This article examines the collective, member-based employers’ associations in the UK that regulate the employment relationship by participating in collective bargaining. The main empirical contribution is to provide, for the first time, a longitudinal dataset of employers’ associations in the UK. We use archival data from the UK Government’s Certification Office to build a new dataset, identifying a decline of 81% in the number of employers’ associations between 1976 and 2013–2014. We also find that political agency and reducing levels of collective bargaining undermined employers’ associations by reducing employers’ incentives to associate, although changes within the UK’s system of employment relations enabled other types of collective employer organisation to survive.
BaccaroLHowellC (2011) A common neoliberal trajectory: The transformation of industrial relations in advanced capitalism. Politics and Society39(4): 521–563.
2.
BehrensMTraxlerF (2004) Employers’ Organisations in Europe, Brussels: EIRO.
3.
BowkettCHauptmeierMHeeryE (2017) Exploring the role of employer forums – The case of Business in the Community Wales. Employee Relations39(7): 986–1000.
4.
BrownWBrysonAForthJ (2009) Competition and the retreat from collective bargaining. In: BrownWBrysonAForthJet al.(eds) The Evolution of the Modern Workplace, Cambridge: CUP, Cambridge University Press, pp 22–47.
5.
Certification Office (CO) (various years) Annual Report of the Certification Officer. London: Certification Office.
6.
Charlwood A (2013) The anatomy of union membership decline in Great Britain, 1980–1998, Unpublished PhD Thesis, London School of Economics.
7.
CleggH (1979) The Changing Systems of Industrial Relations in Great Britain, Basil Blackwell: Oxford.
8.
Demougin P, Gooberman L, Hauptmeier M, et al. (2017) A New Form of Voluntarism – Private Regulation through Employer Forums. Unpublished Manuscript. Cardiff.
9.
DickensLHallM (2006) Fairness – up to a point: Assessing the impact of New Labour’s employment legislation. Human Resource Management Journal16(4): 338–356.
10.
DickensLDealA (2006) Changing times, changing needs: Institutional development through three decades. In: DickensLNealA (eds) The Changing Institutional Face of British Employment Relations, Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law, pp. 1–13.
11.
EmmeneggerP (2014) The Power to Dismiss: Trade Unions and the Regulation of Job Security in Western Europe, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
FreemanRPelletierJ (1990) The impact of industrial relations legislation on British union density. British Journal of Industrial Relations28: 141–164.
13.
GoobermanLHauptmeierMHeeryE (2017a) Countervailing power and the evolution of employers’ organisations in the United Kingdom. Unpublished Manuscript. Cardiff.
14.
GoobermanLHauptmeierMHeeryE (2017b) Employer interest representation in the United Kingdom. Work, Employment and Society. published online first https://doi.org/10.1177/0950017017701074.
15.
GoobermanLHauptmeierMHeeryE (2017c) A typology of contemporary employers’ organisations in the UK. Economic and Industrial Democracy. published online first https://doi.org/10.1177/0143831X17704499.
16.
GoobermanLHauptmeierMHeeryE (2017d) The unexpected survival of employer collective action in the UK. Unpublished Manuscript. Cardiff.
17.
GospelHEdwardsT (2012) Strategic transformation and muddling through: Industrial relations and industrial training in the UK. Journal of European Public Policy19(8): 1229–1248.
18.
HauptmeierM (2011) Reassessing markets and employment relations. In: BlytonPHeeryETurnbullP (eds) Reassessing the Employment Relationship, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 171–194.
19.
Hauptmeier M and Vidal M (eds) (2014) Comparative political economy of work. Critical Perspectives on Work and Organisations. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
20.
HeeryEGoobermanLHauptmeierM (2017) The Petroleum Driver Passport scheme: A case study in reregulation. Industrial Relations Journal48(3): 274–291.
21.
Howell C (2005) Trade Unions and the State. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
22.
Ingham P and Lindop E (2011) Building employer solidarity? britain's experience of co-ordinated bargaining, 1979 to 1997. Industrial Relations Journal 42: 547–564.
23.
JoyceS (2013) The Engineering Employers’ Federation and the crisis of 1989: A case study in the decline of multi-employer bargaining. Historical Studies in Industrial Relations34: 141–171.
24.
KellyJHeeryE (1989) Full-time officers and trade union recruitment. British Journal of Industrial Relations27: 196–213.
25.
McKinlayA (2011) The paradoxes of British employer organization, c. 1897–2000. Historical Studies in Industrial Relations31/32: 89–113.
26.
MarginsonP (2015) The changing nature of collective employment relations. Employee Relations37: 645–657.
Pencavel J (2003) The surprising retreat of Union Britain. National Bureau for Economic Research Working Paper 9564. Cambridge, MA: NBER.
29.
PurcellJ (1995) Ideology and the end of institutional industrial relations: Evidence from the UK. In: CrouchCTraxlerF (eds) Organized Industrial Relations in Europe: What Future?, Aldershot: Avebury, pp. 101–119.
30.
Royal Commission on Trade Unions and Employers’ Associations (1969) Employers’ associations, Research Paper 7. London: HMSO.
31.
SheldonPThornthwaiteL (2004) Business or association? The strategic response of employer associations to the decentralisation of bargaining in Australia. Economic and Labour Relations Review15: 128–158.
32.
SheldonPNacamulliRPaolettiFet al.(2016) Employer association responses to the effects of bargaining decentralization in Australia and Italy: Seeking explanations from organisational theory. British Journal of Industrial Relations54(1): 160–191.
33.
SilviaSJSchroederW (2007) Why are German employers’ associations declining? Arguments and evidence. Comparative Political Studies40: 1433–1459.
34.
TraxlerF (2000) Employers and employer organisations in Europe: Membership strength, density and representativeness. Industrial Relations Journal31: 308–316.
35.
UndyR (1999) New labour’s industrial relations settlement: The third way?British Journal of Industrial Relations37(2): 315–336.
36.
WhiteGHatchettA (2003) The pay review bodies in Britain under the labour government. Public Money & Management23(4): 237–244.
