This article proposes academic displacement as a lens to analyse interconnections between skilled and forced migration, and discusses the policy, work and subjective dimensions of the phenomenon. The analysis suggests that policy construction of academic displacement is framed around a temporal oxymoron between short-term emergency intervention and long-term expectations around ‘rescued’ scholars’ capacity to engage in scientific excellence. It also rests on an individualistic interpretation of academic freedom. Differently, displaced scholars reassert the importance of the communitarian dimension of academic freedom. Being represented as exceptional/temporary guests risks bordering them from both their home academic community and their European ‘host’.
AdebayoKO (2022) The state of academic (un)freedom and scholar rescue programmes. Third World Quarterly43(8): 1817–1836.
2.
AliA (2022) Conceptualizing displacement. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies49(5): 1083–1102.
3.
AndersonVConeTRaffertyR, et al. (2022) Mobile agency and relational webs in women’s narratives of international study. Higher Education83: 911–927.
4.
Anjel-Van DijkDLeungMHW (2022) Scholars in exile in the Netherlands. In: AxyonovaVKohstallFRichterC (eds) Academics in Exile. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, pp.123–140.
5.
AparnaKKramschOTKandeO (2022) ‘Where are the refugees?’ In: CantantCCookIRajaram KumarP (eds) Opening Up the Universities. Oxford: Berghahn Books, pp.247–259.
6.
ArendtH (1943) We refugees. Menorah Journal31(1): 69–77.
BabarZEwersMKhattabN (2019) Im/mobile highly skilled migrants in Qatar. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies45(9): 1553–1570.
9.
BaboA (2021) 38 Paradise Road, being an African francophone refugee scholar in American academia. Journal of International Mobility1(9): 137–158.
10.
BaileyAMulderCH (2017) Highly skilled migration between the Global North and South. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies43(16): 2689–2703.
11.
BarglowskiK (2018) Where, what and whom to study? In: Zapata-BarreroRYalazE (eds) Qualitative Research in European Migration Studies. Cham: Springer, pp.151–168.
12.
BauderH (2012) The international mobility of academics. International Migration53(1): 83–96.
13.
BaumanZ (1989) Modernity and the Holocaust. Cambridge: Polity Press.
14.
BensonMO’ReillyK (2016) From lifestyle migration to lifestyle in migration. Migration Studies4(1): 20–37.
15.
BjarnesenJVighH (2016) Displacement and emplacement. Conflict and Society2: 9–15.
16.
BrubakerRCooperF (2000) Beyond ‘identity’. Theory and Society29(1): 1–47.
17.
BurkeP (2017) Exiles and Expatriates in the History of Knowledge, 1500–2000. Waltham, MA: Brandeis University Press.
18.
CantantCCookIRajaram KumarP (2022) Introduction. In: CantantCCookIRajaram KumarP (eds) Opening Up the Universities. Oxford: Berghahn Books, pp.1–30.
19.
CollyerMDe HaasH (2012) Developing dynamic categorisations of transit migration. Population, Space and Place18: 468–481.
20.
CoserLA (1984) Refugee Scholars in America. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
21.
CranstonS (2017) Expatriate as a ‘good’ migrant. Population, Space and Place23(6): e2058.
22.
CrawfordSElsnerJUlmschneiderK (eds) (2017) Ark of Civilization. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
23.
CrawleyHSkleparisD (2018) Refugees, migrants, neither, both. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies44(1): 48–64.
24.
CroftWCruseDA (2004) Cognitive Linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
25.
CwernerS (2001) The times of migration. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies27(1): 7–36.
26.
DahindenJFischerCMenetJ (2021) Knowledge production, reflexivity, and the use of categories in migration studies. Ethnic and Racial Studies44(4): 535–554.
27.
DideroMRadkeHZargouniN, et al. (2024) Researchers at Risk. Maynooth: Inspireurope+ EU Funded Consortium.
ForstorpPEMellströmU (2013) Eduscapes. Globalisation, Societies and Education11(3): 335–358.
30.
GalloE (2016) In the right place at the right time? Reflections on multi-sited ethnography in the age of migration. In: FalzonM (ed.) multi-sited ethnography. London: Routledge, pp.87–102.
31.
GalloE (2019) A broken chain? Colonial history, middle-class Indian migrants and intergenerational ambivalence. International Journal of Comparative Sociology60(1–2): 37–54.
32.
GalloE (2023) Religion and indian nursing employment in Italy: Three cohorts of migrant women’ in who cares ? In: JohnMWichterichC (eds) Care Extractions and the Struggle of Indian Care Workers. New Delhi: Zubaan, pp.220–247.
33.
GalloE (2012) The unwelcome ethnographer, or what ‘our’ people (may) think of multi-sited research. In: ColemanSVon HellermannP (eds) Multi-Sited Ethnography. London: Routledge, pp.54–72.
34.
GalloEScrinziF (2021) Gendering the migration-religion nexus. Etnografia e Ricerca Qualitativa14(3): 387–410.
35.
GalloEPoggioBBodioP (2022) The importance of the locality in opening universities to refugee students. In: CantantCCookIRajaram KumarP (eds) Opening Up the Universities. Oxford: Berghahn Books, pp.260–274.
36.
GatrellP (2013) The Making of the Modern Refugee. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
37.
GhazzoulN (2022) The unheard voices. In: AxyonovaVKohstallFRichterC (eds) Academics in Exile. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, pp.233–247.
