Studies have shown that intergroup conflict may result from two distinct human motives: the desire to obtain personal retributions from conflict (egoism), and the desire to sacrifice for the benefit of the ingroup (parochial altruism). Yet, the relative strength of these motives is open to debate. In this study, we compare behaviors in two Intergroup Prisoner’s Dilemmas (IPD), which respectively capture altruistic and egoistic motives to generate conflict. Egoistic motives result in about 40% more conflict than altruistic motives. Yet, parochial altruism generates more conflict when three conditions are gathered: i) other ingroup members are parochial altruists, ii) the outgroup is aggressive and iii) the outgroup is rich. Implications regarding the diverging structural causes of terrorism and civil wars are discussed.
AbbinkK.MascletD.MirzaD.. 2018. “Inequality and Inter-Group Conflicts: Experimental Evidence.” Social Choice and Welfare50 (3): 387‐423.
2.
AndreoniJ. 1988. “Why Free Ride?: Strategies and Learning in Public Goods Experiments.” Journal of Public Economics37 (3): 291‐304. doi:10.1016/0047-2727(88)90043-6
3.
AtranS.SheikhH.GomezA.. 2014. “Devoted Actors Sacrifice for Close Comrades and Sacred Cause.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America111 (50): 17702‐17703. doi:10.1073/pnas.1420474111
4.
AtranS.WaziriH.GómezA.SheikhH.López-RodríguezL.RoganC.DavisR.. 2018. “The Islamic State’s Lingering Legacy Among Young Men From the Mosul Area.” CTC Sentinel11 (4): 15‐22.
5.
AxelrodR.HamiltonW. D.. 1981. “The Evolution of Cooperation.” Science211 (4489): 1390‐1396.
6.
BasraR.NeumannP. R.. 2016. “Criminal Pasts, Terrorist Futures: European Jihadists and the New Crime-Terror Nexus.” Perspectives on Terrorism10 (6): 25‐40.
7.
BeckermanS.EricksonP. I.YostJ.RegaladoJ.JaramilloL.SparksC.IromengaM.LongK.. 2009. “Life Histories, Blood Revenge, and Reproductive Success Among the Waorani of Ecuador.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences106 (20): 8134‐8139.
8.
BenslimaneI.CrosettoP.Magni-BertonR.VaraineS.. 2023. “Intellectual Property Reform in the Laboratory.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization206: 204‐221.
9.
BornsteinG. 1992. “The Free-Rider Problem in Intergroup Conflicts Over Step-Level and Continuous Public Goods.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology62 (4): 597.
10.
BornsteinG.Ben-YossefM.. 1994. “Cooperation in Intergroup and Single-Group Social Dilemmas.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology30 (1): 52‐67.
11.
BornsteinG.ErevI.GorenH.. 1994. “The Effect of Repeated Play in the IPG and IPD Team Games.” Journal of Conflict Resolution38 (4): 690‐707.
12.
BouldenJ. 2009. “Terrorism and Civil Wars.” Civil Wars11 (1): 5‐21.
13.
BowlesS. 2009. “Did Warfare Among Ancestral Hunter-Gatherers Affect the Evolution of Human Social Behaviors?” Science324 (5932): 1293‐1298. doi:10.1126/science.1168112
14.
BucknerW.GlowackiL.. 2019. “Reasons to Strike First.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences42: e119.
15.
BöhmR.RuschH.GürerkO.. 2016. “What Makes People go to War? Defensive Intentions Motivate Retaliatory and Preemptive Intergroup Aggression.” Evolution and Human Behavior37 (1): 29‐34.
16.
ChagnonN. A. 1988. “Life Histories, Blood Revenge, and Warfare in a Tribal Population.” Science239 (4843): 985‐992.
17.
ChenD. L.SchongerM.WickensC.. 2016. “oTree—An Open-Source Platform for Laboratory, Online, and Field Experiments.” Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance9: 88‐97.
18.
ChoiJ. K.BowlesS.. 2007. “The Coevolution of Parochial Altruism and War.” Science318 (5850): 636‐640.
19.
ClarkR. P. 1983. “Patterns in the Lives of ETA Members.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism6 (3): 423‐454.
20.
CollierP.HoefflerA.. 2004. “Greed and Grievance in Civil War.” Oxford Economic Papers56 (4): 563‐595.
21.
De DreuC. K.BallietD.HalevyN.. 2014. “Parochial Cooperation in Humans: Forms and Functions of Self-Sacrifice in Intergroup Conflict.” In Advances in Motivation Science, Vol. 1, 1‐47. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
22.
De DreuC. K.GrossJ.. 2019. “Revisiting the Form and Function of Conflict: Neurobiological, Psychological, and Cultural Mechanisms for Attack and Defense Within and Between Groups.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences42: e116.
