Research shows that restrictive immigration policies and practices are associated with poor health, but far less is known about the relationship between inclusive immigration policies and health. Using data from the United States natality files, we estimate associations between state laws granting undocumented immigrants access to driver’s licenses and perinatal outcomes among 4,047,067 singleton births to Mexican and Central American immigrant birthing people (2008–2021). Fitting multivariable log binomial and linear models, we find that the implementation of a license law is associated with improvements in low birthweight and mean birthweight. Replicating these analyses among U.S.-born non-Hispanic White birthing people, we find no association between the implementation of a license law and birthweight. These findings support the hypothesis that states’ extension of legal rights to immigrants improves the health of the next generation.
Amuedo-DorantesCatalinaArenas-ArroyoEstherSevillaAlmudena. 2020. “Labor Market Impacts of States Issuing of Driver’s Licenses to Undocumented Immigrants.” Labour Economics63:101805. doi:10.1016/j.labeco.2020.101805.
2.
ArmentaAmada. 2017. Protect, Serve, and Deport: The Rise of Policing as Immigration Enforcement. Oakland: University of California Press.
3.
ArmentaAmadaVegaIrene. 2017. “Latinos and the Crimmigration System.” Pp. 221–36 in Race, Ethnicity and Law. Vol. 22, edited by DeflemM.Bingley, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited.
4.
AugerNathalieParkAlison L.GamachePhilippePampalonRobertDanielMark. 2012. “Weighing the Contributions of Material and Social Area Deprivation to Preterm Birth.” Social Science & Medicine75(6):1032–37.
5.
BrooksTriciaGardnerAllexaOsorioAubriannaTolbertJenniferCoralloBradleyAmmulaMeghanaMorenoSophia. 2022. Medicaid and CHIP Eligibility and Enrollment Policies as of January 2022: Findings from a 50-State Survey. San Francisco, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
6.
CalavitaKitty. 2010. Inside the State: The Bracero Program, Immigration, and the I.N.S. New Orleans, LA: Quid Pro Books.
7.
CallaghanTimothyWashburnDavid J.NimmonsKatharineDuchicelaDeliaGurramAnoopBurdineJames. 2019. “Immigrant Health Access in Texas: Policy, Rhetoric, and Fear in the Trump Era.” BMC Health Services Research19(1):342. doi:10.1186/s12913-019-4167-1.
8.
CappsRandyChishtiMuzaffarGelattJuliaBolterJessicaRuiz SotoAriel G.2018. Revving up the Deportation Machinery: Enforcement and Pushback under Trump. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.
9.
ChaconJennifer M.2019. “Immigration Federalism in the Weeds.” UCLA Law Review66:1330–93.
10.
ColemanMathew. 2012. “The ‘Local’ Migration State: The Site-Specific Devolution of Immigration Enforcement in the U.S. South.” Law & Policy34(2):159–90.
11.
ConwayKaren SmithKutinovaAndrea. 2006. “Maternal Health: Does Prenatal Care Make a Difference?”Health Economics15(5):461–88.
12.
CrookesDanielle M.StanhopeKaitlyn K.KimYe JiLummusElizabethSugliaShakira F.2021. “Federal, State, and Local Immigrant-Related Policies and Child Health Outcomes: A Systematic Review.” Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities9:478–88.
13.
De GenovaNicholas P.2002. “Migrant ‘Illegality’ and Deportability in Everyday Life.” Annual Review of Anthropology31:419–47.
14.
de GraafJohanna P.SteegersEric A. P.BonselGouke J.2013. “Inequalities in Perinatal and Maternal Health.” Current Opinion in Obstetrics & Gynecology25(2):98–108.
15.
de GraauwEls. 2014. “Municipal ID Cards for Undocumented Immigrants Local Bureaucratic Membership in a Federal System.” Politics & Society42(3):309–30.
16.
DietzPatricia M.BombardJennifer M.HutchingsYalonda L.GauthierJohn P.GambateseMelissa A.KoJean Y.MartinJoyce A.CallaghanWilliam M.2014. “Validation of Obstetric Estimate of Gestational Age on U.S. Birth Certificates.” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology210(4):335.e1–e5.
17.
DonderoMollyAltmanClaire E.2020. “Immigrant Policies as Health Policies: State Immigrant Policy Climates and Health Provider Visits among U.S. Immigrants.” SSM - Population Health10:100559. doi:10.1016/j.ssmph.2020.1005.
