Self-rated health is a valid measure of health that predicts quality of life, morbidity, and mortality. Its predictive value reflects a conceptualization of health that goes beyond a traditional medical model. However, less is known about self-rated mental health (SRMH). Using data from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (N = 2,547), we examine how rating your mental health as good—despite meeting criteria for a mental health problem—predicts outcomes. We found that 62% of people with a mental health problem rated their mental health positively. Persons who rated their mental health as good (compared to poor) had 30% lower odds of having a mental health problem at follow-up. Even without treatment, persons with a mental health problem did better if they perceived their mental health positively. SRMH might comprise information beyond the experience of symptoms. Understanding the unobserved information individuals incorporate into SRMH will help us improve screening and treatment interventions.
American Psychiatric Association. 2013. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: Author.
4.
AnthonyWilliam A.1993. “Recovery from Mental Illness: The Guiding Vision of the Mental Health Service System in the 1990s.” Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal16(4):11–23.
5.
ArrollBruceGoodyear-SmithFelicityCrengleSusanGunnJaneKerseNgaireFishmanTanaFalloonKarenHatcherSimon. 2010. “Validation of PHQ-2 and PHQ-9 to Screen for Major Depression in the Primary Care Population.” Annals of Family Medicine8(4):348–53.
6.
BailisDaniel S.SegallAlexanderChipperfieldJudith G.2003. “Two Views of Self-rated General Health Status.” Social Science & Medicine56(2):203–17.
7.
BenyaminiYael. 2011. “Why Does Self-rated Health Predict Mortality? An Update on Current Knowledge and a Research Agenda for Psychologists.” Psychology & Health26(11):1407–13.
8.
BenyaminiYaelIdlerEllen L.1999. “Community Studies Reporting Association between Self-rated Health and Mortality: Additional Studies, 1995 to 1998.” Research on Aging21(3):392–401.
9.
BenyaminiYaelIdlerEllen L.LeventhalHowardLeventhalElaine A.2000. “Positive Affect and Function as Influences on Self-assessments of Health: Expanding Our View beyond Illness and Disability.” Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences55B(2):107–16.
10.
CairneyJohnVeldhuizenScottWadeTerrance J.KurdyakPaulStreinerDavid L.2007. “Evaluation of 2 Measures of Psychological Distress as Screeners for Depression in the General Population.” Canadian Journal of Psychiatry52(2):111–20.
11.
ChipperfieldJudith G.1993. “Incongruence between Health Perceptions and Health Problems: Implications for Survival among Seniors.” Journal of Aging and Health5(4):475–96.
12.
CornfordCharles S.HillAngelaReillyJoe. 2007. “How Patients with Depressive Symptoms View Their Condition: A Qualitative Study.” Family Practice24(4):358–64.
13.
FerraroKenneth F.1993. “Are Black Older Adults Health-pessimistic?” Journal of Health and Social Behavior34(3):201–14.
14.
FleishmanJohn A.SelimAlfredo J.KazisLewis E.2010. “Deriving SF-12v2 Physical and Mental Health Summary Scores: A Comparison of Different Scoring Algorithms.” Quality of Life Research19(2):231–41.
15.
FleishmanJohn A.ZuvekasSamuel H.2007. “Global Self-rated Mental Health: Associations with Other Mental Health Measures and with Role Functioning.” Medical Care45(7):602–09.
16.
FurukawaToshi A.KawakamiNoritoSaitohMariOnoYutakaNakaneYoshibumiNakamuraYosikazuTachimoriHisateruIwataNoboruUdaHidenoriNakaneHideyukiWatanabeMakotaNaganumaYoichiHataYukihorioKobayashiMasayoMiyakeYukoTakeshimaTadashiKikkawaTakehiko. 2008. “The Performance of the Japanese Version of the K6 and K10 in the World Mental Health Survey Japan.” International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research17(3):152–58.
17.
GillSarah C.ButterworthPeterRodgersBryanMackinnonAndrew. 2007. “Validity of the Mental Health Component Scale of the 12-item Short-form Health Survey (MCS-12) as Measure of Common Mental Disorders in the General Population.” Psychiatry Research152(1):63–71.
18.
Grol-ProkopczykHannaFreeseJeremyHauserRobert M.2011. “Using Anchoring Vignettes to Assess Group Differences in General Self-rated Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52(2):246–61.
19.
