Racial inequalities in breastfeeding have been a U.S. national concern, prompting health science research and public discourse. Social science research reveals structural causes, including racism in labor conditions, maternity care practices, and lactation support. Yet research shows that popular and health science discourses disproportionately focus on individual and community factors, blaming Black women and communities for unequal breastfeeding rates. This study examines how scientific reports are communicated to the public through a critical analysis of 104 U.S. news articles reporting research on racial disparities in breastfeeding. Findings show that articles acknowledge unequal treatment within maternity care but justify it by presenting Black patients as overburdening the maternity care systems they use due to low socioeconomic status, welfare dependency, poor family support, and poor health. Through these representations, articles co-construct racialized motherhood and maternity care systems in ways that hide manifestations of obstetric racism and combat social support for systemic change.
AniAmanishakete. 2015. “C-section and Racism: ‘Cutting’ to the Heart of the Issue for Black Women and Families.” Journal of African American Studies19(4):343–61.
2.
BarnhillAnneMorainStephanie R.2015. “Latch on or Back off? Public Health, Choice, and the Ethics of Breast-Feeding Promotion Campaigns.” International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics8(2):139–71.
3.
BridgesKhiara M.2011. Reproducing Race: An Ethnography of Pregnancy as a Site of Racialization. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Bylaska-DaviesPaula. 2015. “Exploring the Effect of Mass Media on Perceptions of Infant Feeding.” Health Care for Women International36(9):1056–70.
6.
CampbellColleen. 2021. “Medical Violence, Obstetric Racism, and the Limits of Informed Consent for Black Women.” Michigan Journal of Race & Law26(SPC):47–75.
7.
CarterShannon K.2017. “Body-Led Mothering: Constructions of the Breast in Attachment Parenting Literature.” Women’s Studies International Forum62:17–24.
8.
CarterShannon K.StoneAshleyGrahamLainCoxJonathan M.2022. “Creating Intersectional Subjects: A Critical Discourse Analysis of Health Science Breastfeeding Research.” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity8(1):129–44.
9.
ChiangKatelyn V.LiRuoweiAnsteyErica H.PerrineCria G.2021. “Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Breastfeeding Initiation—United States, 2019.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report70(21):769–74.
10.
ClarkeAdele E.2005. Situational Analysis: Grounded Theory after the Postmodern Turn. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
11.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 2000. Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. New York, NY: Routledge.
12.
ConchingAndie Kealohi SatoThayerZaneta. 2019. “Biological Pathways for Historical Trauma to Affect Health: A Conceptual Model Focusing on Epigenetic Modifications.” Social Science & Medicine230:74–82.
13.
DavisCatashaVan Kirk VillalobosAubreyTurnerMonique MitchellLongSahiraLapinskiMaria Knight. 2021. “Racism and Resistance: A Qualitative Study of Bias as a Barrier to Breastfeeding.” Breastfeeding Medicine16(6):471–80.
14.
DavisDána-Ain. 2019a. “Obstetric Racism: The Racial Politics of Pregnancy, Labor, and Birthing.” Medical Anthropology38(7):560–73.
15.
DavisDána-Ain. 2019b. Reproductive Injustice: Racism, Pregnancy, and Premature Birth. New York, NY: New York University Press.
16.
DavisDána-Ain. 2020. “Reproducing While Black: The Crisis of Black Maternal Health, Obstetric Racism, and Assisted Reproductive Technology.” Reproductive Biomedicine & Society Online11:56–64.
17.
DeMarchisAlessamdraRitterGaelenOttenJenniferJohnsonDonna. 2017. “Analysis of Media Coverage on Breastfeeding Policy in Washington State.” Journal of Human Lactation34(1):156–63.
18.
Devane-JohnsonStephanieWilliamsRonaldGiscombeCheryl Woods. 2022. “Historical Research: The History of African American Breastfeeding in the United States.” Journal of Human Lactation38(4):723–31.
19.