18.
DrewryJonathanSenBisakhaWingateMarthaBronsteinJanetFosterE. MichaelKotelchuckMilton. 2015. “The Impact of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program’s Unborn Child Ruling Expansions on Foreign-Born Latina Prenatal Care and Birth Outcomes, 2000–2007.” Maternal and Child Health Journal19(7):1464–71.
19.
FordeAllana T.CrookesDanielle M.SugliaShakira F.DemmerRyan T.2019. “The Weathering Hypothesis as an Explanation for Racial Disparities in Health: A Systematic Review.” Annals of Epidemiology33:1–18.e3.
20.
Fuentes-AfflickElenaHessolNancy A.BauerTamarO’SullivanMary J.Gomez-LoboVeronicaHolmanSusanWilsonTracey E.MinkoffHoward. 2006. “Use of Prenatal Care by Hispanic Women after Welfare Reform.” Obstetrics & Gynecology107(1):151–60.
21.
Fuentes-AfflickElenaHessolNancy A.Pérez-StableEliseo J.1998. “Maternal Birthplace, Ethnicity, and Low Birth Weight in California.” Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine152(11):1105–12.
22.
GardnerTrevor GeorgeIIKohliAarti. 2009. “The C.A.P. Effect: Racial Profiling in the ICE Criminal Alien Program.” SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 3168885. Social Science Research Network, Rochester, NY.
23.
GlassmanAmandaDuranDenizhanFleisherLisaSingerDanielSturkeRachelAngelesGustavoCharlesJodi, et al. 2013. “Impact of Conditional Cash Transfers on Maternal and Newborn Health.” Journal of Health, Population, and Nutrition31(4 Suppl. 2):S48–66.
24.
Golash-BozaTanya. 2015. Deported: Immigrant Policing, Disposable Labor, and Global Capitalism. New York, NY: NYU Press.
25.
GoldfarbSamantha S.SmithWhitneyEpsteinAnne E.BurrowsStevieWingateMartha. 2017. “Disparities in Prenatal Care Utilization among U.S. versus Foreign-Born Women with Chronic Conditions.” Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health19(6):1263–70.
26.
GregoryElizabeth C. W.MartinJoyce A.ArgovErica LeeOstermanM. J.2019. “Assessing the Quality of Medical and Health Data from the 2003 Birth Certificate Revision: Results from New York City.” National Vital Statistics Reports68(8):1–20.
27.
GulasekaramPratheepanRamakrishnanS. Karthick. 2015. The New Immigration Federalism. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
28.
HamiltonErin R.LangerPaola D.PatlerCaitlin. 2021. “DACA’s Association with Birth Outcomes among Mexican-Origin Mothers in the United States.” Demography58(3):975–85.
29.
HardyLisa J.GetrichChristina M.QuezadaJulio C.GuayAmandaMichalowskiRaymond J.HenleyEric. 2012. “A Call for Further Research on the Impact of State-Level Immigration Policies on Public Health.” American Journal of Public Health102(7):1250–53.
30.
HatzenbuehlerMark L.PrinsSeth J.FlakeMorganPhilbinMorganFrazerM. SomjenHagenDanielHirschJennifer. 2017. “Immigration Policies and Mental Health Morbidity among Latinos: A State-Level Analysis.” Social Science & Medicine174:169–78.
31.
HobelCalvin J.GoldsteinAmyBarrettEmily S.2008. “Psychosocial Stress and Pregnancy Outcome.” Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology51(2):333–48.
32.
HoynesHilaryMillerDougSimonDavid. 2015. “Income, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and Infant Health.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy7(1):172–211.
33.
JohnstonGillianMorseAnn. 2013. 2012 Immigration-Related Laws and Resolutions in the States. Denver, CO: National Conference of State Legislatures.
34.
JonesDavid W.2008. Mass Motorization + Mass Transit: An American History and Policy Analysis. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
KlineNolan. 2017. “Pathogenic Policy: Immigrant Policing, Fear, and Parallel Medical Systems in the U.S. South.” Medical Anthropology36(4):396–410.
37.
KoballHeatherKirbyJamesHartigSeth. 2022. “The Relationship between States’ Immigrant-Related Policies and Access to Health Care among Children of Immigrants.” Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health24(4):834–41.