23.
De DreuC. K.GrossJ.FariñaA.MaY.. 2020. “Group Cooperation, Carrying-Capacity Stress, and Intergroup Conflict.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences24 (9): 760‐776.
24.
De DreuC. K.GrossJ.MéderZ.GiffinM.ProchazkovaE.KrikebJ.ColumbusS.. 2016. “In-Group Defense, Out-Group Aggression, and Coordination Failures in Intergroup Conflict.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113 (38): 10524‐10529.
25.
De DreuC. K.PliskinR.Rojek-GiffinM.MéderZ.GrossJ.. 2021. “Political Games of Attack and Defence.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B376 (1822): 20200135.
26.
De LucaG.SekerisP. G.. 2013. “Deterrence in Contests.” Economica80 (317): 171‐189.
27.
DebosM. 2011. “Living by the Gun in Chad: Armed Violence as a Practical Occupation.” The Journal of Modern African Studies49: 409‐428.
28.
Della PortaD. 2006. Social Movements, Political Violence, and the State: A Comparative Analysis of Italy and Germany. Cambridge University Press.
29.
DoğanG.GlowackiL.RuschH.. 2018. “Spoils Division Rules Shape Aggression Between Natural Groups.” Nature Human Behaviour2 (5): 322‐326.
30.
EggerC. M.Magni-BertonR.VaraineS.. 2020. “Jihadism Without Borders: The Rise of Foreign Fighters, Affiliated Terrorists and Lone Wolves Outside Civil Wars”.
31.
FearonJ. D.LaitinD. D.. 2003. “Ethnicity, Insurgency, and Civil War.” American Political Science Review97 (1): 75‐90.
32.
FehrE.GächterS.. 2002. “Altruistic Punishment in Humans.” Nature415 (6868): 137‐140.
33.
FindleyM. G.YoungJ. K.. 2012. “Terrorism and Civil War: A Spatial and Temporal Approach to a Conceptual Problem.” Perspectives on Politics10: 285‐305.
34.
FjeldeH. 2015. “Farming or Fighting? Agricultural Price Shocks and Civil War in Africa.” World Development67: 525‐534. doi:10.1016/j.worlddev.2014.10.032
35.
GarfinkelM. R.SyropoulosC.. 2020. “Inequality and Conflict: Burning Resources to Support Peace.” Economics Letters197: 109601. doi:10.1016/j.econlet.2020.109601
36.
GatA. 2008. War in Human Civilization. Oxford University Press.
37.
GhatakS. 2016. “Challenging the State: Effect of Minority Discrimination, Economic Globalization, and Political Openness on Domestic Terrorism.” International Interactions42 (1): 56‐80.
38.
GhatakS.GoldA.. 2017. “Development, Discrimination, and Domestic Terrorism: Looking Beyond a Linear Relationship.” Conflict Management and Peace Science34 (6): 618‐639.
39.
GhatakS.GoldA.PrinsB. C.. 2019. “Domestic Terrorism In Democratic States: Understanding and Addressing Minority Grievances.” Journal of Conflict Resolution63 (2): 439‐467.
40.
GhatakS.PrinsB. C.. 2017. “The Homegrown Threat: State Strength, Grievance, and Domestic Terrorism.” International Interactions43 (2): 217‐247.
41.
GingesJ.AtranS.. 2009. “What Motivates Participation in Violent Political Action.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences1167 (1): 115‐123.
42.
GlowackiL.WranghamR.. 2015. “Warfare and Reproductive Success in a Tribal Population.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences112 (2): 348‐353.
43.
GlowackiL.WranghamR. W.. 2013. “The Role of Rewards in Motivating Participation in Simple Warfare.” Human Nature24 (4): 444‐460. doi:10.1007/s12110-013-9178-8
44.
GorenH.BornsteinG.. 2000. “The Effects of Intragroup Communication on Intergroup Cooperation in the Repeated Intergroup Prisoner’s Dilemma (IPD) Game.” Journal of Conflict Resolution44 (5): 700‐719.
45.
GoudaM.MarktannerM.. 2019. “Muslim Youth Unemployment and Expat Jihadism: Bored to Death?” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism42 (10): 878‐897.
46.
GómezA.López-RodríguezL.SheikhH.GingesJ.WilsonL.WaziriH.VázquezA.DavisR.AtranS.. 2017. “The Devoted Actor’s Will to Fight and the Spiritual Dimension of Human Conflict.” Nature Human Behaviour1 (9): 673‐679.
47.
HalevyN. 2017. “Preemptive Strikes: Fear, Hope, and Defensive Aggression.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology112 (2): 224‐237.
