, and educational theory and practice. (pp. 226-243). Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.

56.

McBride-Chang

Manis

F. R.

(1996). Structural invariance in the associations of naming speed, phonological awareness, and verbal reasoning in good and poor readers: A test of the double deficit hypothesis. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 8, 323–339.

57.

McCardle

Scarborough

H. S.

Catts

H. W.

(2001). Predicting, explaining, and preventing children’s reading difficulties. Learning Disability Research and Practice, 16, 230–239.

58.

Metsala

J. L.

Stanovich

K. E.

Brown

G. D. A.

(1998). Regularity effects and the phonological deficit model of reading disabilities: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Educational Psychology, 90, 279–293.

59.

Meyer

M. S.

Wood

F. B.

Hart

L. A.

Felton

R. H.

(1998). Longitudinal course of rapid naming in disabled and nondisabled readers. Annals of Dyslexia, 48, 91–114.

60.

Morris

R. D.

Stuebing

K. K.

Fletcher

J. M.

Shaywitz

S. E.

Lyon

G. R.

Shankweiler

D. P.

. . . Shaywitz

B. A.

(1998). Subtypes of reading disability: Variability around a phonological core. Journal of Educational Psychology, 90, 347–373.

61.

Muter

Hulme

Snowling

M. J.

Stevenson

(2004). Phonemes, rimes, vocabulary, and grammatical skills as foundations of early reading development: Evidence from a longitudinal study. Developmental Psychology, 40, 665–681.

62.

Nation

Marshall

C. M.

Snowling

M. J.

(2001). Phonological and sematic contributions to children’s picture naming skill: Evidence from children with developmental reading disorders. Language and Cognitive Processes, 16, 241–259.

63.

Nation

Snowling

M. J.

(1998). Individual differences in contextual facilitation: Evidence from dyslexia and poor reading comprehension. Child Development, 69, 996–1011.

64.

Nation

Snowling

M. J.

(1999). Developmental differences in sensitivity to semantic relations among good and poor comprehenders: Evidence from semantic priming. Cognition, 70, 1–13.

65.

Newcomer

P. L.

Hammill

D. D.

(1988). Test of Language Development (Rev. ed.). Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.

66.

Oakhill

J. V.

Cain

Bryant

P. E.

(2003). The dissociation of word reading and text comprehension: Evidence from component skills. Language and Cognitive Processes, 18, 443–468.

67.

Passolunghi

M. C.

Siegel

L. S.

(2004). Working memory and access to numerical information in children with disability in mathematics. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 88, 348–367.

68.

Pickering

Gathercole

(2001). Working Memory Test Battery for Children. London, UK: Psychological Corporation.

69.

Rack

J. P.

Snowling

M. J.

Olson

R. K.

(1992). The nonword reading deficit in developmental dyslexia: A review. Reading Research Quarterly, 27, 29–53.

70.

Scarborough

H. S.

(1998). Predicting the future achievement of second graders with reading disabilities: Contributions of phonemic awareness, verbal memory, rapid naming, and IQ. Annals of Dyslexia, 48, 115–136.

71.

Scarborough

H. S.

(2005). Developmental relationships between language and reading: Reconciling a beautiful hypothesis with some ugly facts. In Catts

H. W.

Kamhi

A. G.

(Eds.), The connections between language and reading disabilities (pp. 3–24). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

72.

Schatschneider

Francis

D. J.

Fletcher

J. M.

Foorman

B. R.

(2002). The relationship between rapid naming and phonological awareness in the prediction of early reading skills. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 35, 245–256.

73.

Sénéchal

Ouellette

Rodney

(2006). The misunderstood giant: The predictive role of early vocabulary to future reading. In Dickinson

D. K.

Neuman

S. B.

(Eds.), Handbook of early literacy (Vol. 2, pp. 173–185). New York, NY: Guilford.

74.

Shankweiler

D. P.

Crain

(1986). Language mechanisms and reading disorder: A modular approach. Cognition, 24, 139–168.

75.

Shankweiler

Lundquist

Katz

Stuebing

K. K.

Fletcher

J. M.

Brady

. . . Shaywitz

B. A.

(1999). Comprehension and decoding: Patterns of association in children with reading difficulties. Scientific Studies of Reading, 3, 69–94.

