Exposure to a single report about terrorism in the mass media can trigger a range of emotional and political reactions. The consequences of exposure to several terrorism reports in row, however, are a matter of controversy. We examine the effects of prolonged terrorism coverage using an experimental design that combines self-report measures of emotions and political attitudes with instantaneous biometric data on emotions. Consistent with research on nonassociational learning, we find that exposure to multiple videos habituates people to depictions of terrorism: the longer people watch terrorism coverage, the less intense their reactions are to the images of terrorism they see. Some images and videos, however, contribute to this result more than others. This suggests that the ultimate effects of terrorism coverage depend on the interplay between the quantity and quality of reporting, not the quantity alone.
AberJ. LawrenceGershoffElizabeth T.WareAngelicaKotlerJennifer A.. 2004. “Estimating the Effects of September 11th and Other Forms of Violence on the Mental Health and Social Development of New York City’s Youth: A Matter of Context.” Applied Developmental Science8:111–29.
2.
AlbertsonBethanyGadarianShana Kushner. 2015. Anxious Politics: Democratic Citizenship in a Threatening World. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
3.
BanduraAlbertAdamsNancy E.BeyerJanice. 1977. “Cognitive Processes Mediating Behavioral Change.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology35:125–39.
4.
BartholowBruce D.BushmanBrad J.SestirMarc A.. 2006. “Chronic Violent Video Game Exposure and Desensitization to Violence: Behavioral and Event-related Brain Potential Data.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology42:532–39.
5.
BauschAndrew W.FariaJoao R.ZeitzoffThomas. 2013. “Warnings, Terrorist Threats and Resilience: A Laboratory Experiment.” Conflict Management and Peace Science30:433–51.
6.
BleichA.GelkopfM.SolomonZ.. 2003. “Exposure to Terrorism, Stress-related Mental Health Symptoms, and Coping Behaviors among a Nationally Representative Sample in Israel.” Journal of the American Medical Association290:612–20.
7.
BonannoGeorgeKeltnerDacher. 2004. “Brief Report the Coherence of Emotion Systems: Comparing “on-Line” Measures of Appraisal and Facial Expressions, and Self-Report.” Cognition and Emotion18:431–44.
8.
BonannoGeorge A.GaleaSandroBucciarelliAngelaVlahovDavid. 2006. “Psychological Resilience after Disaster: New York City in the Aftermath of the September 11th Terrorist Attack.” Psychological Science17:181–86.
9.
BoothRobert WilliamSharmaDinkarLeaderT. I.. 2016. “The Age of Anxiety? It Depends Where You Look: Changes in Stai Trait Anxiety, 1970–2010.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology51:193–202.
10.
Box-SteffensmeierJanet MFreemanJohn RHittMatthew PPevehouseJon CW. 2014. Time Series Analysis for the Social Sciences. Cambridge University Press.
11.
BradleyMargaret M.CuthbertBruce N.LangPeter J.. 1996. “Picture Media and Emotion: Effects of a Sustained Affective Context.” Psychophysiology33:662–70.
12.
BreckenridgeJames N.ZimbardoPhilip G.SweetonJennifer L.. 2010. “After Years of Media Coverage, Can One More Video Report Trigger Heuristic Judgments? A National Study of American Terrorism Risk Perceptions.” Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression2:163–78.
13.
BrosschotJos F.2002. “Cognitive-emotional Sensitization and Somatic Health Complaints.” Scandinavian Journal of Psychology43:113–21.
14.
CampbellDonald T.StanleyJulian C.. 1963. Experimental and Quasi-experimental Designs for Research. Chicago: Rand McNally.
15.
CarnageyNicholas L.AndersonCraig A.BushmanBrad J.. 2007. “The Effect of Video Game Violence on Physiological Desensitization to Real-life Violence.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology43:489–96.
16.
CheckelJeffrey T.2001. “Why Comply? Social Learning and European Identity Change.” International Organization55:553–88.
17.
ClarkTaylor. 2011. Nerve: Poise under Pressure, Serenity under Stress, and the Brave New Science of Fear and Cool. New York: Little, Brown and Company.
18.
CodispotiMaurizioFerrariVeraBradleyMargaret M.. 2006. “Repetitive Picture Processing: Autonomic and Cortical Correlates.” Brain Research1068:213–20.
19.
CohnJeffrey F.AmbadarZaraEkmanPaul. 2007. “Observer-based Measurement of Facial Expression with the Facial Action Coding System.” In The Handbook of Emotion Elicitation and Assessment, edited by CoanJ. A.AllenJ. J. B., 203–21. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
20.
CrescenziMark J. C.2007. “Reputation and Interstate Conflict.” American Journal of Political Science51:382–96.
