Curved structures made of fibre-reinforced plastics tend to show an out-of-plane failure type, when loaded under bending. One method to determine the related tensile strength in thickness direction, is the standardised unfolding test related to ASTM D6415 with L-profile specimens. However, the standard shall be used for unidirectional materials only, which is not the case for multidirectional laminates. Therefore, this publication presents methods to determine the layer-wise stress and strain state as well as occurring failure types of multidirectional laminates. An extension of the Lekhnitski formulae is presented and its results are validated by comparison with high resolution strain measurements by Digital Image Correlation. Based on the analytical solution, a failure analysis using Cuntze’s Failure Mode Concept is conducted. It was revealed, that the failure load and position can be predicted accurately, if a failure type related strength –in-plane or out-of-plane failure– is used. In the presence of -layers higher deviations occur between test and prediction and therefore limits the validity of the presented analytical failure analysis.
KimJ-HNguyenK-HChoiJ-H, et al.
Experimental and finite element analysis of curved composite structures with C-section. Compos Struct2016;
140: 106–117.
2.
ShenoiRAWangWN.Through-thickness stresses in curved composite laminates and sandwich beams. Compos Sci Technol2001;
61: 1501–1512.
3.
OlssonR.A survey of test methods for multiaxial and out-of-plane strength of composite laminates. Compos Sci Technol2011;
71: 773–783.
4.
ASTM D7291/D7291M.Standard test method for through-thickness “flatwise” tensile strength and elastic modulus of a fiber-reinforced polymer matrix composite material.
West Conshohocken, PA:
ASTM International, 2015.
5.
BenzeggaghMLKhellilKChotardT.Experimental determination of TSAI failure tensorial terms Fij for unidirectional composite materials. Compos Sci Technol1995;
55: 145–156.
6.
HaraEYokozekiTHattaH, et al.
Effects of geometry and specimen size on out-of-plane tensile strength of aligned CFRP determined by direct tensile method. Compos Part A Appl Sci2010;
41: 1425–1433.
7.
HaraEYokozekiTHattaH, et al.
Comparison of out-of-plane tensile moduli of CFRP laminates obtained by 3-point bending and direct loading tests. Compos Part A Appl Sci2014;
67: 77–85.
8.
HielCCSumichMChappellDP.A curved beam test specimen for determining the interlaminar tensile strength of a laminated composite. J Compos Mater1991;
25: 854–868.
9.
TasdemirBCokerD.Comparison of damage mechanisms in curved composite laminates under static and fatigue loading. Compos Struct2019;
213: 190–203.
10.
WimmerGKitzmüllerWPinterG, et al.
Computational and experimental investigation of delamination in L-shaped laminated composite components. Eng Frac Mech2009;
76: 2810–2820.
11.
WisnomM, R.3-D finite element analysis of curved beams in bending. J Compos Mater1996;
30: 1178–1190.
12.
ASTM D6415/D6415M-06a. Standard test method for measuring the curved beam strength of fiber reinforced polymer matrix composite. West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM International, 2013.
13.
ThurnherrCGrohRMJErmanniP, et al.
Higher-order beam model for stress predictions in curved beams made from anisotropic material. Int J Solids Struct2016;
97–98: 16–28.
14.
ThurnherrCGrohRMJErmanniP, et al.
Investigation of failure initiation in curved composite laminates using a higher-order beam model. Compos Struct2017;
168: 143–152.
15.
González-CanteroJMGracianiEBlázquezA, et al.
A new analytical model for evaluating interlaminar stresses in the unfolding failure of composite laminates. Compos Struct2016;
147: 260–273.
16.
González-CanteroJMGracianiEParísF, et al.
Semi-analytic model to evaluate non-regularized stresses causing unfolding failure in composites. Compos Struct2017;
171: 77–91.
17.
CharrierJ-SLaurinFCarrereN, et al.
S., Determination of the out-of-plane tensile strength using four-point bending tests on laminated L-angle specimens with different stacking sequences and total thicknesses. Compos Part A Appl Sci2016;
81: 243–253.