HoffRani A.BruceMartha LivingstonKaslStanislav V.JacobsSelby C.1997. “Subjective Ratings of Emotional Health as a Risk Factor for Major Depression in a Community Sample.” British Journal of Psychiatry170(2):167–72.
20.
HongTantina B.ZaritSteven H.MalmbergBo. 2004. “The Role of Health Congruence in Functional Status and Depression.” Journal of Gerontology59B(4):151–57.
21.
HorwitzAllan V.WakefieldJerome C.2007. The Loss of Sadness: How Psychiatry Transformed Normal Sorrow into Depressive Disorder. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
22.
IdlerEllen L.BenyaminiYael. 1997. “Self-rated Health and Mortality: A Review of Twenty-seven Community Studies.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior38(1):21–37.
23.
IdlerEllen L.HudsonShawna V.LeventhalHoward. 1999. “The Meanings of Self-ratings of Health: A Qualitative and Quantitative Approach. Research on Aging21(3):458–76.
24.
IdlerEllenLeventhalHowardMcLaughlinJulieLeventhalElaine. 2004. “In Sickness but Not in Health: Self-ratings, Identity, and Mortality.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior45(3):336–56.
25.
JangYuriYoonHyunwooChiribogaDavid A.MollinariVictorPowersDaniel A.2015. “Bridging the Gap between Common Mental Disorders and Service Use: The Role of Self-rated Mental Health among African Americans.” American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry23(7):658–65.
26.
JylhäMarja. 2009. “What Is Self-rated Health and Why Does It Predict Mortality? Towards a Unified Conceptual Model.” Social Science & Medicine69(3):307–16.
27.
KangasIlka. 2001. “Making Sense of Depression: Perceptions of Melancholia in Lay Narratives.” Health5(1):76–92.
28.
KaplanGioraBaron-EpelOrna. 2003. “What Lies behind the Subjective Evaluation of Health Status?” Social Science & Medicine56(8):1669–76.
29.
KesslerRonald C.AndrewsG.ColpeLisa J.Eva HiripiMroczekD. K.NormandSharon-Lise T.WaltersEllen E.ZaslavskyAlan M.2002. “Short Screening Scales to Monitor Population Prevalences and Trends in Non-specific Psychological Distress.” Psychological Medicine32(6):959–76.
30.
KesslerRonald C.BarkerPeggy R.ColpeLisa J.EpsteinJoan F.GfroererJoseph C.HiripiEvaHowesMary J.NormandSharon-Lise T.ManderscheidRonald W.WaltersEllen E.ZaslavskyAlan M.2003. “Screening for Serious Mental Illness in the General Population.” Archives of General Psychiatry60(2):184–89.
31.
KesslerRonald C.ÜstünBedirhan. 1994. “The World Mental Health (WMH) Survey Initiative Version of the World Health Organization (WHO) Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI).” International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research13(2):93–121.
32.
KeyesCorey L. M.2002. “The Mental Health Continuum: From Languishing to Flourishing in Life.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior43(2):207–22.
33.
KimGiyeonDeCosterJamieChiribogaDavid A.JangYuriAllenRebeccaParmeleePatricia. 2011. “Associations between Self-rated Mental Health and Psychiatric Disorders among Older Adults: Do Racial/Ethnic Differences Exist?” American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry19(5):416–22.
34.
KrauseNeal M.JayGina M.1994. “What Do Global Self-rated Health Items Measure.” Medical Care32(9):930–42.
35.
KroenkeKurtSpitzerRobert L.WilliamsJanet B. W.2003. “The Patient Health Questionnaire-2: Validity of a Two-item Depression Screener.” Medical Care41(11):1284–92.
36.
LathamKenziePeekChuck W.2012. “Self-rated Health and Morbidity Onset among Late Midlife U.S. Adults.” Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences68(1):107–16.
37.
LayesAudreyAsadaYukikoKephartGeorge. 2012. “Whiners and Deniers: What Does Self-rated Health Measure?” Social Science & Medicine75(1):1–9.
38.
LevinsonDaphnaKaplanGlora. 2014. “What Does Self-rated Mental Health Represent.” Journal of Public Health Research3(287):122–27.
39.
LiChunyuFriedmanBruceConwellYeatesFiscellaKevin. 2007. “Validity of the Patient Health Questionnaire 2 (PHQ-2) in Detecting Depression in Older People.” Journal of the American Geriatric Society55(4):596–602.
40.
