‘You Know What the Truth Is? There are No Touareg Evacuées Here’: On Crisis and Categories of Migration

Abstract

This paper analyses the practices of (im)mobilities and the accompanying emotions to question the exceptionalisation of crisis and migratory categorisations. Focusing on Kel Tamasheq (aka Tuareg) mobile livelihoods and their fluid interconnections with kinship networks and emotions across time, it argues that the multidimensionality of causes behind a migratory project, and the importance of historically contextualising the relation between a crisis, here the ‘Malian crisis’, and regional patterns of (im)mobilities, reveal the arbitrariness of making crisis exceptional and migratory categories uniquely discreet. This paper is based on a 10-month ethnography among Kel Tamasheq in Bamako.

Keywords

Migration crisis Kel Tamasheq Mali immobility/mobility migratory categories emotions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abegunrin

Abidde

(2021) Introduction. In: Abegunrin

Abidde

S O

(eds) African Migrants and the Refugee Crisis. Cham: Springer, pp. xi–xviii.

Ag Ataher Insar

(1990) La scolarisation moderne comme stratégie de résistance. Revue des mondes musulmans et de la Méditerranée 57(1): 91–98.

Amelina

(2021) After the reflexive turn in migration studies. Population, Space and Place 27(1): e2368.

Amselle

(1981) Famine, prolétarisation et création de nouveaux liens de dépendance au Sahel. Politique Africaine 1(1): 5–22.

Andersson

(2022) No Go World. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Bakewell

(2008) Research beyond the categories. Journal of Refugee Studies 21(4): 432–453.

Bardelli

(2020) When the refugee status becomes an economic asset. Ethnic and Racial Studies 43(2): 333–350.

Belalimat

(2019) Réseaux sociaux, nouveaux médias et territoires au Sahara. In: Boulay

Fanchette

(eds) La question des échelles en sciences humaines et sociales. Paris: Éditions Quæ, pp.123–140.

Bencherif

(2019) Récits du conflit entre les Ifoghas et les Imghad. Cahiers d études africaines 234: 427–451.

10.

Bernus

(1995) Pasteurs face à la sécheresse. Géocarrefour 70(3): 255–259.

11.

Betts

(2010) The refugee regime complex. Refugee Survey Quarterly 29(1): 12–37.

12.

Bhatia

Canning

(2021) Introduction. In: Bhatia

Canning

(eds) Stealing Time: Migration, Temporalities and State Violence. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.xv–xxv.

13.

Boccagni

Baldassar

(2015) Emotions on the move. Emotion, Space and Society 16: 73–80.

14.

Boilley

(1999) Les Touaregs entre contraintes géographiques et constructions politiques. Études Rurales 151–152: 255–268.

15.

Bonnecase

Brachet

(2013) Les «crises sahéliennes» entre perceptions locales et gestions internationales. Politique Africaine 2(130): 5–22.

16.

Bourgeot

(1995) Ethonyme et rapports sociaux. In: Bourgeot

(ed.) Les sociétés touarègues. Paris: Karthala.

17.

Brachet

Scheele

(2019) Remoteness is power. Social Anthropology 27(2): 156–171.

18.

Card

(1982) Tuareg music and social identity. PhD Thesis, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN.

19.

Charbonneau

Sears

(2014) Faire la guerre pour un Mali démocratique. Canadian Journal of Political Science 47(3): 597–619.

20.

Chetail

(2005) Introduction. Refugee Survey Quarterly 24(3): 7–8.

21.

Data2 (2022a) Operational data portal. Available at: https://data2.unhcr.org/en/country/mli (accessed 16 July 2023).

22.

Data2 (2022b) Sahel crisis. Available at: https://data2.unhcr.org/en/situations/sahelcrisis (accessed 22 February 2022).

23.

de Bruijn

Foeken

Van Dijk

(2001) Introduction. In: de Bruijn

Foeken

Van Dijk

(eds) Mobile Africa. London: Brill, pp.1–9.

24.

Decimo

Gribaldo

(2017) Nation, migration and kinship through identity categorization. In: Decimo

Gribaldo

(eds) Boundaries Within. Liège: Springer, pp.3–21.

25.

Diallo

(2018) The Truth about the Desert. Koln: Modern Academic Publishing.

26.

Diallo

(in press) Refugee Crisis, labor migration, and the making of Tuareg diaspora in West Africa. JAAS.

27.

Erdal

Oeppen

(2018) Forced to leave? The discursive and analytical significance of describing migration as forced and voluntary. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44(6): 981–998.

28.

Fresia

(2014) Forced migration in West Africa. In: Fiddian-Qasmiyeh Loescher

Long

, et al (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Refugee and Forced Migration Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 541–553.

29.

Gallo

(2015) The irony of kinship migration and the control of emotions among Malayalis. Emotion, Space and Society 16: 108–115.

30.

Giuffrida

(2005) Métamorphoses des relations de dépendance chez les Kel Antessar du cercle de Goundam. Cahiers d’études Africaines 3–4(179–180): 805–830.

31.

Giuffrida

(2010) Tuareg networks. In: Fischer

Kohl

(eds) Tuareg Society within a Globalised World. Saharan Life in Transition. London: Tarrius, pp.23–41.

32.

Gonzales G (2015) Individual and collective identities among Malian Kel Tamasheq refugees in Burkina Faso: Continuities and transformations. Thesis for MPhil in Development Studies, St Antony’s College/Department of International Development, University of Oxford.