DodgsonJoan E.2012. “Racism, Race, and Disparities in Breastfeeding.” Pp. 74–83 in Beyond Health, beyond Choice: Breastfeeding Constraints and Realities, edited by Hall SmithP.HausmanB. L.LabbokM.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
20.
FaircloughNorman. 1992. Discourse and Social Change. Vol. 10. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
21.
FossKatherine A.2017. Breastfeeding and Media: Exploring Conflicting Discourses That Threaten Public Health. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
22.
FossKatherine A.BlakeKen. 2019. “‘It’s Natural and Healthy, but I Don’t Want to See It’: Using Entertainment-Education to Improve Attitudes toward Breastfeeding in Public.” Health Communication34(9):919–30.
23.
FossKatherine A.SouthwellBrian G.2006. “Infant Feeding and the Media: The Relationship between Parents’ Magazine Content and Breastfeeding, 1972–2000.” International Breastfeeding Journal1(10):1–9.
24.
GeeRebekah E.ZerbibLauren D.LuckettBrian G.2012. “Breastfeeding Support for African American Women in Louisiana Hospitals.” Breastfeeding Medicine7(6):431–35.
25.
GreenVictoria L.KillingsNekisha L.ClareCamille A.2021. “The Historical, Psychosocial, Cultural Context of Breastfeeding in the African American Community.” Breastfeeding Medicine16(2):116–20.
26.
GriswoldMichele K.CrawfordSybil L.PerryDonna J.PersonSharina D.RosenbergLynnCozierYvette C.PalmerJulie R.2018. “Experiences of Racism and Breastfeeding Initiation and Duration among First-Time Mothers of the Black Women’s Health Study.” Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities5(6):1180–91.
27.
GrossTyra T.PowellRachelAndersonAlex K.HallJoriDavisMarshaHilyardKaren. 2015. “WIC Peer Counselors’ Perceptions of Breastfeeding in African American Women with Lower Incomes.” Journal of Human Lactation31(1):99–110.
HarrisonLaura. 2019. “Milk Money: Race, Gender, and Breast Milk ‘Donation.’” Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society44(2):281–306.
30.
HausmanBernice L.2014. Mother’s Milk: Breastfeeding Controversies in American Culture. New York, NY: Routledge.
31.
HemingwayShaunaForson-DareZanetaEbelingMylaTaylorSarah N.2021. “Racial Disparities in Sustaining Breastfeeding in a Baby Friendly Designated Southeastern United States Hospital: An Opportunity to Investigate Systemic Racism.” Breastfeeding Medicine16(2):150–55.
32.
HittRoseZhuangJieAndersonJennifer. 2018. “Media Presentation of Breastfeeding Beliefs in Newspapers.” Health Communication33(10):1293–301.
33.
HolcombJeanne. 2017. “Resisting Guilt: Mothers’ Breastfeeding Intentions and Formula Use.” Sociological Focus50(4):361–74.
34.
JanssonMaria. 2009. “Feeding Children and Protecting Women: The Emergence of Breastfeeding as an International Concern.” Women’s Studies International Forum32(3):240–48.
35.
JillaniZaraScottVictoria C.ThorpeAnna M.TaylorYhenneko J.2020. “Depiction of Breastfeeding in Newspapers in the United States: 2007–2016.” Breastfeeding Medicine15(11):739–46.
36.
JohnsonAngela M.KirkRosalindRooksAlfreda JordanMuzikMaria. 2016. “Enhancing Breastfeeding through Healthcare Support: Results from a Focus Group Study of African American Mothers.” Maternal and Child Health Journal20(S1):92–102.
37.
JohnsonAngela MarieMenkeRenaHandelzaltsJonathan EliahuGreenKiddadaMuzikMaria. 2021. “Reimagining Racial Trauma as a Barrier to Breastfeeding versus Childhood Trauma and Depression among African American Mothers.” Breastfeeding Medicine16(6):493–500.
38.
Jordan-ZacheryJulia S.2009. Black Women, Cultural Images, and Social Policy. New York, NY: Routledge.
39.
KettPaula M.2020. “The Individual Focus of Nursing Research in Breastfeeding: Perpetuating a Neoliberal Perspective.” Public Health Nursing37(2):281–86.
