Hostility and exclusionary attitudes toward foreigners and immigrants have emerged as a global phenomenon. Amid enduring historical grievances and strategic rivalry, tentative signs of improvement in China–Japan bilateral relations have been observed since 2024. Based on social identity theory, this study investigates how five types of national ingroup positivity, namely, national ingroup identification, blind and constructive patriotism, nationalism, and collective narcissism, are related to hostile attitudes toward Japanese citizens among Chinese individuals. The results show that blind patriotism and nationalism are positively associated with hostility, whereas collective narcissism is negatively associated with hostility. In addition, constructive patriotism and national ingroup identification do not show a significant relationship with hostility. This study further examines the moderating effects of the psychological constructs of national ingroup positivity and perceived threat on hostility. Based on these findings, the research underscores the importance of promoting healthy forms of national ingroup positivity to mitigate intergroup hostility.
AbbinkKHarrisD (2019) In-group favouritism and out-group discrimination in naturally occurring groups. PLoS One14(9): e0221616.
2.
AgnewJ (2012) Looking back to look forward: Chinese geopolitical narratives and China’s past. Eurasian Geography and Economics53(3): 301–314.
3.
BillietJMaddensBBeertenR (2003) National identity and attitude toward foreigners in a multinational state: a replication. Political Psychology24(2): 241–257.
4.
BilligMTajfelH (1973) Social categorization and similarity in intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology3: 27–52.
5.
BrewerMB (1999) The psychology of prejudice: ingroup love or outgroup hate?Journal of Social Issues55(3): 429–444.
6.
BrewerMB (2017) Intergroup discrimination: ingroup love or outgroup hate? In: SibleyCBarlowF (eds) The Cambridge Handbook of the Psychology of Prejudice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.90–110.
7.
CaiHGriesP (2013) National narcissism: internal dimensions and international correlates. PsyCh Journal2(2): 122–132.
8.
CaricatiL (2018) Perceived threat mediates the relationship between national identification and support for immigrant exclusion: a cross-national test of intergroup threat theory. International Journal of Intercultural Relations66: 41–51.
9.
ChingL (2019) Anti-Japan: The Politics of Sentiment in Postcolonial East Asia. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
10.
ChoiSYAbelMSiqi-LiuA, et al. (2021) National identity can be comprised of more than pride: evidence from collective memories of Americans and Germans. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition10(1): 117–130.
CollierPHoefflerARohnerD (2009) Beyond greed and grievance: feasibility and civil war. Oxford Economic Papers61: 1–27.
13.
ConzoPFuochiGAnfossiL, et al. (2021) Negative media portrayals of immigrants increase ingroup favoritism and hostile physiological and emotional reactions. Scientific Reports11: 16407.
14.
CorreiaIPereiraCRValaJ (2018) Under victimization by an outgroup: belief in a just world, national identification, and ingroup blame. Frontiers in Psychology9: 1160.
15.
De DreuCKW (2010) Social value orientation moderates ingroup love but not outgroup hate in competitive intergroup conflict. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations13(6): 701–713.
16.
DruckmanD (1994) Nationalism, patriotism, and group loyalty: a social psychological perspective. Mershon International Studies Review38(Suppl. 1): 43–68.
17.
EffersonCLaliveRFehrE (2008) The coevolution of cultural groups and ingroup favoritism. Science321(5897): 1844–1849.
18.
FedericoCMGolec De ZavalaABuW (2023) Collective narcissism as a basis for nationalism. Political Psychology44(1): 177–196.
19.
FiedlerSHellmannDMDorroughAR, et al. (2018) Cross-national in-group favoritism in prosocial behavior: evidence from Latin and North America. Judgment and Decision Making13(1): 42–60.
Golec de ZavalaA (2018) Collective narcissism: antecedents and consequences of exaggeration of the in-group image. In: HermannABrunellAFosterJ (eds) Handbook of Trait Narcissism: Key Advances, Research Methods, and Controversies. New York: Springer, pp.79–88.
23.
Golec de ZavalaAKeenanO (2021) Collective narcissism as a framework for understanding populism. Journal of Theoretical Social Psychology5(2): 54–64.
24.
Golec de ZavalaALantosD (2020) Collective narcissism and its social consequences: the bad and the ugly. Current Directions in Psychological Science29(3): 273–278.
25.
Golec de ZavalaACichockaAEidelsonR, et al. (2009) Collective narcissism and its social consequences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology97(6): 1074–1096.
26.
Golec de ZavalaADyduch-HazarKLantosD (2019) Collective narcissism: political consequences of investing self-worth in the ingroup’s image. Political Psychology40(Suppl. 1): 37–74.
27.
GreenfeldL (1992) Nationalism: Five Roads to Modernity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
28.
GriesP (2004) China’s New Nationalism: Pride, Politics, and Diplomacy. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
29.
HaftSLZhouQ (2021) An outbreak of xenophobia: perceived discrimination and anxiety in Chinese American college students before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. International Journal of Psychology56(4): 522–531.
30.
HahmHCXavier HallCDGarciaKT, et al. (2021) Experiences of COVID-19-related anti-Asian discrimination and affective reactions in a multiple race sample of U.S. young adults. BMC Public Health21: 1563.
31.
HalevyNBornsteinGSagivL (2008) “In-group love” and “out-group hate” as motives for individual participation in intergroup conflict: a new game paradigm. Psychological Science19(4): 405–411.
32.
HamleyLHoukamauCAOsborneD, et al. (2020) Ingroup love or outgroup hate (or both)? Mapping distinct bias profiles in the population. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin46(2): 171–188.
33.
HeY (2007) History, Chinese nationalism and the emerging Sino–Japanese conflict. Journal of Contemporary China16(50): 1–24.
34.
HeY (2013) War, myths, and national identity formation: Chinese attitudes toward Japan. In: BouchardG (ed.) National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents. London: Routledge, pp.223–242.
35.
HeizmannBHuthN (2021) Economic conditions and perceptions of immigrants as an economic threat in Europe: temporal dynamics and mediating processes. International Journal of Comparative Sociology62(1): 56–82.
36.
HinkleSBrownR (1990) Intergroup comparisons and social identity: some links and lacunae. In: AbramsDHoggM (eds) Social Identity Theory: Construction and Critical Advances. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf, pp.48–70.
37.
HitlinSKwonHWFiratR (2021) In- and out-groups across cultures: identities and perceived group values. Social Science Research97: 102569.
38.
HoggMASunderlandJ (1991) Self-esteem and intergroup discrimination in the minimal group paradigm. British Journal of Social Psychology30(1): 51–62.
39.
HughesC (2000) Nationalism in Chinese cyberspace. Cambridge Review of International Affairs13(2): 195–209.
40.
JaskoKWebberDKruglanskiAW, et al. (2020) Social context moderates the effects of quest for significance on violent extremism. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology118: 1165–1187.
41.
KostermanRFeshbachS (1989) Toward a measure of patriotic and nationalistic attitudes. Political Psychology10(2): 257–274.
LiffAP (2022) Japan, Taiwan and the “one China” framework after 50 years. The China Quarterly252: 1066–1093.
44.
LyonsPAKenworthyJBPopanJR (2010) Ingroup identification and group-level narcissism and predictors of U.S. citizens’ attitudes and behavior toward Arab immigrants. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin36: 1267–1280.
MayallJ (1990) Nationalism and International Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
47.
MoritaL (2015) Some manifestations of Japanese exclusionism. Sage Open5(3): 1–6.
48.
MummendeyAKlinkABrownR (2001) Nationalism and patriotism: national identification and out-group rejection. British Journal of Social Psychology40(2): 159–172.
49.
NaftaliO (2018) “These war dramas are like cartoons”: education, media consumption, and Chinese youth attitudes towards Japan. Journal of Contemporary China27(113): 703–718.
50.
NincicMRamosJM (2012) The sources of patriotism: survey and experimental evidence. Foreign Policy Analysis8(4): 373–388.
51.
ParkerMTJanoff-BulmanR (2013) Lessons from morality-based social identity: The power of outgroup “hate,” not just ingroup “love..”Social Justice Research26(1): 81–96.
52.
PlatowMJHunterJA (2012) Intergroup relations and conflict: revisiting Sherif’s boys’ camp studies. In: SmithJRHaslamSA (eds) Social Psychology: Revisiting the Classic Studies. London: Sage, pp.142–159.
53.
ReizábalLValenciaJBarrettM (2004) National identifications and attitudes to national ingroups and outgroups amongst children living in the Basque country. Infant and Child Development13(1): 1–20.
54.
RomanoABallietDYamagishiT, et al. (2017) Parochial trust and cooperation across 17 societies. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences114(48): 12702–12707.
SchatzRTStaubELavineH (1999) On the varieties of national attachment: blind versus constructive patriotism. Political Psychology20(1): 151–174.
57.
SchertzerRWoodsET (2021) Nationalism: the ethno-nationalist populism of Donald Trump’s Twitter communication. Ethnic and Racial Studies44(7): 1154–1173.
58.
SchlueterESchmidtPWagnerU (2008) Disentangling the causal relations of perceived group threat and outgroup derogation: cross-national evidence from German and Russian panel surveys. European Sociological Review24(5): 567–581.
59.
ScobieORuffmanTScarfD, et al. (2024) Negative intergroup discrimination and belonging in the minimal group paradigm. In: AkandeA (ed.) Leadership and Politics. New York: Springer, pp.65–89.
SeulJR (1999) “Ours is the way of God”: religion, identity, and intergroup conflict. Journal of Peace Research36(5): 553–569.
62.
SinghP (2021) Populism, nationalism, and nationalist populism. Studies in Comparative International Development56(2): 250–269.
63.
SmithPJ (2009) China-Japan relations and the future geopolitics of East Asia. Asian Affairs: An American Review35(4): 230–256.
64.
SneiderD (2013) Textbooks and patriotic education: wartime memory formation in China and Japan. Asia-Pacific Review20(1): 35–54.
65.
StephanWGRenfroCLEssesVM, et al. (2005) The effects of feeling threatened on attitudes toward immigrants. International Journal of Intercultural Relations29(1): 1–19.
66.
StoneCHCrispRJ (2007) Superordinate and subgroup identification as predictors of intergroup evaluation in common ingroup contexts. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations10(4): 493–513.
67.
TajfelH (1974) Social identity and intergroup behavior. Social Science Information13(2): 65–93.
68.
TajfelH (1982) Social psychology of intergroup relations. Annual Review of Psychology33: 1–39.
69.
TajfelHTurnerJC (1986) An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In: WorchelSAustinW (eds) Psychology of Intergroup Relations. Chicago, IL: Nelson-Hall, pp.2–24.
70.
TajfelHBilligMGBundyRP, et al. (1971) Social categorization and intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology1(2): 149–178.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan (2013) Statement by the Minister for Foreign Affairs on the announcement on the “East China sea air defense identification zone” by the Ministry of National Defense of the People’s Republic of China. Available at: https://www.mofa.go.jp/press/release/press4e_000098.html (accessed 29 April 2025).
73.
TsukamotoSFiskeST (2017) Perceived threat to national values in evaluating stereotyped immigrants. Journal of Social Psychology158(2): 157–172.
74.
Van MeeterenM (2012) Transnational activities and aspirations of irregular migrants in Belgium and the Netherlands. Global Networks12(3): 314–332.
75.
VerkuytenM (2001) National identification and intergroup evaluations in Dutch children. British Journal of Developmental Psychology19: 559–571.
76.
VishkinABloomP (2022) The influence of religion on the acceptance and integration of immigrants: a multi-dimensional perspective. Current Opinion in Psychology47: 101421.
77.
WallaceJLWeissJC (2015) The political geography of nationalist protest in China: cities and the 2012 anti-Japanese protests. The China Quarterly222: 403–429.
78.
WangZ (2008) National humiliation, history education, and the politics of historical memory: patriotic education campaign in China. International Studies Quarterly52(4): 783–806.
79.
WangZ (2014) Never Forget National Humiliation: Historical Memory in Chinese Politics and Foreign Relations. New York: Columbia University Press.
80.
WeiselOBöhmR (2015) “Ingroup love” and “outgroup hate” in intergroup conflict between natural groups. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology60: 110–120.
81.
WeissJC (2014) Powerful Patriots: Nationalist Protest in China’s Foreign Relations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
82.
WhittSWilsonRK (2007) The dictator game, fairness and ethnicity in postwar Bosnia. American Journal of Political Science51(3): 655–668.
83.
WoodsETSchertzerRGreenfeldL, et al. (2020) COVID-19, nationalism, and the politics of crisis: a scholarly exchange. Nations and Nationalism26(4): 807–825.
84.
ZakowskiK (2012) Reaction to popular pressure or a political tool? Different interpretations of China’s policy regarding Koizumi’s visits to the Yasukuni Shrine. Journal of Contemporary Eastern Asia11(2): 47–60.
85.
ZhaiY (2017) Identity, contact, and the reduction of mutual distrust: a survey of Chinese and Japanese youth. Pacific Review30(1): 93–113.
86.
ZhaiY (2021) Discourse power: sovereignty claims over the Diaoyu/Senkaku islands. Territory, Politics, Governance9(2): 203–221.
87.
ZhaiY (2024a) Exclusionist reactions during the COVID-19 pandemic: Chinese, Japanese, and South Korean citizens’ support for border restriction. Social Science Quarterly105(7): 2208–2223.
88.
ZhaiY (2024b) Populism, collective narcissism, and support for war. International Journal of Public Opinion Research36(1): edae007.
89.
ZhaiYLuYWuQ (2023) Patriotism, nationalism, and evaluations of the government’s handling of the coronavirus crisis. Frontiers in Psychology14: 1016435.
90.
ZhaoH (2018) China–Japan compete for infrastructure investment in Southeast Asia: geopolitical rivalry or healthy competition?Journal of Contemporary China28(118): 558–574.
91.
ZhaoS (1998) A state-led nationalism: the patriotic education campaign in post-Tiananmen China. Communist and Post-communist Studies31(3): 287–302.
92.
ZhengD (2019) Modern Chinese nationalism and the awakening of self-consciousness of the Chinese nation. International Journal of Anthropology and Ethnology3: 11.
93.
ZhouMWangH (2017) Anti-Japanese sentiment among Chinese university students: the influence of contemporary nationalist propaganda. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs46(1): 167–185.
