Discussion of growing inequity in U.S. life expectancy increasingly focuses on the popularized narrative that it is driven by a surge of “deaths of despair.” Does this narrative fit the empirical evidence? Using census and Vital Statistics data, we apply life-table methods to calculate cause-specific years of life lost between ages 25 and 84 by sex and educational rank for non-Hispanic blacks and whites in 1990 and 2015. Drug overdoses do contribute importantly to widening inequity for whites, especially men, but trivially for blacks. The contribution of suicide to growing inequity is unremarkable. Cardiovascular disease, non-lung cancers, and other internal causes are key to explaining growing life expectancy inequity. Results underline the speculative nature of attempts to attribute trends in life-expectancy inequity to an epidemic of despair. They call for continued investigation of the possible weathering effects of tenacious high-effort coping with chronic stressors on the health of marginalized populations.
AndersonRobert N.MiniñoArialdi M.HoyertDonna L.RosenbergHarry M.2001. “Comparability of Cause of Death between ICD-9 and ICD-10: Preliminary Estimates.” National Vital Statistics Reports: From the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, National Vital Statistics System49(2):1–32.
2.
BennettGary G.MerrittMarcellus M.SollersJohn J.IIIEdwardsChristopher L.WhitfieldKeith E.BrandonDwayne T.TuckerReginald D.2004. “Stress, Coping, and Health Outcomes among African-Americans: A Review of the John Henryism Hypothesis.” Psychology & Health19(3):369–83.
3.
BoothJaime M.JonassaintCharles R.2016. “The Role of Disadvantaged Neighborhood Environments in the Association of John Henryism with Hypertension and Obesity.” Psychosomatic Medicine78(5):552–61.
4.
BoundJohnGeronimusArline T.RodriguezJavier M.WaidmannTimothy A.2015. “Measuring Recent Apparent Declines in Longevity: The Role of Increasing Educational Attainment.” Health Affairs34(12):2167–73.
5.
BrownDustin C.LariscyJoseph T.KalousováLucie.2018. “Comparability of Mortality Estimates from Social Surveys and Vital Statistics Data in the United States.” Population Research and Policy Review. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-018-9505-1
6.
CaseAnneDeatonAngus. 2015. “Rising Morbidity and Mortality in Midlife among White Non-Hispanic Americans in the 21st Century.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America112(49):15078–83.
7.
CaseAnneDeatonAngus. 2017. “Mortality and Morbidity in the 21st Century.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity2017:397–476.
8.
CohenSheldonJanicki-DevertsDeniseMillerGregory E.2007. “Psychological Stress and Disease.” JAMA298(14):1685–87.
9.
CohenSheldonJanicki-DevertsDeniseTurnerRonald B.DoyleWilliam J.2015. “Does Hugging Provide Stress-Buffering Social Support? A Study of Susceptibility to Upper Respiratory Infection and Illness.” Psychological Science26(2):135–47.
10.
EpelElissa S.LithgowGordon J.2014. “Stress Biology and Aging Mechanisms: Toward Understanding the Deep Connection between Adaptation to Stress and Longevity.” The Journals of Gerontology. Series A, Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences69(Suppl 1):S10–16.
11.
GeronimusArline T.1992. “The Weathering Hypothesis and the Health of African-American Women and Infants: Evidence and Speculations.” Ethnicity and Disease2(3):207–21.
12.
GeronimusArline T.BoundJohnColenCynthia G.2011. “Excess Black Mortality in the United States and in Selected Black and White High-Poverty Areas, 1980–2000.” American Journal of Public Health101(4):720–29.
13.
GeronimusArline T.BoundJohnWaidmannTimothy A.ColenCynthia G.SteffickDiane. 2001. “Inequality in Life Expectancy, Functional Status, and Active Life Expectancy across Selected Black and White Populations in the United States.” Demography38(2):227–51.
14.
GeronimusArline T.HickenMargaretKeeneDanyaBoundJohn. 2006. “‘Weathering’ and Age Patterns of Allostatic Load Scores among Blacks and Whites in the United States.” American Journal of Public Health96(5):826–33.
15.
GeronimusArline T.PearsonJay A.LinnenbringerErinSchulzAmy J.ReyesAngela G.EpelElissa S.LinJueBlackburnElizabeth H.2015. “Race-Ethnicity, Poverty, Urban Stressors, and Telomere Length in a Detroit Community-Based Sample.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior56(2):199–224.
16.
GodboutJonathan P.GlaserRonald. 2006. “Stress-Induced Immune Dysregulation: Implications for Wound Healing, Infectious Disease and Cancer.” Journal of Nueroimmune Pharmacology1(4):421–27.
17.
GrossTalGliedSherryMuennigPeter. 2015. “Widening Mortality Disparities by Educational Attainment among Native-Born Americans Adults over 3 Decades of Follow-Up: The Mystery Deepens.” International Journal of Healthcare. https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/doi/10.7916/D8KS6RZ5
18.