21.
DasEnnyBushmanBrad J.BezemerMarieke D.KerkhofPeterVermeulenIvar E.. 2009. “How Terrorism News Reports Increase Prejudice against Outgroups: A Terror Management Account.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology45:453–59.
22.
DavisDarren W.SilverBrian D.. 2004. “Civil Liberties vs. Security: Public Opinion in the Context of the Terrorist Attacks on America.” American Journal of Political Science48:28–46.
23.
DeatonAngusCartwrightNancy. 2018. “Understanding and Misunderstanding Randomized Controlled Trials.” Social Science & Medicine210:2–21.
24.
Den UylM. J.Van KuilenburgH.. 2005. “The Facereader: Online Facial Expression Recognition.” Paper presented at the Proceedings of Measuring Behavior, Wageningen, the Netherlands.
25.
Di TellaRafaelFreiraLucíaGálvezRamiro H.SchargrodskyErnestoShalomDiegoSigmanMariano. 2019. “Crime and Violence: Desensitization in Victims to Watching Criminal Events.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization159:613–25.
26.
FoaEdna B.KozakMichael J.. 1986. “Emotional Processing of Fear: Exposure to Corrective Information.” Psychological Bulletin99:20.
27.
GadarianShana Kushner. 2010. “The Politics of Threat: How Terrorism News Shapes Foreign Policy Attitudes.” The Journal of Politics72:469–83.
28.
GalReuven. 2014. “Social Resilience in Times of Protracted Crises: An Israeli Case Study.” Armed Forces & Society40:452–75.
29.
GarciaBlake E.GevaNehemia. 2014. “Security versus Liberty in the Context of Counterterrorism: An Experimental Approach.” Terrorism and Political Violence28:1–19.
30.
GelpiChristopherFeaverPeter D.ReiflerJason. 2009. Paying the Human Costs of War: American Public Opinion and Casualties in Military Conflicts. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
31.
GigerenzerGerd. 2006. “Out of the Frying Pan into the Fire: Behavioral Reactions to Terrorist Attacks.” Risk Analysis26:347–51.
32.
GilbertDaniel. 2009. Stumbling on Happiness. Vintage Canada.
33.
GosselinPierrePerronMelanieBeaupréMartin. 2010. “The Voluntary Control of Facial Action Units in Adults.” Emotion10:266.
34.
GrizzardMatthewTamboriniRonSherryJohn L.WeberRenéPrabhuSujayHahnLindsayIdzikPatrick. 2015. “The Thrill Is Gone, but You Might Not Know: Habituation and Generalization of Biophysiological and Self-reported Arousal Responses to Video Games.” Communication Monographs82:64–87.
35.
GrovesPhilip M.ThompsonRichard F.. 1970. “Habituation: A Dual-process Theory.” Psychological Review77:419.
36.
HallTodd H.RossAndrew A. G.. 2015. “Affective Politics after 9/11.” International Organization69:847–79.
37.
Helweg-LarsenMarieShepperdJames A.. 2001. “Do Moderators of the Optimistic Bias Affect Personal or Target Risk Estimates? A Review of the Literature.” Personality and Social Psychology Review5:74–95.
38.
HobfollStevan E.Canetti-NisimDaphnaJohnsonRobert J.. 2006. “Exposure to Terrorism, Stress-related Mental Health Symptoms, and Defensive Coping among Jews and Arabs in Israel.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology74:207–18.
39.
HobfollStevan E.ManciniAnthony D.HallBrian J.CanettiDaphnaBonannoGeorge A.. 2011. “The Limits of Resilience: Distress following Chronic Political Violence among Palestinians.” Social Science & Medicine72:1400–08.
40.
HoffmanAaron M.JengelleyDwaine H. A.DuncanNatasha T.BuehlerMelissaReesMeredith L.. 2010. “How Does the Business of News Influence Terrorism Coverage? Evidence from the Washington Post and USA Today.” Terrorism and Political Violence22:559–80.
41.
HoffmanAaron M.ShelbyWilliam. 2017. “When the ‘Laws of Fear’ Do Not Apply: Effective Counterterrorism and the Sense of Security from Terrorism.” Political Research Quarterly70:618–31.
42.
HolmanE. AlisonGarfinDana RoseSilverRoxane Cohen. 2014. “Media’s Role in Broadcasting Acute Stress following the Boston Marathon Bombings.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America111:93–98.
43.
HopwoodTanya L.SchutteNicola S.. 2017. “Psychological Outcomes in Reaction to Media Exposure to Disasters and Large-scale Violence: A Meta-analysis.” Psychology of Violence7:316–27.
44.
HoughtonDavid Patrick. 2001. US Foreign Policy and the Iran Hostage Crisis. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
45.
