This article sheds light on the counter-terrorism measures enacted by the Maghreb countries, with a comparative approach of the laws in Algeria, Mauritania, Morocco, and Tunisia. Carried out by comparing the Arabic and French original versions, the analysis revealed a common attitude that tended to preserve national security at the expenses of civil freedoms and human rights. In almost all cases, anti-terrorism laws strayed away from their supposed initial finality – fighting terrorism – tackling other issues such as the maintenance of public order or indirectly the control of dissidence and political opposition, with no or scarce legal checks and balances that could restrict possible police or judiciary abuses towards civil and political rights. The legal measures significantly delayed both the first transition to democracy in the region in the 2000s as well as the promising development after the ‘Arab spring’.
AbushoukA (2016) The Arab spring: A fourth wave of democratisation?Digest of Middle East Studies25(1): 52–69.
2.
AlexanderY (2015) Terrorism in North Africa and the Sahel: Threats and responses. In: TomolyaJWhiteL (eds) Terrorist Threats in North Africa from a NATO Perspective. Amsterdam: IOS Press, pp.1–17.
3.
AllaniA (2009) The Islamists in Tunisia between confrontation and participation (1980–2008). The Journal of North African Studies14(2): 257–272.
4.
AntilA (2010) Mohamed Ould Abdel Aziz, the Alchemist [Mohamed Ould Abdel Aziz, l’alchimiste]. L’Année du Maghreb6: 357–372.
5.
BartolucciV (2010) Analysing elite discourse on terrorism and its implications: The case of Morocco. Critical Studies on Terrorism3(11): 119–135.
6.
BartolucciV (2015) Assessing terrorism and counter-terrorism in the Maghreb. In: TomolyaJWhiteL (eds) Terrorist Threats in North Africa from a NATO Perspective. Amsterdam: IOS Press, pp.106–121.
7.
BayatA (2017) Revolutions without Revolutionaries. Making Sense of the Arab Spring. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
8.
Begorre-BretC (2006) The definition of terrorism and the challenge of relativism. Cardozo Law Review27(5): 1987–2004.
9.
BenmansourA (2006) Civil society and terrorism: The attacks of May 16 in Morocco [Société civile et terrorisme: Les attentats du 16 Mai au Maroc]. Revue Marocaine des Régimes Politiques, Juridiques et Politiques6: 20–21.
10.
BettatiM (2013) Terrorism: The Way of International Cooperation. [Le Terrorisme. Vois de la Coopération internationale]. Paris: Odile.
11.
BouhoucheAChafikA (2004) Terrorist Crime in Moroccan Legislation [Le Crime Terroriste dans la Législation Marocaine]. Rabat: Al-Karama.
12.
BrasJ-P (2007) The Maghreb in the “war on terror” : Legal and political issues of “anti-terrorist” legislation [Le Maghreb dans la “guerre contre le terrorisme”: Enjeux juridiques et politiques des législations “anti-terroristes”]. L’année du Maghreb2: 447–467.
13.
BrasJ-P (2016) Tunisia: The drafting of the 2015 law or the paradoxes of security democracy [Tunisie: L’élaboration de la loi de 2015 ou les paradoxes de la démocratie sécuritaire]. L’année du Maghreb15: 309–323.
14.
Bulletin Officiel Royaume du Maroc (BORM), 5June2003, no. 5114.
15.
CarothersT (2004) The end of the transition paradigm. In: CarothersT (ed) Critical Mission: Essays on Democracy Promotion. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
16.
CristianiD (2014) The geography of discontent: Tunisia’s Syrian fighter dilemma. The Jamestown Foundation Terrorim Monitor12(20): 7–9.
17.
DahmaniA (2007) Democracy Challenged by a Digital Society [La Démocratie à l’Epreuve de la Société Numérique]. Paris: Karthala.
18.
DhamapalaJ (2007) The United Nations Response to 9/11. Terrorism and Political Violence17(1–2): 17–23.
19.
DiamondL (2002) Thinking about hybrid regimes. Journal of Democracy13(2): 21–35.
20.
DouglasR (2014) Law, Liberty and the Pursuit of Terrorism. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
21.
DurandG (2011) The Al-Qaeda Organization in the Islamic Maghreb. Reality or Manipulations? [L’Organisation d’Al-Qaida au Maghreb Islamique. Réalité ou Manipulations?] Paris: L’Harmattan.
22.
EntelisJ.P. (2005), The democratic imperative vs. the authoritarian impulse: the Maghrib state between transition and terrorism. Middle East Journal, 54 (4): 537–558.
23.
El BouhairiY (2009) The fight against terrorism: Between the reason of state and human rights. Special reference to Morocco. In: Fernández SánchezP (ed) International Legal Dimension of Terrorism. Leiden: Nijhoff Publishers, pp.43–54.
24.
FernándezP.A. (2009). International legal dimension of terrorism. Hague: Nijhof
25.
ForestJ (2012) Perceptions, challenges faced by al-Qaeda on the battlefield of influence warfare. Perspectives on Terrorism6(1): 8–22.
