This paper analyses the African Union’s (AU) imposition and lifting of sanctions in response to coups d’état. It argues that AU decisions follow a rational logic rooted in member states’ political interests and the principle of civilian control. While existing studies stress ambiguity in AU sanctions post-Arab Spring, few have examined all coup cases. Analysing incidents since 2007, this study finds that ‘non-pure military coups’ rarely triggered sanctions, while lifting them required civilian-led transitions or elections. It shows that, despite perceived inconsistencies, AU responses reflect a largely consistent stance against military rule and are more systematic than often assumed.
AboagyeMOClarkJF (2022) Political legitimacy and military interventions. In: KhisaMDayC (eds) Rethinking Civil-Military Relations in Africa: Beyond the Coup D’état. Boulder, CO; London: Lynne Rienner, pp.39–64.
2.
African Union (2007) African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: African Union.
3.
African Union (2009) Communique of the 181st Meeting of the Peace and Security Council. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: African Union.
4.
AniNC (2021) Coup or not coup: the African Union and the dilemma of ‘popular uprisings’ in Africa. Democracy and Security17(3): 257–277.
5.
AzizSF (2017) Military electoral authoritarianism in Egypt. Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy16(2): 280–295.
6.
BamideleOAyodeleB (2018) In the service of democratic governance: the African Union normative framework on unconstitutional change of government and ECOWAS protocol on good governance and democracy in the post-Arab Spring. Journal of Asian and African Studies53(1): 132–146.
7.
BeardsworthNCheesemanNTinhuS (2019) Zimbabwe: the coup that never was, and the election that could have been. African Affairs118(472): 580–596.
8.
Bueno de MesquitaBSmithASiversonRM, et al. (2005) The Logic of Political Survival. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
9.
ChenowethEPinckneyJLewisO (2018) Days of rage: introducing the NAVCO 3.0 dataset. Journal of Peace Research55(4): 524–534.
10.
ChinJJKirkpatrickJ (2023) African coups in the COVID-19 era: a current history. Frontiers in Political Science5: 1077945.
11.
DammanEDayC (2022) The African Union and the ‘good coup’. In: KhisaMDayC (eds) Rethinking Civil-Military Relations in Africa: Beyond the Coup D’état. Boulder, CO; London: Lynne Rienner, pp.65–90.
12.
DayCKhisaM (2022) Rethinking civil-military relations in Africa. In: KhisaMDayC (eds) Rethinking Civil-Military Relations in Africa: Beyond the Coup D’état. Boulder, CO; London: Lynne Rienner, pp.1–38.
13.
de WetE (2019) The role of democratic legitimacy in the recognition of governments in Africa since the end of the Cold War. International Journal of Constitutional Law17(2): 470–478.
14.
de WetE (2021) The African Union’s struggle against ‘unconstitutional change of government’: from a moral prescription to a requirement under international law?European Journal of International Law32(1): 199–226.
15.
DerssoSA (2017) Defending constitutional rule as a peacemaking enterprise: the case of the AU’s ban of unconstitutional changes of government. International Peacekeeping24(4): 639–660.
16.
DerssoSA (2019) The status and legitimacy of popular uprisings in the AU norms on democracy and constitutional governance. Journal of African Law63(S1): 107–130.
17.
Freedom House (2025) Freedom in the World 2025: The Uphill Battle to Safeguard Rights. Washington, DC: Freedom House.
18.
García-CasasM (2021) The crime of unconstitutional change of government. Journal of International Criminal Justice19(3): 565–581.
19.
GeddesBWrightJFrantzE (2018) How Dictatorships Work. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20.
HellquistE (2021) Regional sanctions as peer review: the African Union against Egypt (2013) and Sudan (2019). International Political Science Review42(4): 451–468.
KhisaMDayC (2020) Reconceptualising civil-military relations in Africa. Civil Wars22(2–3): 174–197.
28.
KuehnDCroissantA (2023) Routes to Reform: Civil-Military Relations and Democracy in the Third Wave. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
29.
MarumahokoSChigwataTC (2020) The idea of a new Zimbabwe post-Mugabe. In: Ndlovu-GatsheniSJRuhanyaP (eds) The History and Political Transition of Zimbabwe: From Mugabe to Mnangagwa. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.299–329.
30.
NyineviCFosuR (2023) The African Union’s prohibition of unconstitutional changes of government: an uneasy choice between fidelity to principle and pragmatism. African Security16(1): 95–119.
31.
OkoliCRNwosuBUOkpalekeFN, et al. (2023) Security in the lake Chad basin and Sahel region after Idris Déby. Small Wars & Insurgencies34(6): 1130–1153.
32.
PowellJLasleyTSchielR (2016) Combating coups d’état in Africa, 1950–2014. Studies in Comparative International Development51(4): 482–502.
WittA (2019) Where regional norms matter: contestation and the domestic impact of the African charter on democracy, elections and governance. Africa Spectrum54(2): 106–126.
35.
ZhuangR (2025) Power, patronage, and reform: the Bongo family’s rule and Gabon’s political transition. Journal of Asian and African Studies. Epub ahead of print 18 April. DOI: 10.1177/00219096251332952.
