When rebel groups with state-building ambitions capture territory, who stays and why? Through semi-structured interviews and an original household survey in the Iraqi city of Mosul, which was controlled by the Islamic State for more than three years, I conduct a multi-method descriptive comparison of the characteristics of “stayers” against “leavers.” I test and find some quantitative and qualitative support for a theory of competitive governance: Civilians who perceived improvements in the quality of governance under IS rule—relative to the Iraqi state—were more likely to stay under IS rule than those who perceived no change or a deterioration, but displacement decisions are multi-causal, influenced by many factors including economic resources, social networks and family structures, information, threat perceptions, and ideology. These findings suggest that historical experiences with weak rule of law and bad governance by states may affect the attitudes and actions of civilians living under rebel governance.
AdhikariPrakash. 2013. “Conflict-induced Displacement, Understanding the Causes of Flight.” American Journal of Political Science57 (1): 82–89.
3.
AhmadRezan. 2015. خارجها الى السفر من الموصل سكان يمنع داعش تنظيم [“Daesh Prohibits Residents of Mosul from Traveling Outside”]. Bas News, January 5. http://www.basnews.com/index.php/ar/news/108791.
AlArabiya. 2013. المالكي باستقالة يطالب وعلاوي الأحد يجتمع العراق برلمان [“Parliament Convenes on Sunday And Allawi Demands the Resignation of al-Maliki”], January 5. http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2013/01/04/258613.html.
Ali MundiSamira. 2013. تحاول تنفيذ السيناريو السوري في العراق ر التظاهرات المناوئة للحكومة يؤشر إلى وجود أطراف محلل سياسي:استمرا [“Political Analyst: The Continuation of Anti-government Demonstrations Indicates the Presence of Parties Trying to Implement the Syrian Scenario in Iraq”]. Iraq Hurr, January 18. https://www.iraqhurr.org/a/24877486.html.
8.
ArjonaAna. 2016. Rebelocracy: Social Order in the Colombian Civil War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
9.
ArjonaAna. 2017. “Civilian Cooperation and Non-cooperation with Non-state Armed Groups: The Centrality of Obedience and Resistance.” Small Wars & Insurgencies28 (4-5): 755–78.
AtuaheneBernadette. 2016. “Dignity Takings and Dignity Restoration: Creating a New Theoretical Framework for Understanding Involuntary Property Loss and the Remedies Required.” Law & Social Inquiry41 (4): 796–823.
13.
Ayn al-Iraq News. 2014. الخروج من اهلها ويمنع محيطها عن نينوى يعزل داعش [“Daesh Isolates Ninewa from its Surroundings and Prohibits its Residents from Leaving”], November 30. http://www.aynaliraqnews.com/index.php?aa=newsid22=25880.
14.
Azzaman. 2012. بغداد بوابات على سنقاتل [“Sheikh al-Dalim: We Will Fight to the Gates of Baghdad”], December 27. https://www.azzaman.com/?p=21341.
15.
BaczkoAdamkoDorronsoroGillesQuesnayArthurYoussefMaa. 2016. “The Rationality of an Eschatological Movement: The Islamist State in Iraq and Syria.” The Program on Governance and Local Development Working Paper No. 7, Program on Governance and Local Development. University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden.
16.
BalcellsLaia. 2018. “Dynamics of Internal Resettlement during Civil War: Evidence from Catalonia (1936–39).” Journal of Peace Research55 (2): 236–51.
17.
BermanEliJShapiroJacobFelteroseph. 2011. “Can Hearts and Minds Be Bought? The Economics of Counterinsurgency in Iraq.” Journal of Political Economy119 (4): 766–819.
18.
BlairGraemeImaiKosukeLyallJason. 2014. “Comparing and Combining List and Endorsement Experiments: Evidence from Afghanistan.” American Journal of Political Science58 (4): 1043–63.
19.
Bohra-MishraPratikshyaMasseyDouglas. 2011. “Individual Decisions to Migrate during Civil Conflict.” Demography48 (2): 401–24.
20.
BoydMonica. 1989. “Family and Personal Networks in International Migration: Recent Developments and New Agendas.” International Migration Review23 (3): 638–70.
21.
CooperDavina. 2007. “Opening Up Ownership: Community Belonging, Belongings, and the Productive Life of Property.” Law & Social Inquiry32 (3): 625–64.
22.
CunninghamKathleen GallagherHuangReykoSawyerKatherine. 2021. “Voting for Militants: Rebel Elections in Civil War.” Journal of Conflict Resolution65 (1): 81–107. doi: 10.1177/0022002720937750.
CzaikaMathiasKis-KatosKrisztina. 2009. “Civil Conflict and Displacement: Village-level Determinants of Forced Migration in Aceh.” Journal of Peace Research46 (3): 399–418.
