Using the China Family Panel Studies data, we construct a household digital divide index through factor analysis to analyze the impact of the digital divide on the formation of the middle class. The results indicate that the digital divide hinders the formation of the middle class. Mechanism analysis reveals that the digital divide adversely affects the formation of the middle class by inhibiting entrepreneurship, financial participation, and employment. Heterogeneity analysis highlights that the inhibiting effect of the digital divide on the middle class is more prominent in the eastern regions, urban areas, groups with lower educational levels, and older age groups.
BirdsallNGrahamCPettinatoS (2000) Stuck in the tunnel: is globalization muddling the middle class? Working paper no. 14, August. Washington, DC: Centre on Social and Economic Dynamics, The Brookings Institution.
2.
BonnefondCClémentMCombarnousF (2015) In search of the elusive Chinese urban middle class: an exploratory analysis. Post-Communist Economies27(1): 41–59.
BruecknerMDabla-NorrisEGradsteinM, et al. (2018) The rise of the middle class and economic growth in ASEAN. Journal of Asian Economics56: 48–58.
5.
ChenCQinB (2014) The emergence of China’s middle class: social mobility in a rapidly urbanizing economy. Habitat International44: 528–535.
6.
ChenJLuC (2011) Democratization and the middle class in China: the middle class’s attitudes toward democracy. Political Research Quarterly64(3): 705–719.
7.
ChenY (2020) Improving market performance in the digital economy. China Economic Review62: 101482.
8.
CrabbMW (2010) Governing the middle-class family in urban China: educational reform and questions of choice. Economy and Society39(3): 385–402.
9.
DarityJrWAddoFRSmithIZ (2021) A subaltern middle class: the case of the missing “Black bourgeoisie” in America. Contemporary Economic Policy39(3): 494–502.
10.
DartantoTMoeisFROtsuboS (2020) Intragenerational economic mobility in Indonesia: a transition from poverty to the middle class in 1993–2014. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies56(2): 193–224.
11.
DiMaggioPBonikowskiB (2008) Make money surfing the web? The impact of internet use on the earnings of US workers. American Sociological Review73(2): 227–250.
12.
DuHZhouNCaoH, et al. (2021) Economic inequality is associated with lower internet use: a nationally representative study. Social Indicators Research155(3): 789–803.
13.
GrabkaMMGoebelJSchröderC, et al. (2016) Shrinking share of middle-income group in Germany and the US. DIW Economic Bulletin6(18): 199–210.
14.
HallerMWengerJBZaberMA, et al. (2022) A consumption-based definition of the middle class. Social Indicators Research164(3): 1249–1270.
15.
HermanssonCJonssonSLiuL (2022) The medium is the message: learning channels, financial literacy, and stock market participation. International Review of Financial Analysis79: 101996.
16.
HidalgoAGabalySMorales-AlonsoG, et al. (2020) The digital divide in light of sustainable development: an approach through advanced machine learning techniques. Technological Forecasting and Social Change150: 119754.
17.
HuaYZhangH (2023) Internet penetration and income inequality: evidence from the Chinese young labor market. Applied Economics55(54): 6444–6458.
18.
HuangTQuanY (2025) Narrowing the digital divide: the growth and distributional effect of internet use on income in rural China. China Economic Review91: 102387.
19.
JiangJWangP (2020) Is linking social capital more beneficial to the health promotion of the poor? Evidence from China. Social Indicators Research147(1): 45–71.
20.
KandoganYJohnsonSD (2016) Role of economic and political freedom in the emergence of global middle class. International Business Review25(3): 711–725.
21.
KewanganL (2021) Entrepreneurship motivation among accounting students: the role of financial literacy and financial behaviour. Jurnal Pengurusan63: 141–152.
22.
KharasH (2010) The emerging middle class in developing countries. Vol. 285. Workingaper no.85,,, 31 January. Washington, DC: OECD Development Center, The Brookings Institution.
23.
KuhnPMansourH (2014) Is internet job search still ineffective?The Economic Journal124(581): 1213–1233.
24.
LeeCCTangMLeeCC (2023) Reaping digital dividends: digital inclusive finance and high-quality development of enterprises in China. Telecommunications Policy47(2): 102484.
25.
LiP (2017) China’s path to overcoming the double middle-income traps. China & World Economy25(6): 28–44.
26.
LuanBZouHHuangJ (2023) Digital divide and household energy poverty in China. Energy Economics119: 106543.
27.
LythreatisSSinghSKEl- KassarAN (2022) The digital divide: a review and future research agenda. Technological Forecasting and Social Change175: 121359.
28.
MaX (2024) Internet use and income gaps between rural and urban residents in China. Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy29(2): 789–809.
29.
MiaoZ (2021) Digital economy value chain: concept, model structure, and mechanism. Applied Economics53(37): 4342–4357.
30.
MilanovicBYitzhakiS (2002) Decomposing world income distribution: does the world have a middle class?Review of Income and Wealth48(2): 155–178.