48.
HalevyN.BornsteinG.SagivL.. 2008. “In-Group Love” and “Out-Group Hate” as Motives for Individual Participation in Intergroup Conflict: A New Game Paradigm.” Psychological Science19 (4): 405‐411.
49.
HalevyN.ChouE. Y.CohenT. R.BornsteinG.. 2010. “Relative Deprivation and Intergroup Competition.” Group Processes and Intergroup Relations13 (6): 685‐700.
50.
HalevyN.WeiselO.BornsteinG.. 2012. “In-Group Love” and “Out-Group Hate” in Repeated Interaction Between Groups.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making25 (2): 188‐195.
51.
HeckerM. 2018. 137 nuances de terrorisme. Les djihadistes de France face à la justice. Focus Stratégique 79. Institut Français des Relations Internationales.
52.
HegghammerT. 2016. “Revisiting the Poverty-Terrorism Link in European Jihadism.” In Society for Terrorism Research Annual Conference. Leiden.
53.
HegreHaØstbyG.RaleighC.. 2009. “Poverty and Civil War Events: A Disaggregated Study of Liberia.” Journal of Conflict Resolution53 (4): 598‐623.
54.
HoefflerA. 2011. “Greed’versus ‘Grievance’: A Useful Conceptual Distinction in the Study of Civil War?” Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism11 (2): 274‐284.
55.
HudsonR. A. 1999. The Sociology and Psychology of Terrorism: Who Becomes a Terrorist and Why? Technical Report. Washington: Library of Congress Washington Dc Federal Research Div.
56.
HumphreysM.WeinsteinJ. M.. 2008. “Who Fights? The Determinants of Participation in Civil War.” American Journal of Political Science52 (2): 436‐455.
57.
JakobsenT. G.De SoysaI.JakobsenJ.. 2013. “Why Do Poor Countries Suffer Costly Conflict? Unpacking Per Capita Income and the Onset of Civil War.” Conflict Management and Peace Science30 (2): 140‐160.
58.
KohutA.BellJ.. 2013. Muslim Publics Share Concerns About Extremist Groups. Technical report, Pew Research Center.
59.
KruegerA. B. 2017. What Makes a Terrorist. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.
60.
KruegerA. B.MalečkováJ.. 2003. “Education, Poverty and Terrorism: Is There a Causal Connection?” Journal of Economic Perspectives17 (4): 119‐144.
61.
LickelB.MillerN.StenstromD. M.DensonT. F.SchmaderT.. 2006. “Vicarious Retribution: The Role of Collective Blame in Intergroup Aggression.” Personality and Social Psychology Review10 (4): 372‐390. doi:10.1207/s15327957pspr1004_6
62.
McCauleyC. R. 2018. “Explaining Homegrown Western Jihadists: The Importance of Western Foreign Policy.” International Journal of Conflict and Violence (IJCV)12: a643‐a643.
63.
MittsT. 2019. “From Isolation to Radicalization: Anti-Muslim Hostility and Support for ISIS in the West.” American Political Science Review113 (1): 173‐194.
64.
National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START). 2017. “Global Terrorism Database.” http://www.start.umd.edu/gtd/
65.
NesserP. 2019. “Military Interventions, Jihadi Networks, and Terrorist Entrepreneurs: How the Islamic State Terror Wave Rose So High in Europe.” CTC Sentinel12 (3): 15‐21.
66.
NormanS. V. 2018. “Narcotization as Security Dilemma: The FARC and Drug Trade in Colombia.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism41 (8): 638‐659.
67.
OyefusiA. 2008. “Oil and the Probability of Rebel Participation Among Youths in the Niger Delta of Nigeria.” Journal of Peace Research45 (4): 539‐555.
68.
PaglieryJ. 2015. Inside the $2 billion ISIS war machine. CNN Money.
PiazzaJ. A. 2006. “Rooted in Poverty?: Terrorism, Poor Economic Development, and Social Cleavages.” Terrorism and Political Violence18 (1): 159‐177.
71.
PiazzaJ. A. 2011. “Poverty, Minority Economic Discrimination, and Domestic Terrorism.” Journal of Peace Research48 (3): 339‐353.
72.
PiazzaJ. A. 2012. “Types of Minority Discrimination and Terrorism.” Conflict Management and Peace Science29 (5): 521‐546.
73.
RebersS.KoopmansR.. 2012. “Altruistic Punishment and Between-Group Competition.” Human Nature23 (2): 173‐190.
74.
RekawekK.MatejkaS.SzucsV.BeňuškaT.KajzarováK.RafayJ.. 2018. Who are the European Jihadis. Project Midterm Report. GLOBSEC Policy Institute.
75.