HuddyLeonieFeldmanStanleyTaberCharlesLahavGallya. 2005. “Threat, Anxiety, and Support of Antiterrorism Policies.” American Journal of Political Science49:593–608.
46.
JhangianiRajiv. 2009. “Psychological Concomitants of the 11 September 2001 Terrorist Attacks: A Review.” Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression2:38–69.
47.
KertzerJoshua D.2017. “Resolve, Time, and Risk.” International Organization71:S109–36.
48.
KlarYechielZakayDanSharvitKeren. 2002. “‘If I Don’t Get Blown Up…’: Realism in Face of Terrorism in an Israeli Nationwide Sample.” Risk, Decision and Policy7:203–19.
49.
KohutAndrewDohertyCarrollDimockMichaelKeeterScott. 2010. “Americans Spending More Time Following the News.” Pew Research Center.
50.
KrahéBarbaraMöllerIngridRowell HuesmannL.KirwilLucynaFelberJulianeBergerAnja. 2011. “Desensitization to Media Violence: Links with Habitual Media Violence Exposure, Aggressive Cognitions, and Aggressive Behavior.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology100:630.
51.
LeboMatthew J.Box-SteffensmeierJanet M.. 2008. “Dynamic Conditional Correlations in Political Science.” American Journal of Political Science52:688–704.
52.
LernerJennifer S.GonzalezRoxana M.SmallDeborah A.FischhoffBaruch. 2003. “Effects of Fear and Anger on Perceived Risks of Terrorism: A National Field Experiment.” Psychological Science14:144–50.
53.
LernerJennifer S.KeltnerDacher. 2001. “Fear, Anger, and Risk.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology81:146–59.
54.
LevyJack S.1994. “Learning and Foreign Policy: Sweeping a Conceptual Minefield.” International Organization48:279–312.
55.
LewinskiPeterden UylTim MButlerCrystal. 2014. “Automated Facial Coding: Validation of Basic Emotions and FACS AUs in Facereader.” Journal of Neuroscience, Psychology, and Economics7:227–36.
56.
LewinskiPeterFransenMarieke L.TanEd S. H.. 2014. “Predicting Advertising Effectiveness by Facial Expressions in Response to Amusing Persuasive Stimuli.” Journal of Neuroscience, Psychology, and Economics7:1–14.
57.
LibermanPeterSkitkaLinda J.. 2017. “Revenge in Us Public Support for War against Iraq.” Public Opinion Quarterly81:636–60.
58.
MerollaJennifer L.RamosJennifer M.ZechmeisterElizabeth J.. 2007. “Crisis, Charisma, and Consequences: Evidence from the 2004 U.S. Presidential Election.” Journal of Politics69:30–42.
59.
MerollaJennifer L.ZechmeisterElizabeth J.. 2009. Democracy at Risk: How Terrorist Threats Affect the Public. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
60.
MillerMark W.HarringtonKelly M.. 2011. “Personality Factors in Resilience to Traumatic Stress.” In Resilience and Mental Health: Challenges across the Lifespan, edited by SouthwickStevenLitzBrett T.CharneyDennisFriedmanMatthew, 56–75. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
61.
MuellerJohn. 1970. War, Presidents, and Public Opinion. New York: Wiley.
62.
MuellerJohn. 2006. Overblown: How Politicians and the Terrorism Industry Inflate National Security Threats, and Why We Believe Them. New York: The Free Press.
63.
NacosBrigitte L.2007. Mass-Mediated Terrorism: The Central Role of the Media in Terrorism and Counterterrorism. Second ed. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
64.
NellisAshley MarieSavageJoanne. 2012. “Does Watching the News Affect Fear of Terrorism? The Importance of Media Exposure on Terrorism Fear.” Crime & Delinquency58:748–68.
65.
Nolen-HoeksemaSusanWiscoBlair E.LyubomirskySonja. 2008. “Rethinking Rumination.” Perspectives on Psychological Science3:400–24.
66.
ÖhmanArne. 2000. “Fear and Anxiety: Evolutionary, Cognitive, and Clinical Perspectives.” In Handbook of Emotions, 2nd ed., edited by LewisMichaelHaviland-JonesJeanette M., 573–93. New York: Guilford Press.
67.
OvermierJ. Bruce. 2002. “Sensitization, Conditioning, and Learning: Can They Help Us Understand Somatization and Disability?” Scandinavian Journal of Psychology43:105–12.
RankinCatharine H.AbramsThomasBarryRobert J.BhatnagarSeemaClaytonDavid F.ColomboJohnCoppolaGianluca. 2009. “Habituation Revisited: An Updated and Revised Description of the Behavioral Characteristics of Habituation.” Neurobiology of Learning and Memory92:135–38.
