Physical,Social and Economic Characteristics of Gated Communities for a Living Choice in Karachi-Pakistan: Comparative Analysis of Kaneez Fatima (CHS) and Naya Nazimabad

Abstract

This article contributes twofold to the international discussion on ‘gated communities as a living choice’. First, this study constructs a ‘living choice’ framework based on the physical, social, and economic characteristics of gated communities as established by the four key researchers. Next, the framework is applied to analyze the reasons for living within gated communities in Karachi, Pakistan. A cross-comparison of two gated communities employs post-occupancy household survey questionnaires from residents, and qualitative interviews with real estate developers, and community managers. The findings ascertain that security and lifestyle are the main values associated with living in gated communities in Karachi.

Keywords

Gated communities Karachi Kaneez Fatima (CHS)Naya Nazimabad living choice

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrahem

(2018) Typology of urban housing and politics in Baghdad: from state-subsidized housing to privatized gated communities. PhD Thesis, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH.

Ahmed

Sadiq

Ahmed

, et al. (2014) 50 Cases, Karachi through the sign. Karachi, Pakistan: Mimeo.

Al Omari

(2015) The emergence of residential gated communities in Jordan. Research Journal of Applied Sciences, Engineering and Technology 11(3): 293–298.

Almatarneh

(2013) Choices and changes in the housing market and community preferences: reasons for the emergence of gated communities in Egypt: a case study of the greater Cairo region, Egypt. Ain Shams Engineering Journal 4(3): 563–583.

Amerigo

Aragones

(1997) A theoretical and methodological approach to the study of residential satisfaction. Journal of Environmental Psychology 17: 47–57.

Baycan-Levent

Gulumser

(2007) Gated Communities in Istanbul: The New Walls of the City (Third Conference). London: UCL.

Blakely

(1999) The gated community debate. Urban Land 58(6): 50–55.

Blakely

Snyder

(1997) Fortress America. Washington, DC: Brookings Institute.

Burke

(2001) The pedestrian behaviour of residents in gated communities. Available at: https://trid.trb.org/view/732831

10.

Caldiera

(2000) City of Walls: Crime, Segregation and Citizenship in Sao Paulo. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

11.

Clarke

Deurloo

Deileman

(2004) Choosing Neighborhoods: Residential Mobility and Neighborhood Careers. Cambridge: European Network of Housing Research Conference.

12.

Dowling

Atkinson

McGuirk

(2010) Privatism, privatization, and social distinction in master-planned residential estates. Urban Policy and Research 28(4): 391–410.

13.

Duren

(2012) Gated Communities: Global South.

14.

Ehwi

Tyler

Morrison

(2018) Market-Led Initiatives to Land Tenure Security in Ghana: Contribution of Gated Communities. Washington, DC: The World Bank, pp.19–23.

15.

El Sayed

(2016) Residents’ satisfaction in gated communities in Egypt. International Journal of Scientific and Engineering Research 7(4): 1185–1196.

16.

Goodfellow

(2017) Urban fortunes and skeleton cityscapes: Real estate and late urbanization in Kigali and Addis Ababa. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 41(5): 786–803.

17.

Grant

Mittelsteadt

(2004) Types of gated communities. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 31(6): 913–930.

18.

Grundstrom

(2018) Gating housing in Sweden: walling in the privileged, walling out the public from public places. In: Brighenti

Kärrholm

(eds) Urban Walls. London: Routledge, pp.181–202.

19.

Hendrikx

Wissink

(2017) Welcome to the club! An exploratory study of service accessibility in commodity housing estates in Guangzhou, China. Social & Cultural Geography 18(3): 371–394.

20.

Hirt

Petrovic

(2011) The Belgrade wall: the proliferation of gated housing in the Serbian capital after socialism. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35(4): 753–777.

21.

Kaker

(2014) Enclaves, insecurity and violence in Karachi. South Asian History and Culture 5(1): 93–107.

22.

Kalantari

Rafieian

Aghasafari

, et al. (2017) Investigation of gated communities in Tehran city. Journal of Research in Ecology 5(2).

23.

Lai

(2016) Stone walls do not a prison make, nor iron bars a cage: the institutional and communitarian possibilities of gated communities. Land Use Policy 54: 378–385.

24.

Landman

(2000) An Overview of Enclosed Neighborhoods in South Africa. Pretoria, South Africa: CSIR.

25.

Landman

(2006) An Exploration of Urban Transformation in Post-Apartheid South Africa through Gated Communities with a Special Focus on Its Relationship to Crime and Impact on Socio-Spatial Segregation. Newcastle upon Tyne: Newcastle University.

26.

Luymes

(1997) The fortification of suburbia: investigating the rise of enclave communities. Landscape and Urban Planning 39(2–3): 187–203.

27.

Mohit

Raja

(2014) Residential satisfaction concepts, theories and empirical studies. Planning Malaysia 3: 47–66.

28.

Nadeem

Hameed

Shabih

, et al. (2013) Residents’ perception and analysis of the contemporary neighbourhood design practices in Lahore, Pakistan. Journal of Engineering and Applied Science 12: 143–158.

29.

Nazmy

Fahmi

Sayed

(2016) Residents’ satisfaction at gated communities in Egypt. International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research 7: 1185–1196.

30.

Osman

Rabe

Bachok

(2011) An investigation of factors influencing communities’ decision to reside in gated development in Kuala Lumpur and Selangor. Available at: http://irep.iium.edu.my/8989/1/00048_GATED_DEVELOPMENT_IN_MALAYSIA.pdf

31.

Roitman

Recio

(2020) Understanding Indonesia’s gated communities. Housing Studies 35(5): 795–819.

32.

Rosen

Razin

(2008) Enclosed residential neighborhoods in Israel: from landscapes of heritage and frontier enclaves to new gated communities. Environment and Planning A 40(12): 2895–2913.

33.

Sadiq

Shakir

Ahmed

(2010) Gated living in the context of Karachi. Journal of Research in Architecture & Planning 9(1): 50–64.

34.

Saif

(2011) Challenge of Egypt’s Economic Transition. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

35.

Shamseldin

(2016) Proposal of adapting the assessment weights of GPRS for different gated communities’ positions. HBRC Journal 14: 224–234.

36.

Tan

(2016) Residential satisfaction in gated communities. Property Management 34(2): 84–99.

37.

Touman

(2002) Gated Communities: Physical Construction or Social Destruction Tool. Grenoble: University Pierre Mendes France.

38.

Verme

Milanovic

Al-Shawarby , et al. (2014) Inside Inequality in the Arab Republic of Egypt: Facts and Perceptions across People, Time and Space. Washington, DC: The World Bank; The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development.

39.

Watson

(2020) Digital visualisation as a new driver of urban change in Africa. Urban Planning 5(2): 35–43.

40.

Webster

(2001) Gated cities of tomorrow. Town Planning Review 72(2): 149–170.

41.

Wissink

Hazelzet

(2016) Bangkok living: encountering others in a gated urban field. Cities 59: 164–172.

42.

Yusuf

(2012) The untold tales of Lyari. Dawn, 7 May. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/716446/the-untold-tales-of-lyari

43.

Zhao

(2017) An ‘unceasing war’ on land development on the urban fringe of Beijing: a case study of gated informal housing societies. Cities 60: 139–146.

44.

Zhao

Zou

(2017) Un-gating the gated community: the spatial restructuring of a resettlement neighbourhood in Nanjing. Cities 62: 78–87.