25.
DavenportChristianMooreWillPoeSteven. 2003. “Sometimes You Just Have to Leave: Domestic Threats and Forced Migration, 1964–1989.” International Interaction29 (1): 27–55.
26.
DuyvesteynIsabelle. 2017. “Rebels & Legitimacy; An Introduction.” Small Wars & Insurgencies28 (4–5): 669–85.
27.
EdwardsScott. 2009. The Chaos of Forced Migration: A Means of Modeling Complexity for Humanitarian Ends. Saarbrücken, Germany: VDM Verlag.
28.
ElliottJamesPaisJeremy. 2006. “Race, Class, and Hurricane Katrina: Social Differences in Human Responses to Disaster.” Social Science Research35 (2): 295–321.
29.
EngelStefanieIbáñezAna María. 2007. “Displacement Due to Violence in Colombia: A Household-level Analysis.” Economic Development and Cultural Change55 (2): 335–65.
30.
FairChristineLittmanRebeccaNugentElizabeth. 2018. “Conceptions of Sharia and Support for Militancy and Democratic Values: Evidence from Pakistan.” Political Science Research and Methods6 (3): 429–48.
31.
GhosnFatenParkinsonSarah. 2019. ““Finding” Sectarianism and Strife in Lebanon.” Political Science & Politics52 (3): 494–97.
32.
GranovetterMark. 1978. “Threshold Models of Collective Behavior.” American Journal of Sociology83 (6): 1420–43.
33.
Herak. 2013. تموز جمعة لالحكومة الفوضى والدماء 17 هتافات متظاهرين حي [“Shouts of Protesters in July 17th Neighborhood: No to the Government of Chaos and Blood–Mosul–Ninewa”], YouTube, June 24. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFFKv-RVilM.
34.
HiwatariMasato. 2016. “Social Networks and Migration Decisions: The Influence of Peer Effects in Rural Households in Central Asia.” Journal of Comparative Economics44 (4): 1115–31.
35.
HollandAlisha C.PetersMargaret E.. 2020. “Explaining Migration Timing: Political Information and Opportunities.” International Organization74 (3): 560–83.
36.
HuangReyko. 2016. The Wartime Origins of Democratization: Civil War, Rebel Governance, and Political Regimes. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Islamic State. 2015b. إلى: الأطباء والصيادلة وأساتذة الطب والتمريض الذين غادروا أرض الخلافة إنذار نهائي [“To: Doctors, Pharmacists, Medical and Nursing Professors Who Have Abandoned the Land of the Caliphate; Subject: Ultimatum”]. Diwan of Health, May 18. http://www.aymennjawad.org/2015/01/archive-of-islamic-state-administrative-documents.
KaplanOliver. 2017. Resisting War: How Communities Protect Themselves. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
47.
KasfirNelson. 2005. “Guerrillas and Civilian Participation: The National Resistance Army in Uganda, 1981–86.” The Journal of Modern African Studies43 (2): 271–96.
KasfirNelson. 2015. “Rebel Governance–Constructing a Field of Inquiry: Definitions, Scope, Patterns, Order, Causes. In Rebel Governance in Civil War, edited by ArjonaAnaNelsonKasfirZachariahMampilly, 21–46. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
50.
KasfirNelsonFrerksGeorgTerpstraNiels. 2017. “Introduction: Armed Groups and Multi-layered Introduction: Armed Groups and Multi-layered Introduction: Armed Groups and Multi-layered Governance.” Civil Wars19 (3): 257–78.
KishLeslie. 1949. “A Procedure for Objective Respondent Selection within the Household.” Journal of the American Statistical Association44 (247): 380–87.
53.
KrauseJana. 2018. Resilient Communities: Non-violence and Civilian Agency in Communal War. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
54.
LahoudNelly. 2017. “Can Women Be Soldiers of the Islamic State?” Survival59 (1): 61–78.
55.
LeviMargaret. 1988. Of Rule and Revenue. Berkeley: University of California Press.
56.
LoyleCyanne. 2021. “Rebel Justice during Armed Conflict.” Journal of Conflict Resolution65 (1): 108–34. doi: 10.1177/0022002720939299.
57.
LyallJasonShiraitoYukiImaiKosuke. 2015. “Coethnic Bias and Wartime Informing.” Journal of Politics77 (3): 833–48.
58.
MalkkiLiisa. 2012. Purity and Exile: Violence, Memory, and National Cosmology among Hutu Refugees in Tanzania. Chicago: University of Chicago.
59.
MampillyZachariah. 2011. Rebel Rulers: Insurgent Governance and Civilian Life During War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
60.