76.

D. L.

(1995). Phonological recoding and self-teaching: Sine qua non of reading acquisition. Cognition, 55, 151–218.

77.

Siegel

L. S.

(1989). IQ is irrelevant to the definition of learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 469–479.

78.

Siegel

L. S.

Linder

(1984). Short-term memory process in children with reading and arithmetic disabilities. Developmental Psychology, 20, 200–207.

79.

Singer

J.B.

Willett

J.B.

(2003). Applied longitudinal data analysis: Modeling change and event occurrence. New York: Oxford University Press.

80.

Smith-Spark

J. H.

Fisk

J. E.

(2007). Working memory functioning in developmental dyslexia. Memory, 15, 34–56.

81.

Snowling

M. J.

(2001). Dyslexia (2nd ed.). Malden, MA: Blackwell.

82.

Stanovich

K. E.

Siegel

L. S.

(1994). Phenotypic performance profile of children with reading disabilities: A regression-based test of phonological-core variable-difference model. Journal of Educational Psychology, 86, 24–53.

83.

Swanson

H. L.

Beebe-Frankenberger

(2004). The relationship between working memory and mathematical problem-solving in children at risk and not at risk for serious math difficulties. Journal of Educational Psychology, 96, 471–491.

84.

Swanson

H. L.

Sachse-Lee

(2001). Mathematical problem-solving and working memory in children with learning disabilities: Both executive and phonological processes are important. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 79, 294–321.

85.

Tabachnick

B. G.

Fidell

L. S.

(2007). Using multivariate statistics (5th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

86.

Torgesen

J. K.

(2000). Individual differences in response to early interventions in reading: The lingering problem of treatment resisters. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 15, 55–64.

87.

U.S. Office of Education. (1968). First annual report of the National Advisory Committee on Handicapped Children. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare.

88.

U.S. Office of Education. (1977). Assistance to states for education for handicapped children: Procedures for evaluation specific learning disabilities. Federal Register, 42, G1082–G1085.

89.

Vellutino

F. R.

Scanlon

D. M.

Sipay

E. R.

Small

S. G.

Pratt

Chen

Denckla

M. B.

(1996). Cognitive profiles of difficult-to-remediate and readily remediated poor readers: Early intervention as a vehicle for distinguishing between cognitive and experiential deficits as basic causes of specific reading disability. Journal of Educational Psychology, 88, 601–638.

90.

Wagner

R. K.

Torgesen

J. K.

Rashotte

C. A.

(1994). The development of reading-related phonological processing abilities: New evidence of bi-directional causality from a latent variable longitudinal study. Developmental Psychology, 30, 73–87.

91.

Wechsler

(1999). Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation.

92.

Westfall

P. H.

Tobias

R. D.

Rom

Wolfinger

R. D.

Hochberg

(1999). Multiple comparisons and multiple tests using SAS system. Cary, NC: SAS Institute.

93.

Wiederholt

J. L.

(1974). Historical perspectives on the education of the learning disabled. In Mann

Sabatino

D. A.

(Eds.), The second review of special education (pp. 103–152). Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.

94.

Wilkinson

G. S.

(1993). The Wide Range Achievement Test-3. Wilmington, DE: Jastak Associates.

95.

Wilson

K. M.

Swanson

H. L.

(2001). Are mathematics disabilities due to a domain-general or a domain-specific working memory deficit? Journal of Learning Disabilities, 34, 237–248.

96.

Wolf

Bally

Morris

(1986). Automaticity, retrieval processes, and reading: A longitudinal study of average and impaired readers. Child Development, 57, 988–1000.

97.

Woodcock

R. W.

(1997). Woodcock Diagnostic Reading Battery. Itasca, IL: Riverside.

98.

Woodcock

R. W.

(1998). Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests–Revised. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.

99.

Woodcock

R. W.

McGrew

K. S.

Mather

(2001). Woodcock–Johnson III Tests of Cognitive Abilities. Itasca, IL: Riverside.

100.

Yap

M. J.

Balota

D. A.

(2009). Visual word recognition of multisyllabic words. Journal of Memory and Language, 60(4), 502-529.

101.

Zhu

(1999). WASI manual. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation.