Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2026
From Political Rhetoric to Policy Implementation: A Comparison between Ghana Beyond Aid Agenda and Strategy and the Five-Year Economic Development Plan of South Korea
This study analyzes why political rhetoric fails to translate into policy implementation in Ghana Beyond Aid by comparing it with South Korea’s Five-Year Economic Development Plan through the lens of the Multiple Streams Framework. While both countries experienced a policy window in the decision stage, only Korea sustained implementation through adaptive policy change with attention from policy entrepreneurs. In contrast, Ghana’s agenda regressed into rhetoric and weakened streams, exacerbated by external shocks. The findings offer insights for developing countries pursuing self-reliance strategies, emphasizing the need for flexible policy change and continuous leadership engagement to sustain development initiatives beyond political rhetoric.
AlamMS (1989) Governments and Markets in Economic Development Strategies: Lessons from Korea, Taiwan, and Japan. New York: Praeger.
2.
AmsdenAH (1989) Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization. New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
AndrewsN (2010) Foreign official development assistance (ODA) and Ghana’s development: the case for bringing culture back into the analysis. International Journal of Sociology and Anthropology2(5): 95–104.
4.
AyitteyG (ed.) (2016) Africa Unchained: The Blueprint for Africa’s Future. New York: Springer.
5.
AyodeleTCudjoeFNolutshunguTA, et al. (2005) African perspectives on aid: foreign assistance will not pull Africa out of poverty. Economic Development Bulletin2: 1–4.
6.
BélandDHowlettM (2016) The role and impact of the multiple-streams approach in comparative policy analysis. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice18(3): 221–227.
7.
BotchwayTPAmoako-GyampahAK (2021) The non-aligned movement, Ghana, and the early days of African diplomacy: reflections on a developing country’s foreign policy. In: DimitrijevićDČavoškiJ (eds) The 60th Anniversary of the Non–Aligned Movement. Belgrade: Institute of International Politics and Economics, pp.289–303.
8.
ByunH (1990) Korea’s five-year economic plans and their impacts. Seoul Journal of Economics3(2): 219–238.
ChoTHKimMJ (2020) Estimation of long-term economic growth rates of DPRK: 1956–1989. Bank of Korea working paper no. 2020–17, 27July. Seoul, South Korea: Economic Research Institute, Bank of Korea.
11.
ChoiBS (1987) The structure of the economic policy-making institutions in Korea and the strategic role of the Economic Planning Board (EPB). Korean Journal of Policy Studies2: 1–25.
12.
ChoiBS (2013) Managing economic policy and coordination: a saga of the economic planning board. In: KwonHKooMG (eds) The Korean Government and Public Policies in a Development Nexus, vol.1. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp.31–54.
13.
ChungJ (2009) Syngman Rhee government’s three-year economic development plan. The Journal of Korean Studies31: 353–386.
14.
ChungJ (2017) John Myon Chang, government’s economic policy initiative, and the Five-Year Economic Development Plan. The Journal of Korean History176: 323–363.
15.
CobbRRossJKRossMH (1976) Agenda-building as a comparative political process. American Political Science Review70(1): 126–138.
16.
CollinsSM (1990) Lessons from Korean economic growth. The American Economic Review80(2): 104–107.
17.
CudjoeP (2024) The Ghana beyond aid, exploring its efficacy as a plan for national development. Master’s Thesis, University of Iceland, Reykjavík.
18.
DaviesMEdingerHTayN, et al. (2008) How China Delivers Development Assistance to Africa. Stellenbosch, South Africa: University of Stellenbosch Matieland.
19.
DeLeoRAZohlnhöferRZahariadisN (2024) Multiple Streams and Policy Ambiguity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
EomSJBaeK (2014) The governance system of industrial policy in the era of growth in Korea from the perspective of state-society relations. Korean Journal of Policy Studies29(3): 1–30.
24.
Ghana Beyond Aid Charter (2019) Ghana beyond Aid Charter and Strategy Document. Accra, Ghana: Office of the Senior Minister (OSM), Government of Ghana.
25.
Gyimah-BoadiEPrempehHK (2012) Oil, politics, and Ghana’s democracy. Journal of Democracy23(3): 94–108.
26.
HanHY (2008) The continuity and discontinuity of the government-initiated economic development policy: based on the experience of economic elites. The Korean Journal of Public Administration45(1): 1–32.
27.
HeoUJeonHKimH, et al. (2008) The political economy of South Korea: economic growth, democratization, and financial crisis. Maryland Series in Contemporary Asian Studies2008(2): 1–24.
28.
HerwegNHußCZohlnhöferR (2015) Straightening the three streams: theorising extensions of the Multiple Streams Framework. European Journal of Political Research54(3): 435–449.
29.
HerwegNZahariadisNZohlnhöferR (2023) The Multiple Streams Framework: foundations, refinements, and empirical applications. In: WeibleCM (ed.) Theories of the Policy Process. New York: Routledge, pp.29–64.
30.
HowlettMMcConnellAPerlA (2016) Weaving the fabric of public policies: comparing and integrating contemporary frameworks for the study of policy processes. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice18(3): 273–289.
31.
HudsonBHunterDPeckhamS (2019) Policy failure and the policy-implementation gap: can policy support programs help?Policy Design and Practice2(1): 1–14.
32.
JonesMDPetersonHLPierceJJ, et al. (2016) A river runs through it: a multiple streams meta-review. Policy Studies Journal44(1): 13–36.
33.
KangGLeeYChoiS (2008) The policy-making system during south Korea’s high-growth era: the economic planning board and policy implementation bodies. Report, Korea Development Institute. Sejong, South Korea, February.
34.
KimBK (1992) Economic Policy and the Economic Planning Board (EPB) in Korea. Asian Affairs: An American Review18(4): 197–213.
35.
KimD (2021) The great divergence on the Korean peninsula (1910–2020). Australian Economic History Review61(3): 318–341.
36.
KingdonJW (2011 [1984]) Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Boston, MA: Longman.
37.
KoK (2022) Understanding the Republic of Korea: Socio-Economic and Administrative System. Goyang-si, South Korea: MoonWooSa.
38.
Korea Development Institute (KDI) (1991) The Five-Year Economic Development Plans Revisited (KDI Research Series). Seoul, South Korea: Korea Development Institute.
39.
KumiE (2020) From donor darling to beyond aid? Public perceptions of “Ghana Beyond Aid.” The Journal of Modern African Studies58(1): 67–90.
40.
MaafoOY (2019) Preface by Senior Minister in the Ghana Beyond Aid Charter and Strategy Document (pp.8–9). Republic of Ghana.
41.
MarteyEEtwirePMKuwornuJK (2020) Economic impacts of smallholder farmers’ adoption of drought-tolerant maize varieties. Land Use Policy94: 104524.
National Development Planning Commission (2017) The Coordinated Programme of Economic and Social Development Policies 2017-2024. Republic of Ghana.
45.
NortonRD (1970) Planning with facts: the case of Korea. The American Economic Review60(2): 59–64.
46.
NtimEOBotchwayTP (2023) Ghana Beyond Aid: a bargaining chip for draconian economic policies in Ghana. The African Review 1(aop):1–33.
47.
PlumecocqG (2014) Rhetoric as a means for sustainable development policy. Environmental Values23(5): 529–549.
48.
PressmanJLWildavskyA (1973) Implementation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
49.
RietigK (2021) Multilevel reinforcing dynamics: global climate governance and European renewable energy policy. Public Administration99(1): 55–71.
50.
SagerFThomannE (2017) Multiple streams in member state implementation: politics, problem construction and policy paths in Swiss asylum policy. Journal of Public Policy37(3): 287–314.
SeohJJooHKimP, et al. (2022) Korea as an aid recipient: historical records and lessons learned. Research report, Report no. 22-07-01, January. Sejong, South Korea: National Research Council for Economics, Humanities, and Social Sciences.
53.
SethMJ (2017) South Korea’s Economic Development, 1948–1996 (Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Asian History). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
54.
ShpaizmanI (2020) Beyond the visible policy agenda: problem definitions disappearing from the agenda as nondecisions. Journal of Public Policy40(1): 72–95.
TettehBNtsifulE (2023) A comparative analysis of the performances of macroeconomic indicators during the global financial crisis, COVID-19 pandemic, and the Russia-Ukraine war: the Ghanaian case. Research in Globalization7: 100174.
57.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) (2021) Economic Development in Africa Report 2021: Reaping the Potential Benefits of the African Continental Free Trade Area for Inclusive Growth (online PDF). Geneva: United Nations. Available at: https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/aldcafrica2021_en.pdf (accessed 21 May 2025).
58.
WhitfieldL (2018) Economies after Colonialism: Ghana and the Struggle for Power. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
YeboahS (2023) Unmasking the storm: an in-depth analysis of COVID-19’s economic ripple effect on Ghana. MPRA working paper no. 117563, 8June. Munich: University Library of Munich.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