38.
GillespieAHowarthCSCornishF (2012) Four problems for researchers using social categories. Culture & Psychology18(3): 391–402.
39.
GuarnieriP (2023) Intellectuals Displaced from Fascist Italy. Firenze: Firenze University Press.
40.
GunterARaghuramP (2017) Internationalization, localization and the eduscape of higher education in the global south. In: Van RiemsdijkMWangQ (eds) Rethinking International Skilled Migration. London: Routledge, pp.111–132.
41.
GusejnovaDDragoleaAPetőA, et al. (2024) Rewarding mobility?Comparative Migration Studies12(4): 1–19.
42.
HeilbutA (1983) Exiled in Paradise. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
43.
JacobsD (2018) Categorising what we study and what we analyse, and the exercise of interpretation. In: Zapata-BarreroRYalazE (eds) Qualitative Research in European Migration Studies. Cham: Springer, pp.133–149.
44.
JonesR (2009) Categories, borders and boundaries. Progress in Human Geography33(2): 174–189.
45.
KinzelbachKLindbergSPelkeL, et al. (2022) Academic freedom index. Available at: https://academic-freedom-index.net/ (accessed 4 August 2024).
KmakMFarzamfarM (2022) Personal and academic narratives of exiled and displaced scholars. In: KmakMBjörklundH (eds) Refugees and Knowledge Production. London: Routledge, pp.109–127.
48.
KunzS (2020) Expatriate, migrant?Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies46(11): 2145–2162.
49.
LoherDStrasserSMonterescuD, et al. (2019) On politics and precarity in academia. Social Anthropology27(S2): 97–117.
50.
LöhrI (2022) The moral economies of ‘research in exile’. In: AxyonovaVKohstallFRichterC (eds) Academics in Exile. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, pp.81–97.
51.
MarksSWeindlingPWintourL (eds) (2011) In Defence of Learning. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52.
MenandL (1996) The limits of academic freedom. In: MenandL (ed.) The Future of Academic Freedom. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press, pp.1–20.
53.
MoncrieffeJ (2007) Labelling, power and accountability. In: MoncrieffeJEybenR (eds) The Power of Labelling. London: Earthscan, pp.1–17.
54.
MorawskaE (2022) Qualitative migration research. In: Zapata-BarreroRYalazE (eds) Qualitative Research in European Migration Studies. Cham: Springer, pp.113–131.
55.
MozetičK (2018) Being highly skilled and a refugee. Refugee Survey Quarterly37(2): 231–251.
56.
OzkirimliU (2017) How to liquidate a people?Globalizations14(6): 851–856.
QuinnRLevineJ (2014) Intellectual-HRDs and claims for academic freedom under human rights law. The International Journal of Human Rights18(7–8): 898–920.
59.
RobertsonS (2019) Status-making: rethinking migrant categorization. Journal of Sociology55(2): 219–233.
60.
RobinsonOC (2014) Sampling in interview-based qualitative research. Qualitative Research in Psychology11(1): 25–41.
61.
SaidEW (1984) Reflections on Exile and Other Essays. New York: Granta Books.
62.
SalibaI (2018) Academic freedom in the MENA region. In: European Institute of the Mediterranean (ed.) Mediterranean Handbook. Barcelona: EuroMed Insights Migration, pp.313–316.
63.
ScherschelK (2011) Who is a refugee?Migration Letters8(1): 67–76.
64.
Scholars at Risk (SAR) (2022) Free to Think Report 2022. New York: Scholars at Risk Network.
65.
Sertdemir ÖzdemirS (2021) Pity the exiled. Journal of Refugee Studies34(1): 936–952.
66.
SeyhanA (2022) Exile in a transnational mode. In: AxyonovaVKohstallKRichterC (eds) Academics in Exile. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, pp.33–58.
67.
StoeberHGaebelMO’GormanS, et al. (2022) Inspireurope Recommendations. Brussels: Inspireurope Publications.
68.
TeichlerU (2015) Academic mobility and migration. European Review23(1): S6–S37.
69.
TelliA (2022) Towards structural responses to the displacement of scholars. In: AxyonovaVKohstallKRichterC (eds) Academics in Exile. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, pp.181–204.
70.
TzanakouCHendersonEF (2021) Stuck and sticky in mobile academia. Higher Education82: 685–693.
71.
Van RiemsdijkMWangQ (2017) Introduction. In: Van RiemsdijkMWangQ (eds) Rethinking International Skilled Migration. London: Routledge, pp.1–16.
72.
VatanseverA (2020) At the Margins of Academia. Leiden: Brill.
73.
VatanseverA (2022) Blessing or curse? In: AxyonovaVKohstallKRichterC (eds) Academics in Exile. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, pp.101–122.
74.
VatanseverAKölemenA (eds) (2023) Academic Freedom and Precarity in the Global North. London: Routledge.
75.
WoodG (1985) The politics of development policy labelling. Development and Change16(3): 347–373.
76.
YakoL (2021) Bullets in Envelopes: Iraqi Academics in Exile. London: Pluto Press.
77.
ZavaleNCLangaPV (2018) African diaspora and the search for academic freedom safe havens. Journal of Higher Education in Africa16(1–2): 1–24.
78.
ZetterR (1991) Labelling refugees. Journal of Refugee Studies4(1): 39–62.
79.
ZetterR (2007) More labels, fewer refugees. Journal of Refugee Studies20(2): 172–191.