26.
GaddesC (2015) The constituent process (2011–2014): Phases and protagonists [Il processo costituente (2011–2014): Fasi e protagonosti]. In: GroppiTSpignoI (eds) The Springs of the Constitutions [Le primavere delle costituzioni]. Roma: Carocci, pp.50–65.
27.
GazdikG (2015) The rise and fall of al-Qaeda in North Africa: AQIM and its role in the region. In: TomolyaJWhiteL (eds) Terrorist Threats in North Africa from a NATO Perspective. Amsterdam: IOS Press, pp.106–121.
28.
GeisserVAyariM (2011) Arab Revivals: Seven Key Questions about Revolutions in March [Renaissances Arabes: 7 Questions Clés sur des Révolutions en Marche]. Paris: La Découverte.
29.
GobeE (2012) Plasticity of Constitutional Law and Dynamics of Authoritarianism in Ben Ali’s Tunisia [Plasticité du Droit Constitutionnel et Dynamique de l’Autoritarisme dans la Tunisie de Ben Ali]. Review of the Muslim Worlds and the Mediterranean [Revue des Mondes Musulmans et de la Meditérranée] 130(2): 215–232.
30.
HarmonsS (2014) Terror and Insurgency in the Sahara-Sahel Region. Corruption, Contraband. Jihad and the Mali War of 2012–2013. London: Routledge.
31.
HowieL. (2012). Witnesses to terror. Understanding the meaning and consequences of Terrorism. London: MacMillan.
32.
HumphreyM (2014) Emergency law and hypergovernance: Human rights and regime change in the Arab Spring. In: FosshagenK (ed) Arab Spring: Uprisings, Powers, Interventions. Berghahn Books, pp.47–64.
33.
HuntingtonS (1991) Democracy’s third wave. The Journal of Democracy2(2): 137–148.
34.
JacksonS (2001) Domestic terrorism in the Islamic legal tradition. The Muslim World91(3–4): 293–310.
35.
Journal Officiel de la République Algérienne Démocratique et Populaire (JORADP), 1October1992, no. 70.
36.
Journal Officiel de la République Islamique de Mauritanie (JORIM), 15September2005, no. 1102.
37.
Journal Officiel de la République Islamique de Mauritanie (JORIM), 30September2010, no. 1124.
38.
Journal Officiel de la République Tunisienne (JORT), 30November1993, no. 91.
39.
Journal Officiel de la République Tunisienne (JORT), 10December2003, no. 99.
40.
Journal Officiel de la République Tunisienne (JORT), 7August2015, no. 63.
41.
KentR (2010) The 9/11 Effect: Comparative Counter Terrorism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
42.
MahmoodMSMasumA (2014) A quest for defining terrorism in international law: The emerging consensus. Journal of International Studies10(77): 77–93.
43.
MartinezL (1999) Civil war and work in Algeria [Guerre civile et oeuvre pies en Algérie]. Critique Internationale4(1): 1127–1137.
44.
MurphyC (2015) Transnational counter-terrorism law: Law, power and legitimacy in the ‘war on terror’. Transnational Legal Theory6(1): 31–54.
45.
MurphyE (2016) The fragility of transition in Tunisia. In: ZoubirYWhiteG (eds) North African Politics. Change and Continuity. Oxon: Routledge, pp.225–239.
46.
PetersR (2005) Crime and Punishment in Islamic Law. Theory and Practice from the Sixteenth to the Twenty-first Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
47.
RosandE (2003) Security council resolution 1373, The Counter-Terrorism Committee, and the fight against terrorism. The American Journal of International Law94(2): 333–341.
48.
SadikiL (2009) Rethinking Arab Democratization. Elections without Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
49.
SadikiLBouandelY (2016) The post Arab Spring Reform: The Maghreb at a cross roads. Digest of Middle East Studies25(1): 109–131.
50.
SchedlerA (2006) Electoral Authoritarism: the Dynamics of Unfree Competition. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
51.
Sela-ShayovitzR (2009) Social control in the face of security and minority threats. The effects of terrorism, minority and economic crisis and law enforcement system in Israel. British Journal of Criminology49(6): 772–787.
52.
ShahinE (1997) Political Ascent: Contemporary Islamic Movements in North Africa. Boulder: Westview.
53.
VermerenP (2009) Mohammed VI’s Morocco : The Unfinished Transition [Le Maroc de Mohammed VI: La Transition Inachevée]. Paris: La Découverte.
54.
VogelEF (2002) The trial of terrorists under classical Islamic law. Harvard International Law Journal41(1): 53–64.
55.
WelchmanLR (2012) Hard places and human rights: Anti-terrorism law and policy in Arab states. In: RamrajVHorMRoachK (eds) Global Anti-Terrorism Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.581–608.
56.
WhitakerBE (2010) Compliance among weak states: Africa and the counter-terrorism regime. Review of International Studies36: 639–662.
57.
WhiteheadL (2012) Democratization: Theory and Experience. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
