Toxicity of Formaldehyde to Human Oral Fibroblasts and Epithelial Cells: Influences of Culture Conditions and Role of Thiol Status

Abstract

The toxicity of formaldehyde, a monomer released from certain polymeric dental materials, was studied in cultured human oral fibroblasts and epithelial cells. The influences of growth conditions were evaluated for both cell types, as well as the role of the internal and external thiol states. A one-hour exposure to formaldehyde decreased the colony-forming efficiency (CFE) of both cell types in a concentration-dependent manner, although the toxicity varied up to 100-fold with the conditions. Clearly, the presence of serum and the thiol cysteine counteracted the toxicity in fibroblasts. Similarly, pituitary extract and cysteine, or a mixture of amino acids and ethanolamines, counteracted the formaldehyde toxicity in serum-free cultures of epithelial cells. In contrast, a growth-promoting surface matrix of fibronectin and collagen did not influence the formaldehyde toxicity, as shown by both the CFE assay and a dye reduction assay. Further, a short-term change to the various growth media per se with or without the supplements serum or cysteine did not significantly alter the CFE. Analysis of the thiol state demonstrated significant differences between epithelial cells and fibroblasts, i.e., comparatively lower cellular levels of the free low-molecular-weight thiols glutathione and cysteine in fibroblasts. This result correlated to significantly higher formaldehyde toxicity in the fibroblasts than in the epithelial cells. Taken together, the results indicated the cytoprotective function of both intracellular and extracellular thiols toward formaldehyde, as well as the usefulness of thiol-free and chemically defined conditions for toxicity assessments in oral epithelial cells and fibroblasts. We conclude that the combined use of a controlled external milieu and the presumed target cell type may be advantageous in evaluations of oral toxicity mechanisms or the toxic potency of dental materials, particularly those which, like formaldehyde, may react with thiols or amines.

Keywords

cytotoxicity thiols formaldehyde oral mucosa cell cultures.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atzori L. , Sundqvist K. , Dypbukt JM , Edman CC , Cotgreave IA , Moldeus P. , et al. (1990). Growth-associated modifications of low-molecular-weight thiols and protein sulfhydryls in human bronchial fibroblasts. J Cell Physiol 143:165-171.

Atzori L. , Dypbukt JM , Hybbinette SS , Moldeus P. , Grafstrom RC (1994). Modifications of cellular thiols during growth and squamous differentiation of cultured human bronchial epithelial cells . Exp Cell Res 211:115-120.

Bean TA , Zhuang WC , Tong PY , Eick JD , Chappelow CC , Yourtee DM (1995). Comparison of tetrazolium colorimetric and 5lCr release assays for cytotoxicity determination of dental biomaterials. Dent Mater 11:327-331.

Browne RM (1985). In vitro cytotoxicity testing of dental restorative materials. CRC Crit Rev Biocompatibility 1:85-110.

Carmichael J. , Degraff WG , Gazdar AF , Minna JD , Mitchell JB (1987). Evaluation of a tetrazolium-based semiautomated colorimetric assay: assessment of chemosensitivity testing. Cancer Res 47:936-942.

Cotgreave IA, Moldeus P (1986). Methodologies for the application of monobromobimane to the simultaneous analysis of soluable and protein thiol components of biological systems. J Biochem Biophys Meth 13:231-249. Grafstrom RC (1990a). In vitro studies of aldehyde effects that relate to human respiratory carcinogenesis. Mutat Res 238:175-184.

Grafstrom RC (1990b). Carcinogenesis studies in human epithelial tissues and cells in vitro: emphasis on serum-free culture conditions and transformation studies. Acta Physiol Scand 140(Suppl 592):93-133.

Grafstrom RC , Dypbukt JM , Willey JC , Sundqvist K. , Edman C. , Atzori L. , et al. (1988). Pathobiological effects of acrolein in cultured human bronchial epithelial cells. Cancer Res 48:1717-1721.

Grafstrom RC, Jernelov MI, Dypbukt JM, Sundqvist K, Atzori L, Zheng X (1996). Aldehyde toxicity and thiol redox state in cell cultures from human aerodigestive tract. In: Correlations between in vitro and in vivo investigations in inhalation toxicology. Mohr U, Adler KB, Dungworth DI, Harris CC, Plopper CG, Saracci R, editors. Washington, DC: ILSE Press, pp. 319-336.

10.

Grafstrom RC , Noren UG , Zheng X. , Elfwing A. , Sundqvist K. (1997). Growth and transformation of human oral epithelium in vitro. In: Risk and progression factors in carcinogenesis. Recent results of cancer research. Vol. 143. Muller-Hermelink HK , Neumann HG , Dekant W , editors. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, pp. 275-306.

11.

Hensten-Pettersen A. (1988). Comparison of the methods available for assessing cytotoxicity. Int Endodont J 21:89-99.

12.

Iarc (1995). Monograph: Evaluation of carcinogenic risks to humans. Wood dust and formaldehyde. Vol. 62. Lyon, France: International Agency for Research on Cancer.

13.

Liu Y. , Arvidson K. , Atzori L. , Sundqvist K. , Silva B. , Cotgreave I. , et al. (1991). Development of low and high serum culture conditions for use of human oral fibroblasts in toxicity testing of dental materials. J Dent Res 70:1068-1073.

14.

Monticello TM , Swenberg JA , Gross EA , Leininger JR , Kimbell JS , Seilkop S. , et al. (1996). Correlation of regional and nonlinear formaldehyde-induced nasal cancer with proliferating populations of cells. Cancer Res 56:1012-1022.

15.

Powis G. , Briehl M. , Oblong J. (1995). Redox signalling and the control of cell growth and cell death. Pharmacol Ther 68:149-173.

16.

Proctor BL , Gaulden ME , Dowd MA ( 1986). Reactivity and fate of benzene and formaldehyde in culture medium with and without fetal calf serum; relevance to in vitro mutagenicity testing. Mutat Res 160:259-266.

17.

Schmalz G (1994). Use of cell cultures for toxicity testing of dental materials-advantages and limitations. J Dent 22(Suppl):S6-Sll.

18.

Schmalz G. , Browne RM (1995). The biological evaluation of medical devices used in dentistry. The influence of the European Union on the preclinical screening of dental materials. Int Dent J 45:275-278.

19.

Sun HW , Feigal RJ , Messer HH (1990). Cytotoxicity of glutaraldehyde and formaldehyde in relation to time of exposure and concentration. Pediatr Dent 12:303-307.

20.

Sundqvist K. , Liu Y. , Nair J. , Bartsch H. , Arvidson K. , Grafstrom RC (1989). Cytotoxic and genotoxic effects of areca nut-related compounds in cultured human buccal epithelial cells. Cancer Res 49:5294-5298.

21.

Sundqvist K. , Liu Y. , Arvidson K. , Ormstad K. , Nilsson L. , Toftgard R. , et al. (1991a). Growth regulation of epithelial cells from normal human buccal mucosa cultured at serum-free conditions. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol 27(A):562-568.

22.

Sundqvist K. , Kulkarni P. , Hybbinette SS , Bertolero F. , Liu Y. , Grafstrom RC (1991b). Serum-free growth and karyotype analyses of cultured normal and tumorous (SqCC/Yl) human buccal epithelial cells. Cancer Commun 3:331-340.

23.

Suruda A. , Schulte P. , Boeniger M. , Hayes RB , Livingstone GK , Steenland K. , et al. (1993). Cytogenetic effects of formaldehyde exposure in students of mortuary science. Cancer Epidem Biomar 2:453-460.

24.

Tsuchiya H. , Shigeru 0 , Yamada K. , Tajima K. , Sato M. ( 1995). Formation of tetrahydro-β-carbolirles in human saliva . Biochem Pharmacol 50:2109-2112.

25.

Wataha JC , Hanks CT , Strawn SE , Fat JC (1994). Cytotoxicity of components of resins and other dental restorative materials. J Oral Rehabil 21:453-462.