GruenewaldTara L.CohenSheldonMatthewsKaren A.TracyRussellSeemanTeresa E.2009. “Association of Socioeconomic Status with Inflammation Markers in Black and White Men and Women in the Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults (CARDIA) Study.” Social Science & Medicine69(3):451–59.
19.
GuyGery P.ZhangKunBohmMichele K.LosbyJanLewisBrianYoungRandallMurphyLouise B.DowellDeborah. 2017. “Vital Signs: Changes in Opioid Prescribing in the United States, 2006–2015.” MMWR. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report66(26):697–704.
20.
HendiArun S.2015. “Trends in U.S. Life Expectancy Gradients: The Role of Changing Educational Composition.” International Journal of Epidemiology44(3):946–55.
21.
HoJessica Y.2017. “The Contribution of Drug Overdose to Educational Gradients in Life Expectancy in the United States, 1992–2011.” Demography54(3):1175–202.
22.
HoJessica Y.FenelonAndrew. 2015. “The Contribution of Smoking to Educational Gradients in U.S. Life Expectancy.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior56(3):307–22.
23.
JamesSherman A.1994. “John Henryism and the Health of African-Americans.” Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry18(2):163–82.
24.
JamesSherman A.Fowler-BrownAngelaRaghunathanTrevillore E.Van HoewykJohn. 2006. “Life-Course Socioeconomic Position and Obesity in African American Women: The Pitt County Study.” American Journal of Public Health96(3):554–60.
25.
JamesSherman A.StrogatzDavid S.WingSteven B.RamseyDiane L.1987. “Socioeconomic Status, John Henryism, and Hypertension in Blacks and Whites.” American Journal of Epidemiology126(4):664–73.
26.
Janicki-DevertsDeniseCohenSheldonMatthewsKaren A.CullenMark R.2008. “History of Unemployment Predicts Future Elevations in C-Reactive Protein among Male Participants in the Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults (CARDIA) Study.” Annals of Behavioral Medicine36(2):176–85.
27.
JemalArhmedinThunMichael J.WardElizabeth E.HenleyS. JaneCokkinidesVilma E.MurrayTaylor E.2008. “Mortality from Leading Causes by Education and Race in the United States, 2001.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine34(1):1–8.e7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2007.09.017
KhansariNematShakibaYadollahMahmoudiMahdi. 2009. “Chronic Inflammation and Oxidative Stress as a Major Cause of Age-Related Diseases and Cancer.” Recent Patents on Inflammation & Allergy Drug Discovery3(1):73–80.
31.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo. 1995. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Disease.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior35(Special Issue):80–94.
32.
LinnenbringerErinGehlertSarahGeronimusArline T.2017. “Black-White Disparities in Breast Cancer Subtype: The Intersection of Socially Patterned Stress and Genetic Expression.” AIMS Public Health4(5):526–56.
33.
MantonKenneth G.StallardEric. 1984. Recent Trends in Mortality Analysis. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
34.
MastersRyan K.TilstraAndrea M.SimonDaniel H.2018. “Explaining Recent Mortality Trends among Younger and Middle-Aged White Americans.” International Journal of Epidemiology47(1):81–88.
35.
McEwenBruce S.1998. “Protective and Damaging Effects of Stress Mediators.” New England Journal of Medicine338(3):171–79.
36.
McEwenBruce S.GianarosPeter J.2010. “Central Role of the Brain in Stress and Adaptation: Links to Socioeconomic Status, Health, and Disease: Central Links between Stress and SES.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences1186(1):190–222.
37.
McEwenBruce S.StellarEliot. 1993. “Stress and the Individual. Mechanisms Leading to Disease.” Archives of Internal Medicine153(18):2093–101.
38.
MearaEllen R.RichardsSethCutlerDavid M.2008. “The Gap Gets Bigger: Changes in Mortality And Life Expectancy, by Education, 1981–2000.” Health Affairs27(2):350–60.
39.
MillerGregory E.YuTianyiChenEdithBrodyGene H.2015. “Self-Control Forecasts Better Psychosocial Outcomes but Faster Epigenetic Aging in Low-SES Youth.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America112(33):10325–30.
MontezJennifer KarasHummerRobert A.HaywardMark D.WooHyeyoungRogersRichard G.2011. “Trends in the Educational Gradient of U.S. Adult Mortality from 1986 to 2006 by Race, Gender, and Age Group.” Research on Aging33(2):145–71.
42.
MontezJennifer KarasZajacovaAnna. 2013a. “Explaining the Widening Education Gap in Mortality among U.S. White Women.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior54(2):166–82.
43.
MontezJennifer KarasZajacovaAnna. 2013b. “Trends in Mortality Risk by Education Level and Cause of Death among US White Women From 1986 to 2006.” American Journal of Public Health103(3):473–79.
44.