LinkBruce G.WellsJenniferPhelanJo C.YangLawrence. 2015. “Understanding the Importance of ‘Symbolic Interaction Stigma’: How Expectations about the Reactions of Others Adds to the Burden of Mental Illness Stigma.” Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal38(2):117–24.
41.
LynessJeffrey M.KingDeborah A.ConwellYeatesDubersteinPaul R.EberlyShirleySörensenSilvia M.CaineEric D.2004. “Self-rated Health, Depression, and One-year Health Outcomes in Older Primary Care Patients.” American Journal Of Geriatric Psychiatry12(1):110–13.
42.
MawaniFarah N.GilmourHeather. 2010. “Validation of Self-rated Mental Health.” Health Reports21(3):61–75.
43.
McMullenCarmit K.LuborskyMark R.2006. “Self-rated Health Appraisal as Cultural and Identity Process: African American Elders’ Health and Evaluative Rationales.” Gerontologist46(4):431–38.
44.
PescosolidoBernice A.MartinJack K.LongJ. ScottMedinaTait R.PhelanJo C.Link.Bruce G.2010. “‘A Disease Like Any Other’? A Decade of Change in Public Reactions to Schizophrenia, Depression and Alcohol Dependence.” American Journal of Psychiatry167(11):1321–30.
45.
RuthigJoelle C.ChipperfieldJudith G.PayneBarbara J.2011. “A Five-year Study of Older Adults’ Health Incongruence: Consistency, Functional Changes and Subsequent Survival.” Psychology & Health26(11):1463–78.
46.
SchnittkerJasonBacakValerio. 2014. “The Increasing Predictive Validity of Self-rated Health.” PLoS ONE9(1):1–11.
47.
ShadboltBruceBarresiJaneCraftPaul. 2002. “Self-rated Health as a Predictor of Survival among Patients with Advanced Cancer.” Journal of Clinical Oncology20(10):2514–19.
48.
Singh-ManouxPekka MartikainenFerrieJaneZinsMarieMarmotMichaelGoldbergMarcel. 2006. “What Does Self Rated Health Measure? Results from the British Whitehall II and French Gazel Cohort Studies.” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health60(4):364–72.
49.
SpencerS.SchulzRichardRooksRonica N.AlbertSteven M.ThorpeRoland J.Jr.BrenesGretchen A.HarrisTamara B.KosterAnnemarieSatterfieldSuzanneAyonayonHilsa N.NewmanAnne B.2009. “Racial Differences in Self-rated Health at Similar Levels of Physical Functioning: An Examination of Health Pessimism in the Health, Aging, and Body Composition Study.” Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences64B(1):87–94.
50.
StenholmSariPenttiJaanaKawachiIchiroWesterlundHugoKivimäkiMikaVahteraJussi. 2014. “Self-rated Health In the Last 12 Years of Life Compared to Matched Surviving Controls: The Health and Retirement Study.” PLoS ONE9(9):1–7.
51.
SuDejunWenMingMarkidesKyriakos S.2013. “Is Self-rated Health Comparable between Non-Hispanic Whites and Hispanics? Evidence from the Health and Retirement Study.” Journal of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences64(4):622–32.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administra-tion. 2015. Racial/Ethnic Differences in Mental Health Services Use among Adults. HHS Publication No. SMA-15-4906. Rockville, MD: Author.
54.
TesslerRichardMechanicDavid. 1978. “Psychological Distress and Perceived Health Status.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior19(3):254–62.
55.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 1999. Mental Health: A Report to the Surgeon General. Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Center for Mental Health Services, National Institutes of Health, and National Institute of Mental Health.
56.
VilagutGemmaForeroCarlos G.Pinto-MezaAlejandraHaroJosep M.de GraafRonBruffaertsRonnyKovessVivianede GirolamoGiovanniMatschingerHerbertFerrerMontserratAlonsoJordion behalf of the ESEMed Investigators. 2013. “The Mental Component of the Short-form 12 Health Survey (SF-12) as a Measure of Depressive Disorders in the General Population: Results from Three Alternative Scoring Methods.” Value in Health16(4):564–73.
57.
WareJohn E.Jr.KosinskiMarkKeller.Susan D.1996. “A 12-item Short-form Health Survey: Construction of Scales and Preliminary Tests of Reliability and Validity.” Medical Care34(3):220–33.
58.
ZuvekasSamuel H.FleishmanJohn A.2008. “Self-rated Mental Health and Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Mental Health Service Use.” Medical Care46(9):915–23.
