Effect of Processing Parameter Changes on the Adhesion of Plasma-treated Carbon Fiber Reinforced Epoxy Composites

Abstract

Atmospheric plasma treatment for the surface preparation of adhesively bonded composite joints appears promising as a replacement to current surface preparation techniques. However, questions remain regarding the sensitivity and optimization of various plasma processing parameters on final composite bond properties. In this study, we continue to investigate how plasma surface treatment processing variables ultimately affect the surface chemistry and bonding behavior of a graphite-epoxy composite. The plasma power level, the working distance of the plasma head, the carrier gas (helium) flow rate, the duration of plasma exposure, and the active gas (oxygen) concentration within the plasma were varied and correlated to surface chemistry variations using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The carboxyl concentration on the surface was then measured as a function of these changes and correlated to lap shear strengths. In addition, samples were monitored using XPS to evaluate the decay behavior of the surface treatment as a function of time. Treated specimens in both inert and air environments exhibited similar decay profiles. Large changes were not observed until after 24 days of out-time. The effects of plasma treatment, duration of plasma exposure, and out-time on the crack delamination resistance (G_IC) of bonded parts were assessed. G_IC measurement indicated that solvent wiped bonded specimens exhibited a purely adhesive failure with unstable crack growth. Specimens with abrasion treatment exhibited reduced performance with cracks initiated in the adhesive traveling through both the adhesive-composite interface as well as the outer surface plies of the composite substrate. We believe damage to the composite substrate due to surface preparation caused this failure mode. On the other hand, plasma-treated specimens exhibited consistent failure modes for all treatments above 12 passes. The failures were entirely cohesive with the very high bond strength promoting crack propagation only within the adhesive. The G_IC values indicated that the plasma-treated composites were two times as resistant to fracture as conventionally prepared specimens.

Keywords

plasma treatment composites surface preparation adhesive.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Armstrong, K. (1996). Effect of Absorbed Water in CFRP Composites on Adhesive Bonding, International Journal of Adhesion and Adhesives, 16: 21-28.

Hicks, R.F. , Babayamn, S.E. , Penelon, J. , Truong, Q. , Deitzel, J. and Gillespie, J.W. ( 2006). Atmospheric Plasma Treatment of Polyetheretherketone Composites for Improved Adhesion In: SAMPE Fall Technical Conference Proceedings: Global Advances in Materials and Process Engineering, Dallas, Texas, pp. 1-9.

Sheutze, A. , Jeong, J. , Babayan, S. , Park, J. , Selwyn, G. and Hicks, R.F. ( 1998). The Atmospheric-Pressure Plasma Jet: A Review and Comparison to Other Plasma Sources, IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science , 26(6): 1685-1694.

Noeske, M. , Degenhardt, J. , Strudthoff, S. and Lommatzsch, U. ( 2004). Plasma Jet Treatment of Five Polymers at Atmospheric Pressure: Surface Modifications and the Relevance for Adhesion, International Journal of Adhesion and Adhesives, 24: 171.

Sharma, R. , Holcomb, E. , Trigwell, S. and Mazumder, M. ( 2004). Stability of Atmospheric-Pressure Plasma Induced Changes on Polycarbonate Surfaces, Journal of Electrostatics , 65: 172.

Zaldivar, R.J. , Nokes, J.P. , Kim , H.I. , Steckel, G.L. and Morgan, B.A. (2009). The Effect of Atmospheric Plasma Treatment on the Chemistry, Morphology and Resultant Bonding Behavior of a Pan-Based Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Epoxy Composite , Journal of Composite Materials.

Comyn, J. and Xia, L. ( 1996). Plasma Treatment of Polyetheretherketone (PEEK) for Adhesive Bonding, International Journal of Adhesion and Adhesives, 16(2): 97-104. (doi: 10.1177/ 0021998309345343).

Gonzalez, E. , Barankin, M. , Guschl , P. and Hicks, R.F. (2008). Remote Atmospheric-Pressure Plasma Activation of the Surfaces of Polyethylene Terephtalate and Polyethylene Naphthalate, Langmuir, 24(21): 12636-12643.