33.

Gonzales G (2020) Niglá: methods and discontinuous (im)mobilities among Malian Kel Tamasheq in Bamako. Nomadic Peoples 24(4): 195–209.

34.

Grémont

(2010) Les Touaregs Iwellemmedan, 1647–1896. Paris: Karthala Editions.

35.

Grémont

(2011) Ancrage au sol et (nouvelles) mobilités dans l’espace saharo-sahélien. L’année du Maghreb vii: 177–189.

36.

Grémont

(2019) In the trap of bids of violence, rivalries, protections and retaliations in the region of Menaka. Herodote 1: 43–62.

37.

Grémont

Marty

Mossa

, et al (2004) Les Liens Sociaux Au Nord-Mali. Paris: Karthala Editions.

38.

Griffiths

Rogers

Anderson

(2013) Migration, time and temporalities. COMPAS 3: 1–31.

39.

Hahn

Klute

(2007) Cultures of Migration. Münster: LIT Verlag.

40.

Harrell-Bond

Voutira

(1992) Anthropology and the study of refugees. Anthropology Today 8(4): 6–10.

41.

Hincker

(2004) Identité et métier des inaḍen. L’Homme 1: 127–151.

42.

Hodges

(2008) Rethinking time’s arrow. Anthropological Theory 8(4): 399–429.

43.

IOM (2021) Indicateurs de gouvernance des migrations. Report. Geneva: IOM .

44.

Köhler

(2020) Space, Place and Identity. New York: Berghahn Books.

45.

Lecocq

(2010) Disputed Desert. London: Brill.

46.

Lecocq

Mann

Whitehouse

, et al (2013) One hippopotamus and eight blind analysts. Review of African Political Economy 40(137): 343–357.

47.

Lecocq

Niang

(2019) Identités sahéliennes en temps de crise. In: Lecocq

Niang

(eds) Identités sahéliennes en temps de crise. Berlin: Lit Verlag, pp.3–23.

48.

Lee

(1996) Internally displaced persons and refugees. Journal of Refugee Studies 9(1): 27–42.

49.

Lesourd

(2007) Capital beauté. Politique Africaine 3(107): 62–80.

50.

Maru

Nori

Scoones

, et al (2022) Embracing uncertainty. Comparative Migration Studies 10(1): 1–18.

51.

McDougall

Scheele

(2012) Introduction. In: McDougall

Scheele

(eds) Saharan Frontiers. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, pp.1–24.

52.

Mooney

(2005) THE concept of internal displacement and the case for internally displaced persons as a category of concern. Refugee Survey Quarterly 24(3): 9–26.

53.

Niang

(2018) Stateness and borderness in mediation. DFG, Working Paper N26. Bonn: DFG.

54.

Nicolaisen

(1997) The Pastoral Tuareg. London: Thames & Hudson.

55.

Oxby

(2021) Born into bondage? Journal of African Diaspora Archaeology and Heritage 10(1–2): 128–160.

56.

Peutz

De Genova

(2010) Introduction. In: De Genova

Peutz

(eds) The Deportation Regime. London: Duke University Press, pp.1–30.

57.

Poudiougou

Zanoletti

(2020) Fabriquer l’identité à la pointe de la kalache. Revue internationale des études du développement 243: 37–65.

58.

RFI (2015) Mali: retour sur l’attaque de l’hôtel Radisson à Bamako. Available at: https://www.rfi.fr/fr/afrique/2min/20151120-direct-mali-radisson-blu-hotel-fusillade-bamako (accessed 22 February 2022).

59.

Rasmussen

(1998) Within the tent and at the crossroads: Travel and gender identity among the Tuareg of Niger. Ethos 26(2): 153–182.

60.

Robertson

(2019) Status-making. Journal of Sociology 55(2): 219–233.

61.

Rossi

(2015) Kinetocracy. In: Vigneswaran

Quirk

(eds) Mobility Makes States. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, pp.149–169.

62.

Sangaré

(2016) Le Centre du Mali. GRIP. Available at: https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/access/item%3A2885830/view (accessed 16 July 2023).

63.

Sangaré

Cold-Ravnkilde

(2020) Internally displaced people in Mali’s capital city. Report. Copenhagen: DIIS.

64.

Scheele

(2012) Smugglers and Saints of the Sahara. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

65.

Soukouna

(2020) L’État malien entre négociations et résistances dans la formulation de politiques sur les migrations. Anthropologie & Développement 51: 69–84.

66.

Svašek

(2010) On the move. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 36(6): 865–880.

67.

Turner

McPeak

Gillin , et al (2016) Reconciling flexibility and tenure security for pastoral resources. Human Ecology 44(2): 199–215.

68.

UNHCR (2022a) Internally displaced peoples. Available at: https://www.unhcr.org/internally-displaced-people.html (accessed 21 February 2022).

69.

UNHCR (2022b) Return of people not in the need of international protection. Available at: https://www.unhcr.org/return-of-people-not-in-need-of-international-protection.html (accessed 21 February 2022).

70.

Vigh

(2008) Crisis and chronicity. Ethnos 73(1): 5–24.

71.

Vigh

Bjarnesen

(2016) Introduction. Conflict and Society 2(1): 9–15.

72.

Walther

Retaillé

(2008) Le modèle sahélien de la circulation, de la mobilité et de l’incertitude spatiale. Autrepart 47(3): 109–124.

73.

Yuval-Davis

(2011) The Politics of Belonging. London: Sage.