18.
HoffmannM. Festigkeitskennwerte in Laminatdickenrichtung zur Versagensanalyse dicker und/oder dreidimensional belasteter FKV-Laminate. Doctoral Thesis University of Stuttgart, Verlag Dr. Hut, Munich, 2018.
19.
LevequeDLaurinFMavelA, et al. Investigation on failure mechanisms of composite structures subjected to 3D state of stresses. In: Proceedings of the SEM annual conference, June 7–10, 2010, Indianapolis, IN, USA.
20.
MakeevASeonGNikishkovY, et al.
Methods for assessment of interlaminar tensile strength of composite materials. J Compos Mater2015;
49: 783–794.
21.
AvalonSCDonaldsonSL.Strength of composite angle brackets with multiple geometries and nanofiber-enhanced resins. J Compos Mater2011;
45: 1017–1030.
22.
NguyenKHJuH-WTruongV-H, et al.
Delamination analysis of multi-angle composite curved beams using an out-of-autoclave material. Compos Struct2018;
183: 320–330.
23.
LiWMaHGaoW.Geometrically exact curved beam element using internal force field defined in deformed configuration. Int J Nonlin Mech2017;
89: 116–126.
24.
RohwerKKappelEStefaniakD, et al.
Spring-in and Warpage – progress in simulating manufacturing aspects. Mech Compos Mater2013;
49: 193–200.
25.
KappelEStefaniakDHühneC.Process distortions in prepreg manufacturing – an experimental study on CFRP L-profiles. Compos Struct2013;
106: 615–625.
26.
LekhnitskiiSG.Anisotropic plates.
Gordon and Breach, New York:
Science Publisher, 1968.
27.
ChouPCCarleoneJHsuCM.Elastic constants of layered media. J Compos Mater1972;
6: 80–93.
28.
KosmannJVölkerinkOSchollererM, et al.
Digital image correlation strain measurement of thick adherend shear test specimen joined with an epoxy film adhesive. Int J Adhes Adhes2019;
90: 32–37.
29.
PetersenECuntzeRHühneC.Experimental determination of material parameters in Cuntze’s failure-mode-concept-based UD strength failure conditions. Compos Sci Technol2016;
134: 12–25.
30.
Hexcel. HexPly M21 data sheet, Publication FTA002d. October, 2008.
31.
RadfordDW. Shape stability in composites. PhD Thesis, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, USA, 1987.
32.
KappelE.Forced-interaction and spring-in – relevant initiators of process-induced distortions in composite manufacturing. Compos Struct2016;
140: 217–229.
33.
KappelE.A zone-based approach to predict process-induced distortions of composite structures based on a ‘spring-in reference curve. Compos Struct2019;
209: 143–149.
34.
HörbergENymanTÅkermoM, et al.
Thickness effect on spring-back of prepreg composite L-profiles. Compos Struct2019;
209: 499–507.
CuntzeRG.The predictive capability of failure mode concept-based strength conditions for laminates composed of unidirectional laminae under static triaxial stress states. J Compos Mater2012;
46: 2563–2594.
39.
CuntzeRG.Comparison between experimental and theoretical results using Cuntze’s failure mode concept model for composites under triaxial loadings – part B of the second world-wide failure exercise. J Compos Mater2013;
47: 893–924.
40.
DavidsonBKrügerRKönigM, et al.
Effect of stacking sequence on energy release rate distribution in multidirectional DCB and ENF specimens. Eng Frac Mech1996;
55: 557–569.
41.
PereiraABde MoraisABde MouraMFSF, et al.
Mode I interlaminar fracture of woven glass/epoxy multidirectional laminates. Compos Part A Appl Sci2005;
36: 1119–1127.
42.
PetersenEHühneC. Determination of critical energy release rates for steel-CFRP interfaces considering residual thermal stresses. In: European conference on spacecraft structures, materials and environmental testing (ECSSMET), Noordwijk, 2018.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