38.
KorinekKimSmithKen R.2011. “Prenatal Care among Immigrant and Racial-Ethnic Minority Women in a New Immigrant Destination: Exploring the Impact of Immigrant Legal Status.” Social Science & Medicine72(10):1695–703.
39.
KramerMichael R.HogueCarol R.2009. “What Causes Racial Disparities in Very Preterm Birth? A Biosocial Perspective.” Epidemiologic Reviews31:84–98.
40.
LeBrónAlana M. W.LopezWilliam D.CowanKetaNovakNicole L.TemrowskiOliviaIbarra-FrayreMariaDelvaJorge. 2018. “Restrictive ID Policies: Implications for Health Equity.” Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health20(2):255–60.
41.
MasseyDouglas S.PrenKaren A.2012. “Unintended Consequences of U.S. Immigration Policy: Explaining the Post-1965 Surge from Latin America.” Population and Development Review38(1):1–29.
42.
MenjívarCeciliaKanstroomDaniel. 2013. “Introduction—Immigrant ‘Illegality’: Constructions and Critiques.” Pp. 1–36 in Constructing Immigrant “Illegality”: Critiques, Experiences, and Responses, edited by MenjívarC.KanstroomD.New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
MoinesterMargot. 2019. “A Look to the Interior: Trends in U.S. Immigration Removals by Criminal Conviction Type, Gender, and Region of Origin, Fiscal Years 2003–2015.” American Behavioral Scientist63(9):1276–98.
NovakNicole L.GeronimusArline T.Martinez-CardosoAresha M.2016. “Change in Birth Outcomes among Infants Born to Latina Mothers after a Major Immigration Raid.” International Journal of Epidemiology46(3):839–49.
50.
O’NeillBarbaraSorhaindoBenoitXiaoJing JianGarmanE. Thomas. 2005. “Financially Distressed Consumers: Their Financial Practices, Financial Well-Being, and Health.” Journal of Financial Counseling and Planning16(1):73–87.
PerreiraKrista M.PedrozaJuan M.2019. “Policies of Exclusion: Implications for the Health of Immigrants and Their Children.” Annual Review of Public Health40:147–66.
53.
PhamHuyenHoang VanPham. 2014. “Measuring the Climate for Immigrants: A State-by-State Analysis.” Pp. 21–40 in Strange Neighbors: The Role of States in Immigration Policy, edited by ChinG. J.HessickC.New York, NY: New York University Press.
54.
PhamHuyenHoang VanPham. 2019. “Subfederal Immigration Regulation and the Trump Effect.” New York University Law Review94(1):125–70.
55.
PhilbinMorgan M.FlakeMorganHatzenbuehlerMark L.HirschJennifer S.2018. “State-Level Immigration and Immigrant-Focused Policies as Drivers of Latino Health Disparities in the United States.” Social Science & Medicine199:29–38.
56.
PotochnickStephanieMaySarah F.FloresLisa Y.2019. “In-State Resident Tuition Policies and the Self-Rated Health of High-School-Aged and College-Aged Mexican Noncitizen Immigrants, Their Families, and the Latina/o Community.” Harvard Educational Review89(1):1–29.
57.
ReedMary M.WestfallJohn M.BublitzCarolineBattagliaCatherineFickenscherAlexandra. 2005. “Birth Outcomes in Colorado’s Undocumented Immigrant Population.” BMC Public Health5:100. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-5-100.
58.
RhodesScott D.MannLilliSimánFlorence M.SongEunyoungAlonzoJorgeDownsMarioLawlorEmma, et al. 2015. “The Impact of Local Immigration Enforcement Policies on the Health of Immigrant Hispanics/Latinos in the United States.” American Journal of Public Health105(2):329–37.
59.
RoAnnieBrucknerTim A.Duquette-RuryLauren. 2020. “Immigrant Apprehensions and Birth Outcomes: Evidence from California Birth Records 2008–2015.” Social Science & Medicine249:112849. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2020.112849.
60.
RosenbergJuliaShabanovaVeronikaMcCollumSarahSharifiMona. 2022. “Insurance and Health Care Outcomes in Regions Where Undocumented Children Are Medicaid-Eligible.” Pediatrics150(3): e2022057034. doi:10.1542/peds.2022-057034.