70.
RenshonJonathanLeeJulia J.TingleyDustin. 2017. “Emotions and the Micro-foundations of Commitment Problems.” International Organization71:S189–218.
71.
RomanovDmitriZussmanAsafZussmanNoam. 2012. “Does Terrorism Demoralize? Evidence from Israel.” Economica79:183–98.
72.
RomerDanielJamiesonKathleen HallAdaySean. 2003. “Television News and the Cultivation of Fear of Crime.” Journal of Communication53:88–104.
73.
RubinG. JamesBrewinChris R.GreenbergNeilSimpsonJohnWesselySimon. 2005. “Psychological and Behavioural Reactions to the Bombings in London on 7 July 2005: Cross Sectional Survey of a Representative Sample of Londoners.” British Medical Journal331:606–06.
74.
RuiterRobert A. C.KesselsLoes T. E.PetersGjalt-Jorn Y.KokGerjo. 2014. “Sixty Years of Fear Appeal Research: Current State of the Evidence.” International Journal of Psychology49:63–70.
75.
SchusterMark A.SteinBradley D.JaycoxLisa H.CollinsRebecca L.MarshallGrant N.ElliottMarc N.ZhouAnnie J.KanouseDavid E.MorrisonJanina L.BerrySandra H.. 2001. “A National Survey of Stress Reactions after the September 11, 2001, Terrorist Attacks.” New England Journal of Medicine345:1507–12.
76.
SearsDavid O.1986. “College Sophomores in the Laboratory: Influences of a Narrow Data Base on Social Psychology’s View of Human Nature.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology51:515–30.
77.
SellAaronToobyJohnCosmidesLeda. 2009. “Formidability and the Logic of Human Anger.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America106:15073–78.
78.
ShorBorisBafumiJosephKeeleLukeParkDavid. 2007. “A Bayesian Multilevel Modeling Approach to Time-series Cross-sectional Data.” Political Analysis15:165–81.
79.
SilverRoxane CohenAlison HolmanE.McIntoshDaniel N.PoulinMichaelGil-RivasVirginia. 2002. “Nationwide Longitudinal Study of Psychological Responses to September 11.” The Journal of the American Medical Association288:1235–44.
80.
SloneMichelle. 2000. “Responses to Media Coverage of Terrorism.” Journal of Conflict Resolution44:508–22.
81.
SloneMichelleShoshaniAnatBaumgarten-KatzInbar. 2008. “The Relation between Actual Exposure to Political Violence and Preparatory Intervention for Exposure to Media Coverage of Terrorism.” Anxiety, Stress, & Coping21:243–61.
82.
SmithJ. CarsonBradleyMargaret M.LangPeter J.. 2005. “State Anxiety and Affective Physiology: Effects of Sustained Exposure to Affective Pictures.” Biological Psychology69:247–60.
SpilermanSeymourStecklovGuy. 2009. “Societal Responses to Terrorist Attacks.” Annual Review of Sociology35:167–89.
85.
SunsteinCass R.2005. Laws of Fear: Beyond the Precautionary Principle. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
86.
TerzisVasileiosMoridisChristos N.EconomidesAnastasios A.. 2013. “Measuring Instant Emotions Based on Facial Expressions during Computer-based Assessment.” Personal and Ubiquitous Computing17:43–52.
87.
ThompsonRichard F.2009. “Habituation: A History.” Neurobiology of Learning and Memory92:127–34.
88.
TseY. K.2000. “A Test for Constant Correlations in a Multivariate Garch Model.” Journal of Econometrics98:107–27.
89.
UrsinHolger. 2014. “Brain Sensitization to External and Internal Stimuli.” Psychoneuroendocrinology42:134–45.
90.
ValadezJose J.FergusonChristopher J.. 2012. “Just a Game after All: Violent Video Game Exposure and Time Spent Playing Effects on Hostile Feelings, Depression, and Visuospatial Cognition.” Computers in Human Behavior28:608–16.
91.
WaymentHeidi A.2004. “It Could Have Been Me: Vicarious Victims and Disaster-focused Distress.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin30:515–28.
92.
WillerRobbAdamsNick. 2008. “The Threat of Terrorism and Support for the 2008 Presidential Candidates: Results of a National Field Experiment.” Current Research in Social Psychology14:1–22.
93.
WitteKim. 1992. “Putting the Fear Back into Fear Appeals: The Extended Parallel Process Model.” Communication Monographs59:329–49.
94.
YechiamEldadBarronGregErevIdo. 2005. “The Role of Personal Experience in Contributing to Different Patterns of Response to Rare Terrorist Attacks.” Journal of Conflict Resolution49:430–39.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