ASTM D 3165-07. (2001). Standard Test Method for Strength Properties of Adhesives in Shear by Tension Loading of Single-lap-joint Laminated Assemblies, In: Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 15.06, pp. 213-216, ASTM International, Philadelphia.

10.

ASTM D 5528-94a. (2001 ). Standard Test Method for Mode I Interlaminar Fracture Toughness of Unidirectional Fiber-reinforced Polymer Matrix Composites, In: Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 15.03, pp. 289-298, ASTM International , Philadelphia.

11.

Blythe, A. , Briggs, D. , Kendall, C. , Rance, D. and Zichy, V.J. ( 1979). Surface Modification of Polyethylene by Electrical Discharge Treatment and the Mechanism of Autoadhesion, Polymer , 19: 1273.

12.

Jeong, J. , Babayan, S. , Sheutze, A. , Tu, V. , Park, J. , Henins, I. , Selwyn, G. and Hicks, R.F. ( 1999). Etching Polyimide with a Nonequilibrium Atmospheric-Pressure Plasma Jet, Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology A, 17: 2581.

13.

Jeong, J. , Park, J. , Henins, I. , Babayan, S. , Tu, V. , Selwyn, G. , Ding, G. and Hicks, R.F. ( 2001). Reaction Chemistry in the Aftereglow of an Oxygen-Helium, Atmospheric-Pressure Plasma, Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2000(104): 8027-8032.

14.

Moravej, M. , Yang, X. , Nowling , G.R. , Chang, J.P. , Babayan, S.E. and Hicks, R.F. (2004). Physics of High Pressure Helium and Argon Radio-Frequency Plasmas, Journal of Applied Physics, 96(12): 7011-7016.

15.

Nowling, G.R. , Babayan, S.E. , Jankovic, V. and Hicks, R.F. (2002). Chamberless Plasma Deposition of Glass Coatings on Plastic, Plasma Sources Science and Technology, 11: 97.

16.

Hegemann, D. , Brunner, H. and Oehr, C. ( 2003). Plasma Treatment of Polymers for Surface and Adhesion Improvement, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research B, 208: 281-286.

17.

De Geyter, N. , Morent, R. , Geyter , N.D. , Ley , C. , Gengembre, L. and Payen, E. (2007). Treatment of Polymer Films with a Dielectric Barrier Discharge in Air, Helium and Argon at Medium Pressure, Surface and Coatings Technology, 201(18): 7847-7854.

18.

Takke, V. , Behary, N. , Perwueltz, A. and Campagne, C. ( 2009). Studies on the Atmospheric Air-Plasma Treatment of PET (Polyethylene Terephtalate) Woven Fabrics: Effect of process parameters and of aging, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 114(1): 348-357.

19.

Bain, C.D. , Troughton, E.B. , Tao, Y.T. , Evall, J. , Whitesides, G.M. and Nuzzo, R.G. ( 1989). Formation of Monolayer Films by the Spontaneous Assembly of Organic Thiols from Solutions onto Gold, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 111: 321-335.

20.

Cik, G. , Zalupsky, P. , Cirak, J. , Tomcik, P. and Vegh, D. ( 2003). Structural Model of Langmuir Monomolecular Layer of Mono N-Octyl-Ester of 3 (3-Thienyl) Glutaric Acid Trimer at the Air-Water Interface , Synthetic Metals , 139: 355-360.

21.

Strein, E. and Allred, D. ( 2008). Eliminating Carbon Contamination on Oxidized Si Surfaces Using a VUV Excimer Lamp, Thin Solid Films, 517: 1011-1015.

22.

Whelan, C.M. , Smyth, M.R. , Barnes, C.J. , Brown, N.M.D. and Anderson , C.A. (1998). An XPS Study of Heterocyclic Thiol Self-Assembly on Au(111), Applied Surface Science, 134: 144-158.

23.

Liu, Y. and Messmer, M.C. ( 2002). Comparison of Contact Angle Measurements Using Various Probe Liquids on Incomplete OTS SAMS. In: Soriaga, M.P. et al. (eds), Thin Films: Preparation, Characterization, Applications, pp. 291-300, Kluwer Academic/ Plenum Publishers: New York.