61.
SanchezThomas W.StolzRichMaJacinta S.2003. Moving to Equity: Addressing Inequitable Effects of Transportation Policies on Minorities. Cambridge, MA: The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University.
62.
SchutRebecca AnnaBoenCourtney. 2022. “State Immigration Policy Contexts and Racialized Legal Status Disparities in Health Care Utilization among U.S. Agricultural Workers.” Demography59(6):2079–107.
63.
StanhopeKaitlyn K.HogueCarol R.SugliaShakira F.LeonJuan S.KramerMichael R.2019. “Restrictive Sub-federal Immigration Policy Climates and Very Preterm Birth Risk among U.S.-Born and Foreign-Born Hispanic Mothers in the United States, 2005–2016.” Health & Place60:102209. doi:10.1016/j.healthplace.2019.102209.
64.
StuesseAngelaColemanMathew. 2014. “Automobility, Immobility, Altermobility: Surviving and Resisting the Intensification of Immigrant Policing.” City & Society26(1):51–72.
65.
SudhinarasetMayWoofterRebeccaDe Trinidad YoungMaria-ElenaLandrianAmandaVildaDovileWallaceSteven P.2021. “Analysis of State-Level Immigrant Policies and Preterm Births by Race-Ethnicity among Women Born in the U.S. and Women Born outside the U.S.” JAMA Network Open4(4):e214482. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.4482.
66.
SwartzJonas J.HainmuellerJensLawrenceDuncanRodriguezMaria I.2017. “Expanding Prenatal Care to Unauthorized Immigrant Women and the Effects on Infant Health.” Obstetrics and Gynecology130(5):938–45.
67.
SwartzJonas J.HainmuellerJensLawrenceDuncanRodriguezMaria I.2019. “Oregon’s Expansion of Prenatal Care Improved Utilization among Immigrant Women.” Maternal and Child Health Journal23(2):173–82.
68.
TorcheFlorenciaConleyDalton. 2015. “A Pound of Flesh: The Use of Birthweight as a Measure of Human Capital Endowment in Economics Research.” Pp. 632–49 in The Oxford Handbook of Economics and Human Biology, edited by KomlosJ.KellyI. R.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
69.
TorcheFlorenciaSiroisCatherine. 2019. “Restrictive Immigration Law and Birth Outcomes of Immigrant Women.” American Journal of Epidemiology188(1):24–33.
TraylorClaire S.JohnsonJasmine D.KimmelMary C.ManuckTracy A.2020. “Effects of Psychological Stress on Adverse Pregnancy Outcomes and Nonpharmacologic Approaches for Reduction: An Expert Review.” American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology MFM2(4):100229. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100229.
72.
WangJulia Shu-HuahKaushalNeeraj. 2019. “Health and Mental Health Effects of Local Immigration Enforcement.” International Migration Review53(4):970–1001.
73.
WaslinMichele L.2013. “Driving while Immigrant: Driver’s License Policy and Immigration Enforcement.” Pp. 3–22 in Outside Justice: Immigration and the Criminalizing Impact of Changing Policy and Practice, edited by BrothertonD. C.StagemanD. L.LeyroS. P.New York, NY: Springer.
74.
WherryLaura R.FabiRachelSchickedanzAdamSalonerBrendan. 2017. “State and Federal Coverage for Pregnant Immigrants: Prenatal Care Increased, No Change Detected For Infant Health.” Health Affairs36(4):607–15.
75.
YoungMaria-Elena De TrinidadCrookesDanielle M.TorresJacqueline M.2022. “Self-Rated Health of Both U.S. Citizens and Noncitizens Is Associated with State-Level Immigrant Criminalization Policies.” SSM - Population Health19:101199. doi:10.1016/j.ssmph.2022.101199.
76.
YoungMaria-Elena De TrinidadLeon-PerezGabrielaWellsChristine R.WallaceSteven P.2019. “Inclusive State Immigrant Policies and Health Insurance among Latino, Asian/Pacific Islander, Black, and White Noncitizens in the United States.” Ethnicity & Health24(8):960–72.
77.
YoungMaria-Elena De TrinidadWallaceSteven P.2019. “Included, but Deportable: A New Public Health Approach to Policies That Criminalize and Integrate Immigrants.” American Journal of Public Health109(9):1171–76.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