31.
MillanJMLyalkovSBurkeA, et al. (2021) “Digital divide” among European entrepreneurs: which types benefit most from ICT implementation?Journal of Business Research125: 533–547.
32.
MyovellaGKaracukaMHaucapJ (2020) Digitalization and economic growth: a comparative analysis of Sub-Saharan Africa and OECD economies. Telecommunications Policy44(2): 101856.
33.
NissanovZ (2017) Income mobility and the middle class in Russia, 1995–2007. Post-Communist Economies29(2): 250–264.
34.
OrtegaAOtero-IglesiasMSteinbergF (2018) A globalisation challenge: preventing a clash between the middle classes of the developed and emerging economies. Economics12(1): 1–12.
35.
ParkS (2017) Digital inequalities in rural Australia: a double jeopardy of remoteness and social exclusion. Journal of Rural Studies54: 399–407.
36.
PengZDanT (2023) Digital dividend or digital divide? Digital economy and urban-rural income inequality in China. Telecommunications Policy47(9): 102616.
37.
Perez-AmaralTValarezo LópezÁRGarín-MuñozT (2021) Digital divides across consumers of internet services in Spain using panel data 2007–2019. Narrowing or not?Telecommunications Policy45(2): 102093.
38.
PressmanS (2010) The middle class throughout the world in the mid-2000s. Journal of Economic Issues44(1): 243–262.
39.
PressmanS (2015) Defining and measuring the middle class. American Institute for Economic Research13: 1–27.
40.
RachingerMRauterRMüllerC, et al. (2018) Digitalization and its influence on business model innovation. Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management30(8): 1143–1160.
41.
RantaVAarikka-StenroosLVäisänenJM (2021) Digital technologies catalyzing business model innovation for circular economy—multiple case study. Resources, Conservation and Recycling164: 105155.
42.
RavallionM (2010) The developing world’s bulging (but vulnerable) middle class. World Development38(4): 445–454.
43.
SchwanderH (2020) Labor market insecurity among the middle class: a cross-pressured group. Political Science Research and Methods8(2): 369–374.
44.
ShabanA (2021) Growth and determinants of the middle class in rural and urban India in the post-liberalisation period. Rural–Urban Dichotomies and Spatial Development in Asia249–274.
45.
ShakinaEParshakovPAlsufievA (2021) Rethinking the corporate digital divide: the complementarity of technologies and the demand for digital skills. Technological Forecasting and Social Change162: 120405.
46.
ShenJHLongZLeeCC, et al. (2022) Comparative advantage, endowment structure, and trade imbalances. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics60: 365–375.
47.
SiawAJiangYTwumasiMA, et al. (2020) The impact of internet use on income: the case of rural Ghana. Sustainability12(8): 3255.
48.
TanYLiX (2022) The impact of internet on entrepreneurship. International Review of Economics & Finance77: 135–142.
49.
TangGNRenFZhouJ (2022) Does the digital economy promote “innovation and entrepreneurship” in rural tourism in China?Frontiers in Psychology13: 979027.
50.
TorcheFLopez-CalvaLF (2013) Stability and vulnerability of the Latin American middle class. Oxford Development Studies41(4): 409–435.
51.
Van DijkJA (2006) Digital divide research, achievements and shortcomings. Poetics34(4): 221–235.
52.
VassilakopoulouPHustadE (2023) Bridging digital divides: a literature review and research agenda for information systems research. Information Systems Frontiers25(3): 955–969.
53.
WangCChenXHuJ, et al. (2023) Poverty alleviation and rural revitalization: perspective of fiscal spending and data evidence from 81 Chinese counties. Heliyon9(7): e17451.
54.
WuFCuiFLiuT (2023) The influence of digital inclusive finance on household wealth: a study based on CHFS data. Finance Research Letters58: 104460.
55.
YiCHanJLongC (2023) Does internet use increase public perception of environmental pollution? Evidence from China. Social Indicators Research166(3): 665–685.
56.
YinZGongXGuoP, et al. (2019) What drives entrepreneurship in digital economy? Evidence from China. Economic Modelling82: 66–73.
57.
YuanKZhangX (2024) The impact of internet usage preferences on labor income: evidence from China. PLoS One19(8): e0308287.
58.
ZangYHuSZhouBB, et al. (2023) Entrepreneurship and the formation mechanism of Taobao villages: implications for sustainable development in rural areas. Journal of Rural Studies100: 103030.
59.
ZhaoXWengZ (2024) Digital dividend or divide: the digital economy and urban entrepreneurial activity. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences93: 101857.
60.
ZhongWJiangT (2021) Can internet finance alleviate the exclusiveness of traditional finance? Evidence from Chinese P2P lending markets. Finance Research Letters40: 101731.
61.
ZhouJLanHZhaoC, et al. (2024) The employment effects of digital infrastructure: firm-level evidence from the “Broadband China” strategy. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management36(10): 2647–2661.