40.
KirkseyKristen. 2021. “A Social History of Racial Disparities in Breastfeeding in the United States.” Social Science & Medicine289:114365. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114365.
41.
KnaakStephanie J.2010. “Contextualizing Risk, Constructing Choice: Breastfeeding and Good Mothering in Risk Society.” Health, Risk, & Society12(4):345–55.
42.
KuklaRebecca. 2006. “Ethics and Ideology in Breastfeeding Advocacy Campaigns.” Hypatia21(1):157–80.
43.
LiLeixiWanWenlinZhuChan. 2021. “Breastfeeding after a Cesarean Section: A Literature Review.” Midwifery103:103117. doi:10.1016/j.midw.2021.103117.
44.
Louis-JacquesAdetola F.MarhefkaStephanie L.BrumleyJessicaSchaferEllen J.TaylorTomaro I.BrownAlyssa J.LivingstonTaylor A.SpatzDiane L.MillerElizabeth M.2020. “Historical Antecedents of Breastfeeding for African American Women: From the Pre-colonial Period to the Mid-twentieth Century.” Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities7(5):1003–12.
45.
LuceAnnCashMarilynHundleyVanoraCheyneHelenVan TeijlingenEdwinAngellCatherine. 2016. “‘Is it Realistic?’ The Portrayal of Pregnancy and Childbirth in the Media.” BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth16:40. doi:10.1186/s12884-016-0827-x.
46.
LudlowValerie. 2012. “How Formula Feeding Mothers Balance Risks and Define Themselves as ‘Good Mothers.’” Health, Risk, & Society14(3):291–306.
47.
LundquistJenniferXuZhunBarfieldWandaEloIrma. 2015. “Do Black–White Racial Disparities in Breastfeeding Persist in the Military Community?” Maternal and Child Health Journal19(2):419–27.
48.
MannEmily S.GrzankaPatrick R.2018. “Agency-without-Choice: The Visual Rhetorics of Long-Acting Reversible Contraception Promotion.” Symbolic Interaction41(3):334–56.
49.
McCarter-SpauldingDeborahLucasJenniferGoreRebecca. 2011. “Employment and Breastfeeding Outcomes in a Sample of Black Women in the United States.” Journal of National Black Nurses’ Association22(2):38–45.
50.
McKinneyChelsea O.Hahn-HolbrookJenniferChase-LansdaleP. LindsayRameySharon L.KrohnJulieReed-VanceMaxineRajuTonse N. K.ShalowitzMadeleine U.; on Behalf of the Community Child Health Research Network. 2016. “Racial and Ethnic Differences in Breastfeeding.” Pediatrics138(2):e20152388. doi:10.1542/peds.2015-2388.
51.
MeekJoan YoungerNobleLawrence. 2022. “Policy Statement: Breastfeeding and the Use of Human Milk.” Pediatrics150(1):e2022057988. doi:10.1542/peds.2022-057988.
52.
MehraReneeBoydLisa M.MagriplesUraniaKershawTrace S.IckovicsJeannette R.KeeneDanya E.2020. “Black Pregnant Women ‘Get the Most Judgment’: A Qualitative Study of the Experiences of Black Women at the Intersection of Race, Gender, and Pregnancy.” Women’s Health Issues30(6):484–92.
53.
MerewoodAnneBuggKimarieBurnhamLauraKraneKirstenNickelNathanBroomSarahEdwardsRogerFeldman-WinterLori. 2019. “Addressing Racial Inequities in Breastfeeding in the Southern United States.” Pediatrics143(2):e20181897. doi:10.1542/peds.2018-1897.
54.
MorrisTheresaMcInerneyKatherine. 2010. “Media Representations of Pregnancy and Childbirth: An Analysis of Reality Television Programs in the United States.” Birth37(2):134–40.
55.
MorrisseyMegan ElizabethKimballKaren Y.2017. “#SpoiledMilk: Blacktavists, Visibility, and the Exploitation of the Black Breast.” Women’s Studies in Communication40(1):48–66.