MampillyZachariah. 2015. “Performing the Nation-State: Rebel Governance and Symbolic Processes.” In Rebel Governance in Civil War, edited by AnaArjonaNelsonKasfirZachariahMampilly, 74–97. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
61.
MampillyZachariahStewartMegan A.. 2021. “A Typology of Rebel Political Institutional Arrangements.” Journal of Conflict Resolution65 (1): 15–45. doi: 10.1177/0022002720935642.
MooreMick. 2008. “Between Coercion and Contract: Competing Narratives on Taxation and Governance.” In Taxation and State-building in Developing Countries: Capacity and Consent, edited by BrautigamDeborahOdd-HelgeFjeldstadMickMoore, 34–63. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
64.
MooreWillShellmanStephen. 2007. “Whither Will They Go? A Global Study of Refugees’ Destinations, 1965–1995.” International Studies Quarterly51:811–34.
PrichardWilson. 2015. Taxation, Responsiveness and Accountability in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Dynamics of Tax Bargaining. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
69.
RadinMargaret Jane. 1981. “Property and Personhood.” Stanford Law Review34:957–1015.
RevkinMara Redlich. 2018a. After the Islamic State: Balancing Accountability and Reconciliation in Iraq. New York: United Nations University Centre for Policy Research.
73.
RevkinMara Redlich. 2018b. “When Terrorists Govern: Protecting Civilians in Conflicts with State-building Armed Groups.” Harvard National Security Journal9:100–45.
74.
RevkinMara Redlich. 2020. “What Explains Taxation by Resource-rich Rebels? Evidence from the Islamic State in Syria.” Journal of Politics82 (2): 757–64.
75.
RobinsonEricEgelDanielJohnstonPatrickMannSeanRothenbergAlexanderStebbinsDavid. 2017. “When the Islamic State Comes to Town: The Economic Impact of Islamic State Governance in Iraq and Syria.” RAND Corporation. Accessed August 21, 2020. https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR1970.html.
76.
RosemanCurtis C.1971. “Migration as a Spatial and Temporal Process.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers61 (3): 589–98.
77.
SchlichteKlaus. 2009. In the Shadow of Violence: The Politics of Armed Groups, vol. 1. Frankfurt, Germany: Campus Verlag.
78.
SchmeidlSusanne. 1997. “Exploring the Causes of Forced Migration: A Pooled Time-series Analysis, 1971–1990.” Social Science Quarterly78 (2): 284–308.
79.
SchonJustin. 2019. “Motivation and Opportunity for Conflict-induced Migration: An Analysis of Syrian Migration Timing.” Journal of Peace Research56 (1): 12–27.
Shawkwmakw. 2015. داعش اصدر ضوابط جديدة من أجل منع سكان مدينة الموصل من مغادرتها [“Daesh Issues New Regulations to Prevent the Residents of Mosul from Leaving”], March 13. goo.gl/3QEn3W.
SolomonErica. 2017. العراق في جديد جرح بفتح ينذر «داعش» صفحة طي . نينوى [“Ninewa: The Collapse of Daesh Brings the Opening of a New Wound in Iraq”]. al-Iqtisadiya, May 13. http://www.aleqt.com/2017/05/13/article_1186616.html.
84.
SteeleAbbey. 2018. “IDP Resettlement and Collective Targeting during Civil Wars: Evidence from Colombia.” Journal of Peace Research55 (6): 810–24.
85.
StewartMegan. 2018. “Civil War as State-making: Strategic Governance in Civil War.” International Organization72 (1): 205–26.
WinterCharlie. 2018. “Apocalypse, Later: A Longitudinal Study of the Islamic State Brand.” Critical Studies in Media Communication35 (1): 103–21.
91.
WoodElisabeth Jean. 2003. Insurgent Collective Action and Civil War in El Salvador. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
92.
YouTube. 2013. العباده مع تنظيم داعش اهل الموصل يحتفلون بسقوط الموصل والرقص في مساجد [“The People of Mosul Celebrate the Fall of Mosul and Dance in Mosques in Support of Daesh”]. YouTube, June 24. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zscEq6sDlPg.
93.
YouTube. 2014. المالكي جيش من بتحريرها الموصل احتفالات [“Celebrations in Mosul after the City’s Liberation from al-Maliki’s Army”]. YouTube, June 12. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xDLz94Kbk8.
94.
Zaidal-Anzi. 2017. بداعش الموصل أهل فرحة حقيقة [“The Truth of the Happiness of the People of Mosul over Daesh”]. Noon Post, June 24, https://www.noonpost.org/content/3039.
95.
ZanganaHaifa. 2014. بداعش؟ الموصل اهل رحب لماذا [“Why Did Mosul Welcome ISIS?”]. Al-Quds, June. 25. http://www.alquds.co.uk/?p=184079.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