RiekB. M.ManiaE. W.GaertnerS. L.. 2006. “Intergroup Threat and Outgroup Attitudes: A Meta-Analytic Review.” Personality and Social Psychology Review10 (4): 336‐353.
76.
RothM. P.SeverM.. 2007. “The Kurdish Workers Party (PKK) as Criminal Syndicate: Funding Terrorism Through Organized Crime, a Case Study.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism30 (10): 901‐920.
77.
RuschH. 2013. “Asymmetries in Altruistic Behavior During Violent Intergroup Conflict.” Evolutionary Psychology11 (5): 147470491301100504.
78.
RuschH. 2014. “The Two Sides of Warfare.” Human Nature25 (3): 359‐377.
79.
RuschH.BöhmR.. 2019. “A Note on the Endogeneity of Attacker and Defender Roles in Asymmetric Conflicts.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences42: e139.
80.
RussellC. A.MillerB. H.. 1977. “Profile of a Terrorist.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism1 (1): 17‐34.
81.
SagemanM. 2004. Understanding Terror Networks. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
82.
SahinF. S. 2001. Case Studies in Terrorism-drug Connection: The Kurdistan Workers’ Party, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, and the Shining Path. PhD Thesis. Denton: University of North Texas.
83.
SambanisN. 2008. “Terrorism and Civil War. In Terrorism, Economic Development, and Political Openness, 174‐206.
84.
SharvitK.KruglanskiA. W.WangM.ShevelandA.GanorB.AzaniE.. 2015. “Palestinian Public Opinion and Terrorism: A Two-Way Street?” Journal of Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism10 (2): 71‐87.
85.
SkaperdasS. 1998. “On the Formation of Alliances in Conflict and Contests.” Public Choice96 (1): 25‐42.
86.
SpeckhardA.AhkmedovaK.. 2006. “The Making of a Martyr: Chechen Suicide Terrorism.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism29 (5): 429‐492. doi:10.1080/10576100600698550
87.
SpeckhardA.EllenbergM. D.. 2020. “ISIS in Their Own Words: Recruitment History, Motivations for Joining, Travel, Experiences in ISIS, and Disillusionment over Time–Analysis of 220 In-depth Interviews of ISIS Returnees, Defectors and Prisoners.” Journal of Strategic Security13 (1): 5‐127.
88.
StenstromD. M.LickelB.DensonT. F.MillerN.. 2008. “The Roles of Ingroup Identification and Outgroup Entitativity in Intergroup Retribution.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin34 (11): 1570‐1582. doi:10.1177/0146167208322999
89.
SwannW. B.JettenJ.GómezA.WhitehouseH.BastianB.. 2012. “When Group Membership Gets Personal: A Theory of Identity Fusion.” Psychological Review119 (3): 441‐456.
90.
Sánchez-CuencaI.De la CalleL.. 2009. “Domestic Terrorism: The Hidden Side of Political Violence.” Annual Review of Political Science12: 31‐49.
91.
VaraineS.BenslimaneI.Magni-BertonR.CrosettoP.. 2023. “Attacking the Weak or the Strong? An Experiment on the Targets of Parochial Altruism.” Political Behavior45: 211‐242.
92.
VerwimpP. 2016. “Foreign Fighters in Syria and Iraq and the Socio-Economic Environment They Faced at Home: A Comparison of European Countries.” Perspectives on Terrorism10 (6): 68‐81.
93.
WeiselO.BöhmR.. 2015. “Ingroup Love” and “Outgroup Hate” in Intergroup Conflict Between Natural Groups.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology60: 110‐120.
94.
WeiselO.ZultanR.. 2016. “Social Motives in Intergroup Conflict: Group Identity and Perceived Target of Threat.” European Economic Review90: 122‐133.
95.
WeiselO.ZultanR.. 2021. “Perceptions of Conflict: Parochial Cooperation and Outgroup Spite Revisited.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes167: 57‐71.
96.
WhitehouseH. 2018. “Dying for the Group: Towards a General Theory of Extreme Self-Sacrifice.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences41: e192.
97.
WhitehouseH.McQuinnB.BuhrmesterM.SwannW. B.. 2014. “Brothers in Arms: Libyan Revolutionaries Bond Like Family.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences111 (50): 17783‐17785.
98.
WoodfordI.SmithM. L. R.. 2018. “The Political Economy of the Provos: Inside the Finances of the Provisional IRA—A Revision.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism41 (3): 213‐240.
99.
YangJ.ZhangH.NiJ.De DreuC. K.MaY.. 2020. “Within-Group Synchronization in the Prefrontal Cortex Associates With Intergroup Conflict.” Nature Neuroscience23 (6): 754‐760.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