56.
MorrowArdythe L.McClainJanelleConreyShannon C.NiuLiangKinzerAlexandraClineAllison R.PiaseckiAlexandra M., et al. 2021. “Breastfeeding Disparities and Their Mediators in an Urban Birth Cohort of Black and White Mothers.” Breastfeeding Medicine16(6):452–62.
57.
NashJennifer C.2021a. Birthing Black Mothers. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
58.
NashJennifer C.2021b. “Black Lactation Aesthetics: Remaking the Natural in Lakisha Cohill’s Photographs.” Feminist Studies47(1):94–111.
59.
OwensDeirdre CooperFettSharla M.2019. “Black Maternal and Infant Health: Historical Legacies of Slavery.” American Journal of Public Health109(1):1342–45.
60.
PetrovskaKarolinaSheehanAthenaHomerCaroline S. E.2017. “Media Representations of Breech Birth: A Prospective Analysis of Web-Based News Reports.” Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health62(4):434–41.
61.
RobertsDorothy E.1997. Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty. New York, NY: Vintage.
RobinsonKarenFialAlissaHansonLisa. 2019. “Racism, Bias, and Discrimination as Modifiable Barriers to Breastfeeding for African American Women: A Scoping Review of the Literature.” Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health64(6):734–42.
64.
SipsmaHeather L.RabinowitzMolly R.YoungDaniellePhillipiCarrieLarsonIlse A.KairLaura R.2019. “Exposure to Hospital Breastfeeding Support by Maternal Race and Ethnicity: A Pilot Study.” Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health64(6):743–48.
65.
StringsSabrina. 2015. “Obese Black Women as ‘Social Dead Weight’: Reinventing the ‘Diseased Black Woman.’” Signs41(1):107–30.
66.
StringsSabrina. 2019. Fearing the Black Body: The Racial Origins of Fat Phobia. New York, NY: New York University Press.
67.
TakeshitaChikako. 2017. “Countering Technocracy: ‘Natural’ Birth in The Business of Being Born and Call the Midwife.” Feminist Media Studies17(3):332–46.
68.
TaylorJamila K.2020. “Structural Racism and Maternal Health among Black Women.” Journal of Law, Medicine, & Ethics48(3):506–17.
69.
ThomasErin V.2018. “‘Why Even Bother; They Are Not Going to Do It?’ The Structural Roots of Racism and Discrimination in Lactation Care.” Qualitative Health Research28(7):1050–64.
70.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. 2010. “Healthy People 2020.” https://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. 2020. “Healthy People 2030.” https://health.gov/healthypeople.
73.
van DijkTeun A.1993. “Principles of Critical Discourse Analysis.” Discourse & Society4(2):249–83.
74.
WaggonerMiranda R.2017. The Zero Trimester: Prepregnancy Care and the Politics of Reproductive Risk. Oakland: University of California Press.
75.
WallGlenda. 2001. “Moral Constructions of Motherhood in Breastfeeding Discourse.” Gender & Society15(4):592–610.
76.
WestEmilyKnightRosie J.2017. “Mothers’ Milk: Slavery, Wet-Nursing, and Black and White Women in the Antebellum South.” Journal of Southern History83(1):37–68.
77.
WhitleyMargaretBanksAshley. 2022. “Work as an Understudied Driver of Racial Inequities in Breastfeeding.” NEW SOLUTIONS: A Journal of Environmental and Occupational Health Policy32(3):189–200.
78.
WilliamsQuantanise M.2021. “The Effects of Trauma and Chronic Stress on Black Women’s Reproductive and Sexual Health.” Pp. 93–114 in African Americans in the Human Sciences: Challenges and Opportunities, edited by JacksonV. P.HollandJ. M.Miller ArlineJ. R.Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
79.
WolfJoan B.2007. “Is Breast Really Best? Risk and Total Motherhood in the National Breastfeeding Awareness Campaign.” Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law32(4):595–636.
80.
ZuberiTukufu. 2001. Thicker than Blood: How Racial Statistics Lie. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