MoodyDanielle L. BeattyChangYue-FangPantescoElizabeth J.DardenTaylor M.LewisTené T.BrownCharlotteBrombergerJoyce T.MatthewsKaren A.2018. “Everyday Discrimination Prospectively Predicts Blood Pressure across 10 Years in Racially/Ethnically Diverse Midlife Women: Study of Women’s Health across the Nation.” Annals of Behavioral Medicine53(1):1–13
45.
MuennigPeter A.ReynoldsMeganFinkDavid S.ZafariZafarGeronimusArline T.2018. “America’s Declining Well-Being, Health, and Life Expectancy: Not Just a White Problem.” American Journal of Public Health108(12):1621–26.
46.
OlshanskyS. JayAntonucciToniBerkmanLisaBinstockRobert H.Boersch-SupanAxelCacioppoJohn T.CarnesBruce A.CarstensenLaura L.FriedLinda P.GoldmanDana P.2012. “Differences in Life Expectancy Due to Race and Educational Differences Are Widening, and Many May Not Catch Up.” Health Affairs31(8):1803–13.
47.
ParenteVictoriaHaleLaurenPalermoTia. 2013. “Association between Breast Cancer and Allostatic Load by Race: National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 1999–2008: Biomarkers of Breast Cancer.” Psycho-Oncology22(3):621–28.
48.
PhillipsJulie A.HempsteadKatherine. 2017. “Differences in U.S. Suicide Rates by Educational Attainment, 2000–2014.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine53(4):e123–30.
49.
PrestonSamuel H.EloIrma T.1995. “Are Educational Differentials in Adult Mortality Increasing in the United States?”Journal of Aging and Health7(4):476–96.
50.
PrestonSamuel H.EloIrma T.1999. “Effects of Age Misreporting on Mortality Estimates at Older Ages.” Population Studies53(2):165–77.
51.
QuinonesSam. 2016. Dreamland: The True Tale of America’s Opiate Epidemic. New York: Bloomsbury Press.
52.
RockettIan R. H.SamoraJulie B.CobenJeffrey H.2006. “The Black-White Suicide Paradox: Possible Effects of Misclassification.” Social Science & Medicine63(8):2165–75.
53.
RodriguezJavier M.KarlamanglaArun S.GruenewaldTara L.Miller-MartinezDanaMerkinSharon S.SeemanTeresa E.2019. “Social Stratification and Allostatic Load: Shapes of Heal111th Differences in the MIDUS Study in the United States.” Journal of Biosocial Science. doi:10.1017/S002193201800037
RuhmChristopher J.2017a. “Drug Involvement in Fatal Overdoses.” SSM–Population Health3:219–26.
57.
RuhmChristopher J.2017b. “Geographic Variation in Opioid and Heroin Involved Drug Poisoning Mortality Rates.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine53(6):745–53.
58.
RuhmChristopher J.2018. “Deaths of Despair or Drug Problems?”National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 24188.
59.
SapolskyRobert M.RomeroL. MichaelMunckAllan U.2000. “How Do Glucocorticoids Influence Stress Responses? Integrating Permissive, Suppressive, Stimulatory, and Preparative Actions.” Endocrine Reviews21(1):55–89.
60.
SassonIsaac. 2016. “Diverging Trends in Cause-Specific Mortality and Life Years Lost by Educational Attainment: Evidence from United States Vital Statistics Data, 1990–2010”PLOS ONE11(10):e0163412. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0163412
61.
SassonIsaac. 2017. “Reply to Trends in Education-Specific Life Expectancy, Data Quality, and Shifting Education Distributions: A Note on Recent Research.” Demography54(3):1215–19.
62.
SeemanTeresaEpelElissaGruenewaldTaraKarlamanglaArunMcEwenBruce S.2010. “Socio-Economic Differentials in Peripheral Biology: Cumulative Allostatic Load.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences1186(1):223–39.
63.
SeemanTeresaThomasDuncanMerkinSharon SteinMooreKariWatsonKarolKarlamanglaArun. 2018. “The Great Recession Worsened Blood Pressure and Blood Glucose Levels in American Adults.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences115(13):3296–301.
64.
SteptoeAndrewKivimäkiMika. 2013. “Stress and Cardiovascular Disease: An Update on Current Knowledge.” Annual Review of Public Health34(1):337–54.
65.
ThoitsPeggy A.2010. “Stress and Health: Major Findings and Policy Implications.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(Suppl 1):S41–53.
66.
TinettiMary E.McAvayGail J.MurphyTerrence E.GrossCary P.LinHaiqunAlloreHeather G.2012. “Contribution of Individual Diseases to Death in Older Adults with Multiple Diseases.” Journal of the American Geriatrics Society60(8):1448–56.
67.
TraustadóttirTinnaBoschPamela R.MattKathleen S.2005. “The HPA Axis Response to Stress in Women: Effects of Aging and Fitness.” Psychoneuroendocrinology30(4):392–402.
68.
Van ZeeArt.2009. “The Promotion and Marketing of OxyContin: Commercial Triumph, Public Health Tragedy.” American Journal of Public Health99(2):221–27.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
